PE1206, by Catriona Black, on behalf of the mums need to use Lothian Buses too campaign, urges the Scottish Government to encourage public transport operators and appropriate stakeholders to provide parents and carers of babies and young children with equitable access to public buses when using prams, travel systems and buggies. There is further correspondence on the issue, and the petition has previously come before the committee. Are there any comments or observations on what to do with it?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Public Transport (Equal Access) (PE1206)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 8
- Bill Butler Lab 5
- Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP 5
- Marlyn Glen Lab 2
- Nigel Don SNP 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
- Nanette Milne Con 1
The record
25 contributionsWe do not have a locus in terms of the conditions of carriage—those are a matter for each bus operator. There is guidance in the Public Service Vehicles (Conduct of Drivers, Inspectors, Conductors and Passengers) (Amendment) Regulations 2002, which clearly define the rules on the conduct that is expected. I am not sure what else we can usefully do, but the convener will be open to suggestions from other members.
Do other members have any comments?
I have to agree with Bill Butler. I do not see what else we can do. The petition seems to have got to the end of the road—although not back to the bus station, unfortunately. I am mystified as to why Lothian Buses persists in taking an approach that no other bus company takes, as far as I can see. However, we do not have the power to make the company change its mind. We might just have to wait until it does so.
Shirley-Anne Somerville has just arrived. Shirley-Anne, we are discussing what—if anything—we can do about PE1206. So far, members have said that there is not much more that we can do. I know that you have raised the issue, so we wanted to get hold of you before concluding our consideration of the petition.
link
I apologise for my late arrival, convener. I had to be pulled out of the meeting of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee.There is still a role for the Scottish Parliament. I urge the committee to consider two points. First, I see from the submissions that you are still waiting for replies from UK Government ministers on the issue. It would be advisable to await a response from Westminster, which might provide more information about how regulations are implemented and the difference between what is said in guidance and what happens in reality.Secondly, and on a wider point, the Parliament has a responsibility to encourage equal opportunities. Companies have been told that, by law, they must consider disabled groups, which is entirely appropriate, but it is disappointing that groups that are not mentioned in legislation, such as mothers of young babies, are being left behind. I think that that is discrimination against carers of young children. We should bear it in mind that we are talking not about a pram ban but a ban on babies and young children.If equal opportunities are to be taken seriously, they must be for all vulnerable groups and not just for groups that are covered by legislation. Someone needs to stand up for groups whose needs are not required by law to be catered for, and someone needs to investigate how a company can continue to discriminate against a vulnerable group. I strongly suggest that the Parliament can and should play that role, to ensure that vulnerable groups in society are properly represented and are not forgotten.
Thank you. I know that you rushed in to make your comments—you did well.
I declare an interest as a member for the Lothians.Does Shirley-Anne Somerville think that we should refer the petition to the Equal Opportunities Committee?
link
I would be happy if you did that, as I am sure the campaign group would be. The petition highlights a problem about a vulnerable group in society. I appreciate that, in many ways, the Scottish Parliament's hands are tied in relation to what the Public Petitions Committee and the Scottish Government can do, but the problem will continue and it is an equal opportunities issue.
The issue is sensitive. The committee has received submissions from groups who campaign on behalf of individuals who have a disability, who feel strongly that, given the legal framework, their rights should predominate. Bus operators have told us in correspondence that they are trying to manage divergent expectations and that their primary duty is to ensure that there is space on buses for individuals who use a wheelchair. I do not know whether the issue can be resolved. I will be honest and admit that I think that a wheelchair user's need to be able to use a bus is more important that a young mother's need, irrespective of the inconvenience that might be caused.
link
I would have much more sympathy with Lothian Buses if I thought that that was why the policy was developed, but I do not think that, for two reasons. When I asked in correspondence when the company had sought legal advice, I was told that it sought advice from Brodies LLP on 8 August last year. The ban was introduced in June 2008. I am surprised that legal advice was not sought before June, if the ban is supposed to be based on that advice.I also asked whether figures were available that detailed the number of complaints about prams. It took two weeks for the company to get back to me, because the figures were not available. When it got back to me, the figures covered foldable and unfoldable buggies. Given that Lothian Buses did not have those figures to hand, the figures that it provided obviously were not based on a report that detailed the numbers of complaints and the problems that caused them.I asked how many complaints had been submitted because of problems with suitcases or luggage or because buses had been full of commuters, with the result that wheelchair users could not get on them. I am still waiting for a reply to that, albeit that I asked for the information just last week. The fact that the company does not have figures that break down the reasons why wheelchair users could not get on buses shows that it was not looking at the problem of wheelchair access in its entirety; it simply picked on the issue with prams.We have reached a position in which, instead of trying to find a solution, the company is defending its policy by any means. The way in which it has sought to do so is particularly disappointing. I believe that Lothian Buses drew the committee's attention to an Ipsos MORI poll.The phraseology has been used that in the battle of the wheels, the wheelchair users have won, but no one has won. Wheelchair users are still having problems getting on to Lothian buses because of foldable prams, suitcases and full buses. The problem is not being dealt with. If wheelchair access is indeed a problem, we must examine it in the round, rather than pick out of thin air a policy that does not seem to be based on legal advice or complaints.
I guess that all colleagues on the committee, all members of the Parliament and the majority of members of the public will have a great deal of sympathy with the petition. I do not mind if we do as Ms Somerville suggests and wait for replies from Westminster on a number of issues pertaining to the guidance and its implementation—that would be fine—and I do not disagree with referring the petition to the Equal Opportunities Committee, if that were thought appropriate. The problem is more to do with the fact that the legislation—which I would have hoped would be more passenger friendly than bus operating company friendly—is reserved to Westminster.I do not think that the proper balance has been struck, but that is not a matter for the committee or even the Parliament to address. I do not have any objection to our waiting for the results of the monitoring of the guidance that has been issued or to our referring the petition to another committee, but, in the end, that might not get us anywhere, which would be unfortunate.
As a member of the Equal Opportunities Committee, I am not sure how referring the petition to that committee would progress matters, as consideration of it would not fit into our work programme. We would still be in the same position.The member makes an extremely strong case, which comes back to the point that only Lothian Buses has taken the action in question; everyone else must have worked out how to solve the problem. I agree that we should not close the petition but should wait for replies to the letters that the member has written and from Westminster about the guidelines.In the meantime, we can only hope that Lothian Buses will open up discussions and talk about the issue. As Shirley-Anne Somerville says, wheelchair users need to be able to get on to buses, regardless of what is in their way. From an equal opportunities perspective, there is certainly an argument that the gender duty is just as strong as any other duty. Women with children also need to have access to transport.
I am happy with what has been suggested. I am not sure whether Shirley-Anne Somerville knows whether Lothian Buses has been in communication with other companies. The buses and trains that I travel on have notices up that ask passengers to vacate a space if a wheelchair user needs it. It is clear that wheelchair users have priority, but if there is no wheelchair user to use a space, there is no reason why other people should not use it, whether for a buggy or for luggage.
link
Lothian Buses does not appear to be interested in finding a solution. The transport committee of the City of Edinburgh Council, which owns Lothian Buses, requested that Lothian Buses meet the campaign group. The transport committee is interested in a public education campaign, in which everyone who might use the wheelchair spaces gets a leaflet with information and advice.The problems continue. Lothian Buses is continuing with its policy and has not taken up the council's request. The transport committee gave its instructions a number of months ago, but Lothian Buses has refused to comply.
And you say that Lothian Buses is owned by the council.
link
Indeed.
Well, that is a strange one.I hope that Lothian Buses would not want to be seen as a company that is deaf to its owners and is instituting what is, in effect, a baby ban. That would be very bad publicity, so I hope that the company will desist. "Baby ban" would be one of the least productive slogans for a publicly-owned company that is trying to attract customers. We all agree on that, do we not, convener?
The recommendation is that we keep the petition open, but the question remains whether it would be appropriate to refer it to the Equal Opportunities Committee.
I am concerned about the petition being batted to the Equal Opportunities Committee and nothing happening for a long time. If this committee keeps it on the table, we can give it more of a push. Are we in a position to write and ask about the meeting that should have taken place, just to encourage things along?
Yes, we can do that. We will take on board all the recommendations that committee members have made. A debate continues in the Lothians about the right to use bus services.We will keep the petition open and pursue the recommendation that we write to Lothian Buses about the concerns that have been raised.
Can we also write to City of Edinburgh Council to ask whether there is anything that we can do to assist it in persuading the bus company to do its duty?
Okay. Thank you, Shirley-Anne. I know it was a bit of a rush, but you can get back to the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee now.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Feb 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 10 February 2009 Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 58
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 25
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.