To ask the Scottish Executive whether its definition of personal care is the same as that contained in the report of the Sutherland Royal Commission on Long Term Care of the Elderly. (S1O-2960)
Official Report · Chamber
Personal Care
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 5
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 2
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
- Mary Scanlon Con 1
- Keith Raffan LD 1
The record
10 contributionsWe have made it clear that we accept the Sutherland principles. The challenge now is to work on the detail and to translate the principles into applicable and understandable practical arrangements.
Rather than answering my question, that begs the question and poses another. Why has the care development group been asked not to translate the principles of the Sutherland report, but to
"provide a clear definition of what is meant by personal care"?
Given the importance of this issue, and for the avoidance of doubt, will the minister give us a guarantee that the clear definition that the care development group has been asked to come up with will in no respect be narrower than the already clear definition that is contained in the Sutherland report?
"provide a clear definition of what is meant by personal care"?
Given the importance of this issue, and for the avoidance of doubt, will the minister give us a guarantee that the clear definition that the care development group has been asked to come up with will in no respect be narrower than the already clear definition that is contained in the Sutherland report?
As it did yesterday, the Opposition is trying to dance on the head of a pin and confuse older people about this most important matter. Nicola Sturgeon did not listen to my answer. We all welcome the exceptionally able group of people who have agreed to serve under my convenership. The group will consider the detail in the first instance, but it will also deal with the very real and important task of translating principles into action. While the Opposition tries to confuse, we are determined to translate aspiration into action and rhetoric into reality.
What plans does the minister have to make the work of the development and implementation group an open and inclusive process? Will he publish a list of the groups that that group will consult? Will he keep the Parliament informed of progress, to ensure that we end up with a clear, widely acceptable and—most important—sustainable implementation plan?
I can assure Richard Simpson that this will be a most inclusive process. As the parliamentary answer that revealed the names of the group said, we are determined to consult widely, particularly with older people in Scotland. I will consult older people's groups and other mechanisms will be used to ensure that the consultation is wide and inclusive. My only worry about Richard Simpson's suggestion of naming the groups we will consult is that we may exclude somebody. In principle, I entirely agree with what he says.
I will give the minister another opportunity to stop us asking the same question every week and to stop us having continually, as he says, to dance on the head of a pin. I understand that the minister accepts the principles of Sutherland but, as the chairman of the development group, does he accept the definition of personal care in chapter 6 of the Sutherland report—or is his remit to narrow and redefine that definition? I give him my word that if he gives us a clear answer I will not mention the matter again until after the development group has reported.
If Mary Scanlon had listened to the answer, she would not have had to ask the question. Sir Stewart Sutherland would be the first person in the world to admit that he has not said the last word in detail about personal care. He said as much in his report. I am delighted that Sir Stewart Sutherland will be one of the people who will give advice to our group as we work over the next six months.
Will the minister ensure that, under his chairmanship, the care development group will consider free personal care for the younger disabled? Will he discuss with such organisations as the Leonard Cheshire Foundation, which has expertise and experience in the field, what many perceive to be a significant deficiency in service provision?
It is clear that Keith Raffan has introduced another dimension to our work. As the remit of the care development group makes clear, we are focusing on older people in particular. We have a range of issues to consider and have not focused solely on personal care. Unlike the Opposition parties, we are examining all the other aspects of care for elderly people, particularly the crucial issue of the development of services. That will be our focus, but the work to which Keith Raffan refers will have to be done.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Feb 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 15 February 2001 Debate · 1
- Motion of No Confidence Debate · 108
- Education Debate · 128
- Business Motion Business motions · 48
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Compensation (Ex-Miners) Questions · 8
- Scottish Arts Council Questions · 6
- Skills Development Questions · 4
- Water Industry Questions · 8
- Schools (Access) Questions · 8
- Social Inclusion (Rural Communities) Questions · 6
- Pollution (River Quality) Questions · 6
- Schools (Placing Requests) Questions · 8
- BCG Vaccination Questions · 7
- Camanachd Association Questions · 8
- Personal Care Questions · 10
- Health Service (Underspend) Questions · 6
- Young Offenders Questions · 4
- “The same as you?” Questions · 4
- River Clyde (Radioactivity) Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Safer Communities First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Nutrition (Elderly People) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Scottish Qualifications Authority First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Children's Services Debate · 46
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 22
- Decision Time Decision time · 45
- Hospices Members’ business · 21
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.