To ask the Scottish Executive what support exists in Scotland to assist schoolchildren suffering from dyslexia. (S1O-874) The Minister for Children and Education (Mr Sam Galbraith): The Scottish Executive provides £5 million to local authorities for in-service special educational needs staff development and training, including training in dyslexia.
Official Report · Chamber
Dyslexia
Open Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sam Galbraith Lab 5
- Annabel Goldie Con 3
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 3
- Sir David Steel 3
- Johann Lamont Lab 1
- Duncan Hamilton SNP 1
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 1
The record
17 contributionsI am obliged to the minister. Given that there is no standard screening programme in Scottish schools to identify children suffering from dyslexia, and that dyslexia has no respect for age, sex or background, does Mr Galbraith agree that to consider such an initiative would be an encouraging demonstration of the Executive's social inclusion policy? In particular, will the Executive consider entering into dialogue with the Dyslexia Institute of Scotland?
Yes. The member is right—it is important to pick up dyslexia early if it is to be dealt with effectively. I am pleased to be able to tell her that in 1998-99, 165 teachers received training in dyslexia awareness and early identification of it through a project funded jointly by the Scottish Executive and the Scottish Dyslexia Trust. The expansion of pre-school education and early intervention will also help us to identify earlier those children who suffer from dyslexia.
I thank the minister for expanding on that point, but does he agree that the absence of a standard programme is an alarming omission? There are clear disparities between different communities in Scotland. Is not that a matter for some concern, which the Executive could usefully address?
Yes. One of the reasons why we set up the special educational needs advisory forum was to highlight such problems before they develop to the stage where they present significant difficulties. Standard guidance was established several years ago and there is specific guidance on children with dyslexia. The framework is in place, but we are not complacent about it. We set up the special educational needs advisory forum to keep us informed. We have put money into additional training on dyslexia and into special educational needs in general. I hope that the member will be assured that that package goes some way towards rectifying the problem that she rightly identified.
Will the minister join me in welcoming the young people who have come here this afternoon to speak to members and to ask us difficult questions about the education service that we provide? Does he recognise the importance of providing for a broad range of special needs and for, for example, bullying? Does he agree that the key to delivering the service will be to listen to young people, who have so much to say on such issues?
I take a particular interest in consulting those who are involved in the service. We must always remember that the basis of any service should be delivery to the users of the service, not its producers. I have spent a considerable amount of time consulting in several areas, and not just through the consultation programme for the education bill. The Executive is spending large sums of additional money on special educational needs. The recent Riddell report has resulted in the creation of the special educational needs advisory forum. We have done a lot of work on the subject.
Is Mr Galbraith aware that many of the schoolchildren who suffer from dyslexia also suffer from dyspraxia? Will he tell us what resources the Executive is putting into provision for that?
As the member knows, dyspraxia is related to fine movements—there is disjunction of fine movements, particularly in the hands, but also in facial and oral muscles. We are putting money into dealing with dyslexia, dyspraxia and all areas of special educational needs that must be addressed.
Will the minister ensure that the education bill includes a presumption that all children with special needs will be taught within mainstream education?
Yes. I am not sure if I am allowed to say this before the bill comes to the Parliament—the bill is currently with you, Presiding Officer, and we hope that it will be available to everyone at the start of next year—but it is my intention to put a presumption in the bill that individuals with special educational needs will be taught in mainstream schooling. I do not want to put that into the bill just yet, until it has been fully consulted on. I will be asking the special educational needs advisory forum to consult us. I hope that it will be able to come back to me in time to get that presumption into the bill.
On a point of order. I am not entirely sure whether this, strictly speaking, will qualify as a point of order. [Interruption.]
No doubt you will keep me right, Presiding Officer—and the members of the Conservative party ought to just listen because this will affect them as well.
At 2.55 pm I received an e-mail about the new year information technology arrangements for the Parliament. I quote:
"The Scottish Parliament network will close for the New Year as from 1700 hours on 30th December and will reopen at 0900 hours on 5 January. This will mean that access is denied to all users, including Dial-In use."
The e-mail continues:
"During this period, all e-mails received will be held and distributed to their recipients when they logon on 5 January."
I do not suppose that for a day or two in that period any of us will be looking at our e-mails or trying to work, but—for those of us who rely entirely on the network for their work load—this is a ridiculously intrusive and disruptive length of time to shut the network down. As we are going into recess in a couple of hours, I ask that we make representations—through you, Presiding Officer—that that decision cannot be allowed to stand.
No doubt you will keep me right, Presiding Officer—and the members of the Conservative party ought to just listen because this will affect them as well.
At 2.55 pm I received an e-mail about the new year information technology arrangements for the Parliament. I quote:
"The Scottish Parliament network will close for the New Year as from 1700 hours on 30th December and will reopen at 0900 hours on 5 January. This will mean that access is denied to all users, including Dial-In use."
The e-mail continues:
"During this period, all e-mails received will be held and distributed to their recipients when they logon on 5 January."
I do not suppose that for a day or two in that period any of us will be looking at our e-mails or trying to work, but—for those of us who rely entirely on the network for their work load—this is a ridiculously intrusive and disruptive length of time to shut the network down. As we are going into recess in a couple of hours, I ask that we make representations—through you, Presiding Officer—that that decision cannot be allowed to stand.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Technically, that probably was not a point of order, but it was a point of importance. The Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body discussed that matter in detail some time ago, and we decided that the safest period to shut down the system was from 30 December to 5 January, to ensure that millennium bug issues were sorted out before the network went live again in the new year. There will be public holidays on 3 and 4 January; while I admire Roseanna Cunningham's assiduity, I cannot believe that she will need the system on 31 December or 1 January.
Further to the point of order.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
It is not a point of order, but let us hear it anyway.
Despite the fact that this is brand new technology, and despite the fact that all our laptops and computers have been dealt with over the past few weeks and months, presumably to make them millennium compliant, are we being told that they are not?
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
You must remember that the corporate body is a collection of lay men and women, just as we all are. We considered the issue and took professional advice; the e-mail gives the view that we arrived at. We can, perhaps, argue outside the chamber about your point, but let us start the health debate now.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 Dec 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 16 December 1999 Statement · 2
- Motion without notice Business motions · 75
- Act of Settlement Debate · 101
- Hampden Park Debate · 32
- Business Motion Business motions · 14
- Deputy Conveners Debate · 7
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Prime Minister (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Housing Partnership Initiative Questions · 4
- Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority Questions · 3
- Prisons Questions · 3
- Rural Schools Questions · 3
- Prostate Cancer Questions · 3
- Poverty Questions · 4
- Child Welfare Questions · 3
- Prisoners (Drug Misuse) Questions · 3
- Pig Farming Questions · 5
- Hunting with Dogs Questions · 3
- Rural Transport Strategy Questions · 3
- Smoking Questions · 4
- Local Authority Leisure Facilities Questions · 4
- Road Accidents Questions · 3
- Holyrood Project Questions · 5
- Housing Questions · 3
- Child Care Strategy Questions · 4
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 16
- Dyslexia Questions · 17
- Health Service Debate · 151
- Decision Time Decision time · 31
- Cornton Vale Prison Members’ business · 29
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.