PE812, from Caroline Paterson on behalf of Stirling Before Pylons, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to acknowledge the potential health hazards that are associated with long-term exposure to electromagnetic fields from high voltage transmission lines, and to introduce as a matter of urgency effective planning regulations to protect public health.At its meeting on 23 February 2005, the committee agreed to write to the Scottish Executive, Scottish Power, Scottish and Southern Energy and the human radiation effects group of the University of Bristol, and to seek independent advice on the implications of underground cables. Sylvia Jackson has an interest in the petition.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
High Voltage Transmission Lines (Potential Health Hazards) (PE812)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 6
- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 2
- Andrew Arbuckle LD 1
- Mark Ruskell Green 1
- Bruce Crawford SNP 1
- John Scott Con 1
The record
12 contributionsI do, as the constituency member for Stirling. The main thrust of the petition is about the health effects of the high voltage power lines. It concerns my constituents in the Kinbuck area, but also others outwith my constituency because of the huge area that the Beauly to Denny power line covers. A number of points in the material that has been received by the committee need to be restated because of their importance. The first is the important National Radiological Protection Board note, which"recommended that Government consider the possible need for further precautionary measures." As members will note, the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Public Health, Melanie Johnson MP, has set up SAGE, the stakeholders advisory group on extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields, in response to the problem. On that group is Professor Denis Henshaw from the University of Bristol; his letter, which is in the committee papers, makes a number of important points in his letter. Professor Henshaw says:"I am a member of SAGE and the issue of siting power lines near existing homes as well as the build of new houses near existing power lines is one of the issues receiving urgent attention."He also says that"Specifically, more is known about EMF health effects than about passive smoking, than about viruses purportedly linked to the incidence of childhood leukaemia and about ionising radiation at normal background levels".He continues:I would throw down a challenge here to anyone who claims that there is not a strong link between EMF and increased risk of adverse health. I will offer to send them every week for the rest of their lives a good peer reviewed scientific paper in a respected international journal reporting clear evidence of adverse health effects from exposure to power frequency electric and magnetic fields."He goes on in his last paragraph to state:"I urge the Scottish Parliament to consider immediate strict precaution against the siting of power lines near houses or the converse. I would remind the Parliament that we are well behind some other countries in this regard: In 1996, Sweden introduced a similar 0.2 microtesla exposure limit for new power line installations; Switzerland introduced a similar 1 microtesla limit in 1999 and three autonomous Italian regions (Toscana, Veneto and Emilia-Romagna) introduced a similar 0.2 microtesla limit in 2000."In addition, the Draper report has reported since then. It not only sets out concerns about childhood leukaemia, but mentions other issues relating to the power lines. It talks about depression, for example, and other mental health problems. I do not want to go on at length because all the information is in the papers.
I am glad that you said that—a lot of people still want to speak.
I suggest that because the cost to public health has not been a consideration in the routing of the power line—Scottish and Southern Energy states that—we should wait until we see the report from SAGE, which we are told is fairly imminent. We should recommend to the Scottish Executive that it take up Professor Henshaw's call for a precautionary approach.
Three members wish to speak. I hope that they will be brief, because we are not here to rehearse the discussion that took place when the petitioner came before us; rather, we have must discuss what we should do in the light of responses.
I assure you that I will be brief because Sylvia Jackson has given a good explanation of the case. Serious health issues have been underlined in both the Draper and Henshaw reports. I believe that William Stewart's phrase, the "precautionary principle", should be paramount and that the call for a moratorium, at least until we see what SAGE comes up with, has to be adhered to.As a councillor, I wrestled with planning applications, and the environment sometimes took priority over human life. If bats are mentioned in a planning application, everybody dives for cover and the whole thing is sterilised. However, here is a situation in which human life is at risk but the planning process cannot deal with the matter. That is totally wrong. I attended a presentation by the applicants at which I was surprised by their total resistance to undergrounding. They virtually told me that it was technically impossible. I think that they were afraid to establish whether it is possible. They said that, even if that were done, their technology would require a 100m wide swathe across the countryside. I believe that that information was out of date and that the technology does exist to put the lines under the ground; however, that is a separate issue. I fully support what Sylvia Jackson said about calling for a moratorium.
I set Mark Ruskell the same challenge to speak briefly and to tell us something that we did not already know.
link
Okay—I will be brief. The committee has considered three petitions—PE650, PE728 and PE769—on EMF radiation, health and the planning system. To my mind, PE812 addresses the same issue, except that it relates to power lines rather than to terrestrial trunked radio communication masts. The Communities Committee has considered those three petitions on TETRA, but it appears to be reluctant to deal with the health issues that PE812 raises. I understand that that committee will consider the general issue of how health relates to the planning system, alongside its consideration of the imminent planning bill; however, that has resulted in a lot of disappointment among the petitioners. There is a need for the Health Committee to consider the broader issue of EMF and health.Issues about TETRA are coming forward from communities throughout Scotland and issues about power lines are now coming forward. There is a need for a dispassionate examination of EMF and health to find out whether the guidelines are working appropriately across a range of different technologies. I also think that there is a need for the Communities Committee to revisit the three petitions on TETRA and to consider how health is dealt with in the planning system. That committee should add PE812 to that consideration, because the petitions are pretty much identical in raising issues about guidelines and whether health is a material consideration in the planning system.
I will try to be even briefer. The letter from Professor Henshaw is eloquent and strongly worded. The evidence from the industry seems to contradict what the professor says, although it does not talk about nocturnal impact. The letter from the National Radiological Protection Board talks about the need for further precautionary measures. That is a Government agency suggesting that we should go down that road. Therefore, there are strong and valid reasons for particular courses of action.Sylvia Jackson suggested a moratorium and Mark Ruskell wants the petition to be passed to the Health Committee. Those are both valid suggestions. The committee will want to hear the minister's view of what SAGE is going to say
and it will probably want to find out the minister's view on what Professor Henshaw's letter says, given the very powerful health evidence that is trailed there.Additionally, given that the issue will become part of a planning application under the Electricity Act 1989, the committee might consider advising the minister who has responsibility for planning that there should, because of the strong conflicting evidence, be a public inquiry into the planning application from SSE that is before ministers at the moment. That planning inquiry might begin to deal with the many conflicting issues.
A lot of points have been raised across the committee.
I draw the committee's attention to paragraph 6.2 of the response from Scottish Power, on line routing. It strikes me that Scottish Power undoubtedly deliberately routes high voltage lines away from housing. I speak from experience, as Scottish Power did that for the Scotland-Northern Ireland interconnector. I would have thought that that was obvious good sense and good practice. I am surprised that Scottish and Southern Energy is not prepared to adopt similar obvious good practice by keeping those pylon lines away from housing, based on the precautionary principle that the weight of evidence that is before us would support. The least strong evidence seems to be the NRPB's view that more research needs to be done.There is a conflict, and those arguments were rehearsed at the public planning inquiry that took place for the interconnector. The reporter at that time came to the conclusion that the arguments did not stack up. However, we are nearly 10 years further down the line; perhaps there is new evidence. I would certainly be interested in seeing whether that new evidence is more conclusive than previous evidence.
There is still an awful lot of mileage in the petition. All the suggestions have been valid, but we have to get them in order. We must first get the views of the Minister for Health and Community Care on the report of the work of SAGE, Professor Draper and Professor Henshaw. Once we have the Executive's position, we can consider the industry side of things and the information that is out there in previous reports. We will certainly not get involved in any of the planning application discussions, but we have a lot of scope to look in general terms at how such decisions are made. That is something that we can ask people to consider further down the line in the context of the proposed planning bill, but our starting point must be a letter to the minister. We can re-evaluate our position when his response comes. We shall ask him specifically to give us an update on the work of SAGE and a response on the views of the Draper report and Professor Henshaw's work. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Sep 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Thursday 8 September 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 77
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 41
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 26
- Public Petitions Committee Event Petitions · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.