The word democracy has been much bandied about today, particularly by Labour members. Perhaps Mr Chisholm and Mr McAllion have forgotten about the so-called democracy that was bandied about within the Scottish Labour party—if so, they have very short memories. Mr McAllion's speech seemed to be all about "do as we say or do as we do, or else".
Unfortunately, to me and to perhaps most of the people in the public galleries, democracy seems to have rolled over and died in this chamber since the formation of the Lib-Lab pact. The Labour party and the Liberal party in particular should be ashamed of themselves. They talk about effective opposition, but how can we have effective opposition if only the Liberal Democrat party gets any Short money? Why are the other Opposition parties not allowed to put forward their positions— not only the position of their parties but the position of the Scottish people who voted for them? This Parliament is supposed to be all about the Scottish people—the voters—and not about the Labour and Liberal parties getting together to form a pact so that they can deliver what is best for them.
The people in the gallery today have seen what I would call anti-democracy at work. This is supposed to be a new Parliament, but we are debating the same old things. The Labour party tells us that everything is wonderful for it, but because we—the SNP, the Tories and the three independents—are in opposition, we get nothing while the coalition party gets everything. That is all I have to say.
Unfortunately, to me and to perhaps most of the people in the public galleries, democracy seems to have rolled over and died in this chamber since the formation of the Lib-Lab pact. The Labour party and the Liberal party in particular should be ashamed of themselves. They talk about effective opposition, but how can we have effective opposition if only the Liberal Democrat party gets any Short money? Why are the other Opposition parties not allowed to put forward their positions— not only the position of their parties but the position of the Scottish people who voted for them? This Parliament is supposed to be all about the Scottish people—the voters—and not about the Labour and Liberal parties getting together to form a pact so that they can deliver what is best for them.
The people in the gallery today have seen what I would call anti-democracy at work. This is supposed to be a new Parliament, but we are debating the same old things. The Labour party tells us that everything is wonderful for it, but because we—the SNP, the Tories and the three independents—are in opposition, we get nothing while the coalition party gets everything. That is all I have to say.