Today's final petition deals with the environmental and planning issues relating to water treatment plants. This is the first time that we have considered the petition, which calls on the Parliament to investigate local authority regulation of water treatment plants as regards environmental protection and planning legislation, to investigate possible solutions to the problem of noxious odours and airborne bacteria from such plants and to investigate the level and method of investment needed to prevent the release of noxious odours and airborne bacteria.I ask members to note that Susan Deacon, who is unable to attend the meeting today, has indicated an interest in the issue and members should have before them comments that she has submitted by e-mail.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Water Treatment Plants (PE517)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bristow Muldoon Lab 5
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 2
- John Scott Con 2
- Angus MacKay Lab 1
- Bruce Crawford SNP 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
The record
13 contributionsThis is an extremely important petition and deserves a lot of study. My concern is that we do not have time in this session of Parliament to do it justice. The petition addresses the problem of odour, which seems impossible to deal with. We have come across it in relation to the spreading of organic waste and the burning of animal carcases in the Carntyne incinerator. We have to get to grips with the problem.It is suggested that we write to the Executive for further information, particularly on how to achieve odour control. I have had personal experience of similar cases and I know that it is difficult to get local authorities to agree that there is a problem. In this instance, however, it seems that the Scottish Environment Protection Agency is not taking responsibility either. The review of SEPA's responsibilities has not yet concluded and I hope that, when it is concluded, the gaps surrounding the issue of odour control are identified.As the matter needs a great deal of investigation and input, which will take time, I think that we should also refer the petition back to the Public Petitions Committee so that, after the election, the petition can be picked up again by whatever committee has transport within its remit.
It is unfortunate that, because of her family bereavement, Susan Deacon cannot be here as I know that she has thrown herself into the issue energetically. She has sympathy with the position of the petitioners and has an informed view of the matter, given the particular interest that she has taken on the issue.Trying to reflect Susan Deacon's views and the broad concern that members of the committee no doubt have, I would say that the number 1 priority is that this issue should not be lost simply because we are approaching the election. We need to find a way of parking it effectively so that we can be reasonably confident that it will be dealt with by the appropriate committee after the election.My heartfelt sympathies go out to the petitioners and the people living in the area. While it does not form part of the Edinburgh constituency that I represent, I know the area reasonably well. The petitioners must be at their wits' end, as it is particularly difficult to persuade people who do not live in the immediate environment that there is a problem or that something needs to be done about it. Like noise caused by nuisance neighbours, the nature of odour means that it is not necessarily always present. Residents in those circumstances have difficulty persuading appropriate public agencies that there is a problem because people from those agencies are not there when the problems occur. Odours can consistently occur at certain times of the day or week and can make people's lives a misery. I hope that the committee will take a proactive stance on this petition, as the matter pertains not only to the people living in the affected part of Edinburgh, but is replicated across Scotland. Effective action must be taken.
Angus MacKay's final point is correct: this issue affects all of Scotland. As Maureen Macmillan pointed out, we have come across the problem before in relation to cattle incinerators, chicken litter and sewage plants. As Angus MacKay said, the folk involved must be at their wits' end. In Kirkcaldy, in the region that I represent, a sewage plant is causing a similar problem and the people are at a loss as to what to do about it.As far as I am aware, the only legislation that has any effect is that which enables local authorities to act in relation to a nuisance of odour. However, the problem is that it is difficult to measure odour. It is down to the particular environmental health officer, together with the complainants, to take an action in court. The only successful case that I know of involved chicken litter in Kinrosshire. I was one of the councillors involved in the prosecution on behalf of the community. Odour is extremely difficult to control and it is difficult for local authorities to deal with. The legislation is difficult to enforce because you cannot measure odour.The best way of keeping the petition alive might be to ensure that it gets to the committee whose remit includes transport after the election. That committee could give detailed consideration to the complex and wide-ranging issues that are involved. If we began a process of investigation, we would not be able to complete it and the job would be left half done. We need to ensure that a committee can present a recommendation to the Executive that will strengthen the legislation and give some succour to people who live in the affected areas.
If we initiate action, that would not stop us ensuring that the petition is referred to the relevant committee that is established after the election. It would be difficult for a reporter to complete the work in the time that is available, but we could raise the issue with the Executive. At a subsequent date, we could refer all the correspondence to the Public Petitions Committee, which would then refer the petition and the accompanying correspondence to the relevant committee after the election.
We must remember that there are technical ways of solving the sewage odour problem. The documentation that accompanies the petition gave us the details of that. The question is whether Scottish Water can be convinced to introduce the updated equipment or whether the Parliament will need to legislate to force it to do so.
I agree with everything that has been said. This is an important issue and we should either refer the petition to the Public Petitions Committee now or do so after getting a response from the minister. I would like to know what the European position is on the matter of nuisance odours. Without meaning to be uncomplimentary, I would suggest that the issue is more of a problem in Europe, where temperatures are higher, than it is in Scotland. If European countries have come up with a satisfactory way of dealing with the problem, the Scottish Parliament, following a report by a committee, might want to consider introducing legislation to require minimum standards to be introduced by Scottish Water and so on.There is a huge amount of work to be done on this. For example, the Health and Community Care Committee might need to consider what the health implications are. We can only scratch the surface prior to the dissolution of Parliament. Nonetheless, we should write to the minister and try to start the process by gathering as much information as we can because, as others have said, this is a problem that affects people across Scotland.
I hope that your party leadership has authorised your suggestion that we look to Europe to provide an answer.
I am not too bothered about that.
When we write to the Executive, we should ask about SEPA's responsibilities. As far as I am aware, SEPA does not have responsibility for sewage works. As I said earlier, the review of SEPA's responsibilities has not yet concluded. We could ask when the review will be concluded and whether the outcome will include consideration of odour control.
There is broad agreement that this issue must be addressed and recognition that it would be difficult for this committee to conclude consideration of the petition before the dissolution of Parliament. Do we agree to write to the Executive about the issues that are raised by the petition and the points on SEPA that Maureen Macmillan raised?
Members indicated agreement.
Once we have got that response, we will formally refer the petition back to the Public Petitions Committee in order to keep it live over the election period.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Jan 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 8 January 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Item in Private Procedure · 2
- Building (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 101
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5
- Petitions Petitions · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 7
- Petitions Petitions · 7
- Petitions Petitions · 14
- Petitions Petitions · 16
- Petitions Petitions · 13
- Rail Inquiry Committee business · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.