I welcome members to the 23rd meeting of the Subordinate Legislation Committee this year. I have apologies from Murray Tosh, who is attending a meeting of the British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body. I also have apologies from Mike Pringle, who made arrangements before the recess dates were changed.The first item on our agenda is Executive responses. Members will remember that we received a letter from Dennis Canavan outlining his concerns about how this second order was dealt with. The people who objected to the first version of the order were not told that there was a second order.We have a lengthy brief from the legal adviser. It would appear that although there is nothing to say that the Scottish Executive had to inform the previous objectors, there is no doubt a wee bit of concern that they were not told, especially as there were only 13 of them. More particularly, there is concern that Dennis Canavan was not told about the second order and brought into the consultation process.
Official Report · Committee
Executive Responses
Assynt - Coigach Area Protection Order 2004 (SSI 2004/260)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 5
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 2
- Christine May Lab 2
- Stewart Maxwell SNP 2
The record
11 contributionsAlthough the Executive has followed the letter of the law, that is not the point. Dennis Canavan feels—and I think we feel—that in this day and age there should have been a more significant degree of consultation. At a minimum, those people who objected to the first order should have been contacted, especially because the second order is substantially different, as the Executive admits. I do not see that doing that would have incommoded the Executive in any way and it would have been in the spirit of what we hope is our approach to legislation.
Absolutely.
I support that entirely. In support of Alasdair Morgan's view, I cite the fact that we and the Executive urge the public to become involved, to take an interest and to participate. Here we have an example of people who are doing just that by putting forward their objections, and they are almost being ignored. That is not how to engender public support and trust. If nothing else, the Executive might want to consider what it might do on a formally informal—if I can put it that way—basis from now on in such circumstances.
I agree with both the members who have spoken. It comes down to natural justice and best practice. The rules of natural justice have been ignored, and this is not best practice. I was unhappy when I read the briefing the first time around. Dennis Canavan makes some very pertinent points, as do the objectors he represents. Clearly, the objectors should have been informed. I do not think that we should leave the issue at that. As Alasdair Morgan pointed out, although the Executive did not break any laws or rules, we should bring the matter to the attention of the Parliament. In particular we should point out to the lead committee what Alasdair Morgan said about lack of consultation.
We cannot formally bring the order to the attention of the lead committee, but we could send a letter or a copy of the report.
Rather than just sending a copy of the report and saying nothing, I think that we should at least send a letter to the convener.
We will draw the attention of Parliament to the order on the ground that we are concerned about it; that can be documented. We will also draw our conclusions when we have that information from the Scottish Executive. We will write a letter to the lead committee along the same lines and we will include a copy of our report. Do we want to write to the Scottish Executive?
My view is that we should let the Executive know the view that we have come to as a result of Dennis Canavan's comments. More important, we should ask the Executive if it proposes to make arrangements or lay down guidelines for dealing with such matters in future.
The Executive seems to be missing a trick on its own behalf. Although it is not clearly detailed in the letter, presumably some of the objections to the first order were taken into account. So it would be to the Executive's benefit to write to the first set of objectors to tell them that it has listened to them and changed the legislation as a result.
Absolutely. Our legal advice says that it is not clear what points have been taken on board. The Executive could have shown that it had done a lot more work on the order.We will also write a letter to Dennis Canavan, telling him what has happened.Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Jun 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Subordinate Legislation Committee Tuesday 29 June 2004 (Morning) Subordinate legislation · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 11
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 62
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Instrument Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instrument Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.