Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Football Stadia (Safe Standing Areas) (PE1248)

Tuesday 5 May 2009 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 53 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

53 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Welcome to the eighth meeting in 2009 of the Scottish Parliament's Public Petitions Committee. I thank everyone for their attendance. We have received no apologies, but one member may be late because of another committee commitment.I say to everyone in the room that all mobile phones and other electronic devices should be switched off.Agenda item 1 is new petitions. We have five new petitions to consider. Members have copies of them and the supporting information in the papers that were issued for the meeting.The first petition is PE1248, by Stephen Taylor, on behalf of Dunfermline Athletic Supporters Society Ltd. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to reintroduce safe standing areas at Scottish Premier League football stadia to give professional clubs the option of having seated or standing areas at their football grounds. I welcome to the meeting Stephen Taylor, Andrew Bailey and Deborah Paton. John Park MSP has also indicated an interest in the petition.Stephen Taylor has two or three minutes to speak to the key points in the petition. He can then respond to questions from members of the committee. Andrew Bailey and Deborah Paton should feel free to speak when appropriate.

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

On behalf of the Pars Supporters Trust, I thank the committee for giving us an opportunity to speak to it. That opportunity has lifted our campaign's profile and given us a boost. I hope that it will give us a good platform as we proceed. I also thank the parliamentary support staff for their help in getting us this far and John Park for his support.Why do we want safe standing areas to be reintroduced in top-class football grounds in Scotland? I think that it is generally accepted that we have seen a bit of a decline in support at football matches in Scotland in recent years. Even visits by the old firm to provincial clubs do not necessarily guarantee ticket sell-outs now. Many factors are involved—the standing/sitting debate is only one factor to consider—but it is clear that we need to draw supporters back to the game.Football has a major economic influence in Scotland. It supports many businesses and jobs throughout the country and is therefore extremely important.The Scottish Football Association's licensing rules for member clubs impose minimum standards in all aspects of running a professional club. They include the minimum 6,000-seat rule and the no-standing rule for Scottish Premier League clubs. Many clubs have put themselves into severe financial difficulty to comply with the all-seated rule. They include our club, Kilmarnock Football Club and Inverness Caledonian Thistle. I think that Falkirk FC is introducing a new third stand as well. We saw the demise of Gretna FC last year. That was partly due to the ground rules, which meant that it had to share with Motherwell FC for a season. That certainly did not help its financial situation.This time next year, clubs such as Queen of the South, Greenock Morton and Ross County could be in contention for promotion to the SPL, and they might have to spend hundreds of thousands of pounds to upgrade their grounds. That is silly in these difficult economic times. Many of the seats will never be needed, so what is the point of having them?We believe that there has been a clear reduction in the general atmosphere at football matches. The tone tends to be lower and things tend to be a bit quiet when everybody sits. I think that even old firm fans would say that the atmosphere can be a bit flat in normal, run-of-the-mill games at Parkhead and Ibrox, although it is not in UEFA champions league matches or when the old firm meet at those grounds. We were at Dumfries on Saturday. Queen of the South has one of the largest traditional terracings in the country. It was well populated and safe.Safety is a major concern in the campaign. We have been asked many questions about safety over the past three or four months. It is a bit of a coincidence—an unhappy coincidence in some respects—that our campaign has clashed with the 20th anniversary of the Hillsborough disaster. That has caused many questions about safety to be asked.The Taylor report made it clear that the Hillsborough disaster was not an issue about sitting or standing. The problems at Hillsborough were to do with access to the ground and the fact that supporters were being moved into a caged area that had no escape routes. German football leagues have coped with a mix of standing and sitting for many years. As ever, the Germans are perhaps technically ahead of us in the style and construction of terracing and seating.We have reached the stage at which the policing and stewarding at football matches is very much on top of crowd control. Trouble and safety are not really issues in the standing/sitting debate. Standing is not inherently unsafe. What is the first thing that fans do at half-time in an all-seated stadium? They stand up. What do they do when their team scores a goal? Admittedly, it has not happened at Dunfermline all that much this year, but they stand up and jump around. It is not unsafe to stand up. Why is it that we are allowed to stand at a rock concert or a racecourse?The football authorities have not always shown themselves to be on the side of the supporters, who tend to be a wee bit down the pecking order. We saw that recently, when some international matches were televised on obscure satellite channels. The fans do not always get the attention that they deserve from the authorities. The campaign has already been knocked back by the SFA and the SPL.We are not looking for mandatory change or new legislation. Enough red tape surrounds football already. What we are really looking for is support from Parliament to give the football authorities in this country a nudge and to get them to consider reintroducing limited safe standing areas.We are conscious that Henry McLeish will be heading up a new commission on Scottish football. It would be a great plus for us if we could get on to his agenda. It is great that we are achieving a profile here: we have John Park's support and I hope that we will also have that of committee members.On the issue of where we go from here, to a certain extent we will have to pass that ball back to the committee. We believe that this is a campaign worthy of support and that it has wide support throughout the country, but it is a matter of choice. We do not want clubs to be forced to introduce seating. Individuals clubs should be able to discuss the matter with their supporters.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you, Stephen. I invite committee members to ask questions. At the end, if John Park wishes to contribute he can do so too.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Good afternoon, colleagues. I have a number of questions. First, Stephen, you said that there is wide support from other clubs and supporters organisations. How do you know that, and how wide and profound is that support?

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

The petition had almost 2,400 signatures from all parts of the country and abroad. We are part of the Supporters Direct network. Most clubs in the country—Scotland and down south—have set up supporters trusts, which are members of Supporters Direct. We know that there has been tremendous support from other supporters organisations throughout the country. A major campaign in England, which I think is being organised by the Football Supporters Federation, is very much behind us as well.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

You talked about the German experience in the Bundesliga. Have there been any incidents that should give us pause for thought before we support the intent of your petition? In other words, given what you said about Germany being an example that we should follow, is it completely safe?

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

I have found no notable recorded incidents of any form in Germany. Within the past two months, there have been recorded incidents in all-seater stadia in Africa, which goes against the idea that all-seater stadia are safe. The two major incidents in world football have been in all-seater stadia. We are not aware of anything in the German league to cause any concern.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Stephen Taylor mentioned Hillsborough, and you explained why you do not think that that is a correct analogy to the intent of your petition. Am I right in thinking that what you are asking for would only involve part of a football ground? The Ibrox disaster—for those of us who are old enough to remember it—was to do with people standing up and there being too many people. I remember that, when I was a kid, there was a great atmosphere. There were about 110,000 people at the old Hampden Park when Denis Law scored the equaliser against West Germany in 1969—it was exciting, but a wee bit intimidating. Am I right about what you are asking for?

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

Absolutely—we are not looking at going back to where we were. We are looking at probably quite limited standing areas, whether they would be a small corner or a section of an existing stand. Some of the major German stadia—including those of some of the top clubs in the Bundesliga—have some terracing that can take up to 20,000 supporters. I do not think that any grounds in this country would really stretch to that, other than perhaps the two old firm grounds. We are not suggesting that we go back that way. The facilities at football grounds have moved on tremendously in the past 30 to 40 years, and we certainly do not want to do anything that would be viewed as a backwards step.

Andrew Bailey Pars Supporters Trust
link

One aspect that must be considered is the situation in the German Bundesliga. In a lot of cases, the fans are self-regulating and self-policing; it is actually the fans who regulate the safety in the stadium—they take individual and collective responsibility for that.

Andrew Bailey Pars Supporters Trust
link

It appears to work in the majority of stadiums in the Bundesliga where the fans do that.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

That is not the question. The question is whether self-regulation—fans regulating themselves—always works.

Andrew Bailey Pars Supporters Trust
link

In the majority of instances that we have looked at. Borussia Dortmund is a keen example of where it actually works: the fans take responsibility for ensuring that the gangways and exits are clear.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I accept that, but again I come back to my previous question: does it work in all cases? Can you guarantee that?

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

We cannot guarantee that, but we are not asking for self-stewarding—we would continue to work with the police and the stewarding forces to have a safe standing area covering approximately 10 or 20 per cent of the ground. We are not considering going back to terracing en masse.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I thank Deborah Paton for answering my question to Andrew Bailey.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

In my many years of experience in attending football matches—and rugby matches, for that matter—I have often regretted the passing of the standing areas, because the atmosphere is different. I am happy to accept that as a strong argument.Most of my questions have already been answered, but I have one further question. You have quoted evidence only from Germany at the moment—do you have evidence from other football leagues in Europe? Do you intend to look at other leagues to back up your arguments?

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

It is an on-going process. We are looking throughout the world to find out where safe standing areas have been introduced. A lot of countries have not moved to all-seater stadia, so there are still a large number of terraces out there. The situation in Germany is the most obvious example, and we have quite a lot of information about that, but we are continuing to look around. I cannot give you any more information than that at this point—sorry.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

More research would be appreciated by those people who might be on your side.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I was quite impressed when I read the petition—you have done your homework on the subject. It was persuasive for me when you mentioned the possibility of Greenock Morton getting to the SPL.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

That is an ambitious commitment.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

It is a five-year plan, convener.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

There are two other things that I found persuasive in your arguments. One was the analogy of a rock concert, which made me think. You are right: at rock concerts people can either be seated or standing, and concerts are often held in football stadia such as Hampden Park. I am interested in that argument and the fact that you are not talking about making standing areas mandatory.What concerns me, however, is that you state that the Taylor report says that the Hillsborough disaster was not to do with whether there was seating or standing. In the part of the report that discussed how to achieve overall safety, Lord Taylor said:"I am satisfied that seating does more to achieve these objectives than any other single measure".That implies that he was citing the fact that the stadium was not all seated as a cause of the disaster. Do you dispute that he is saying that? Am I interpreting it wrongly? If I am not interpreting it wrongly, I will be interested to hear your comments on that statement.

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

I take your point. We all accept that sitting down tends to lower the temperature and subdue the atmosphere in grounds; for a start, you do not get the same movement. However, I maintain that the basic problems that arose at Hillsborough—as with the Ibrox disaster, which was mentioned earlier—were more to do with entering the ground. Once you get people into the safe standing or sitting area, there are usually no problems. Of course, there are other major factors such as policing and stewarding, the design of stairways and so on. As I say, though, I accept that seating is a contributory factor, which is why we are not saying that we should go back to the massive terracing that we had in the past. We are simply saying that there should be fairly limited, well-controlled and well-maintained areas.By the way, Dunfermline are playing Greenock Morton tonight. They could be in trouble.

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

Speaking of which, I point out that at Greenock Morton's ground the terracing opposite the main stand has seating with standing behind it. That is quite unusual; I do not think that any other ground in Scotland has that.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

That is for Greenock Morton's escape committee.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Have you discussed your plans with the police? If so, what response did you receive?

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

We have not spoken directly to the police, but we have taken the matter up with Dunfermline's stadium manager, who is the main liaison with the match day commander. We realise that we are going to have to talk to the police at some stage; after all, we can do all this work and get everyone on side, but if the police say no that will be the end of it.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

You have made some good and interesting points but, when I watch a football match on the television, I cannot tell whether the spectators are sitting or standing. In fact, they sometimes have a great big flag on top of them and I simply do not think that any of them can see the match. What are the benefits of standing as opposed to sitting? Surely if the spectators do not have a clear view, it does not matter whether they are standing or sitting.If you replaced a seating area for 500 people with a standing-only area, would that increase or reduce a ground's capacity?

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

That might be a relevant issue to discuss with the police or, indeed, the SFA's licensing committee. Such a move could reduce a ground's capacity, because we are not looking for a return to the days when everyone was hemmed in shoulder to shoulder, but I cannot say for certain.

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

Some top-class games will always have a capacity crowd, but I think that, in the 12 years that East End Park has been an all-seater stadium, it has been filled to capacity only twice. There are always lots of empty seats. As a result, even if capacity were reduced, we would not expect it to have a significant financial effect on the club.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I suppose that this applies to other clubs such as Greenock Morton and Partick Thistle that hope to get into the Premier League, but if Dunfermline were promoted how many fans would you like or expect to see in a standing area? I imagine that the average attendance at one of your home matches is 4,500 to 5,000.Given that the petition is on behalf of the Pars Supporters Trust, why have fans been compelled to express themselves on this issue? Is it because of concerns about the SPL's punitive conditions for entry into the league, which have made it difficult for clubs to survive economically? Indeed, a number of clubs have had to make difficult decisions that have had various consequences.

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

There are three key issues to address. First, I have to say that we would love to have gates of 4,500 at our football matches. The figure is probably closer to about 3,000.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

But if you were in the Premier League—

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

In that case, the answer is yes; we would hope to get 4,500 to 5,000 at Premier League matches. It would be great to get 10 to 20 per cent of home fans in the standing area; certainly a pilot that involved 10 per cent would be a good way to go.As we have already made clear, we feel compelled to bring this petition to the Parliament because of the financial implications that the issue has for clubs. Our club has already been through this process, and our stadium is now all-seater. Of course, reversing that would have financial implications that would have to be dealt with, and the truth is that, at the moment, our club would be unable to cover the costs.As Stephen Taylor has pointed out, fans are the customers of Scottish football, but they have no choice at games. That is causing ructions between different fans, because those who choose to stand in inappropriate places block the view of the people who want to sit down. We want to give all fans the opportunity to enjoy the football experience in their chosen environment.I cannot remember what the third issue was.

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

We are probably talking about having 500 in the standing area. We do not want to go back to the old days when several thousand people might have been standing in one area. Quite a lot of supporters have got used to sitting, and we do not expect all of them to get back on their feet again.

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

That reminds me of my third point, which is about atmosphere. A couple of months ago, when we played in the quarter-final at Pittodrie, all the Dunfermline fans were standing and the atmosphere that was generated was—rightly or wrongly—totally different from anything that we have experienced recently. Of course it was wrong for them to be standing, but there was a better atmosphere. As a result, we feel that it would be better to give fans the choice of going into a safe standing area.

John Park Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have to say that I prefer to sit at matches, particularly when I bring my children along. However, if you are in the north stand at Hampden at a Scotland match, you have no option but to stand, because the vast majority of the people are on their feet. In fact, I would argue that at Scotland matches the whole ground stands, apart from the fans in the main stand. That gives you some idea of the challenges that face police and stewards and the issues that can arise between supporters.Perhaps I should give the committee some background about the Pars Supporters Trust. It does a lot of work in the club—for example, it generates a lot of income for youth development, represents supporters' views and so on—and I am pleased to support not only its petition but its work in general.Members have helpfully highlighted certain issues that the trust will have to reflect on. For example, Anne McLaughlin made a pertinent point about Justice Taylor's 1989 report about Hillsborough and the fact that at that point the only solution for improving safety in grounds was to introduce seating. However, the culture of supporting football has changed a lot over the past 20 years: for example, more families attend matches than ever before. The grounds, and particularly access to them, have improved and the police, the stewards and the authorities have more of an understanding about crowd control.The trust is looking for a number of things, and I know that their proposals have wider support from football fans. However, the authorities need to take a closer look at the issue. It would be useful if it could be covered in the upcoming review of Scottish football and, indeed, if it could be examined by some of the other parliamentary committees.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

As John Park made clear, it is interesting to compare what happens at football games nowadays, with families and children going along, with the joys and pleasures that I experienced at Saturday afternoon games 30 or 40 years ago and my expectations of what was going to happen either behind or in front of me.I want to draw out comparisons with the Bundesliga, where the witnesses said the fans police themselves. I suppose that one question is whether there is confidence that the fans would do that in a standing-only terrace in Scotland. The fact is that not every fan is like that—as John Park said, at a Scotland game you could end up standing for the whole 90 minutes because the fans in front of you were standing. That detracts from the pleasure of people who bring their families and young children along to enjoy the game. If someone who is 6ft 6in is standing in front of a child, who is seated or is standing in order to look over that person, their view of the game is completely different. I remember that on the terraces parents had to lift their children on to their shoulders to enable them to watch the game. We need to ensure that the pleasure of watching the game is retained, and we should not assume that self-policing on certain terraces is the panacea that will allow us to move forward.A number of changes have taken place in football grounds, including in the use of alcohol. The facilities that are available in some grounds now are a lot better than those that were available 30 or 40 years ago, but there needs to be self-policing among fans. If we have standing areas in grounds, how will we regulate them? Will football clubs and police authorities have to put more people in situ? The Ibrox disaster, which has been mentioned, was caused not by people standing on the terraces but by people trying to get back up stairway 13 because a last-minute goal had been scored; there was a crush on the stairway, not on the terraces. We must regulate to ensure that we do not have another such disaster.One criticism at Hillsborough was that the police and stewards let more and more fans in, so that people had to escape the crush that was taking place. Can we guarantee that that situation will not arise again on standing terraces, especially at some of the smaller league grounds, if 20,000 fans are outside trying to push their way in and the police or stewards decide to open the gates to allow more in?

Deborah Paton Pars Supporters Trust
link

You have raised two key issues—thank you for making those points. You mentioned the change that has taken place in the past few years, in that more families now go to football matches. When I went to the football 30 years ago, I went with my dad. His choice was to take us to the main stand, so that we were not on the terracing. The crux of the petition is to give people choice, which is no longer available—fans currently have no choice but to sit.I do not want to take the discussion too far into the issue of self-regulation. The petition is not about that—it is about working with the authorities to ensure that there is a small, safe standing area in which we can create some atmosphere in a sport that is struggling in this country.

Stephen Taylor Pars Supporters Trust
link

You have given us a perfect example of why we need dedicated standing areas, so that people do not stand where they should not and block the view of families and others. Our campaign started partly because youngsters were standing up and other people could not see.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

A fair number of questions have been asked, and the answers have been thorough. You know that this is a sensitive issue, as we have just had the 20-year anniversary of a terrible tragedy that occurred elsewhere in the United Kingdom; we have also had our own tragedies in Scotland in the past 30 or 40 years.I am trying to get a sense of the dimensions of what is proposed. You identified a couple of issues that are subject to on-going review by the SFA; we can discuss whether we want to refer the petition to that review. There are other issues relating to the legislative framework and the SPL's criteria for the condition of grounds and the nature of pitches. I invite members to indicate how they think we should proceed. We can then pull together and act on the suggestions that are made.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

It has been an interesting session that has cleared up matters for me and, I hope, for other members. I think that we should write to the Scottish Government. I know that it has said that it has no plans to review the current policy on all-seater stadia but, when we write to the Government, we could perhaps ask whether there are any circumstances in which it might hold such a review. We could ask it what representations it has received on the issue from football clubs, supporters organisations, the police and other interested parties.Health and safety is important, so we should perhaps write to the Health and Safety Executive for its views on whether standing areas should be reintroduced, albeit on a restricted basis. Is there any evidence of a causal link between standing and accidents at football stadia? It would be helpful to know about that.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I would like to follow up my question to Mr Taylor by asking the police what they think. That would probably mean writing to the Scottish Police Federation and the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland to seek their views.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

We should ask them to acknowledge that an increasing problem is being caused by people standing in seating areas.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We should refer the petition to the McLeish review, which will perhaps have some discussions on the matter. It might be asking too much of the review to find solutions to all the issues that face Scottish football, however.I am intrigued by the question that has been raised. Watching coverage of the Bundesliga, I am struck by the numbers of people and the atmosphere. There are still big attendances at games in Germany, where access to football matches is still relatively inexpensive compared with Scottish or British football. I would be interested if the Scottish Parliament information centre could provide us with an overview of the issues from around the world, including Germany—an advanced European nation with similar infrastructure characteristics to ours. It is a good example to consider.There could also be a discussion with the SPL and the Scottish Football League about whether there is any flexibility on interpretation regarding the nature of football grounds, given that the requirements have caused clubs difficulty in the recent past and bearing in mind the economic climate that clubs face and its effect on attendances. There will continue to be pressure on clubs.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I suggest that, when we write to the Health and Safety Executive, and possibly when we write to the Government, we ask why the rules are different for rock concerts, particularly given that they are often held in football stadia.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I am not sure whether Supporters Direct or the Football Supporters Federation have been mentioned. It would be useful to get the views of the fans, too, and to see whether there is a general demand for the reintroduction of standing areas. In particular, I would like to draw out the views of the fans who support the petition on family attendance at games. We must bear it in mind that we are trying to widen out football to bring in the younger generation, not only to view and support the game but to participate. It would be useful to find out whether any difficulties are foreseen with younger children. There used to be parent-and-child terraces in many grounds—but that is going back a few years ago now.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I think that we have gone through all the issues, so I will explain what happens next.We will explore the issues further, and the petitioners will be kept fully up to date on what happens. The petition will return to the committee once we have received the responses. Although you do not have the opportunity to speak directly to the petition again, given that you have had this involvement today, the MSPs who express an interest in a petition often come back to the committee to follow through on the issues. You will also be invited to the committee when the petition is considered again, although, as I have said, you cannot participate directly at that stage.I hope that we can explore some of the issues further. I thank the petitioners for their time. They have raised an issue that people wish to be explored further, and I hope that we can assist with some of that discourse.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 5 May 2009 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 53
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 29
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 10
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 21
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 24
  25. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.