We now come to the regulations that have been causing us most concern. The legal advisers have identified four main points. First, that "there are very serious doubts as to whether it is intra vires on points 1, 2, 3 and 4 and to a lesser extent on point 6".Secondly, that there is"a devolution issue on point 3".Thirdly, that there is "defective drafting on points 5, 6 and 7".And finally, that there has been a"failure to follow proper legislative practice on points 8 and 9."It is suggested that a radical rethink is needed. I invite members' views.
Official Report · Committee
Executive Responses
Environmental Protection (Restriction on Use of Lead Shot) (Scotland) Regulations 2004 (SSI 2004/289)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 20
- Gordon Jackson Lab 12
- Alasdair Rankin Clerk 12
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 9
- Christine May Lab 7
- Stewart Maxwell SNP 2
The record
62 contributionsI wonder how we highlight to the lead committee that we have really serious concerns about the vires and enforceability of the regulations. The regulations seem to have been got so wrong. We were amused by our earlier discussion about disjunctive ands, but the point is that the regulations should have been advertised in both the London Gazette and the Edinburgh Gazette, yet that requirement appears simply to have been ignored. That really will not do. We cannot have folk running round the country trying to arrest people on the basis of flawed regulations. That certainly will not do. We need to have wording that expresses our real, serious concern to the lead committee. We suggest that the Executive withdraws the regulations, or that the lead committee asks the Executive to withdraw and re-lay the regulations.
At certain points in the regulations, the degree by which they are ultra vires is beyond a simple technicality, as is sometimes the case. There are substantive issues, particularly around the power of arrest and the search of persons, as opposed to the search of premises.
What kind of Scottish statutory instrument is it?
It is subject to annulment.
I wonder what the duty of the committee is in this instance. If we take the view that an instrument is a dud, I do not suppose that we have any right or duty simply to stop the instrument.
No.
We could speak against it, or that sort of thing.
We could do. We could make a recommendation.
In the case of an affirmative instrument, which comes before the Parliament, would we be entitled to stand up and speak against it, saying that it is our job to check things and we think that the instrument is a dud and should not go through? I am curious about what exactly our powers and duties are.
It might be possible to pray against the instrument.
We do not have any powers in this regard, but we certainly have a duty.
Yes—I am just asking what we are meant to do.
Any member could speak against the instrument when it comes before the Parliament.
But this instrument will not come before the Parliament.
The lead committee is looking at the regulations tomorrow. We need to get something to it speedily.
Which is the lead committee?
It is the Environment and Rural Development Committee.
When does the 40-day period expire? Will the 40-day period still be live after the recess?
No.
What happens as far as the clock is concerned? Unless the 40-day period expires this Friday, does the clock carry on ticking during the recess, or does it stop?
The clock stops, but there might not be time to accommodate the process of the lead committee recommending to the Parliament that the regulations be annulled. Upon such a recommendation, the Parliamentary Bureau would have to lodge a motion to annul for consideration in the chamber, and there would not be time for all that to happen on the other side of recess.
Any member may lodge a motion to annul within the 40-day period. Is that something that we could do at the beginning of September, if we were so inclined?
Under standing orders, that could happen. The parliamentary timetable in early September, following the summer recess, might make it necessary to hold meetings outside of the usual schedule. The Parliamentary Bureau would need to consider the matter. It is for the bureau to lodge a motion to annul for debate in the chamber and it might be necessary to arrange business specifically for that. Your suggestion is possible in theory, but those additional actions would be required.
What I am picking up from this is that we must first alert the lead committee to the difficulties with the regulations. What can the lead committee do?
The lead committee can debate the regulations and recommend that the Parliament annuls them. The bureau would then have to lodge a motion to annul, which the whole Parliament would consider.
And that will come up in September. We could recommend that to the lead committee.
I think that that is what we should recommend.
The lead committee could not discuss a motion to annul at its meeting tomorrow, unless the convener were to change the agenda today.
A motion to annul the regulations would need to be lodged—by any member of the Parliament—at the chamber desk.
I have done it before—I have tried to have an instrument annulled.
This committee could ask the convener of the lead committee to lodge a motion to annul at the chamber desk.
The committee could make that recommendation.
Is it for the lead committee to do that? Could we do that?
The standing orders provide for a debate on a motion to annul to take place at the lead committee. An hour and a half is allowed for that debate, although any member can lodge a motion to annul.
I previously lodged a motion to annul an SSI for consideration at a committee, which held a debate on that motion. I didn't win, right enough.
It has to happen sometime.
It was quite a big debate on a serious issue.
Is the matter on the agenda for discussion by the Environment and Rural Development Committee tomorrow?
The instrument is on its agenda for tomorrow.
Will that committee be having a discussion that could lead to its lodging a motion to annul?
Yes, but notice of such a motion would normally be expected to be given, so that anyone who wanted to attend the committee's debate on that motion could do so. The Minister for Environment and Rural Development is entitled to speak in that debate. It would need to be publicised so that the minister knew to turn up. In such circumstances, the minister will usually wish to speak to his or her legislation.
If we do nothing, or if we simply communicate with the lead committee, which debates the instrument tomorrow and decides that it agrees with this committee, then it will not be until after the recess that the lead committee could discuss a motion to annul. That is, unless it were to decide to have another meeting this week.
The day that is set aside for committee meetings in the week following the recess is Thursday 9 September. We are trying to check the procedure and due process according to which the instrument would be considered again on that Thursday.
Normally, when a motion is debated by a lead committee, that is when the decision would be taken by that committee to recommend annulment. Subsequently, a motion to annul the regulations would be lodged by the Parliamentary Bureau for debate in the chamber. As I understand it, chamber business is to come first during the first week after the recess, so that could happen on the Wednesday of that week, which is 8 September.
Do we know when the 40-day period ends with respect to the regulations?
Around mid-September.
So we have time.
We would have time. I suggest that, in the first instance, we draw the attention of the lead committee to our grave concern about the instrument. We should do that as swiftly as possible via the clerk, who should write to the lead committee saying that we think that the instrument needs to be radically redrawn.
Or relaid, if that is the correct term.
I have a doubt about such issues. Presumably, the Executive lawyers think that they are right. Perhaps that is not the case and they have just dug themselves so far into a hole that they will not stop digging—I do not know what is going on in their minds. However, I have always thought that once the Executive lawyers adopt a position, the only place where that can ultimately be tested is in court, once somebody has been charged. It is hard for us, whether we are lawyers or not, to arbitrate on such issues. We have experienced that problem before. Once the Executive lawyers adopt a legal interpretation, part of me just says, "Hell mend them." If their position works, it works; if it does not, it does not. I never quite know how the Parliament decides on a legal argument.
Given human nature, they might just have dug themselves into a hole. As far as is possible, we need to test whether that is the syndrome.
Absolutely.The ideal solution would be to take evidence from Executive officials, but I do not know whether that is possible.
Could we do that after the summer recess?
We would need to hear that evidence on 9 September.
In the absence of a detailed explanation of what the Executive lawyers have based their arguments on, the matter is very difficult.
Without committing myself to anything, I must say that, on the surface, the Executive lawyers' arguments do not look good. However, they might be right.
Given that the 40 days do not finish until the middle of September, could we take evidence from the Executive officials on 14 September?
Leaving the matter until the second week after the recess—until our meeting on 14 September—would be rather late, given the practicalities. The lead committee would need to debate a motion, and the Parliamentary Bureau would need to lodge a motion and timetable it into parliamentary business.
We have two alternatives. We can draw the matter to the attention of the lead committee as swiftly as possible and write to the Scottish Executive to express our concern. Alternatively, or additionally, we can ask Scottish Executive officials to give evidence at our first meeting after the summer recess, which would need to be on Thursday 9 September.
My preference is that we do elements of both. We should draw the regulations to the attention of the lead committee and express our grave concern, as we have already agreed to do. In addition, although we might prefer not to have a meeting in the first week back in September, we should take that opportunity to hear a detailed explanation from the Executive, if it agrees. It is always possible to stop or withdraw regulations; it is more difficult to lay another instrument at the last minute.
Is it agreed that we should do that?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Jun 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Subordinate Legislation Committee Tuesday 29 June 2004 (Morning) Subordinate legislation · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 11
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 62
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Instrument Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instrument Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.