Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 9 September 2009 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Procedure 44 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Showing Wendy Alexander only · show everyone

Wendy Alexander’s contributions

10 contributions
Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I have one suggestion regarding a subject that is mentioned in the paper but that, understandably, does not feature in the timetable. I draw the committee's attention to the issues under "Ongoing tourism scrutiny", including the proposals for a tourism bank and a national tourism investment plan and the evaluation of the year of homecoming. There are also issues about tourism skills. I was struck by how downbeat John Lennon was when we used him as an adviser. He felt that the very robust recommendations on which there was unanimity in the committee had not been progressed. We could maybe slot that into the back half of the year. Let us not lose sight of that, even if we have to come back to it in March or June.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

The one other area would simply be to reflect on what we were told last year. That applies to budget scrutiny and also the Council of Economic Advisers. I am keen to build some continuity into the scrutiny when we get to year 3 of a parliamentary session, so we should examine the undertakings, rationales and explanations that were given on the issues that we raised last year and consider where we are a year on. In some cases, the position will rightly have changed because of changing economic circumstances, but effective scrutiny is about finding out where we are on the undertakings that were given a year ago. That would be helpful. I do not think that we will all go and find the Official Report, but perhaps somebody else could do so on our behalf and draw that out.I will give one example. Last year's draft tourism budget had a 5 per cent real-terms cut for this year. I made a huge fuss about that and, in the final version of the budget, which appeared in January with no press notice of any kind, the real-terms cut had miraculously become a standstill budget. The committee was never notified of that.That is one area on which we focused and on which there were changes. Another was the total sum of money that was devoted to energy efficiency. Commitments were given on that budget that we might want to re-examine.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

Did we not also ask the clerks to consider whether we should have a formal committee session with the STUC to create a parallel with how we handle the Council of Economic Advisers? I take it from the proposal that that has been rejected.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

We should think about doing it in the same way as we handle the Council of Economic Advisers. That might address the point that Christopher Harvie makes. It may be that the STUC cannot do a Wednesday morning, but that option should be on the table.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I should perhaps declare an interest—although it is not technically an interest. When I worked in consultancy about a dozen years ago, I did a lot of work on the global consolidation of the spirits industry. The issue then was the loss of brown spirits to white spirits—demand was growing much more quickly for vodka than for whisky—so it seems to me that the note that was sent to all committee members about how the long-term growth trends of white spirits versus brown spirits have not been reversed is at the heart of the issue. Perhaps when the SPICe researchers prepare their paper they can draw on that note—I do not know who sent it to us—as it seemed very well informed. That point would also fit within a wider trade and international exports inquiry, because we would not be discussing whether we need two bottling plants or three if the industry was growing either at the rate of the world economy or at the rate of demand for other distilled spirits. I simply highlight that insightful note to the SPICe researchers because, for self-evident reasons, we do not always hear that point from the Scotch Whisky Association. If we are to do the issue justice—the issue about preserving all these small distilleries—we need to understand why, despite the efforts of major companies such as Diageo, white spirits hugely outperform brown spirits globally.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

It is nothing to do with tall or short drinks. The only reason that we are not declining is because we have managed to substitute short for tall drinks, but brown spirits are still, a decade on, hugely behind white spirits.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

The right analogy is with French wine production, and the real issue, which the GMB raised, is whether bottling in Scotland is compelled. Because of the influence of some of the large players in the industry, the Scotch Whisky Association does not support bottling in Scotland, which is astonishing. The big players speak with forked tongue and will say that they bottle whiskies abroad only in countries in which there are tariff barriers. If that were the case and 85 per cent was bottled here, there would be every reason to do so. Of course, white spirits can be bottled anywhere in the world. There is no prospect of Finland and Sweden saying that that can be done only there. The big strategic decision on whisky is whether there is a move to insisting on its being distilled and bottled here. It is interesting that the trade body for Scotch whisky does not favour that position. However, the issue is not simple. Diageo's prospects are distinct from the prospects of the industry as a whole and the question whether its fortunes are best preserved by bottling in Scotland.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I was unaware of that. I should say that on the record.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I would like to add a caveat. I have spent a little time exploring the matter, and have been told that a decision on bottling in Scotland is a United Kingdom decision. There is a decision pending on the matter for all malts. Whether one compels malts to be bottled here but not blends that are mixed with grain is a genuinely difficult and interesting strategic issue. The critical issue is whether the matter is reserved or devolved. We might take a different view about ways, issues and consideration if the matter is not ours to decide. Clarity on that from SPICe would be helpful.

  1. Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 9 September 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  3. National Trust for Scotland Evidence session · 118
  4. Arbitration (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 10
  5. Work Programme Procedure · 44
  6. Business in the Parliament Committee business · 2
  7. Energy Inquiry Committee business · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.