Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Devolution

Wednesday 2 June 1999 Meeting of the Parliament Debate 96 contributions · 27 speakers

Speakers

Showing Allan Wilson only · show everyone
3 more speakers

Allan Wilson’s contributions

3 contributions
Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link
There has been much self-righteousness and indignation in this chamber and in the press about the principle of democracy when the real issue is the price of democracy. At issue is the use of taxpayers' money to fund political opposition. It seems to me that taxpayers resolved to fund this Parliament, but opposition is not limitless and the public purse is not bottomless. What has been proposed appears to be fair and reasonable to Opposition parties and taxpayers.

The Opposition parties seem to want to have their cake—then more of that cake—and eat it. They cannot have it both ways: aping Westminster when the politics suits, but rejecting Westminster when it does not. The two systems are different. The Westminster system takes account of the fact that some parties, such as the SNP, get a lot of votes but few seats. The Scottish system is distinct. The number of seats is more closely proportional to the number of votes. The total amount of funding for Opposition parties being distributed in Scotland is broadly comparable to that distributed in Westminster. Transposing a new system from Westminster to Scotland would distort the existing system.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link
We debated the size of the

Scottish Executive the week before last and we agreed its size. Taxpayers will fund the Executive and it is right and proper that they should. I would not condone extravagance or waste by the Executive or by the Opposition parties.

Our job is to reach agreement on a new system that is suitable for Scotland and reflects the political and constitutional settlement that is this Parliament. Perhaps the first thing we should do is dispense with the term Short money, as any analyst can clearly identify that no Opposition party is going to be short of cash—quite the contrary. That is as it should be: it is democracy and democracy has to be paid for.

In another life, before I came here, I negotiated increases—usually increases—in wages and improvements in conditions for workers in the public sector. That was much more difficult during the Tory years. The arguments then were similar to those that we hear today; the merits of the claim must be set against the ability to pay. If I had negotiated a sixfold increase in public funding for my members I would be a hero and a popular figure among them—probably much more popular than the SNP appears to be with the Scottish people.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link
No, I am going to finish.

What is now being proposed is arguably fair and generous. We will have the opportunity to debate the matter as it is a section 30 order. It is appropriate that the Scottish Parliament should fix things. It is incongruous for a nationalist party to refer the matter outside this Parliament for it to be decided on elsewhere.

  1. Scottish Parliament Wednesday 2 June 1999 Debate · 7
  2. Kenny Macintyre Debate · 4
  3. Business Motion Business motions · 42
  4. Devolution Debate · 96
  5. Decision Time Decision time · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.