Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Telecommunications Developments (Planning) (PE425)

Wednesday 22 May 2002 Transport and the Environment Committee Petitions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

The next petition is PE425, from Anne-Marie Glashan, on the siting of mobile phone masts. At this stage, we are not being asked to deal with the petition, but to consider whether the committee is content with the Executive's reaction to the recommendations of our "Report on Proposals to Introduce New Planning Procedures for Telecommunications Developments". The Executive introduced a new NPPG, which responded to a number of points in the committee's report. The Public Petitions Committee wants to know only how content we are with the action that the Executive has taken.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

I understand that we must give only our views on the Executive's response to our report, but I want to highlight two items in the Executive's letter to the Public Petitions Committee on the matter. I think that members will not be entirely satisfied with them.Recommendation 21 of our report stated:"local authorities should establish a hierarchy of preferred locations"for mobile phone masts, but the Executive's letter states that the committee did not recommend exclusion zones. That is playing with words. The committee was not entirely happy—at least I was not—with NPPG 19, given our recommendation 21.I also want to mention the part about scientific research in the Executive's response to the Public Petitions Committee. All that it contains is a one-paragraph answer laying out the research and the dates. Both the committees must ask why the research is taking so long. The initial invitation to submit research proposals was not made until nine months after the Stewart report and 11 months after the committee's report, which recommended that research had to be done.Why did it take nine months to put out the call for research? Twenty-six full proposals were requested. That was nearly a year ago. What is happening? What is the status of the research? We are 18 months down the line. Is the research being conducted yet? Why is it taking so long?

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

We were not particularly happy with the Executive's initial response to our report. I have never been happy with the idea that planning permission was not required for all masts, whatever their height or location.

Des McNulty Lab Clydebank and Milngavie
link

Three issues that arise from the implementation of the Executive's approach strike me as worthy of further investigation. First, how far have the Executive and local authorities gone in preparing planning guidance? Is that being implemented consistently throughout Scotland? Secondly, is any updated information available on scientific research that has been produced since we conducted the inquiry and since the Executive reached its view? Does an updating process exist whereby the Executive relays appropriate scientific advice to the planning agencies that must make the decisions?Thirdly, it was central to our initial recommendations that authorities should engage in planning forums with operators, with a view to rationalising masts and co-ordinating the roll-out of masts. My gut feeling is that that has not happened. Individual operators continue to make individual applications to planning authorities, which make one-off decisions. We argued for a more co-ordinated approach. That issue would be worth consideration. I am not sure whether the petition is the vehicle for doing that. We might want to examine the issue as part of post-legislative scrutiny, which we should consider seriously.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

The Executive went a long way towards addressing the recommendations in our report. The introduction of planning procedures for most masts was to be welcomed, although, from the committee's point of view, adoption of all our recommendations would have been preferable.I am entirely comfortable with our encouraging the updating of the research position. On health issues, it is important to note one conclusion of the Stewart report, which is mentioned in the Executive's response, that"the balance of evidence indicates that there is no general risk to the health of people living near to base stations on the basis that exposures are expected to be small fractions of guidelines."We should be cognisant of that. I am unaware of more recent research that contradicts that.Some members' comments concern the recommendations that the Executive did not implement. It would be fair to draw them to the attention of the Public Petitions Committee. I agree with Des McNulty's view that, at some stage, the committee should consider post-legislative scrutiny, how the guidelines have worked and whether they need to be improved. I am not convinced that we have sufficient evidence from local authorities and others to gauge that adequately yet. That is for further down the road.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

I draw to the Public Petitions Committee's attention the introduction to our report, which said:"Based on the evidence received the Committee considers that there is reasonable doubt about the health risks and recommends that health should be viewed as a material planning consideration and a precautionary approach should be adopted".It is important that the petitioner understands that that was the view in our report, which backs up the need for further timeous research.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

I suppose the best way for us to deal with this would be to correspond with the Public Petitions Committee and draw its attention to the extracts from today's Official Report. Members of the Public Petitions Committee will then be able to see our views that members have expressed about the petition and that can inform their decision. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 22 May 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 3
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Aquaculture Inquiry Evidence session · 175
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
  7. Highlands and Islands Ferry Services Committee business · 12
  8. Petitions Petitions · 13
  9. Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. Petitions Petitions · 32

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.