PE1249, by Stanley Player, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government to introduce a statutory duty on landlords who offer properties for short-term, holiday and party-flat lets to register the properties as such; and to comply with all necessary houses in multiple occupation, noise, safety and environmental regulations. I welcome to the meeting Stanley Player. Sarah Boyack MSP has been raising the issues, and we have a letter from Shirley-Anne Somerville MSP about the impact of party-flat lets in the Lothians. I am aware, however, that such flats are a feature in cities throughout the country. I invite Stanley to speak to his petition.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Holiday and Party Flats (Regulation) (PE1249)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 10
- Stanley Player 8
- Bill Butler Lab 3
- Sarah Boyack Lab 2
- Marlyn Glen Lab 2
- Anne McLaughlin SNP 1
- Margo MacDonald Ind 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
29 contributionsThere seems to be confusion between the terms "holiday lets" and "party flats". The term "holiday let" sums up a nice little place in the country, or even a festival flat, where visitors stay while they take in the city, go out and see shows and have a nice time. There seems to be a suggestion that we are somehow trying to stop the Edinburgh festival existing. I was born in and live in Edinburgh. I was there at the start of the festival, which is wonderful. Nothing is going to stop the festival; a couple of little laws will not stop it going ahead. We need some sort of link between the public and the party flats.Party flats cause a lot of noise, misery and fear—fear of parties starting up at all times of the morning. We are woken up by parties at 1, 2, 3 or 4 o'clock in the morning. There is no one we can call. We can call social services, but they do not seem to react to such situations. If I phone the noise team and say that there are 15 people up in the top flat creating a rammy, they say that it is a police matter—I might have already waited an hour to get through. Meanwhile, the police arrive and ask what we are doing about the situation. I tell them what the situation is and what I am doing to try to stop it. They tell me that I am doing all the right things and then they walk away and leave me. There is nothing to stop these situations.The situation is not unique to Edinburgh. It is not unique to our street; it happens in the centre, the old town, the new town, the suburbs and Leith. Everybody is having problems with party flats. I have here an article that explains that Glasgow has exactly the same problems that we have with noise and people being sick and urinating in the stair. If you live in a stair and someone rings the bell at 2 o'clock in the morning, it gets you up and you have to answer the door. That is when the problems start.I have just received a letter, which I am sure that committee members have received, too, about Sapphire Point in Lochend Road. There are 52 flats in the development, of which 42 were bought by one person. They have now become party flats. That means that the remaining 10 residents have to put up with all those parties going on. That must be absolute hell on earth to live with.It is hell for us, too. Busloads of people arrive and they all go up to a small flat that has wall-to-wall beds. The problems are absolutely horrendous. People come in and go out at all times, with doors banging. We cannot get our sleep because we are disturbed.The situation is deplorable and we cannot seem to do anything about it. Whatever authorities we call do not seem to take any notice. I am looking for some sort of legislation to rectify the situation.
I invite Sarah Boyack to comment, from the point of view of a constituency member who receives complaints about the issue from constituents.
I first heard of the concept of a party flat just over a year ago. As Stan Player said, Edinburgh has a long history of promoting tourism, so the point is not that we have not previously had tourists staying in the city—we have lots of accommodation that we want tourists to come and stay in. However, a party let is not a short-term let, as the property is let for only a weekend. As Stan Player said, 10 to 25 people can come to a normal tenement flat of the sort that there are in Glasgow and other big Scottish cities. Although those flats accommodated quite a few people in their early days, they did not accommodate as many people as there are in party flats. The people who come for the weekend want to have a good time and enjoy themselves. The issue is not that they hold parties in the flats, but that there is a lot of noise when they arrive, when they get ready to go out and when they come back, sometimes in the middle of the night or the early hours of the morning.In the past year, I have become much more aware of the issue. In some areas in the city centre, landlords are targeting the market. On the internet, one finds that stag and hen weekends are targeted. It is not good for the name of the city, and there is a particular problem for residents in reasonably busy residential streets, who might have HMO properties near them. The party flats are beginning to tip the balance and the situation has become untenable.I am also concerned about safety. One reason why the HMO legislation was introduced was that we had fatalities. I worry about the mix of overcrowding, alcohol and people who are here for a good weekend. There is nobody to oversee the situation. The flats are not bed and breakfasts, so nobody is there to check whether people are okay or to ensure that they look after the property. There is a lot of money in these lets, so the issue has become an economic one. We need regulatory checks and somebody to take an interest in the issue. An unintended consequence of the HMO legislation has been to put into people's minds the idea that they can rent out flats in this way—it has become an attractive and lucrative industry. Many party flats in the city are advertised on the internet.I am worried about the health and safety aspects for the people who rent the accommodation. I am also worried about other tenants and owners in the stairs where the party flats are. Something needs to be done. It is difficult to involve the police, because they do not regard the activity as illegal. As members know, it is necessary to get somebody to deal with a noise problem at the time, because otherwise the people who are making the noise will be long gone or will have gone quiet. We might assume that the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004 would be a good source of action, but the way in which it is crafted means that it simply enables the Scottish Government to introduce regulations to include party flats or holiday lets—it does not include those at present, so we have ended up with a loophole.The practice is a new and unregulated economic activity. As the member for Edinburgh city centre, I absolutely do not suggest that we should destroy the tourism industry in Edinburgh, but the problem of party flats must be considered. Neither the antisocial behaviour legislation nor the HMO legislation is easily applicable because, when that legislation was written, the use of accommodation in this way was not envisaged. The loophole must be examined, and I hope that the committee is interested in doing so.
Committee members will have sympathy with the points that have been made, particularly those on noise nuisance, safety and antisocial behaviour. However, in our briefing, there are comments about responsibility for repairs. Will you comment on that, too?
These people do not seem to exist. We have tried to have a conversation with them but, when we arranged a meeting with them, they did not turn up. Three other residents and I went to the police station, where the owner of the party flat had agreed to meet us, the police and someone from social services. However, the owner did not turn up. That is extreme arrogance and is the type of thing that people have to put up with when dealing with the owners of these flats. On the issue of repairs, you can imagine what happens when you have 20, 30 or 40 people in these flats, all using the facilities, toilets and showers at the same time. A lady at the bottom of number 31 was nearly drowned in sewage because 25 girls were in the party flat and the shower seemed to clog up—the flat even ran out of water. The flats were not built to deal with that sort of situation.
I know that people in tenements often have difficulty getting other residents to maintain the communal areas, such as the stairwells. Is that a particular problem for you?
We are fortunate enough to have our own private garden at the back, but all we get is cigarettes coming out of that flat—they are not stubbed out; they come down lit. What happens in the flat when they are smoking? Do they drop cigarettes down the back of chairs and so on? The idea that there might be a fire terrifies us.Most of the party flats are on the top floors of tenements, which means that you get 20 or 30 people going up and down the stairs at all times of day. Where is the sense in that? There is no legislation to say that the flats cannot be used in that way. That is our problem.
When did the problem start to kick in? Did you previously have a fairly stable environment in the tenement and notice a substantial shift in the past year or so, following the purchase of certain properties? That is a problem across all our cities. People no longer know who lives in their neighbourhood or residential area, and they can feel quite insecure when they find that they do not recognise the faces of people who live around them.
The problem has been going on for a long time, but it seems to be gaining momentum. I have had letters handed in to me about the situation in the city. The woman who wrote to me from Lochend Road is having terrible problems. She has a young family and has to deal with appalling noise and disruption. As you say, it is not only Edinburgh that is experiencing this problem. The same thing is happening in Glasgow and even England. The situation is intolerable and something must be done about it. If we go on like this, the problems will escalate and become more serious. The people in the flats are unattended, and I do not know whether the flats are covered by fire regulations and so on. We telephoned the fire brigade to ask about that and, although we got a response, no one ever arrived to inspect the situation. The problem must be brought under control. The fire brigade, the police and the social services must be brought into the situation, or there will be a serious accident.
I sympathise with you and support your call for the Government to consider ways of tackling the problem. When I lived in a tenement flat, I had an antisocial neighbour. Every six weeks or so, he would play his music all night long—I would not have minded if I enjoyed the music, but I did not. At the time, I realised how hard it is if people cannot shut the door behind them and just relax in their own home. The situation was utterly stressful. I knew the man very well, but I found it extremely difficult to go to his door. If that is how I felt, I can imagine that you find it almost impossible to face a group of up to 25 strangers. When I went to his door, he would not answer it, and the music would go off eventually. He would avoid the neighbours for a week, and the following week he would look pretty sheepish when he saw us. That was because he knew us, but you are dealing with people who are going to disappear in a day or two, so they do not need to try to maintain good, neighbourly relations with you. That makes things much more difficult for you. Further, people who are on holiday or are away for a night or a weekend with their friends are much more likely to behave badly than if they are in their own home. People tend to go a bit wild on holiday—they will stay up later and drink more. Another issue is that some of the people who are causing the problems that you are talking about might not realise that they are doing so. I had friends who had a party in an apartment in Edinburgh that they had rented for the weekend. However, one of the neighbours came to the door at four in the morning and said, "Could you just stop, please? We have work to do tomorrow." My friends were horrified because they thought that all the flats were holiday flats; they did not know that there were residents who lived there all the time. The fact that you are dealing with people who do not have any requirement to build up a relationship with you as a neighbour makes things difficult. It is difficult enough to maintain a tenement when everyone in the flats lives there all the time, but your situation is much worse. I support your call for the Government to consider how to tackle the problem, because that is no way to live in your own home.
You are quite right. We have a great problem trying to get something done about the flats. There is a website called hen Edinburgh. Is that how we want Edinburgh to be known? We have nothing against these people coming to the city for hen nights, stag nights or anything like that. However, we have hotels that they can stay in. We have a 200-bed hotel at the bottom of our garden, and we have never had any problems with that. Hen and stag parties use that hotel all the time. Why do they also have to be able to use flats in tenement buildings?If I rented a party flat, I would go there expecting to party. However, as you have suggested, I might not realise that there would be people around me who were not on holiday. You cannot talk to the people who rent the flats because some of them are that drunk that they would not know what they were saying anyway. Some of them have great difficulty finding the keyhole, so they ring every bell in the stair. That is the sort of situation that we have to cope with. There are times when the party flat is empty, and you are still tense, because you are expecting something to happen. You ask, "Where are they? What's happened?" You look out of the window to see what is happening. That is the type of tension that these flats create. My children are grown up, but someone with a young family must feel that they are living through a nightmare. We are frightened to ask people around to our house in case a party starts upstairs and we end up with drunks outside our door. Again, I say that we do not blame the visitors, as they are only doing what they expect to be able to do in a party flat.
We should now discuss the ways in which we can respond to the petition.
Mr Player, would I be right in saying that, at times, you and your neighbours feel yourselves to be prisoners in your own homes?
Yes. As I say, you cannot go and confront them. One of our neighbours did that, and the police came the next day to see him—not about the party flat but about him confronting the neighbours. There is no way out.We cannot define a party flat as being the same as a holiday let. They are two different things. They are complete opposites. There is no way that party flats should be able to operate without rules and regulations. It might be easier to take action if a clear distinction was made between the two sorts of accommodation. I stress again that we are not against people having a good time in Edinburgh. Why people who are against our position keep bringing the festival into it is beyond my comprehension. They seem to think that the festival will come to an end if there are no party flats, but that is not the case. Indeed, hotels will be put out of business if people keep opening up party flats, because they are a cheap option—as I have said, you can pack 10 or 20 people in a room.We do not know what is going to happen next. If there is a fire, drunk people are not going to get out the door; they will just sit there and breathe in the fumes.
Margo MacDonald is with us to discuss a later petition, but perhaps she has something to contribute to this debate—I know that she has lived the life of a Rechabite.
Thank you, convener. Mr Player, the type of behaviour that you describe is not acceptable in any circumstances, whether people are in a party flat or not—I say that not because I am a sinner who has repented, but because it is a piece of nonsense to think otherwise. People should not expect to come to Edinburgh and behave in a way that would be unacceptable in their own place.Since we cannot prevent private owners from letting their property in the short term, perhaps we could have notices in every room reminding folk that there are laws against drunkenness, offensive behaviour, fouling the streets and making other people feel that they do not have the freedom to walk them. There should be wee notices all over the place telling people that if they do not behave properly they will be lifted.
We cannot get people to act in these situations. What would they do with 25 girls in a flat? They could not put them out on the street, and they could not put them in jail because they would fill up the police stations. What can you do?
It is like a lot of things. You will have talked to your pals over the years, so you will know that, for example, the big visit for Glaswegians used to be Blackpool, but they would never consider behaving back home in Glasgow in the way they thought they could get away with behaving in Blackpool. People live colourful lives.The issue is about the framework that operates around where you live and whether agencies are able to deal with these situations. A recent phenomenon has emerged, with people in different cities purchasing properties knowing that in recent years those cities have emerged as weekend destinations. That has happened as part of the tourism framework—and quite rightly. Those people recognised that there is a market, and they know that they are ahead of whatever legislation is in place; they know there is a gap between the antisocial behaviour legislation and the HMO legislation.As a result of your petition, we will try to explore whether there are ways—through guidance and interpreting the legislation—that we can do more to try to empower residents so that they have more peace of mind where they live and are not inconvenienced. That is where we want to get to with the petition. I am looking to members of the committee to suggest helpful ways in which we can move the petition forward so that we can try to address the issue that Mr Player and others have raised with us.
It would certainly be useful to ask a selection of police forces what figures they have. It would also be useful to know whether they record figures for party lets separately. In other words, when they are called out by people in a stair, do the police make a distinction between a disturbance in the stair and a disturbance in a party flat? If they are not doing that already, they should start to do so. That is an important point.I would ask the police whether they record these incidents separately or as part of a general picture. Any force that records the figures in such a way as to be of assistance to us should be asked to go back over them for the past three years. I am pretty certain that the police might support the petition.
I am sure everyone around the table has a great deal of sympathy for Mr Player. It is not an Edinburgh phenomenon: it has spread to Glasgow and perhaps it is a Scotland-wide phenomenon. I have an Evening Times headline here that says: "Forced Out of Homes by Party Animals". I have only one quibble with the headline: why bring poor animals into a situation that involves people misbehaving in such an abominable way?There has to be a close examination of the regulations and whether they can be made more resilient so that they can act on behalf of people who find themselves in the circumstances in which Mr Player and his neighbours—and the residents of Balvicar Street in Queen's Park—have found themselves recently.I suggest that we write to the Scottish Government and ask a number of questions: what is the timescale for the review of the licensing of short-term lets, as part of discussions about implementing new rules on HMOs; what assurances will the Government give that the specific issues of short-term holiday and party lets will be fully addressed; and what immediate measures will it take to alleviate the suffering—I put it as strongly as that—that people have to endure because of these so-called party lets.
The loophole in the current legislation, to which Sarah Boyack referred, must be closed immediately, or as soon as the Government can do so. Mr Player's example of rooms with 15 beds in them, wall to wall, in a party flat shows how people are flouting the legislation that the Government introduced to prevent unscrupulous landlords from filling up rooms with as many beds as possible. In residential areas, where other residents are trying to live a normal life, that is a dramatic flouting of the legislation. We need to find a way to close the loophole in the legislation as quickly as possible.It is also incumbent on us to write to local authorities. Mr Player talked about phoning up the council and trying to get it to intervene on his behalf, as a council taxpayer and a resident, to resolve the situation and stop it happening. There is an onus on local authorities to ensure that people can lead peaceful lives in their own houses without being disturbed by party lets. We should write to local authorities—particularly the City of Edinburgh Council, given the cases in Edinburgh that we have heard about today—to find out how many calls they receive annually from residents who are complaining about the use of party flats.We should also try to find out whether the City of Edinburgh Council knows how many party flats there are in Edinburgh. There should be a register of HMOs. Does the council know how many flats in Edinburgh are being used as party flats? Does it know about the impact that they are having? If there are 15 or 20 people in a flat that is designed to hold six people at the most, the facilities in the flat will be overstretched and will cause problems for the other residents in the area.It might be useful for us to ask local authorities whether they have such figures. If they do not, we should ask why they are not monitoring the situation. There is also the issue of why antisocial behaviour orders have not been taken out against the owners of the flats, making them responsible for the behaviour of the people who use the flats.
That is a series of constructive suggestions from committee members. We will get a range of views from the police and local authorities on the powers that are available at the moment and the interpretation of the legislation. If we pull all that together, we will have a coherent response to the issues that the petitioner has raised with us this afternoon.
I have one final suggestion, which arises from what John Wilson said. Can we ask the Government why it has not considered modifying part 7 of the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004 to remove holiday lets, or party flats, as they are popularly called, from the list of exemptions? I think that there is a way, through regulation, to make the 2004 act much more resilient.
Okay. Does Sarah Boyack have any final comments to make before we conclude our consideration of the petition?
I thank the committee members for all their questions and their interest. Party flats are a relatively recent phenomenon and an economic opportunity for people who own property.I have experience of taking people through the process that is set out in the 2004 act. People tend to keep a diary. As members know, it takes months before anything can happen, as proof is required that it is not just someone complaining. Another difficulty with monitoring party flats and short-term holiday lets is that they are not registered in the same way as other properties, and the landlord's details cannot be found as easily. That can be quite intimidating for people. Marlyn Glen asked about common repairs. It gets a lot harder to resolve the situation when the person who is responsible for the property that has created the problem cannot be found.It would be really useful to address all those issues. I think that, when the legislation was drafted, people did not imagine that flats would be used in the way that has been described this afternoon. That is why the issue needs to be examined reasonably urgently. A relatively small number of properties is involved at the moment, but I worry that the problem will be much bigger in the future if action is not taken.
I hope that the discussion has been helpful, Mr Player. We will pull together the responses and notify you in due course when the committee is to discuss the petition next, after it has received the responses. We will continue to raise the matter and we hope to explore some of the issues on your behalf. The committee's questioning indicates our genuine sympathy with the plight that you and other residents face. We hope to find better solutions that overcome some of the difficulties that you have experienced in past years.
Thank you. I hope that the committee finds solutions, because the situation cannot continue.
Thank you for your time.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 May 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 5 May 2009 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 53
- New Petitions Petitions · 29
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 10
- New Petitions Petitions · 21
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 24
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.