To ask the First Minister what measures are already in place to prevent flood damage in Scotland this winter and what further action it intends to take in this respect. (S1F-644)
Official Report · Chamber
Floods
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Henry McLeish Lab 5
- Donald Gorrie LD 2
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
- Margaret Jamieson Lab 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
The record
10 contributionsThe Executive's priorities were set out—forgive me, we are on question 3.
Local authorities have already constructed more than 50 flood prevention schemes. Additional resources were made available from the spending review to allow councils to take forward further flood defence measures. Given the disastrous consequences of flooding, I am sure that councils will be urgently reviewing what action they can take to reduce the risk of flooding.
Local authorities have already constructed more than 50 flood prevention schemes. Additional resources were made available from the spending review to allow councils to take forward further flood defence measures. Given the disastrous consequences of flooding, I am sure that councils will be urgently reviewing what action they can take to reduce the risk of flooding.
I ask the First Minister to give assurances on two points. First, will he examine the planning system to ensure that no more residential developments are foolishly sited on low ground that is liable to flood? Secondly, will he—along the lines that he mentioned—agree a programme of priorities with local authorities to deal with flooding and fund that adequately? Given the choice between doing something more immediate—such as repairing a school—or dealing with potential floods, councils will naturally deal with the more immediate issue.
That question gives me the opportunity to make further remarks about the flooding. We were all grateful that we did not experience some of the difficulties that we saw in the south—especially in Yorkshire and the south-east.
I say to Donald Gorrie that we intend to take matters further. Local authorities and landowners have the first responsibilities, but Sam Galbraith is working hard to examine how best we can improve the situation.
Climate change will have consequences for Scotland and the United Kingdom over the next few years. In relation to the intensity and frequency of serious flooding, we can look forward—if that is the appropriate phrase—to an increase of between 5 and 15 per cent of such intense rainfall over the next 40 years. We therefore take this matter very seriously.
In addition to urging local authorities to consider their schemes and prepare new defences against flooding, we want to improve flood warnings. If a flood warning is given, the public should have the confidence to be able to react to it and get the necessary help much quicker. That is being considered. A meeting will soon be held with the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, at which Sam Galbraith will examine new measures to be taken. We want to improve emergency communication measures.
Funding will be made available. Over the past few years, £4 million has been used each year for such activities. Over the next three years, that figure will rise to £8.5 million, £9 million and £10 million. There will be consequentials, as a result of the situation in England and Wales, from the £50 million that was announced by John Prescott at the weekend.
We intend to move rapidly to ensure that public confidence is inherent in the system. The environment is a crucial issue in Scotland and what we are doing now will help to allay fears and, more important, tackle what will be serious problems in the future if we do not reinforce our procedures.
I say to Donald Gorrie that we intend to take matters further. Local authorities and landowners have the first responsibilities, but Sam Galbraith is working hard to examine how best we can improve the situation.
Climate change will have consequences for Scotland and the United Kingdom over the next few years. In relation to the intensity and frequency of serious flooding, we can look forward—if that is the appropriate phrase—to an increase of between 5 and 15 per cent of such intense rainfall over the next 40 years. We therefore take this matter very seriously.
In addition to urging local authorities to consider their schemes and prepare new defences against flooding, we want to improve flood warnings. If a flood warning is given, the public should have the confidence to be able to react to it and get the necessary help much quicker. That is being considered. A meeting will soon be held with the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, at which Sam Galbraith will examine new measures to be taken. We want to improve emergency communication measures.
Funding will be made available. Over the past few years, £4 million has been used each year for such activities. Over the next three years, that figure will rise to £8.5 million, £9 million and £10 million. There will be consequentials, as a result of the situation in England and Wales, from the £50 million that was announced by John Prescott at the weekend.
We intend to move rapidly to ensure that public confidence is inherent in the system. The environment is a crucial issue in Scotland and what we are doing now will help to allay fears and, more important, tackle what will be serious problems in the future if we do not reinforce our procedures.
Is the First Minister aware that the gaps in the banks of the Water of Leith are urgently in need of reinforcement and that other flood-prevention measures are required? Will he give sturdy advice and guidance to local authorities to put flood prevention measures effectively in place well in advance of flooding occurring—especially in such places as the Hanover (Scotland) Housing Association's old folk's home in Stockbridge, which Sam Galbraith and I visited a few days ago?
I am happy to give those assurances. We have a fairly settled pattern of difficulties in Scotland, as we have seen over the past few days. The local authorities must ensure that their defences are strengthened, and Sam Galbraith has asked them to do that. Other parts of Scotland will be affected over the next 10, 20, 30 or 40 years, so that advice is not just for the local authorities that are experiencing difficulties, but to ensure that other areas of Scotland, which might be affected and have scientific evidence to confirm that, will take the necessary steps so that public life and property are protected.
Will the First Minister assure my constituents and East Ayrshire Council that he will give due consideration to speeding up the process of agreeing flood prevention applications, thereby alleviating the persistent problems of the flooding of homes and businesses?
Again, I am happy to give that assurance. This situation demands strategic operations and getting the logistics right. Resources are available and I urge local authorities to ensure that they have done what Sam Galbraith has suggested—to review procedures. Whether in Kilmarnock or in other parts of Scotland, we are very willing to help, and I think that the local authorities will respond.
I am sure that the minister is aware that many embankment schemes simply push problems further downstream or upstream. Will the Executive take seriously the concepts that are being developed by groups such as the Forth Estuary Forum for managed retreat and for increasing the number of water meadows as part of the flood control measures?
The Executive is preparing a number of reports and is considering the science that is coming from global organisations for use in the future. We are also examining the quality of flood defence procedures and structures. We will seek to take advantage of the best available science to inform us of what is happening.
The point is well made about planning authorities and building—that is a commonsense issue. We hope that this issue will impact a bit more on some planning decisions than it has done in the past. However, we are keen not just to push problems further down the system. We must recognise that any steps that are taken may have a knock-on adverse effect on lives and property.
The point is well made about planning authorities and building—that is a commonsense issue. We hope that this issue will impact a bit more on some planning decisions than it has done in the past. However, we are keen not just to push problems further down the system. We must recognise that any steps that are taken may have a knock-on adverse effect on lives and property.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Nov 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 9 November 2000 Debate · 1
- Homelessness Statement · 15
- National Health Service Debate · 46
- Business Motion Business motions · 5
- Homeless People (Christmas) Questions · 7
- Young Carers Questions · 5
- Local Access Panels Questions · 6
- Mobile Phone Masts Questions · 10
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Scottish Qualifications Authority Questions · 8
- Flu Vaccines Questions · 12
- Rural Public Transport Questions · 13
- Employment (Career Breaks) Questions · 4
- Scottish Parliament (Autonomy) Questions · 11
- Energy Efficiency Questions · 4
- Bridges (Funding) Questions · 8
- Post-adoption Services Questions · 4
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Scottish Executive Priorities First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Floods First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Budget (Devolved Matters) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Sport Debate · 77
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 29
- Alcohol Misuse Members’ business · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.