Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 3 June 2009 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Procedure 40 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Gavin Brown only · show everyone

Gavin Brown’s contributions

1 contributions
Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

I apologise for arriving late this morning. The powers of this or any other committee—ad hoc or otherwise—are outlined in section 23 of the Scotland Act 1998. As I understand it, we do not have great powers to compel the key players in the banking crisis and the credit crunch. We have tried to invite key players in the past, and those invitations have been declined, so it would be difficult for us to compel or invite witnesses from the Bank of England, the Financial Services Authority or the Treasury. That is the tripartite relationship that holds responsibility. If we cannot get any of them, we will have a tough start. I am not sure whether any United Kingdom Government ministers would be willing to attend, so we will not get much from them. I am also unsure—this is a bit more opaque—about the degree to which we could get directors or former directors and others who held responsibility for what went on in the various banks in the lead-up to the crisis.There is a host of people whom we could invite but I would be dubious about whether they would turn up or wish to give evidence and it is not clear to me that we have powers to compel them. Therefore, my first big query is who would come and who would be able to take us forward.If there is to be an inquiry, two principles are critical. First, there should be no replication. There have been two committee inquiries at Westminster and simply rehashing to any degree what has been done there would not be a good use of any committee's time. Secondly, anything that we do on the matter must be forward looking as opposed to backward looking. Simply examining what happened is not helpful and has been done, but it might be helpful to consider where we go from here and what the committee and Parliament can do. Our powers are limited, but I am sure that there are things that we can do.On the debate about whether this committee, another committee or an ad hoc committee should undertake any inquiry, we are the committee with responsibility for the economy and the issue is closer to our remit than to any other committee's. I am not persuaded by the arguments that I have heard so far for some sort of ad hoc committee. One or two members have made the point that there is a crossover on skills with the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee, but we would not consider the issue of skills alone, although it would be part of any inquiry. We considered skills as part of the tourism inquiry, and we did not feel that we needed to set up an ad hoc committee in relation to that. Skills has also been a key subject in our current energy inquiry, and, again, there has been no crossover with the education committee in that regard.I am not persuaded that we need an ad hoc committee because there might be some crossover in one area, or because of the regional argument that many of the financial services jobs are in the central belt and members in that area might therefore be affected more than other members. If we were to consider issues such as renewable energy and marine energy, we might argue, for example, that those issues affect the Pentland Firth more than other areas and that there should be an ad hoc energy committee of members who represent the surrounding areas. We are an economy committee, and we broadly represent the regions of Scotland. I am comfortable with the idea that we do not need a regionally based ad hoc committee—we are perfectly capable of delving into the issues.There are things that we can do, but it would not be helpful to have a banking inquiry that is looking back. Anything that we do needs a clear focus. We have had a tourism inquiry and we are about to conclude an energy inquiry, so it is right that we focus on something to do with the economy, partly because we have not covered it in the form of a larger inquiry, and partly because the current circumstances are exceptional.

  1. Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 3 June 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 40
  3. Budget Process 2010-11 (Adviser) Committee business · 4
  4. Arbitration (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 109

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.