I ask the Scottish Executive to join me in welcoming the leader of Plaid Cymru, Dafydd Wigley, who is with us today. [Applause.] To ask the Scottish Executivewhether it intends making representations to Her Majesty's Government requesting an increase in the Scottish block. (S1O-302)
Official Report · Chamber
Finance
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Neil SNP 2
- Jack McConnell Lab 2
The record
4 contributionsI have a choice of answers: I could say yes to the first question and ignore the second one. I welcome our colleague from Wales.
The present system for funding Scotland's budget has produced a fair settlement over a number of years. The arrangements for agreeing that settlement are set out in the statement on funding policy that was published by Her Majesty's Treasury on 31 March 1999. The Executive will make representations from time to time for increases in the Scottish budget in line with the circumstances that are set out in that document.
The present system for funding Scotland's budget has produced a fair settlement over a number of years. The arrangements for agreeing that settlement are set out in the statement on funding policy that was published by Her Majesty's Treasury on 31 March 1999. The Executive will make representations from time to time for increases in the Scottish budget in line with the circumstances that are set out in that document.
Is the minister aware of the independent report that was prepared by the London-based Centre for Economics and Business Research and published a couple of weeks ago, which shows that Scotland is a net contributor to the UK Treasury? We are paying more taxes in than we are getting money back out. Does he not agree that, rather than subsidising the UK Treasury, it would be far better for Scotland to get its own money back in order to use it to settle the teachers' dispute and to abolish tuition fees without robbing any other budget in Scotland?
I am tempted to say no this time. However, I have two points that I want to make. First, as I have said, Scotland does very well out of our national agreement with the UK Treasury. The comprehensive spending review last year produced £800 million—sorry, produced £800 of extra public expenditure over the next three years for every man, woman and child in Scotland. It will produce an extra £1.8 billion for health and £1.3 billion for education.
Another London-based report that was published yesterday was welcomed this morning by Mr Wilson on behalf of the Scottish National party. However, last December he described the same organisation as talking economic gibberish when it accurately reported that Scotland would be a very large debtor of public expenditure if it went down the route that Mr Neil wants to follow, even if some of his front-bench colleagues now have reservations about independence.
Another London-based report that was published yesterday was welcomed this morning by Mr Wilson on behalf of the Scottish National party. However, last December he described the same organisation as talking economic gibberish when it accurately reported that Scotland would be a very large debtor of public expenditure if it went down the route that Mr Neil wants to follow, even if some of his front-bench colleagues now have reservations about independence.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 Sep 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 16 September 1999 Debate · 6
- Non-Executive Business: Transport Debate · 240
- Business Motion Business motions · 7
- Continental Tyres Debate · 16
- Stracathro Hospital Questions · 3
- Scottish Joint Negotiating Committee Questions · 4
- Finance Questions · 4
- Student Awards Agency Questions · 3
- Domestic Violence Questions · 4
- Scottish University for Industry Questions · 4
- Ministerial Meetings Questions · 6
- Inverness College Questions · 3
- Deer Farming Questions · 5
- Rail Services Questions · 4
- Health Care Questions · 3
- Tourism Questions · 3
- Education Service Questions · 4
- St Mary's Episcopal Primary School, Dunblane Questions · 7
- Fisheries Questions · 5
- Stracathro Hospital Questions · 3
- “Making it work together” Questions · 5
- Local Government Finance Questions · 4
- Health Care Questions · 3
- People's Juries Questions · 3
- Higher Education Questions · 7
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 9
- Objective 2 Funding Questions · 9
- Water Industry Statement · 32
- Homelessness Debate · 52
- Decision Time Decision time · 31
- Salmon Farming Members’ business · 27
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.