To ask the Scottish Executive what assessment it has made of the impact of the "Barnett squeeze" on the resources available for public services in Scotland. (S1O-805)
Official Report · Chamber
Public Services
Open Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jack McConnell Lab 7
- Andrew Wilson SNP 2
- Sir David Steel 2
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 1
- Kay Ullrich SNP 1
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
- Donald Gorrie LD 1
- David Davidson Con 1
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
17 contributionsThe Barnett formula delivers the same increases or decreases in spending per head on comparable programmes in Scotland as are planned in England.
Is the Minister for Finance aware that, according to Professor Brian Ashcroft
of the University of Strathclyde, spending on public services in England will increase two and a half times more quickly during this Administration than it will in Scotland? Is he aware that, as was pointed out yesterday, Labour will spend less during this Administration than was spent under the Conservatives? Is he further aware that, despite the warm words and deceitful spin, Labour is not delivering for Scottish public services?
of the University of Strathclyde, spending on public services in England will increase two and a half times more quickly during this Administration than it will in Scotland? Is he aware that, as was pointed out yesterday, Labour will spend less during this Administration than was spent under the Conservatives? Is he further aware that, despite the warm words and deceitful spin, Labour is not delivering for Scottish public services?
I am aware that Mr Wilson's claims are complete and total rubbish. By the end of the comprehensive spending review, this coalition Administration and the Government at Westminster will be spending more money per head, not only in Scotland but throughout the United Kingdom, than the Tories did at the high point of their spending in 1994-95. As I said yesterday, the amount of money spent on local government in Scotland will be higher this year, next year and the year after that than it was under the Tories' plans for the same period.
Will the Minister for Finance provide the SNP with a maths teacher—Mr Canavan springs to mind—to explain to its members that if one starts with a higher base and gets the same expenditure boost as from a lower base, the higher base necessarily creates a lower percentage increase?
The problem with the SNP is that, as someone said last week, it wants to take Scotland out of Britain instead of taking poverty out of Scotland. The real divide in this country is between the rich and the poor, not between Scotland and England, and those constant comparisons do no good whatever for Scotland.
Will the minister confirm that health spending in Scotland in the next financial period will not match the level of spending in England and Wales, and that that means a loss of £400 in health terms for every man, woman and child in Scotland?
It is absolutely shocking that the health spokesperson for a major political party in Scotland does not know that health spending in this country is 20 per cent higher per head than it is in England. [Applause.] The coalition Administration is committed to ensuring that health spending will be at its highest level ever by the end of this Parliament.
Will the Minister for Finance give a rough estimate of the additional expenditure that would be involved in implementing the promises already made by the SNP, over and above the fact that the Scottish block budget is 18 per cent higher than the average budget for English regions?
I may have been a mathematics teacher, and my arithmetic and algebra were both very good, but I am afraid that I have had problems with exponential functions as a pupil, a student and a teacher. [Laughter.] However, I will certainly try to do what Dr Simpson suggests and will publish the results in due course.
Will the minister take issue with the Chancellor of the Exchequer to secure more spending on a UK basis to which the Barnett formula might then apply?
Mr Gorrie asked me the same question yesterday. Discussions are constantly taking place between departments here in Scotland and at UK level on overall spending and on the expenditure that is appropriate in any given area; those discussions will continue. I must stress, as I have done on a number of occasions since June, that this Parliament must ensure that the money that we spend—some £17 billion—is spent in the best possible way on the services that we provide. I do not believe that constant comparisons, to which this question time has occasionally stooped, between expenditure in Scotland and in England are the best way forward for this Parliament. We were elected to make best use of the money that we have. If we do that, we will be serving Scotland well.
As he is in expansive mood today, will the minister kindly tell the chamber why, week after week, he insists on talking in cash terms and not in real terms, so making his spending look important?
If Mr Davidson listened occasionally, he would have heard that, in my earlier answer to Mr Wilson's question, I said that, by the end of the comprehensive spending review, real-terms spending in Scotland and in the rest of the UK will be significantly higher than it was at the very highest point of spending under the Conservative Government in 1994-95. That is in real terms—real real terms—which is why it will count more.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
That concludes question time.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. I draw your attention to a matter of which I have already given notice to you and to the Deputy Minister for Rural Affairs, Mr John Home Robertson. It refers to an issue that I raised in yesterday's debate, when I queried nephrops allocations for the Clyde fishing area—
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Hang on, Mr Gallie. Quite courteously, you gave me notice of this but, before you go any further, I have to say that it is not a point of order. You are arguing about the
content of a ministerial answer; I am afraid that you will have to take that up with the minister.
content of a ministerial answer; I am afraid that you will have to take that up with the minister.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Dec 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 9 December 1999 Debate · 9
- National Waste Strategy Statement · 29
- Housing Debate · 24
- Draft Standing Orders Debate · 14
- Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 24
- Business Motion Business motions · 12
- Amnesic Shellfish Poisoning Debate · 4
- Devolution Debate · 8
- Rural General Practitioners Questions · 3
- Strategic Rail Authority Questions · 4
- Anti-drug Education Programme Questions · 4
- Student Finance Questions · 6
- National Park Questions · 3
- Roads (A75) Questions · 5
- Fire Service Questions · 5
- Banking Facilities Questions · 3
- Hill Farming Questions · 3
- Landfill Questions · 3
- Pig Industry Questions · 5
- Fur Farming Questions · 3
- Teachers Questions · 3
- Airport Rail Links Questions · 3
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities Questions · 3
- Concessionary Fares Questions · 3
- Polio Centre Questions · 3
- Secretary of State for Trade and Industry(Meetings) Questions · 3
- Island General Practitioners Questions · 3
- Local Government Boundaries Questions · 3
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 26
- Public Services Questions · 17
- Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 27
- Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 25
- Pollokshaws Sports Centre Members’ business · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.