Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Planning Process (PE508)

Wednesday 8 January 2003 Transport and the Environment Committee Petitions 16 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

16 contributions
Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

That brings us to petition PE508, on the implementation of environmental impact assessments. This is the first time that we have been asked to consider this petition, which calls for Parliament to review the implementation of environmental impact assessments and policy advice note 58 guidelines. The petition derives from the petitioner's experience of the applications by West of Scotland Water and Scotland Water for a water treatment plant in Milngavie. The committee's stance on petitions that relate to local issues is not to consider specific incidents. We consider such petitions only if they raise issues for the wider planning framework. I ask members to comment on the recommendations that were circulated with the covering note. I would like to know what course of action members would prefer us to follow.

Bruce Crawford SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It is tempting to get dragged into the original issue raised in the petition, because it was so tortuous. There are lessons to learn about how consultation should and should not be carried out. Particular elements of the community in the area around the Milngavie development proposals rightly have a grievance about the consultation process. I hope that the appropriate bodies have learned something from the harsh lessons of the recent past.The convener has rightly asked us to consider the wider strategic issues. Strathblane community council's petition asks us to examine two issues that are not specific to the Milngavie application, but which are of wider significance. The first is a statutory requirement to consult appropriate community councils. I was surprised that that requirement does not exist. I thought that it did, but there you go. The second is the fact that developers who pay consultants to do environmental impact assessments also set the consultants' remits. The petitioners rightly ask whether it might not be more appropriate for local authorities to set a consultant's remit and, indeed, choose the consultant. Developers should still pay the costs, because it would not be appropriate for local authorities to do so. Those two issues are strategic in nature and are not associated only with the water treatment plant for Milngavie.I was a bit surprised by the Executive's blunt refusal to re-examine those particular issues. I would have thought that it is reasonable for appropriate community councils to be statutorily consulted about planning applications and that we could re-examine the whole issue of choosing, paying and setting the remit for consultants in relation to environmental impact assessments, particularly as there is no third-party right of appeal for parties who want to object to a development going ahead.The Executive might not want to consider such issues in isolation, but a planning review has been promised and, for the life of me, I cannot understand why the Executive could not consider those particular aspects as part of that overall planning review. The Executive will have to open the Pandora's box of planning anyway, so surely we should examine every aspect of it. We should have proper consultation on whether community councils should be statutory consultees and on who should choose, pay and set the remit for consultants who do environmental impact assessments. It is only fair that we go back to the Executive and ask whether it is prepared to re-examine those areas as part of its wider planning review; otherwise what is the point of having such a review?

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Bruce Crawford took the words out of my mouth. I agree with everything that he said, particularly about consultants. I agree that developers should pay for them, but it would be much more sensible, and signify greater transparency, if a local authority committee appointed the consultants.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

If we state in our recommendations that it might be appropriate to conclude the petition now, what does that mean? Would we not write to the Executive with Bruce Crawford's suggestions, which Robin Harper supported? PE508 refers to a specific case, with which I have been heavily involved for over a year, so I have a degree of insight to back up Bruce Crawford's request that we should bring the issue to the Executive's attention for any future review of planning. The Executive states in its response that it does not intend to review either the process of environmental impact assessments or the PAN 58 guidelines; it is being blinkered, and we must remove those blinkers and ensure that it reviews the guidelines.I am involved in the case and with another local issue regarding the extension of a quarry, and it has become apparent that environmental impact assessments are not being accorded the status, weight and priority that they should be in the preparation of planning applications. The committee must review the EIA process to ensure that my opinion, which is gained from my experience with two local cases, is not generic to all planning applications.As the environment committee, we are concerned that all planning applications take the environmental impact into consideration, and it would be useful to consider how the process works and whether EIAs are being accorded the status that they should enjoy.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

I agree with everything that has been said. It is vital that consultation is seen to be done. That is where the process has broken down. Like Bruce Crawford, I thought that community councils would be one of the statutory consultees and I am surprised that they are not. It is right that all those matters, especially the weighting, should be considered. In fact, the weighting that environmental impact assessments have in the new planning bill should, perhaps, be a matter for parliamentary debate.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

A degree of confusion may have arisen. The Executive's response on the question of consultation states:"In accordance with the EIA Directive, the legislative requirements for public consultation in relation to the EIA process are tied to the submission of an environmental statement. Environmental statements must be advertised and the public given an opportunity to comment. These arrangements are in addition to the normal public consultation requirements associated with planning applications, which include neighbour notification and consultation with community councils. PAN 58 recommends even earlier consultation with the public in relation to EIA, at the scoping stage for example."The question of consultation may have caused confusion, but it does not seem that community councils are excluded from the process.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

That they appear to feel that they have been excluded is bad, and, according to the correspondence, they appear not to have been aware of the consultation process until the decision was taken.

Bruce Crawford SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I understand your point, convener. You are right to say that community councils are consulted about the process, but statutory consultation requires that the appropriate community councils be contacted directly by developers as part of the notification process. I am not sure that PAN 58 covers that aspect of the process, and that is the distinction that must be made.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

It seems likely that major planning legislation will be introduced in the new session, and it is unlikely that major planning changes will be effected between now and the dissolution of Parliament. Therefore, perhaps several of the issues raised by PE508 would best be addressed when the Parliament is considering what changes it intends to make to planning legislation in general.However, if we want to explore any of those questions, we could do so at the meeting that we have scheduled with the minister and the head of planning on general planning issues. We could notify the minister that we want to explore those issues as part of that meeting. Once we have talked to the minister, we could decide whether there is anything further that we need to do in relation to the petition.

Bruce Crawford SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That seems reasonable. When has the meeting with the minister and the head of planning been scheduled for?

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

The date has not been fixed yet. The clerks and the minister are negotiating.

Bruce Crawford SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Will we get a paper that outlines the areas that we will discuss at that meeting?

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

Do we agree that we should explore this matter in the meeting that we have scheduled with the minister and the head of planning?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 8 January 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Building (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 101
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5
  7. Petitions Petitions · 1
  8. Petitions Petitions · 7
  9. Petitions Petitions · 7
  10. Petitions Petitions · 14
  11. Petitions Petitions · 16
  12. Petitions Petitions · 13
  13. Rail Inquiry Committee business · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.