To ask the First Minister what representations the Scottish Executive has made to the Chancellor of the Exchequer in advance of the green budget regarding issues which impact on devolved matters. (S1F-641)
Official Report · Chamber
Budget (Devolved Matters)
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Henry McLeish Lab 5
- Sir David Steel 3
- Andrew Wilson SNP 2
- Ben Wallace Con 2
- Hugh Henry Lab 1
- Margaret Smith LD 1
- Michael Russell SNP 1
The record
15 contributionsI am in regular contact with the chancellor to promote Scotland's interests in budget issues. His excellent financial stewardship, delivering sound public finances and a strong economy, benefited Scotland's budget in the spending review.
I am tempted to ask the First Minister whether he can name a petrol station in central Fife that sells low-sulphur fuel.
What did the First Minister say in his representations to the chancellor to defend the funding of Scottish public services? Did he mention that Scotland—the highest-taxed region of the United Kingdom—is sending a surplus of £3 billion of revenue over expenditure to the Treasury this year alone? According to the chancellor's statement yesterday, next year, the oil revenues will be worth more than £7,000 million—£1,400 per person in Scotland. Given the strength of Scotland's position, why will spending on health and education increase faster in the rest of the UK, as a result of the chancellor's policies, than in Scotland?
What did the First Minister say in his representations to the chancellor to defend the funding of Scottish public services? Did he mention that Scotland—the highest-taxed region of the United Kingdom—is sending a surplus of £3 billion of revenue over expenditure to the Treasury this year alone? According to the chancellor's statement yesterday, next year, the oil revenues will be worth more than £7,000 million—£1,400 per person in Scotland. Given the strength of Scotland's position, why will spending on health and education increase faster in the rest of the UK, as a result of the chancellor's policies, than in Scotland?
It is the same tired old story. However, despite the daily improvements that are being made for the future of Scotland and its people through the chancellor's pre-budget statement and our excellent spending commitments over the next three years, we find the SNP still clutching at political straws on every occasion. At the moment, there is a well-known television programme called "The Weakest Link"—the SNP is Scotland's weakest link.
In welcoming the chancellor's pre-budget statement, the First Minister might be aware that fewer than 15 petrol stations in Scotland offer low-sulphur diesel and petrol. In light of that fact, how practical is a pragmatism that offers tax cuts on products that no one can buy?
If Ben Wallace had been listening closely to the chancellor's statement, he would know about the coincidence of two factors: Scotland will be provided with low-sulphur petrol and diesel in April 2001, which is the date from which the new measures that he outlined will apply. As the chancellor has spelled out that point, there should be no controversy over or difficulty with it. Of course, the major oil companies will ensure that those measures are applied.
Will the First Minister comment on the billions of pounds of extra public spending in Scotland as a result of the chancellor's stewardship of the economy? Would those funds have been available if we had followed Andrew Wilson's economic programme for the SNP? If the funds were available in those circumstances, would they be better spent on embassies and armed forces than on health and education?
I notice that one of Andrew Wilson's latest press releases was sent out from Valencia—that visit obviously coincided with his colleague's visit to Brussels.
I agree with Hugh Henry. [Members: "Oh."] I am quite happy to say it again: I agree with Hugh Henry. We are talking about real investment from both Westminster and Edinburgh that will benefit the Scottish people.
I will finish on a topical note to show what we get from the SNP. Yesterday, Jackie Baillie—
I agree with Hugh Henry. [Members: "Oh."] I am quite happy to say it again: I agree with Hugh Henry. We are talking about real investment from both Westminster and Edinburgh that will benefit the Scottish people.
I will finish on a topical note to show what we get from the SNP. Yesterday, Jackie Baillie—
That is not an answer.
The question is about policies, investment, equality and equal opportunities. That is important to us.
Yesterday, Fiona Hyslop had a great quote—perhaps I should start a competition. She said that Jackie Baillie's equality strategy was
"self-congratulatory, navel-gazing mince, which will mean hee-haw"—[Official Report, 8 November 2000; Vol. 8, c 1426.]
to people in Scotland. That sums up the differences between us. The Executive is taking the politics and the people of Scotland seriously; the SNP still means "Still No Policies" and it is still playing games.
Yesterday, Fiona Hyslop had a great quote—perhaps I should start a competition. She said that Jackie Baillie's equality strategy was
"self-congratulatory, navel-gazing mince, which will mean hee-haw"—[Official Report, 8 November 2000; Vol. 8, c 1426.]
to people in Scotland. That sums up the differences between us. The Executive is taking the politics and the people of Scotland seriously; the SNP still means "Still No Policies" and it is still playing games.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
That brings us to the end of question time. We now move to the debate—
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. As convener of the Health and Community Care Committee, I have been approached by committee members from three parties who are as concerned as I am at plans for an SNP debate on community care next week. That will happen only a matter of days before the publication of a committee report on which members from all parties have been working for 10 months. Committee members, including party spokespeople, will be in danger of revealing the content of a private report. In light of that fact, I seek your guidance on this matter and ask you to use your influence to delay the debate until after the report's publication so that all members can benefit from it.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
That is not really a matter for me; no doubt the Parliamentary Bureau will consider the situation at its meeting next Tuesday. However, in the interests of harmony in the chamber, I urge members to discuss the matter informally among themselves and see whether they can reach agreement on how to handle it.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. You will have noticed that, despite the fact that you ran three minutes over the allocated time, we reached only question 4 in the business bulletin. One of the major problems was the First Minister's misunderstanding of what First Minister's questions are. He did not really answer any questions; indeed, at one stage, he was even asking questions. Could you perhaps advise the First Minister on how to answer questions?
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
As I have said many times, ministerial answers are not a matter for the chair.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Nov 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 9 November 2000 Debate · 1
- Homelessness Statement · 15
- National Health Service Debate · 46
- Business Motion Business motions · 5
- Homeless People (Christmas) Questions · 7
- Young Carers Questions · 5
- Local Access Panels Questions · 6
- Mobile Phone Masts Questions · 10
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Scottish Qualifications Authority Questions · 8
- Flu Vaccines Questions · 12
- Rural Public Transport Questions · 13
- Employment (Career Breaks) Questions · 4
- Scottish Parliament (Autonomy) Questions · 11
- Energy Efficiency Questions · 4
- Bridges (Funding) Questions · 8
- Post-adoption Services Questions · 4
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Scottish Executive Priorities First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Floods First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Budget (Devolved Matters) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Sport Debate · 77
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 29
- Alcohol Misuse Members’ business · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.