Our next petitions are PE814, PE826 and PE776 on NHS 24.PE776 by John MacPherson, on behalf of Braemar community council, calls on the Scottish Parliament to investigate the merits of proposed new arrangements for out-of-hours medical services in remote rural communities such as Braemar. If we discuss all the petitions together, we can also consider PE814 by John MacPherson, on behalf of Killin community council, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to consider and debate the implications for rural areas of the introduction of NHS 24 services, particularly in relation to ambulance cover and timescales in getting medical assistance to patients in rural areas.PE826, by Mr W D R Chalmers, urges the Scottish Executive to ensure that NHS services in rural areas such as Mid and Upper Nithsdale are adequate, equitable and acceptable, as required by the NHS Reform (Scotland) Act 2004, especially in relation to out-of-hours services.At its meeting on 16 March 2005, the Public Petitions Committee agreed to link PE814 and PE826 and to write to the Scottish Executive. A response has been received from the Minister for Health and Community Care, which has been circulated to members. Do members have views on the petitions?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Out-of-hours Medical Services (Rural Communities) (PE776)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 12
- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 6
- Sandra White SNP 5
- John Scott Con 2
- Campbell Martin Ind 1
The record
26 contributionsJohn MacPherson's petition PE814, which I am speaking to because Killin is in the Stirling constituency, is particularly about ambulance cover out of hours. First, I note that the minister in his reply seems to suggest that he thought that the committee should consider the response from the Scottish Ambulance Service, but I did not see anything in the papers. Did you get a response from the Scottish Ambulance Service?
Yes—we will try to get it to you.
I am sorry, but I did not see it.
You would not have seen that response because it is for Public Petitions Committee members only.
You can perhaps say in your summing up what is in the response.
The response states:"We would be grateful if you note that we do not wish the attachment to this submission to be made public."I do not know how we will address that, but I have to abide by the request so the response has been circulated only to Public Petitions Committee members.
Okay.Since the petition came to the committee, there have been a number of incidents. I have to say, in fairness, that at the same time there has been on-going consultation between the community, the Scottish Ambulance Service, Forth Valley NHS Board and, on occasions, NHS 24, to try to make the situation better.The first incident, in April, relates to a fatal accident inquiry. The incident did not happen out of hours, but it happened during the day when the GP practice was closed for training, so it was a very similar scenario.A briefing note on the investigation states:"the investigation concluded that the management of the RRU"—rapid response unit—"in particular had been inappropriate. At 15.50 hours with the Callander Ambulance in the Breadalbane area the EMDC authorised the RRU to travel to NHS Forth Valley Acute Operating Division HQ. This was to allow the completion of administration apparently required by the RRU Paramedic to facilitate their Hospital placement".In essence, that was because we had been urging that there had to be double-crewed ambulances and that the training had to take place as soon as possible. However, that was an inappropriate visit by the ambulance when it had been given an emergency call at Killin. It was concluded in the opinion of Stirling procurator fiscal that the person's death would have happened anyway, but nevertheless no ambulance was available.There have been other incidents. I will not go into details, but in one case following a road accident on the A84 south of Lochearnhead, the local fire brigade attended to find one single-manned ambulance in attendance. The casualty had to await the arrival of another ambulance from Crieff. That happened again on 28 July on the A85 near Glenogle. There was a long wait on that occasion for a person who had spinal injuries, which was particularly distressing for that person. Despite our on-going meetings, there is still great concern in the community that we do not have a safe ambulance service operating out of hours. I would like to make a recommendation and to hear the committee's ideas. We have been talking about call centres, especially for rural areas, and I think that there has been talk involving Tayside and the Highlands. I am not sure whether there might be something similar for the more rural parts of the Forth valley area, including Killin, Crianlarich and Tyndrum. People in the call centres still do not seem to know where Killin is—it is so far away from Falkirk and district or Stirling royal infirmaries. That is a big issue.Despite the fact that we have, throughout our meetings, tried to encourage liaison between NHS 24 and the Scottish Ambulance Service so that ambulances can be brought quickly to the person in need, there is still in the community a lack of confidence. I know that the committee has received information about the interim report following the review of NHS 24, and that the final report is due in September, but I suggest that we continue to press for the rural situation to be examined, in particular with respect to ambulance cover in places such as Killin.
I very much welcome the interim findings. I am not au fait with the situation in Killin, but the interim report's recommendations following the review of NHS 24 are to be welcomed. It might not be generally known but, in Ayrshire and Arran, there is a pilot scheme that is essentially the same as what Sylvia Jackson wishes for her area. Essentially, what was previously the e-doc system has been resurrected, providing local additionality to the NHS 24 service. As I understand it—I could be wrong—that has been broadly welcomed. When the matter was discussed more than a month ago, it was said that four such pilot schemes were being rolled out in Scotland. If those are successful, that would help address the problems of NHS 24. That is welcome in as much as it means a return to NHS boards and their ability to provide for themselves the required services. That is also in line with the Kerr report.
I listened with great interest to what Sylvia Jackson said. She speaks for all MSPs, and especially for the people in the areas directly concerned. Issues around ambulance services, the call-out rate and NHS 24 have been raised again and again. The interim report has addressed some of those issues, and there are some concerns there for the Minister for Health and Community Care. I hope that the minister sees the petition, and I hope that he will have the opportunity to see the responses that have been made today by Sylvia Jackson and others. Perhaps he will be able to take on board some of the ideas that she has highlighted. NHS 24 is the crux of the matter, and we should write to that organisation for an update on its service improvements—if there have been any. It would be good to get an update on what improvements NHS 24 has carried out and then to write to the Minister for Health and Community Care to request a full report from the independent review team. Could we send the minister a copy of the petition and of what has been said here? The issues that Sylvia Jackson has just raised are very important, and they should reach the right ears.
Do you mean that we should send a copy of the Official Report?
Yes. We are writing to the minister to ask for an update on the independent review; is it within our competence to send the minister a copy?
The minister will have already seen the petition.
I mean a copy of what has been said today.
You want to ensure that the minister is aware of the comments—
That Sylvia Jackson made in particular—
In the Official Report.
Yes.
We will bring it to his attention.
We could ask the minister when the full report is going to be delivered. We are aware of the interim report and the recommendations, but when is the remainder to come?
It is due in September.
On 30 September.
We will get a response on the points that have been made by Sylvia Jackson and other committee members.
I have one final point to make. This is a matter of trying to reassure the community that the situation in Killin—and, judging from what Sandra White said, elsewhere—will be subject to on-going monitoring. Somebody should be looking at the situation. Although we have been having local meetings and have been gradually securing some improvements for the community at large, when the incidents happen it seems as if we are not getting any improvement. We need on-going monitoring to help to improve the situation. We could possibly make use of some of the pilot work that John Scott mentioned. It is a question of how we move things on.
We will ensure that the minister is aware of the concerns that Sylvia Jackson has raised.
Thank you.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Sep 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Thursday 8 September 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 77
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 41
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 26
- Public Petitions Committee Event Petitions · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.