Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 3 June 2009 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Procedure 40 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Wendy Alexander only · show everyone

Wendy Alexander’s contributions

2 contributions
Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

Whether we are talking about an inquiry by us or by another body, greater clarity is needed. Almost no part of the issue that Chris Harvie raises about whether the banking system is fit for purpose falls within our remit. Rob Gibson talked about having a look back. If we look at the period from when the credit crunch began to be visible in the United States in the autumn of 2007 until the crisis hit fully in September 2008, we see that the issues in that time were, for example, the capital adequacy ratios for banks, the degree of regulation of products that were in the shadow banking market and whether the prospectuses for rights issues that were issued in March 2008 were wholly honest about the circumstances of the institutions. We would then be into the territory of the terms of a takeover and the role of the Office of Fair Trading, which was the issue that dominated much of our discussion in the autumn. We would also be considering the undertakings that the Financial Services Authority gave about the state of some of our banks at that time.Not one of those issues—including prospectuses, the role of the shadow banking market, capital adequacy ratios, international regulation and the OFT's degree of leverage in takeovers—is ours, but if you take a look back, those are the issues that matter. The United States courts are now pursuing them. I am not against further investigation of all those things. I do not see how you can construct a global banking system without reflecting on those matters, but it seems to me that none of them falls within our remit. The critical issue is clarity about what is within and what is outwith the scope of the inquiry, which I do not think that we have achieved.Chris Harvie raised one issue that it is appropriate for this committee to consider, which is the quality of banking, or the lending environment, for small and large businesses in Scotland. However, that is only one part of the forward prospectus. Other parts are the role of the financial sector, given that it is the dominant sector in the Scottish economy, the role of the skills base and a future skills map.It seems to me that there are three issues: banking as a service provider to the wider global economy; the shifting nature of the contribution of the Scottish financial sector; and the implications for the skills base. The issue of the lending environment for businesses in Scotland would need further work, but the remit for that would be very different from the remit that we are talking about. Skills, which is not in our territory, and the role of the financial services sector in the Scottish economy, are areas that we might want to look at in the context of the six priority areas on which the enterprise networks have chosen to focus.I have highlighted some of the difficulties with looking back. Many witnesses would say, "I am sorry, but that's not your business," and I am not sure that that would enhance the reputation of the Parliament. Even if witnesses did seek to answer, it would be difficult for us to pursue the matter.Bearing in mind the concentration of financial services in Edinburgh and, to a lesser extent, Glasgow, and the role of skills, if it were just the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee that held an inquiry we would not allow for key Lothian members, including Margo MacDonald, who first raised the issue and put it on the agenda, to participate and we also would not capture the skills agenda, which seems the most pressing one for us, given that Scottish public policy could have a material influence on the future of the sector.I do not think that there is clarity around what is within or outwith the scope of the inquiry and what part of a look-back would be within our remit. I cannot see how any of the critical decisions are primarily in our territory, which takes me back to the point about joint work with committees in other places. If we are taking a look forward—I say this as a west of Scotland member—it is vital to recognise the role of Edinburgh and the Lothians. Probably the key lever at our disposal, as identified by the Financial Services Advisory Board, is around skills. We would want to pursue these issues through a vehicle that allowed the parts of the Parliament that have a remit around skills and the prospects of our new skills organisation to rise to the challenge, to be part of any inquiry. We would get into difficulties if we tried to look at whether Skills Development Scotland was the right body.I am nervous about trying to shoehorn an inquiry into this committee alone.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

The other matter that is on our agenda is the budget. Obviously, a new comprehensive spending review is coming up and, although we do not yet know what it will be, it is fair to say that, given that the enterprise budget has taken significant hits over the past two years, which were times of relative largesse, the pressure on it might intensify in a more constrained environment.Historically, the difficulty has been that committees do not get the Government's proposals early enough to enable them to examine them in depth. However, I think that we, along with the budget adviser, should do as much as we can to understand the choices and shifts that will have been made. That will be valuable in informing some of the work that we will do. Inevitably, there will be trade-offs between money going into innovation, money going into the enterprise network—and, within that, into various parts of the enterprise network—money going into tourism and so on.Because of the factors that I have outlined, we should do a little more work on the budget this year than we have done in the past. The export and manufacturing inquiry and the productivity and innovation inquiry are not time limited, while the work on the budget is. I would therefore welcome the chance to have a couple of sessions in the period between September and Christmas with the budget adviser, whom we will appoint next week. During those sessions, we could reflect on shifts in overall enterprise spending in, say, the past decade and whether they make sense in terms of the emerging issues.In suggesting that, I am mindful of the fact that it would be a good idea to have a one-off session in the first half of next year during which we could look back on the year of homecoming. That would give us insights into issues around, for example, tourism spend and the cost of events.

  1. Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 3 June 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 40
  3. Budget Process 2010-11 (Adviser) Committee business · 4
  4. Arbitration (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 109

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.