An update from the clerks on our work programme has been circulated to members. There are one or two points that we must consider. We have quite a busy few months ahead of us with the proposed banking and financial services inquiry and budget scrutiny. Those are the two major items between now and Christmas. There are also proposals in the work programme in relation to the annual seminar with the Scottish Trades Union Congress and the business in the Parliament conference. Members may also wish to consider holding a meeting with the Council of Economic Advisers, as we did last year. Two requests were submitted over the summer for additional inquiries, which I will come to in a moment, along with recommendations.Do members have any comments on the work programme, excluding the two additional items of the proposed whisky and fossil fuel levy inquiries?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Iain Smith only · show everyone- Iain Smith LD 16
- Wendy Alexander Lab 10
- Rob Gibson SNP 7
- Christopher Harvie SNP 5
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 4
- Gavin Brown Con 1
Iain Smith’s contributions
16 contributionsSo we agree to carry on with the banking inquiry as indicated and to make progress on the innovation/productivity inquiry and the international trade and exports inquiry over the next few months.
We certainly do have to keep an eye on that and slot it in at an appropriate time when there is a gap in business. There will be opportunities to pick up some of those issues under budget scrutiny, as well, to find out what progress is being made.
I suggest that, at this stage, we keep a watching brief on the matter. If specific issues arise on which we feel that we need to take further evidence, we can try to slot that in at appropriate times. The key point will be the trust's report on its financial year, which will tell us whether the restructuring on which it has embarked is delivering the intended results and whether there are any further potential consequences.Are members content with the proposed outline for budget scrutiny?
Members are requested to advise the clerk of their preferred focus for the budget scrutiny. I think that the key focus of our budget scrutiny will be on how the budget is delivering on the Government's economic recovery plan.
If there are no other comments on that, we will move on to consider events. The paper suggests that the clerk and I be delegated to hold initial discussions with the STUC on themes for this year's annual STUC seminar and bring a further report back to the committee. The seminar is usually in the early part of February.
No, the intention is to have discussions with the STUC and make proposals. That is one of them.
The other event is the business in the Parliament conference. A report on that will be discussed later.The other item for future business was a suggestion that we review the reform of the enterprise agencies towards the end of the parliamentary year—that is, round about May—because that will mean that the reforms will have been in place for two years and, in relation to the Highlands business gateway, a full year.
That is a valid point. I would be interested to know about some of the things that are happening in Wales, such as how the Welsh are managing to make use of the joint European resources for micro to medium enterprises—JEREMIE—fund, which we do not seem to be doing in Scotland.We will move on to the two requests for inquiries, the first of which is the whisky inquiry. I have been breaking the rules about BlackBerrys and I see that Diageo has announced that it intends to go ahead with its original proposal to close the Kilmarnock and Port Dundas plants and create 500 additional jobs in Fife. That information may have an impact on any decisions that we take on that matter.I propose that we ask the Scottish Parliament information centre to produce a research paper on the current state of the whisky industry and any issues. That could inform any future consideration of whether the committee wishes to hold a wider inquiry into the industry. Can we agree that and come back to a discussion about Diageo?
The suggestion is that we ask SPICe to produce a paper, but I do not know what the timescale for that would be. The paper would then provide us with background information, against which we could make an informed decision about the nature of any inquiry that we wish to undertake. We would look at the whisky industry in general, not at Diageo in particular.
Certainly, that is sensible. We want a fairly urgent report, but it must be thorough. We do not want a report that cuts corners and does not give us the information that we need. The clerk will discuss timelines with SPICe and will report back to the committee as soon as possible on when we might expect that report so that we can then consider where to go from there.As members are content with that approach for the whisky industry in general, does anyone wish to raise any points about the Diageo situation?
Any member who has any issues that they want the SPICe team to consider can e-mail them to the clerk. They will then be passed on to SPICe.
We will try to get information on that.Given the announcement that has been made about Diageo, do members wish to take further action on that or accept that there is a done deal?
Okay. We will leave that matter on the pending one-off inquiry pile.The second proposal that I received through the deputy convener was for an inquiry into the fossil fuel levy. The issue arose in our energy inquiry, and the Government has responded to that point in its response to the inquiry. It might be of benefit at this stage to write to the Scottish Government and HM Treasury to ask them what they are doing on the matter. Then we can consider whether there is anything further to do. There are some issues around whether or not the matter falls under the remit of the committee, in the sense that it is about technical financial things, which might make it more something for the Finance Committee's remit, but there is no harm in our following up our energy inquiry and asking the Scottish Government and HM Treasury what they are doing.
It was to the Scottish ministers, yes.
Yes. We will write to the Treasury to ask what it is doing in relation to the requests.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Sep 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 9 September 2009 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- National Trust for Scotland Evidence session · 118
- Arbitration (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 10
- Work Programme Procedure · 44
- Business in the Parliament Committee business · 2
- Energy Inquiry Committee business · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.