The first petition is PE1150, by David Wemyss, on behalf of the Aberdeen prison visiting committee, which calls on Parliament to urge the Government to consider whether large prisons that are remote from prisoners' families offer the best way of rehabilitating offenders, or whether, as an alternative, community prisons should be supported much more strongly in order to maintain genuinely easy access to family links and to other community virtues.Subsequent to our discussion of the petition, it is useful to have present this afternoon the minister with responsibility for prisons, Kenny MacAskill, along with Tom Fox from the Scottish Prison Service. I welcome you both to this afternoon's meeting. We wish to follow up on a number of issues arising from the petition. If the minister wishes to make any opening statement he may do so—although I see that he is happy simply to respond to questions.Several constituency and regional members have expressed an interest in the matter, and some might well be present at some point in the meeting.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Community Prisons (PE1150)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kenny MacAskill SNP 23
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 9
- Frank McAveety Lab 7
- Richard Baker Lab 5
- Nanette Milne Con 4
- Marlyn Glen Lab 4
- Nigel Don SNP 4
- Robin Harper Green 2
The record
58 contributionsI am glad to see you before the committee this afternoon, cabinet secretary.The focus of the petitioner, and of North East Scotland members such as me, has been on whether Peterhead is the right place for the Grampian community prison. I am aware that the committee cannot focus on that, however, and that it must focus on the Government's national policy intentions, so I will not deal with specifics at this stage.We have heard from Families Outside and other bodies that the best way for prisoners to be rehabilitated into the community is for them to maintain regular contact with their families. That is backed up by research.Can large prisons that are quite remote from prisoners' homes, and which might be difficult for their families to access, offer the best means of rehabilitation? Would not support for community prisons close to where prisoners live—which would allow their families easy access and make maintaining regular contact easier—be more likely to lead to successful rehabilitation?
As a Government, we accept that key factors in boosting rehabilitation are prisoners' ability to maintain family contact, to have homes to go back to and jobs to pick up. At present, 56 per cent of prisoners from an Aberdeen area postcode are not in prison in Aberdeen.To some extent, it is a question of balance. We cannot have a prison in every community, nor would we want that, because that would be indicative of problems in our communities. Many places in Scotland do not have their own prison, including the city of Dundee, East Kilbride and Paisley, despite their significant size. Ideally, prisons would be available in such places, but there has to be a balance. There is also the issue of resources to consider.There are particular pressures on resources in Aberdeen. Understandably, people want the Aberdeen western peripheral bypass. A prison is not cheap. Prisons are not cheap to run—it costs £40,000 per prisoner per annum and it costs at least £140 million to build one. If we were to build a prison in Aberdeen, we would either have to not build one elsewhere, or to take resources from the budget that—thankfully—we signed off last week.We accept that there are difficulties, but we believe that HM Prison Grampian in Peterhead offers great opportunities. We are rebuilding on-site at Peterhead. That could not be done at Aberdeen. There are difficulties to do with land acquisition for a prison in Aberdeen and the clamour for a prison is greater in Peterhead. People there welcome the fact that a new prison is being built. That is not always the case—some people do not welcome the name of their town being given to a prison.Are there difficulties with distance? Yes, but the distance between Aberdeen and Peterhead is 30 miles, whereas Aberdeen to Glenochil is a 220-mile round trip, so the new prison will allow people in Aberdeen to make a significant saving. At present, they have to go to Glenochil or Polmont to visit young offenders and to Cornton Vale to visit women. The prison for the Grampian area in Peterhead will be community facing—it will take youngsters and women prisoners, as well as local prisoners.
That has opened up issues with regard to the current prison in Aberdeen, which had women prisoners until fairly recently, when the accommodation was reckoned not to be fit for purpose. Some people in the city are of the viewpoint that that could be put right.You mentioned Glenochil, but it is not easy to get from Aberdeen to Peterhead. The bus service is not good, there is no train service and many of the people concerned will not have their own transport. What would be a reasonable travelling time for those people, given that around 80 per cent of the prisoners at HM Prison Aberdeen are from Aberdeen itself?
We make no apologies for the fact that there are no women prisoners in Aberdeen prison. The decision to stop sending women prisoners to Aberdeen, taken by our predecessor Government, which was of a different political inclination, was quite correct. During my 20 years as a defence agent, I visited women prisoners in the prison in Aberdeen. The environment there was intimidating and threatening, and the circumstances in which women were held were, frankly, unacceptable. Previous ministers took the correct decision, which we have adhered to.There is a distance between Aberdeen and Peterhead, but we must put the situation in perspective. The First Minister and Stewart Stevenson would dispute the assertion that Peterhead is the ends of the earth, even if it is at the end of a juncture. For legitimate reasons, the places where many prisons are located are not the easiest places to get to. Saughton and Barlinnie are in the middle of communities for historical reasons, but Kilmarnock prison is at the end of a long road and is outwith the town of Kilmarnock. Addiewell might be adjacent to Loganlea and places near where I grew up, but it is not that easy to get to.The Government and the Scottish Prison Service accept that we must do what we can to ensure that relationships can be continued and that families—husbands, wives, grannies or aunties—can visit. The maintenance of such relationships is beneficial to rehabilitation.Our point is that Peterhead is not the ends of the earth. There is a limit to where we can go. In fact, there is considerably more merit and savings for individuals, both those being transported and those having to travel, in going to Peterhead from the Aberdeen area than there is in their having to go to Glenochil and Cornton Vale. It comes back to my earlier point—56 per cent of prisoners from Aberdeen are currently outwith the city of Aberdeen. We hope that the opening of HM Prison Grampian will allow the numbers to increase.Not everyone from an Aberdeen postcode wants to go to prison there, for good reason. Members might have come across that in their constituencies. I have had people come to me on behalf of a son or daughter who is in prison in England and who wants to come back, for example. I have also heard from prisoners who want to move because their girlfriend or whoever has relocated.It is about trying to strike a balance. On the one hand, resources are limited. However, we accept the point that the committee and the petitioner correctly made, which is that maintaining access for families is one of the most pivotal issues, along with a home to go back to and, at some stage, employment to get into.
Obviously, there are different opinions. I will leave it at that.
I have a more general question about the long-term future plans for prisons. When you talk about a new prison you are talking about something that will last a long time. Would the long-term strategy not be to have localised community prisons?
We have inherited a crumbling prison estate. People say that some of it is Victorian, but some of it—for example HM Prison Perth—is Napoleonic. I have been told by the governor at Perth prison that it was in those times that its construction was commenced. We have to address that. We are investing £120 million per annum over the next few years to ensure that we can sign off HM Prison Addiewell, which we inherited, and construct HM Prison Grampian and the prison at Bishopbriggs, which will be adjacent to the old prison at Low Moss. Planning has commenced, but it will be for another Government to sign off replacements for Inverness and Greenock. Those are our plans. As the committee probably knows, Inverness prison is dilapidated, Greenock prison is running into difficulties and there are ongoing works at Shotts and elsewhere. The Government refuses to take the south-of-the-border perspective of titan prisons and so on.It comes back to "You pays your money and you takes your choice." There are people, such as my good friend Bill Aitken, who is not here today, who say, "Let's just build more prisons. Build two additional prisons. Build six additional prisons." We can build as many prisons as we like but we have to pay for them. We will build Grampian and the prison at Bishopbriggs. We will consider replacing Greenock and Inverness, and we will upgrade Ratho Hall and Saughton and consider a replacement at Shotts. However, there comes a time when spending on prisons means that we cannot spend on pensioners. If we build for inmates, we cannot provide schools, homes and hospitals. It is a matter of choice.
What I was really asking was whether there is a long-term vision. What you have described is all reactive stuff, for the future although I absolutely understand that you have got to deal with what exists now. The Equal Opportunities Committee is doing an inquiry into female offenders.
It is a matter of balance. Yes, we want community-facing prisons, which is what HM Prison Grampian will provide for remand prisoners, for youngsters who would have gone to Polmont, and for women prisoners who would have been sent to Cornton Vale. However, some of the numbers affect what the prison can deal with and some prisoners cannot, for security reasons, be dealt with in more local prisons. We support the concept of community-facing prisons so that prisoners' families do not have to travel great distances. It also benefits the Scottish Prison Service if transport requirements are reduced. That has to be balanced against the facts that some prisoners have to be in particular prisons for their own safety, and that others have to be moved elsewhere for gang-related or other reasons. Furthermore, some things cannot be achieved with a restricted number of prisoners. For example, the specialist care that is needed might be located elsewhere.
That leads on to another area altogether. The cost of prisons is an interesting subject. The Government should be comparing the cost of rehabilitation and the overall cost to the community of offenders who are not rehabilitated. I am, therefore, interested in the arguments about costs.The principle of having community prisons is important, too. You have talked about specialised prisons. We are considering Cornton Vale, where specialist services are available, but you are suggesting something entirely different from that. Are you going to have the facilities that are needed in specialised prisons?
It comes back to the question of balance. It is the same in every walk of life. Some things cannot be provided everywhere, but can be provided only where there is a critical mass. It is our intention that there should be community-facing prisons and the opportunity to deal with matters in those prisons. Nevertheless, it is for the SPS to make operational decisions on whether various kinds of education or whatever are provided in prisons. We cannot say that every prison will have X, Y or Z, because that might not be feasible.Community-facing prisons are important if we are, for security reasons, to minimise the amount of necessary travel and minimise the inconvenience for families in order that we can maintain prisoners' links to them.Equally, there are prisons where security must be the priority. Shotts prison, for example, has always been in that category because of the type of prisoners who go there. Also, a limited number of prisoners can create difficulties in respect of providing services for prisoners there, because there is no critical mass to justify those resources. That has been discovered in other prisons.
I would suggest that we want fewer prisoners, not more, and that they should have the appropriate facilities available to them. I will not go on about the costs, but I think that you should look at the costs on a very wide basis, including the costs of reoffending.
You can take it as read that that is the direction of travel that the Government has chosen. We need prisons in this country because we have people who commit serious offences, who must go to prison because they are a danger to our communities and need to be detained. Equally, however, it is clear that a person is less likely to reoffend if they are given a community sentence rather than a short prison sentence.We need a coherent prisons policy whereby prisons are used for serious and dangerous offenders while those who have committed less serious offences pay their communities back through the sweat of their brow for the harm that they have done. That is cheaper for us and is more likely to rehabilitate offenders. It also means that offenders repay their communities for the damage that they have done instead of sitting on their beds and twiddling their thumbs at the taxpayers' expense.
I declare an interest as a long-time member of the Howard League for Penal Reform.I welcome the minister's last few remarks. He will accept that we jail more offenders per head of population than almost any other country in Europe and that we have a huge problem with reoffending. Marlyn Glen asked this question. Is the Government currently discussing a long-term vision for community prisons—for moving away from the present structure of large prisons? The minister is clearly critical of the idea of titan prisons. I would welcome any hint from him that an alternative policy is being actively pursued.
The Government's aim is to have a coherent prisons policy and a coherent penal policy. There is something manifestly wrong if, while we have the lowest level of recorded crimes in 28 years, we have the highest recorded level of imprisonment. As the McLeish commission has confirmed, we in Scotland are not bad people per se and there is no good reason why we should be locking up far more people than our Celtic cousins in the Republic of Ireland or comparable nations elsewhere in Europe.Something is out of kilter. That is not to say that we do not have to have prisons or that people do not have to be in prison. If someone goes around stabbing people we expect them to go to jail. A person who commits a serious offence must be punished and we have to protect people.We have a significant problem with the prison estate because of years of underinvestment. My good friend Bill Aitken is not here, and we should remember that the Tories in power did not build one new prison. Others have had to pick up the slack, which is why we signed off Addiewell prison and Bishopbriggs prison, and why Grampian prison will be built. Replacement prisons are needed. Anyone who visits Greenock prison or Inverness prison sees the problems that we face.We want to discuss community-facing prisons and other matters with community justice authorities. The issue is not just where prisons are located; it is how we deal with prisoners and offenders in communities. CJAs are a recent development and we are working with them and fully support them. My view is that the approach will develop, although many of the issues will not be dealt with in the short term, because in the short term we must provide an estate that is fit for purpose and we must deal with the problem of having far too many people in jail who do not need to be there.The Government thinks that community-facing prisons are the right direction of travel. Other approaches will no doubt be required, because people who commit serious offences and receive significant sentences will be with us for some time to come.
Prison must serve three purposes: punishment, removing people from the community while they are dangerous, and rehabilitation. Do you agree that the punishment should be for the prisoner and not his family, in particular his children? I should have said "his or her children"; a smaller number of children have mothers who are in prison. A child should not be punished because their parent is in prison. Proper and easy access to parents is an important part of the equation, to which the Government should give due consideration.
We absolutely accept that maintaining family contact is important. We draw the line at the suggestion that people who have children should not go to prison. Sentencing is and always will be a matter for the judiciary. Any sheriff or judge must consider the effect of the sentence on the family. However, we should remember that victims have children too. Their rights must also be considered.Social inquiry reports provide sentencers with important background information about the family situation. We must ensure that prison facilities are such that fathers and mothers can continue to interact with their children, because the bond between parent and child is important. It is also important to try to provide for family stability when the prisoner is released. We fully support the general direction of travel that you are talking about.
Perhaps I should declare an interest. I live within walking distance of Aberdeen prison and have been in the prison, but only in a professional capacity. I have also accompanied the police on Union Street on a Saturday night, as I am sure other members have. The shortage of custody cells is of particular relevance in Aberdeen—I am sure that it is an issue in other places. There is therefore an issue about remand cells, given that the courts are bang in the middle of Aberdeen, about 30 miles from Peterhead.What is the possibility of the cabinet secretary's working with the police and the SPS in Aberdeen and elsewhere to ensure that there is an excess—if I dare use the word—of cells close to city centres and courts? That would provide flexibility and might mean that in time prisoners could be released from somewhere nearer their homes.
We are always happy to meet chief constables and police boards. I will meet the chief constable of Grampian Police on Friday morning.Detention cells, unlike remand prisoners, are not in the SPS's domain, but are the responsibility of the police. I expect the SPS would be happy to discuss the configuration of services in Aberdeen and how the chief constable and police board want to spend their money.The SPS is responsible for prisoners who have been convicted and sentenced or who have been remanded awaiting sentence. It is not responsible for people who are detained pending appearance in court—that is the responsibility of the police. In Aberdeen, as in every other community, what you describe as remand—detention on a Friday or Saturday night—is a police responsibility. However, if there is a desire for such a facility, the Government is more than happy to discuss the suggestion and to work with people on it.
That is encouraging. I encourage the cabinet secretary, the police and the SPS to consider to what extent they can work together, especially in city centres. In Aberdeen and, no doubt, other places such as Dundee, there is scope for having an appropriate number of cells for times of peak custody, which are, sadly, usually at weekends, for reasons that we know. Some prisoners who are about to finish their sentences could be housed in those cells for a period, perhaps of weeks. That would keep them closer to home and might assist the process of rehabilitation.
That suggestion could pose practical difficulties for the SPS. The process of arranging release from prison includes various checks and balances. It is not simply a matter a holding or detaining someone—different organisations are involved. Police detention cells are meant to be used for a limited period. Custody courts run even on bank holidays, when the main courts are closed, because there are precise time limits for holding people.I have visited police cells in Scotland in a professional capacity. They are not meant to be places where people are kept for a week or a fortnight, but places where people can be detained safely and securely until the earliest available court day. If someone is detained late on a Friday, they will appear in court on the following Monday morning. If there is a Monday holiday, they may appear on Saturday. Extension of the use of police cells to other people would involve a significant change in structures. We do not rule it out, but we are investing £120 million through the SPS. It is for police boards to consider whether money would be better invested in police officers or in some form of cell accommodation.
You have confirmed that the issue is not as simple as I suggested. The different types of cell accommodation cater for two quite different activities and are not interchangeable.
As any prison governor would tell you, for people on the point of release, there are discussions about housing, families, maintaining treatments for addiction and other issues that members have correctly raised. That provision requires resourcing that would not be available in a detention cell. We are trying to ensure that, when we open the door, prisoners have the opportunity to go home, to be met by their families, to try to obtain employment and to maintain their alcohol or drug addiction treatment policies. We do not want them to be bent by the nearest pimp or drug dealer or to go straight to the nearest off-licence.
A couple of members with constituency or regional interests in the petition have questions.
Further to Nigel Don's questions, you will recall that on 1 November 2007 I asked you in Parliament whether you would consider the case that the Aberdeen prison visitors committee has made for a modern, purpose-built remand centre in Aberdeen. Can I take it from your answer to Mr Don's questions that you still intend not to go down that road?
No. We are open to any suggestions. The proposal would have to be put before us, as it does not relate to an SPS responsibility and raises practical issues—the police board would have to consider how it could be financed. However, I do not rule out such suggestions.
You may have misunderstood my question, which relates to a specific SPS responsibility—the 100 prisoners held at Craiginches who are on remand. Would you consider creating a unit in Aberdeen to house those prisoners prior to their attendance at court?
The issue is where we would get the funding from for that. If you are suggesting that funds could be freed up from other areas, I am more than happy to look at that. At present, with the budget that we face, there ain't no money there. If such a unit is wanted in Aberdeen, would I rule it out? We recognise that we are a minority Government and these things could be forced on us. I return to the point that I made to Nanette Milne at the outset: if that is what you want, what do you want to cut?
So, in essence, your view is that either Peterhead prison goes ahead as a rebuild as you have planned or you create a facility in Aberdeen. You are not prepared to consider both within your current budget.
It is not simply Peterhead. Low Moss/Bishopbriggs, Inverclyde and Inverness are coming on the horizon—never mind Ratho hall and upgrades at Shotts and other prisons, such as Perth, which has other issues. There is on-going investment of £120 million and there just ain't no cash.
You are of course aware that the submission to the committee's inquiry from Families Outside, which seeks to represent the views and interests of families of people in prison, said that classifying HMP Grampian as a community-facing prison for Aberdeen is ludicrous. Do you understand why it has taken that view?
I met Dr Loucks at the Skills for Justice centre. I disagree entirely with that view. It comes back to the point that 56 per cent of Aberdeen postcode prisoners are currently not in Craiginches. The idea that, somehow or another, we are transporting them from Aberdeen to the boonies up in Peterhead is not true. In fact, more people with an Aberdeen postcode are likely to be able to be located in HMP Grampian than are currently located in the antediluvian premises that we have at Craiginches. The point that you raise is factually wrong.
Do you accept that 85 per cent of those who are imprisoned at Craiginches are from the city of Aberdeen and only 10 per cent are from the other AB postcodes to which you referred? In other words, some of the explanation for your numbers lies with the prisoners from Morayshire and Banffshire who are in prison at Inverness rather than Aberdeen. The vast majority of the 200 or more adult male prisoners at Aberdeen are from the city of Aberdeen. You are proposing to remove their local prison and to house them some 37 miles away at Peterhead.
We have a substantial number of prisoners in Aberdeen, and in Cornton Vale, who come not from Aberdeen or Aberdeenshire but from Birmingham and other places, because of the problem that we have with crack and other narcotic substances. It depends which way you look at the statistics. Our position is that 56 per cent of prisoners from Aberdeen are not currently housed at Aberdeen. Are they going to have to move from Aberdeen to Peterhead? The answer is yes, some will have to. However, that appears to us to be offset by the gain that young men in the main will not have to go to HMP Polmont and many women will not have to go to Cornton Vale. Prisoners who are currently not in Aberdeen but in Greenock, Saughton, Barlinnie or wherever else will go to Peterhead. Does that mean that Aberdeen will not have a prison? Yes, but not every major city or town has a prison. I am thinking of Dundee, East Kilbride, Hamilton, Motherwell and Paisley—I could go on.
But of course Aberdeen does. That is the point, is it not? When you described your vision for community-facing prisons, you said that it was important to minimise travel and improve security. You will be aware of Grampian Police's concern about the increased risk of escapes from relocating Aberdeen prison 40 miles up the road. Given that 85 per cent of the prisoners currently held at Craiginches are from the city of Aberdeen, I draw to your attention the fact that a journey from Aberdeen to Peterhead prison is an hour by bus, which runs three times a day. It would cost the partner of somebody who is held at that prison £14 to make that journey. By contrast, the bus to Craiginches, which goes every 10 minutes, would cost that person £1.50. Do you recognise that, far from minimising travel or reducing the distance between prisoners and their families, you are vastly increasing the cost and difficulty of making the journey for the families of the 200 adult male prisoners at Craiginches? That will have significant implications for the rehabilitation of prisoners as well as cost implications for their families.
There are three issues there. My primary responsibility is to the Government and the people of Scotland, not simply to individuals who happen to be in Aberdeen prison. Are you correct that some might have a worse situation in terms of their personal relationships? The answer is yes. Equally, I have to take cognisance of the fact that we have 5 million people in Scotland. Taxpayers expect to get best value and expect us to use Government resources as best we can. We cannot build a prison in every community. As I said, we have decided to spend £120 million per annum in forthcoming years; if we were not in this situation, we would probably prefer to spend it on schools, homes and hospitals, but we are where we are.On escapes, I do not accept that there is any risk to public safety. We are well served by our police and our prison service. The idea of there being some kind of bandit country between Aberdeen and Peterhead is, frankly, absurd and I do not accept it.When building prisons, we took cognisance of the fact that we could build on the Peterhead site because of its size, but we could not build at Craiginches because we could not develop on that site. A prison in Aberdeen would have to be built elsewhere. I do not know whether communities in Aberdeen volunteered where prisons should be sited. I would have been happy to listen, but I do not remember a community coming forward and saying, "Build this prison and build it here; we are for it." Peterhead was happy to have a prison, whereas many communities are not. As I mentioned earlier, some communities do not even want their name attached to a prison.To return to my earlier point about costs, some individuals might have longer to travel to see their son in Peterhead than they would have if he were in Aberdeen, but such matters have to be looked at in the context of the Scotland-wide position, which is best served by building HMP Grampian. Where the prison for the north-east of Scotland would be sited was under discussion for many years before I had the privilege of becoming the Cabinet Secretary for Justice. We thought it important not only for prisoners but for prison officers and their families that a decision should be made. We made that decision and are now pressing on to make sure that HMP Grampian can protect our communities and detain those whom we have to.
I note that you suggest—
I am conscious that Richard Baker wants to ask a question, so please make this your final question.
That is fine. Cabinet secretary, I note your use of the word "absurd". I am sure that you are aware that it was Superintendent Innes Skene of Grampian Police who referred in his submission to the"potential increased instances of escapes, accidents and breakdowns which may arise due to the inherent risks associated with increased travel distances". You might not share that view, but it is important to put it on the record that that is the police's view, not mine.Given your decision to create a community-facing prison in Grampian, which we support, your argument that many prisoners from Aberdeen are held elsewhere, which is recognised, and the fact that the vast majority of those held currently at Craiginches and of those elsewhere in the prison system from AB postcode areas come from the city of Aberdeen, will you tell us in one or two short sentences why you decided to close Aberdeen prison and open HMP Grampian in Peterhead rather than in Aberdeen?
I do not accept any suggestion that public safety is jeopardised. If I choose to drive rather than walk to work, there is a greater likelihood that I will break down or have a car smash. If you choose to put somebody in a vehicle to travel from Aberdeen to Peterhead, there is more likelihood statistically that the vehicle will break down. That said, we are very well served by Reliance and the number of escapes is infinitesimal, so I do not believe that public safety will be jeopardised. Any visit to Reliance will let you see that prisoners move around Scotland on a daily basis.Understandably, I have been lobbied by groups such as those mentioned today about the great difficulties for female prisoners who are moved around the country in Reliance vans because they have to go to Cornton Vale. It will be much better for female prisoners in Aberdeen to be sent the short distance to Peterhead than to be sent the long distance to Cornton Vale in what are often uncomfortable and inconvenient circumstances.The latest information is that there are 435 people in prison with Grampian postcodes, 159 of whom are in Aberdeen. In response to the question why we signed off our decision, time was of the essence when we came into government. We had to make a decision because of the pressures that the Prison Service and prison estate were under. It was clear to us that Peterhead was easily accessible, that the site was available, and that it had staff expertise and a whole variety of other factors. No site in Aberdeen was volunteered and in those circumstances the best, most expeditious and cost-efficient place to build was at Peterhead.
We have spent a long time on the petition, so I want to draw the discussion to a conclusion.
I will ask just a couple of questions. It is clear that the plans for HMP Grampian are important and that we all agree that proximity to the community is beneficial. HMP Peterhead has a specialised remit for and expertise in the management of sex offenders. To what extent is HMP Grampian planned to have such a role, which would also have an impact on capacity?
Peterhead is not the only prison with expertise in dealing with sexual offences. We hope to roll out expertise in dealing with sex offenders, whom we must tackle—many of them are the most dangerous people in prisons.As I say, we wish to have a community-facing prison. We want to ensure that the Prison Service has specialised knowledge, not simply for those who are in the Grampian area, but for those elsewhere. As I say, Peterhead cannot go on as it is—to be frank, it is unsustainable.
If the expert management of sex offenders is to be dissipated throughout the prison estate, that has a severe impact on the case for retaining a prison in Peterhead rather than creating a new community prison in or near Aberdeen. You talk about a community-facing prison, but the proposed prison will face the community that it serves from 40 miles away. I am sure that no one here would call the intervening 40 miles bandit country or wish it to be so described, but the fact is that the relatives of prisoners will depend on a journey that is difficult on public transport.I presume that you have not yet put the contract for HMP Grampian out to tender. Why did you make your decision without even looking for a site in or near Aberdeen? Surely there is still time to consult services and people who have made representations on the issue on whether that is still a possibility.
I assume from what you say that you are asking whether I will cancel the new Peterhead prison and build in Aberdeen. The short answer is no, I am not prepared to do that. We must press on. It is strange that you so criticise alleged delays—which do not exist—in building HMP Bishopbriggs while you are so desirous of delaying HMP Grampian. You cannot have it both ways. You cannot criticise the Government for not moving fast enough to build Bishopbriggs and for moving far too fast in locating HMP Grampian in Peterhead when you want it to be located in Aberdeen.I accept that some people wish that the new prison was going to be in Aberdeen. However, the Government had to act expeditiously. We did not have the funds, and we do not desire, to build prisons all over the country, so we decided to build in Peterhead, because that can be done on site and we have the staff there. HMP Peterhead has 300 prisoners; the new HMP Grampian will accommodate 700. The expertise in dealing with sex offenders will be not dissipated but shared throughout the prison estate. We use that expertise not only in Peterhead, as I said.
Is the new prison's capacity 700 or 500?
It is 500. I am sorry; 700 was a mistake.
That makes quite a big difference.
I have a final question on staffing. You say that you have the staff at Peterhead, but I understand that the Scottish Prison Service has significant vacancies. Are you confident that it will have enough staff in Peterhead? I am aware that a number of people who serve in Aberdeen will not go to Peterhead if they are asked to.
We have significant problems in the north-east of Scotland in recruiting for the SPS. That has been because of the buoyancy of the oil and gas sector, which has meant that people chose to take higher salaries offshore than are offered in the Prison Service, although it provides a safe, secure and excellent working environment. However, the situation is changing. Some of the economic dislocation that we have faced has resulted in more recruitment into the Prison Service, which has worked to address the issue. Are we ever-vigilant about the matter? Yes. Have there been difficulties? Yes—we accept that, but those difficulties relate to the economy in the Grampian area. As I say, the issue is being tackled.
I will ask the final question.The petition is about the implications of a shift in location and is prompted by concerns about access and being community facing. If an opportunity arose for the prison estate because of developments in the capital funding programme and other aspects of capital expenditure that emanate from the budget, which the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth outlined last week, and given that you have an opportunity to influence spending rounds in the future, would you consider addressing in future bids to the Cabinet some of the issues that the petitioners have raised and which fall within your ministerial responsibility?
Absolutely. We do not rule that out. As we plan for Inverclyde and Inverness, we will have to discuss with the local communities where the prisons are sited.If you are talking about remand and detention, I am more than happy to discuss that as a philosophical matter, but the budget for that would not necessarily come from the Scottish Government. It would have to come from police boards because they are responsible for the detention cells for those who are due to appear in the court at the first available court sitting. That is not for the SPS, which is there to deal with remand and convicted prisoners.We are happy to discuss the general philosophical issue, because some of the issues come from many years back. There are good reasons for them, and I am sure that you will probably discuss them with the chief constable of Strathclyde, who recognises that some of the facilities in Glasgow are not how he would like them to be configured. We will be more than happy to discuss those matters with appropriate stakeholders.
I am aware that I said that that was the final question, but Nigel Don has a question.
I would like to put on the record the fact that my diary map confirms that Peterhead really is only about 30 miles from Aberdeen.
It is more like 40.
That is factually incorrect.
We will not have a pedometer with us this afternoon to confirm it one way or the other.I am conscious that we have spent three quarters of an hour on the petition. I thank the cabinet secretary for coming this afternoon. It has been helpful to the discussion. We will take on board the discussion we have had, and take another opportunity to consider the information that we have received.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Feb 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 10 February 2009 Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 58
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 25
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.