Members will recall that petition PE421, from Alasdair Nicholson, was originally scheduled for consideration, along with some other petitions, at a previous meeting of the committee. However, because that meeting overran considerably, we delayed consideration of those petitions.PE421 calls on the Scottish Parliament to promote and trial a road equivalent tariff for ferry services between the Western Isles and the mainland. Road equivalent tariff is a method of price setting that relates the fare charged for ferry transport to the cost of driving the equivalent road distance.The petition has already been brought to the attention of Maureen Macmillan and Des McNulty, the appointed committee reporters on Highlands and Islands ferry services. Before seeking other members' views, I offer the reporters an opportunity to comment on the petition and on the recommendation that is made in paper TE/02/17/7.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Road Equivalent Tariff (PE421)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bristow Muldoon Lab 3
- Des McNulty Lab 3
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 2
- Robin Harper Green 2
- Nora Radcliffe LD 1
- Fiona McLeod SNP 1
The record
13 contributionsIt is appropriate that the petition be discussed in the light of the draft service specification when that is published. Des McNulty and I—and the committee—will consider all the proposals for fare structures. That would be the appropriate place to deal with the matter. A road equivalent tariff has been suggested for a long time. It is not a new suggestion; it comes up often. We have a good chance to consider it properly.
The draft service specification will drive us into considering ferry issues. Arguably, the road equivalent tariff is a different principle to the one that generally applies to the way in which ferry tariffs are set. We could ask the various community organisations about the road equivalent tariff as part of that process. It might also be interesting to speak to the various public authorities about the operational issues that are associated with moving down that route.
We should also ask them about the financial issues, as there would be financial implications.
We will presumably be in a position to report back on the matter following the consultation.
I have every sympathy with anybody who wants to reduce the cost of travelling by ferry. Apart from anything else, it is a relatively environmentally benign form of transport. However, I have a problem with the idea of a road equivalent tariff. I would prefer a rail equivalent tariff, not only because travel by rail is more environmentally acceptable, but because the real costs of road transport are considerably greater than the simple cost of putting a gallon of petrol in the back of a car. The real costs are hugely greater than that. That is the danger of accepting a road equivalent tariff as a way of calculating ferry fares. I would be happy to use rail equivalents as a guideline for setting ferry fares, but I would be very unhappy with a road equivalent tariff because of the environmental and real cost implications.
What do we mean by a road equivalent tariff? Would it include the cost of providing the road and all the ancillary costs, such as depreciation of cars—would it be a real road equivalent tariff? My other point is the general one that we do not calculate fares for other forms of public transport on the basis of a comparison with what it costs to drive between two places.
I am pleased that the reporters think that they should consider a road equivalent tariff and that it should be considered seriously. I note that the Executive response is basically, "RET? No thanks." I note also that CalMac considered RET as part of its fares review. We must satisfy ourselves that that evidence is being properly weighed in the balance. I look forward to the reporters doing that.I suggest to the reporters that it may be worth speaking to Professor Neil Kay of the University of Strathclyde, who does a lot of academic work on the subject of ferries. I am sure that you have spoken to him already in other contexts, but the issue may be another one worth exploring with him.
I am sure that the reporters would be more than happy to talk to Professor Kay. He has sent us several items of information in the course of our work on the issue, and I am sure that he has done the same for the reporters.
I have two brief points. When Maureen Macmillan and I visited Orkney earlier this year, we talked to people about NorthLink Ferries. The Finance Committee will go to Orkney tomorrow and I have a meeting with representatives of NorthLink Ferries. Further information will be available about that.I say to Robin Harper that all kinds of radical options should be considered in drawing up the service specification. Attention should be given to a number of environmental options and to the road equivalent tariff or other viable alternatives. We have only one chance to get the matter right. It is important that we do not simply replicate existing unsatisfactory systems.
I want to make it absolutely clear that I think that the equivalent tariff should be based on a set of environmental criteria for what is the best method of transporting people from one place to another. That would be to the advantage of sea travel.
Do members agree to the recommendation in the paper and to refer the matter to the reporters for consideration?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 22 May 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 22 May 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 3
- Item in Private Procedure · 2
- Aquaculture Inquiry Evidence session · 175
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
- Highlands and Islands Ferry Services Committee business · 12
- Petitions Petitions · 13
- Petitions Petitions · 8
- Petitions Petitions · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.