To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will make a statement on the questions to be included in the 2001 census and in particular whether there will be any questions seeking information about religious denomination. (S1O-907)
Official Report · Chamber
2001 Census
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Wallace LD 4
- Karen Whitefield Lab 2
- Irene McGugan SNP 1
- Keith Raffan LD 1
The record
8 contributionsDetails of our proposals for the 2001 census in Scotland were announced last Monday when the draft census order in council was laid before the Parliament. It is not proposed to include a question on religion. We believe that, in Scottish circumstances, alternative ways of collecting information on religion will be a more appropriate way of meeting user needs. We plan to do that by sample surveys.
I thank the minister for his response, but I must say that I am somewhat disappointed. Is he aware that research undertaken by the social and public health sciences unit of the University of Glasgow indicates that there are differences in health and employment opportunities between Catholics and people of Irish descent and non-Catholics? Does he feel that, in line with our commitment to tackling exclusion, there is a need to gain further and more substantial information on the matter, and that the inclusion of a question on religion in the 2001 census, which will happen in other parts of the United Kingdom, would provide that information?
I appreciate that this is an important issue. We have received a number of representations about it, all of which were given careful consideration. However, the conclusion was reached that the census was not the appropriate vehicle for gathering the sort of worthwhile information on this subject to which Karen Whitefield has referred. It can be difficult to identify how such a question is to be answered. For example, is a Christian a communicant Church member or someone who attends church regularly or irregularly?
We accept the point that, in advancing our equality strategy, some of that information must be made available. However, we believe that an examination of qualitative issues, such as the relevance of religion to promoting social inclusion and equality in the wider context of culture and lifestyle, can be better done and the results better achieved through sample surveys. That is what we are committed to doing.
We accept the point that, in advancing our equality strategy, some of that information must be made available. However, we believe that an examination of qualitative issues, such as the relevance of religion to promoting social inclusion and equality in the wider context of culture and lifestyle, can be better done and the results better achieved through sample surveys. That is what we are committed to doing.
Can the minister provide the reasons for not including a question on the Scots language in the census? Is there scope for amendment of the draft census order under the terms of the Census Act 1920?
We received a number of representations about the Scots language, but it appears from research that the Scots language means different things to different people, in terms
of what would be understood in answering the question. The proposal was rejected, as research undertaken on behalf of the Registrar General showed that such a question would not work well because there was no demonstrable need for it at a small-area level, for which census information is important.
It is my understanding that, in some cases, it may be possible to amend the order that was laid. I will confirm in a letter to Irene McGugan whether that question is one that can be amended. Any amendment would have to proceed by way of primary legislation because there is no provision in the Census Act 1920 for a question on religion.
of what would be understood in answering the question. The proposal was rejected, as research undertaken on behalf of the Registrar General showed that such a question would not work well because there was no demonstrable need for it at a small-area level, for which census information is important.
It is my understanding that, in some cases, it may be possible to amend the order that was laid. I will confirm in a letter to Irene McGugan whether that question is one that can be amended. Any amendment would have to proceed by way of primary legislation because there is no provision in the Census Act 1920 for a question on religion.
Is the minister aware of the concern among ethnic minorities that the previous census grossly underestimated their numbers? What consultations has he had with ethnic minority groups to try to overcome that problem, particularly in terms of the range of languages that can be used on the census form and on the way in which the census is conducted?
There was considerable consultation following the publication of a white paper by the UK Government before the establishment of this Parliament. Many ethnic groups were involved in that consultation. There will be a question on ethnicity in the census, and it is my understanding that census forms can be made available with translation.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Jan 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 13 January 2000 Debate · 4
- Housing Debate · 183
- Lead Committee Debate · 6
- Question Time Questions · 1
- Rural Communities Questions · 8
- Housing (Stock Transfer) Questions · 10
- Drug Rehabilitation Questions · 6
- Parliamentary Debates Questions · 5
- Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust Questions · 7
- Oban Hospital Questions · 9
- Carers Questions · 5
- Roads (M74) Questions · 6
- 2001 Census Questions · 8
- Foreign Language Teaching Questions · 3
- Local Government Finance Questions · 5
- Landfill Questions · 3
- French Beef Questions · 6
- EU Beef Labelling Scheme Questions · 5
- Rural Schools (Traffic Calming) Questions · 3
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 19
- National Health Service First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Govan Shipyard First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Housing Debate · 77
- Representation of the People Bill Bill debate · 3
- Membership of Committees Debate · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 30
- Social Workers and Violence Members’ business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.