Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Subordinate Legislation

Budget (Scotland) Act 2003 Amendment Order 2003 (draft)

Thursday 19 June 2003 Meeting of the Parliament Debate 6 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

6 contributions
Motion moved,

That the Parliament agrees that the draft Budget (Scotland) Act 2003 Amendment Order 2003 be approved.—[Tavish Scott.]

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link
I rise to oppose the motion. The order in question does two things, the first of which is to make a change in accounting practice. That particular measure is dull and worthy, and we support it. Yesterday, the Deputy Minister for Finance and Public Services assured me that the measure could be introduced at a later date if the order is rejected today. However, the order's second purpose is to provide almost an additional £100 million for the Holyrood project, which could not be more controversial.

The SNP opposes the motion because it was not persuaded at yesterday's meeting of the Finance Committee that a case has been proven for the expenditure of the additional £37.7 million that was dealt with yesterday. Indeed, some elements have not been proven at all.

I want to outline some of the unanswered questions that members of all parties raised yesterday. What exactly are the total fees for each consultant? How much money has been saved by the recent cap, which the Presiding Officer referred to? We do not know; those are secrets. When we asked why the contingency had been calculated at £5.692 million, the project team told us that the figure displayed a "spurious accuracy". We asked about the justification for the failure to finalise the design of a boundary wall and the exterior staircase, but answer came there nane.

There are many more points I could mention; however, I have outlined three of the most serious. Today we are being asked to make provision from the public purse of nearly £100 million for the most controversial project in Scotland. The SNP is determined to cap the cost at not a penny more than the legal minimum.

The SNP supports public-private partnership schemes where the expenditure is on pupils, patients and the police. By contrast, during the general election campaign, the Minister for Finance and Public Services, Mr Kerr, who has just arrived, said that the £338 million cost of the Holyrood project was a "drop in the ocean". Mr Kerr, who does not seem to be concentrating on this important debate, might call £37.7 million a droplet, if he believes that £338 million is a drop in the ocean. I fear that henceforth the Minister for Finance and Public Services might be known as Andy drop-in-the-ocean Kerr.

Andy Kerr Lab The Minister for Finance and Public Services · East Kilbride
link
Will the member take an intervention?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link
I have only 10 seconds to go.

The SNP voted against the Holyrood project in 1999 and in 2000, whereas Labour and Liberal members voted for it. We are where we are. The building must be completed. Rejecting the motion will in no way prevent the completion of the building. Another motion can be lodged. Let us oppose the motion and act in accordance with the wishes of the majority of the Scottish public.

Tavish Scott LD The Deputy Minister for Finance and Public Services · Shetland
link
Mr Ewing is wrong for three reasons. In fact, he is wrong for many more reasons, but three will suffice for today. First, the accounting change on capital charges is important. Mr Ewing is correct on one point because the change could wait until the autumn or until next year. Indeed, the change could be made at any time before April 2004. Two measures have been put together in one revision, as they were in the motion that the Finance Committee debated, because that is the most efficient mechanism for taking matters forward.

The Finance Committee agreed the process on 11 February. At that meeting, Mr Ewing's colleagues Mr Morgan and Mr Adam were content with the process. Mr Ewing shakes his head, but I suggest that he check the Official Report. The process was agreed on 11 February as a method of dealing with the Holyrood budget increase that we knew about at that time, which was £58 million.

Secondly, the budget revision provides authority for additional spending on the Holyrood building of up to £94.377 million. That figure includes the final increase in costs of £37 million. Through its scrutiny role, the Finance Committee can play a major part in ensuring that the full amount provided for is used only if that is necessary. I would have thought that that was a compelling argument, but it is clear that Mr Ewing rejects it.

The Executive's job is to amend the Scottish budget in the light of the most accurate figures that are available to us to ensure that the Holyrood project can continue. That is the purpose of the budget revision. The Executive would be delighted if it turned out that it had provided for more funding than was necessary. We hope that that will be the case. Nevertheless, the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body has asked us for an additional £94 million and we do not intend to amend the SPCB's estimate.

Thirdly, Mr Reid, the Presiding Officer, has stated repeatedly that any further delay, in terms of the budget revision and costs, would simply delay the opening of the Holyrood building. Mr Ewing and his party are taking an astonishing position that could delay further the completion of the building. It is evident that that is the case. I suggest that Mr Ewing listen to Mr Reid's protestations on the matter. I urge members to accept the budget revision order.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 19 June 2003 Debate · 1
  2. Water Industry Debate · 134
  3. Care Homes for the Elderly Debate · 66
  4. Business Motion Business motions · 5
  5. Holyrood Project Statement · 30
  6. Minister for Justice (Visits to Stirling) Questions · 6
  7. Deprived Communities (Cultural Activity) Questions · 4
  8. Less Favoured Areas Support Scheme Questions · 6
  9. National Health Service (Prescription Charges) Questions · 10
  10. Minority Sports Questions · 6
  11. National Health Service (Prescription Charges) Questions · 6
  12. Prison Conditions Questions · 8
  13. Transport Budget Questions · 10
  14. Hepatitis C (Financial Assistance) Questions · 4
  15. High Court (Time Limit for Commencement of Cases) Questions · 6
  16. Fostering (Remuneration) Questions · 6
  17. Landfill Sites (Road Transportation of Waste) Questions · 4
  18. Kerbside Recycling Questions · 5
  19. Solutions RMC Questions · 5
  20. Angus Council (Road Improvement Projects) Questions · 6
  21. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  22. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  23. Sustainable Future First Minister’s Questions · 4
  24. Cabinet Reshuffle (Constitutional Changes) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  25. West Coast Main Line Railway First Minister’s Questions · 4
  26. Police Numbers First Minister’s Questions · 7
  27. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 47
  28. Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Bill Bill debate · 34
  29. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 1
  30. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 6
  31. Subordinate Legislation Debate · 8
  32. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  33. Motion without Notice Business motions · 4
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 55
  35. Airport Investment (Glasgow and Edinburgh) Members’ business · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.