Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Higher Education

Open Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 16 September 1999 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 7 contributions · 2 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
To ask the Scottish Executive what are the details of its higher education policy. (S1O-318) The First Minister (Donald Dewar): We are committed to the highest standards in further and higher education on the principle that anyone who can benefit from it should have the opportunity to do so. As Alex Salmond will remember, if we take the comprehensive spending review period, the additional funds for higher education compared with the figure that we inherited amount to £250 million. He will have read the programme for government document, and will therefore know that that sets out our priorities on how to deliver our policies.

Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
Both the First Minister and I benefited from student grants and no tuition fees.

Can the First Minister explain the rights of this Parliament and clear up some confusion that has crept in? After a suggestion that a vote against tuition fees would not be binding on the Parliament, an Executive spokesperson, in what was described as a carefully phrased statement, said:

"The Executive would always wish to take into account the views expressed by the Parliament".

It is reassuring to know that our views will be taken into account, but this is a Parliament, so I ask the First Minister: if this Parliament passes by resolution a motion against tuition fees, will it be binding on the Executive, yes or no?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
The position is simply that this Parliament is master at the end of the day, but that not every motion that is passed by this Parliament is binding upon the Executive. If the Executive did not respond in a way that Parliament found satisfactory, a whole range of democratic options is open to Parliament. I leave to Mr Salmond the selection that he might want to make if the circumstance occurred.

We are all, if we are sensible, waiting for the response from Andrew Cubie and his colleagues with regard to tuition fees. We will all want to look at what is a complex matter, and if Mr Salmond has been following, as I have, the evidence that has been submitted by various organisations, he will see that the issue requires not a snatched or prejudiced decision, but a long, careful and proper look at the evidence. That is what the Executive, and I hope this Parliament, will do.

Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
On the evidence that has been submitted by various organisations, the Conservative party, the Liberal Democrat party and the Scottish National party have all submitted evidence against tuition fees. There has been no submission of evidence by the Labour party in Scotland. Can the First Minister remind this Parliament when the Labour party in Scotland passed a motion in favour of tuition fees for higher education?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
I do not know the extent to which I can talk on party matters, as I am here to answer questions as a member of the Executive, but if I may be allowed the indulgence, the Labour party is in favour of widening access to higher education and ensuring that we sustain the improvements that we have seen in the past, but which until recently have been undermined by the lack of proper financing. The financing system that is required is the conundrum that the Cubie committee has been invited to consider. Of course, that is the problem that we in the Parliament must address—not just the Executive, but the elected body representing all parts of Scotland.

The important fact is that an elected body that is to command trust is one that will be prepared to look and listen and make a considered judgment about the advice and the evidence that come out of the Cubie inquiry.

Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
To my knowledge, no resolution has been passed in favour of tuition fees by the Labour party in Scotland, nor did the words "tuition fees" appear in the Labour party manifesto for this year's election. Those of us who did have a manifesto commitment against tuition fees looked with some warmth at the words of Iain Smith on Monday, when he said about the Liberal Democrats:

"We will vote against tuition fees. There has never been room for compromise on that".

I welcome those words, but does the First Minister consider them compatible with his definition of collective responsibility in his Executive?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
I have said this consistently, and I hope that no one will criticise me for repeating it. I believe that it is in everyone's interest to consider the evidence that is produced, to measure their approach against that evidence and to come to a conclusion that they believe is right. I have always understood that the Liberal Democrat party had a position and that it would submit evidence in support of that. When the Cubie report comes out and the evidence is there, we will see whether that ameliorates things or changes views.

If Alex Salmond is telling me that his position is that he has taken up a stance, and in the face of all the evidence—whatever it might suggest—he

will never alter that stance, he is taking an unwise position. That is a matter entirely for him. We will examine the evidence and consult our friends, and the Executive will decide on the best way forward in the interest of higher education in Scotland. If we had a constructive debate rather than scare stories, that would help the cause considerably.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 16 September 1999 Debate · 6
  2. Non-Executive Business: Transport Debate · 240
  3. Business Motion Business motions · 7
  4. Continental Tyres Debate · 16
  5. Stracathro Hospital Questions · 3
  6. Scottish Joint Negotiating Committee Questions · 4
  7. Finance Questions · 4
  8. Student Awards Agency Questions · 3
  9. Domestic Violence Questions · 4
  10. Scottish University for Industry Questions · 4
  11. Ministerial Meetings Questions · 6
  12. Inverness College Questions · 3
  13. Deer Farming Questions · 5
  14. Rail Services Questions · 4
  15. Health Care Questions · 3
  16. Tourism Questions · 3
  17. Education Service Questions · 4
  18. St Mary's Episcopal Primary School, Dunblane Questions · 7
  19. Fisheries Questions · 5
  20. Stracathro Hospital Questions · 3
  21. “Making it work together” Questions · 5
  22. Local Government Finance Questions · 4
  23. Health Care Questions · 3
  24. People's Juries Questions · 3
  25. Higher Education Questions · 7
  26. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 9
  27. Objective 2 Funding Questions · 9
  28. Water Industry Statement · 32
  29. Homelessness Debate · 52
  30. Decision Time Decision time · 31
  31. Salmon Farming Members’ business · 27

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.