To ask the Scottish Executive whether it has considered the introduction of a scheme similar to the NHS digital hearing aid pilot project in England. (S1O-3974)
Official Report · Chamber
Audiology Services
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 5
- Mike Rumbles LD 2
- Cathie Craigie Lab 1
- Shona Robison SNP 1
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
10 contributionsThe Executive has initiated a wide-ranging review of audiology services to address the wider issues of hearing aid provision. That is being progressed in consultation with the Public Health Institute of Scotland. We are monitoring progress of the pilot studies in England and will consider constructively the results when they become available, but have no plans to introduce a similar scheme in Scotland. NHS Scotland has already introduced 11 different types of digital hearing aids on to its central contract range.
Is the minister aware that more than 20 trusts in England have already gone digital, and that all patients in England will have access to digital aids within three years? If digital aids are bulk-purchased, the cost can be dramatically reduced, from the current price of £2,500 each to something like £250. Despite much pressure and despite the items that the minister has approved, health boards such as Grampian Health Board have still given no date for when they will go digital. Digital aids are not available. Will the minister take action to put the situation right for the people of Scotland?
Susan Deacon and I are both concerned about the situation, but I remind Mike Rumbles of the wider review that is taking place. I accept that digital hearing aids are an important part of that agenda. I met representatives from the Royal National Institute for Deaf People over the summer, and Susan Deacon will meet them in a few weeks' time. We are certainly keen to see progress on the matter. The review will report next year and we will watch the progress of the English pilot studies. Members should remember that it is only in the pilot areas that the provision to which Mike Rumbles referred is available. Where someone would benefit clinically from a digital hearing aid, it certainly ought to be available.
The minister is aware of my interest in the matter and of the Royal National Institute for Deaf People's postcard campaign on the issue. He said that he would monitor the findings of the projects that are under way in England. Will he liaise with his Westminster colleagues and ask to be involved in seeing the research work and the outcome of the English projects? Will he put that information to good use for deaf and hard-of-hearing people in Scotland?
As I said, we are certainly keen to monitor the results of those projects. It is clear from what I hear at this early stage that some people can benefit greatly from digital hearing aids. That reinforces what we already know. There is some dispute among clinicians about how much advantage digital hearing aids might have, and it looks as if some people will benefit more than others. However, the principle that I outlined, which is stated in Scottish Executive guidance, is that if someone will benefit clinically from a digital hearing aid, it should be available.
I have been contacted by a 93-year-old man who has not been able to access a digital hearing aid on the NHS despite an assessment that it would benefit him. Does the minister agree that Scots requiring digital hearing aids on the NHS should have the same access to them as their counterparts in England? Does he accept that that is clearly not the case at present, as only 1 per cent of Scots who require a digital hearing aid have access to one? Instead of talking about reviews, will he give a commitment to roll out a programme of digital hearing aids across the NHS in Scotland?
There are pilot studies in England, but it is quite misleading to say that more people in England have a digital hearing aid than in Scotland. If one takes population differences into account, the numbers who have a digital hearing aid in Scotland are more or less the same as in England. That is not enough people, as I have acknowledged, and we are determined that more people who can benefit from them will have access to digital hearing aids. Matters are not helped by making inaccurate and exaggerated references to a situation in England that does not exist.
Has the minister taken on board the massive cost savings that Mike Rumbles identified? I accept that there are many burdens on health service budgets, but does Mr Chisholm recognise that the benefits of those cost savings achieved south of the border could perhaps be relayed north and that individuals could be allowed to make a privileged purchase if that was their desire?
One of the good things that is happening is that the cost of digital hearing aids is falling. I am sure that we all welcome that. I agree that that is important, not least because I have responsibility for older people—many people who need hearing aids are older people. That is an important part of our many-faceted strategy for older people. We are determined that there will be progress on the issue, and I assure members that that progress will come soon.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Nov 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 1 November 2001 Debate · 1
- Teaching and Research Funding (Scottish Higher Education Funding Council Review) Debate · 64
- Presiding Officer's Ruling Procedure · 7
- Business Motions Business motions · 45
- Presiding Officer's Ruling Procedure · 3
- Ferry Services (Orkney and Shetland) Questions · 6
- Scottish Economy Questions · 6
- Paramedics Questions · 6
- Hospitals (Length of Stay) Questions · 8
- Children's Hearings Questions · 6
- Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Questions · 8
- Free Personal Care Questions · 4
- Trunk Roads (Maintenance) Questions · 12
- Audiology Services Questions · 10
- Scotland Week Questions · 21
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Hospitals (New Developments) First Minister’s Questions · 21
- Committee of the Whole Parliament Debate · 1
- Police and Fire Services (Finance) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 26
- Scottish Parliament Debate · 1
- Police and Fire Services (Finance) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 8
- Motion without Notice Business motions · 8
- Decision Time Decision time · 6
- Inverness Airport Members’ business · 36
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.