Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Govan Shipyard

First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 13 January 2000 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 9 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
Duncan McNeil Lab Greenock and Inverclyde
link
To ask the First Minister what steps have been taken by Scottish ministers to support the bid to build up to six roll-on-roll-off ferries for the Ministry of Defence at BAE Systems' Govan shipyard. (S1F-17) The First Minister (Donald Dewar): Scottish

ministers are fully aware that that order is critically important in securing a future for the BAE Systems yard in Govan. The Secretary of State for Defence is aware of and appreciates the strong support for Govan's bid from all—I hope—the parties in Scotland. He is also aware of the industrial and strategic importance of that particular order.

Duncan McNeil Lab Greenock and Inverclyde
link
I welcome the First Minister's answer, and I am sure that my colleagues in the cross-party shipbuilding group will do so as well.

As the First Minister said, the bid is important not only for people in Govan—many people in my constituency work there.

This is a major contract, and securing it would mean three years of job security and would lay real foundations for a long-term future. Does the First Minister agree that it would be an absolute failure and a severe blow to the industry if the contract went outside the United Kingdom?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
As Duncan McNeil and most members will appreciate, one of the problems is that this is not a warship contract—it is a contract for commercially operated ferries. The protection for Royal Navy orders that allows us to confine bids to UK yards therefore does not apply.

It is also fair to remind the chamber that the hulls—which would be Govan's contribution if the Sea Lion Consortium were to be successful—are a comparatively small part of the total contract, which includes the running and management of the ferries over a number of years.

It is a complex and difficult situation. I have great faith in Govan and in the work force there. They have done remarkably well to survive recent crises and difficulties. However, it is only prudent and fair to remind people that this is a competitive tender, and that Govan's bid will therefore have to be competitive. With the workers' skills, I very much hope that it will be. Everyone in the chamber will certainly wish Govan well and will do everything that they can to give it a fair wind.

My colleague Henry McLeish has met not only the representatives of the work force, but senior management from BAE Systems. We all hope that there will be a happy outcome, which the yard deserves.

Ben Wallace Con North East Scotland
link
Will the First Minister make representations to the Secretary of State for Defence, to ensure that Scotland puts forward the best possible case to secure the contract for the two supercarriers that are due to be ordered in the next few years for the Ministry of Defence?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
That is a rather more general question about different orders, and I might get into difficulty if I went too far down that road.

We are in an age in which the competitiveness of the tender and the ability to meet the technical specifications are the first essential requirements for any successful bid. Orders of this importance are not and should not normally be settled on competitive lobbying, but are settled on the ability to deliver. That is a truism which we should not lose sight of.

Sir David Steel The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
We will have one last question, from Jamie Stone.

Jamie Stone LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
link
As I will not get to ask my coppers question, I will repeat Ben Wallace's question and ask the First Minister to consider the BARMAC yards and—

Sir David Steel The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
I called Mr Stone to ask question 5 on police funding. He has blown it, Mr Dewar, but you may answer.

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
The BARMAC question definitely goes somewhat wide of the original question 5, but I understand Jamie Stone's concern and interest. The situation is difficult, because we have lost a large number of jobs up there in what is, admittedly, a cyclical industry. The support group for oil and gas fabricators is sitting at the moment. The Government is at that table along with the owners, and we will do all that we can to encourage the industry—although, as I am sure Jamie Stone recognises, the present stage of development in the North sea makes it harder to find the kind of large platform orders that have traditionally gone to BARMAC and yards like it.

It may be of little comfort at the moment, but I was pleased to see that the yard at Methil had this week at least obtained an order worth, I think, £14 million for a structure. We have to hope that the steps that the Government has taken to stimulate the oil industry and exploration in the North sea will, over a period, bring some recovery to an industry that is of real importance to the Highlands.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 13 January 2000 Debate · 4
  2. Housing Debate · 183
  3. Lead Committee Debate · 6
  4. Question Time Questions · 1
  5. Rural Communities Questions · 8
  6. Housing (Stock Transfer) Questions · 10
  7. Drug Rehabilitation Questions · 6
  8. Parliamentary Debates Questions · 5
  9. Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust Questions · 7
  10. Oban Hospital Questions · 9
  11. Carers Questions · 5
  12. Roads (M74) Questions · 6
  13. 2001 Census Questions · 8
  14. Foreign Language Teaching Questions · 3
  15. Local Government Finance Questions · 5
  16. Landfill Questions · 3
  17. French Beef Questions · 6
  18. EU Beef Labelling Scheme Questions · 5
  19. Rural Schools (Traffic Calming) Questions · 3
  20. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 19
  21. National Health Service First Minister’s Questions · 7
  22. Govan Shipyard First Minister’s Questions · 9
  23. Housing Debate · 77
  24. Representation of the People Bill Bill debate · 3
  25. Membership of Committees Debate · 5
  26. Decision Time Decision time · 30
  27. Social Workers and Violence Members’ business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.