Petition PE841, from the Curran family, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to amend the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 to make provision for a mandatory inquiry in the case of a road death caused by careless driving. Pat and Sandra Curran are here to make a brief statement to the committee in support of the petition, accompanied by Margaret Dekker from Scotland's Campaign against Irresponsible Drivers. I welcome you all to the committee. You have a few minutes to make some introductory comments, after which we will discuss the issue that you have brought before us.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 (PE841)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sandra Curran 11
- Mike Watson Ind 9
- Margaret Dekker Scotland's Campaign against Irresponsible Drivers 8
- Michael McMahon Lab 7
- John Scott Con 6
- Pat Curran 4
- Jackie Baillie Lab 3
- Rosie Kane SSP 2
The record
50 contributionsMany of you here will have said goodbye to your loved ones this morning without a thought. You expect to see them tonight when you return home, just as we did on 15 December 2003. Sadly for us, however, a so-called careless driver had other ideas and our beautiful, much-loved daughter and sister never made it home. As a family, we will never get over the loss of Gillian or the fact that she has been treated with so little respect when she did nothing wrong. Gillian paid the ultimate price for someone else's carelessness: her young life. The most important fact—the loss of a precious life—was completely ignored when the case came to court. That is unforgivable and totally unacceptable in this day and age. We are not looking for favouritism for Gillian; all we seek is the same right that other victims have to be considered in the charge. Losing Gillian completely devastated our family. We miss her so much. Someone must put a stop to victims being treated in the way that she was treated, so that families like ours can be allowed peace to grieve. Gillian's death should surely send shivers down the spine of any motorist. It beggars belief that someone who had stopped in a well-ordered queue of traffic could lose their life as a consequence. If the victim had been the loved one of a member of the committee, would you want them to be treated in that way? Please help us to put a stop to injustice. Any one of us could be in Gillian's situation tonight.The committee will be aware that the charge of careless driving is wide ranging and covers everything from minor carelessness to gross carelessness. It is the only option in law when, first, there is insufficient evidence to bring a charge of dangerous driving; secondly, there is no proof that drink or drugs were contributory factors—for example, when a driver leaves the scene to avoid detection; and, thirdly, when a higher charge is plea bargained. Families who are bereaved by the actions of careless drivers experience aggravated grief because there is no recognition in law that their loved one was killed or that their loved one was an innocent victim.The Road Traffic Act 1988 addresses a reserved matter, but we ask the Scottish Parliament to consider the application and administration of the law, which is a devolved issue. The law has evolved quite separately north and south of the border. For example, a coroner's inquest is the norm after all sudden deaths in England and Wales and takes place before any criminal proceedings. The coroner is an independent judicial officer who is empowered to inquire into the death to ascertain who the deceased was and how, when and where they met their death. The Data Protection Act 1998 specifies that, at the end of the inquest, an inquisition form that sets out those findings should be completed.In Scotland, however, a fatal accident inquiry following a road crash is held at the discretion of the Lord Advocate and is mandatory only if a driver dies while driving in the course of his or her employment. A discretionary fatal accident inquiry following a road death is a rare occurrence. The purpose of a fatal accident inquiry is not to apportion blame; it is to determine where and when the death took place, the cause of the death, the reasonable precautions whereby the death might have been avoided and any other facts that are relevant to the circumstances of the death.The Road Traffic Act 1988 denies bereaved families and innocent families recognition or dignity, so we ask the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to amend the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths Inquiry (Scotland) Act 1976 to make provision for a mandatory inquiry in the case of a road death caused by a careless driver. Such a step would bring compliance with the European convention on human rights, to which the Scottish Parliament agreed.
Thank you, Mr Curran. Do members have comments or questions for the petitioners?
link
I welcome the petitioners to the committee. I am sure that other members of the committee will, like me, want to express their regret for the loss of your daughter Gillian in such tragic circumstances. I acknowledge how difficult it must be for you to be here today.I read the background information that you supplied to the committee and I have a couple of questions. First, was one of the problems the lack of contact with the procurator fiscal's office after Gillian's death, despite your efforts to make contact? Can you expand on the nature of the contact that you had? Secondly, am I right in picking up from the papers that not until about six and a half months after Gillian's death did you receive a letter that said that a charge of careless driving, rather than causing death by dangerous driving, would be brought? Was that your first contact?
That was the first contact that we had. It had been arranged that Pat would phone on the last Friday of every month to find out what was happening. Every month he phoned and was told that nothing was happening. After five and a half months, at 12.30 on the Friday afternoon before the case went to court—it went to court on the Wednesday—we received a letter telling us that the person who killed Gillian would be charged with careless driving and the fact that Gillian had been killed as a result of that careless driving would not be considered in the charge. We had been told at the beginning that we would be kept in contact with the fiscal's office at all times. That never happened. As I said, every time Pat phoned, we were told that there was nothing to report. We had never been in such circumstances before and we left the law to the law. We were told that we were not entitled to have anybody to represent us, as that was the fiscal's job. We took it on trust that the fiscal's office would do everything that it said that it would do. However, when we received that letter on the Friday afternoon, it shook us to the core that we and Gillian could be treated so badly. We should have been taken to the fiscal's office. We were told at least twice that we would be kept informed at all times, but that never happened. I know that the office says that that is the way that it should be done, but that is not the way that it happened with us. You are right—it was five and a half months before we heard anything. We did not know what the careless driving charge was to do with. When the police told us about the accident on the night that it happened, we were told that Gillian had been hit at speed and that the other driver was entirely to blame. However, we were later told that they could not establish a speed. The driver had travelled from Preston to where she hit Gillian in two hours and five minutes, although it should take more than three hours and 10 minutes. However, the police could not take into account the distance that she had travelled from A to B when they were trying to find out whether she had been driving at speed. We are stunned that none of those facts was taken into account. Sixteen months down the line, we know no more information than we did the night that Gillian was killed. Every time we asked anything, we were told that it would prejudice the case if we were given any information. However, now the case is over and done with and we are still none the wiser. That is why we would like a fatal accident inquiry. A lot of people in our position might not want a fatal accident inquiry, but we do. Gillian was far too precious to be treated the way in which she has been treated. She was sitting, stationary, in a queue of traffic, with her handbrake on. She was the last car in a mile-long tailback when the other car hit her at speed. She had done nothing wrong. Why has she been treated like this? Why has she been ignored?
link
As I understand it, the Lord Advocate has the power to instruct that there be a fatal accident inquiry if he so wishes. You want to make a fatal accident inquiry mandatory in all cases. Can you understand that some people might not want an inquiry in certain circumstances?
Yes. However, when people die in jail or while doing their job, there are mandatory fatal accident inquiries. What difference is there between those situations and our situation? We expect the same treatment. Perhaps people who do not want one would not have to go along to the hearings. However, there should be inquiries into fatal accidents. We had to go to court and listen to someone being charged for being careless. The fact that they took a life was not even acknowledged. However, whenever a death has occurred, that should be the thing that anybody who is involved in the case should start with. It should not be the last point that is dealt with and it should not be ignored completely. The death is the most important thing. Gillian was the most important thing in our world and she has been ignored by the justice system.
The accident that Mr and Mrs Curran have referred to took place in my constituency. I do not know whether I have to declare an interest, but I have a lot of knowledge of the case. I am particularly interested in the fact that Mr and Mrs Curran are asking for a fatal accident inquiry to consider the reasonable precautions that could be taken to address the circumstances that might have led to the accident. I am aware that the junction where the accident happened, which most people will know as the Shawhead junction, is a particularly difficult one, as a bypass with a 60mph speed limit meets the A8, which also has a 60mph speed limit. The junction is not suitable for that type of traffic flow and, at certain times of the day, it virtually becomes a car park and traffic goes from 60mph to zero in a short space of time. Furthermore, at the junction, two lanes become one lane without any prior warning. I would have hoped that an examination of an accident such as the one that we are discussing would result in the junction being altered to take away the traffic problems. That is the aspect of the idea that there should be a fatal accident inquiry following a road traffic accident in which I am particularly interested. For that reason, I have a lot of sympathy with the issue that you have brought before us. Indeed, everyone on the committee has the greatest sympathy for your circumstances. We cannot look solely at your daughter's case, however. We have to look at the way in which we can ask the Scottish Executive to use the example of what happened to your daughter to make the situation in Scotland better for other people who might find themselves in similar circumstances. If that is the case, would a fatal accident inquiry help to address the issues that I have just outlined?
Yes.
If I may, I will come in, convener. What you said about precaution is reasonable, but even if a sheriff makes that sort of recommendation, the authorities have no power to put the recommendations into force. As Scotland's Campaign against Irresponsible Drivers knows all too well, the Curran family and all the families like them seek recognition of the victim at a fatal accident inquiry. Although the fact that an innocent victim can be ignored in a charge is a reserved matter, the opportunity is open to us in Scotland to correct the situation through amending the law on fatal accident inquiries.The committee might not be aware of the fact that 85 fatal accident inquiries were held in 2002. The figures for the number of mandatory and discretionary inquiries are not disaggregated, but it would be interesting to know how many of those inquiries were held on a discretionary basis after a road death. It could be argued that a fatal accident inquiry should be held into all road deaths because of the lessons that can be learned. However, PE841 calls on the Parliament to look at recognition of the victim. A fatal accident inquiry into the death of Gillian Curran would give dignity to the family.
I, too, express my condolences on the loss of a daughter and sister. I am concerned that the fiscal's office did not make more effort to keep the family informed about the progress of the case. If the fiscal's office had done so, I suspect that our petitioners may not have been at committee today.
I would still have been here. My daughter's death would still not have been recognised and the whole purpose of our being at the committee today is to get that recognition. The fact that the people in the fiscal's office did not do their job does not change the outcome.
In the inquiries that you made in bringing the petition to the Parliament, did you come across other people who had also not been kept informed by a fiscal's office?
We have made contact only with one other family. They told us that their fiscal was great, but that was a situation in which the family knew the fiscal. They felt that everything had been done properly: they were shown round the court and they knew beforehand about everything that was going to happen. Until we got the letter on the Friday and Pat phoned the fiscal's office that afternoon to make an appointment, no one had been in touch. They did not even offer us an appointment in the letter that they sent to us; Pat had to ask for one.The other family's daughter was killed in Cumbernauld. The family was taken to Stirling and shown around the court. In fact, they went up and down to Stirling a couple of times and spoke to the fiscal on a few occasions. That did not happen to us.
In our case, one of the fiscals took ill and was off for two months. We think that our daughter's case was not looked at during that time.
In reflecting on what you are telling us, I wonder whether guidelines are set down for fiscals on how they should keep in touch with people in advance of a fatal accident inquiry.
Guidelines are in place. The Crown Office publication "Criminal Proceedings and Fatal Accident Inquiries" gives details of the way in which families should be kept informed. Although some families have been kept very well informed, you are right to suggest that there is a problem in the imparting of information. Even at the conclusion of a case, families do not always have their questions answered. That is because answering those questions may involve witness statements and all the rest of it. The point is that a fatal accident inquiry would ventilate the facts in public. An inquiry is not intended to apportion blame, but it would give the families the opportunity to hear the evidence and the witness statements for themselves and in some way deal with their grief. Their grief is aggravated because the victim has not been recognised and there is a lack of knowledge about the circumstances of the death.
I understand.
We called for a meeting after the case was over. Two fiscals in Hamilton, two senior traffic investigators and a reporting officer were at the meeting. Pat, Margaret Dekker, Nicola and I went along to the meeting. At the meeting, the police told us that they had recommended a dangerous driving charge but that that had been reduced to a careless driving charge because they did not have enough evidence. I do not know how they did not have enough evidence. When Gillian's records were sent to our lawyer, he advised us not to look at them because her car looked as if it had been through a crusher. The police could not establish a speed. I do not know how there was not enough evidence. They had a body and someone had been killed. I am not saying that it would have made us happy if the girl who killed Gillian had been given 10 years or even a month in jail—it would not. The fact is that Gillian should be recognised. That is what we are calling for. We are not out for vengeance; we want recognition. The very least that Gillian deserves is recognition.
I will return briefly to the point about the guidelines. In your view, Mrs Dekker, were the guidelines not followed as they should have been in this case? Does that happen in other cases?
In some cases, the guidelines have been followed, but in the majority of cases that we have dealt with—perhaps it is why families come to us—they have not been. We know that fiscals are overworked. SCID would like specialist fiscals to deal with road deaths. However, leaving that aside, I think that the fact that fiscals are overworked should not be the problem of families. The families have put their faith in the justice system, but they come out with an aggravated grief.
I, too, pass on my condolences and pay tribute to the strength and dignity that you are showing today. It must be very difficult.Mr and Mrs Curran, you said that you were told to phone the fiscal's office on the last Friday of every month to get an update, but that each time you phoned you were told that there were no developments. How long after you were last told that there were no developments did you get notice on the Friday that the court case was coming the following Wednesday?
We got notice on the last Friday of the month. Pat had just come in from work and he was going to phone the fiscal's office when the postman came.
So the notice came on the last Friday of the month.
Yes. The letter came that afternoon.
I find it surprising that the fiscal's office would not have had more notice than that. Given that you were phoning on a monthly basis, you ought to have been informed in advance of your monthly call. It is difficult for us to get into the details of the case. What has been detailed this morning is that the approach by procurators fiscal is patchy. They should follow basic guidelines. I take Mrs Dekker's point that staff shortages, staff illnesses or staff holidays should not be an issue. Mrs Dekker also said that there were 85 FAIs in Scotland in 2004.
In 2002—the last available figures are for 2002.
Do you know how many of those related to traffic accident deaths?
No. There is no information on that, although it would be useful to know the figure.
Is even the cause of death not listed publicly?
We do not know how many FAIs were mandatory, how many were discretionary and how many were related to road deaths.
I understand that you would not know whether the inquiries were mandatory or discretionary, but I would have thought that the cause of death would be made public.
I got the figures from "Civil Judicial Statistics Scotland 2002". There is no further information or breakdown of the figures in that publication.
Your submission suggests that there should be a mandatory FAI in cases of careless driving. You believe that that would bring compliance with the European convention on human rights. Can you explain what part of the convention that would involve?
For a start, it would involve the right to respect for family life. We believe that the fact that a family member has been killed and there has been no recognition of that is a violation of that right. The introduction to the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland's "Road Death Investigation Manual" includes the following mission statement:"Article 13 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) suggests that ‘when an individual dies in suspicious circumstances' there is a requirement that the police conduct a ‘thorough and effective investigation capable of leading to the identification and punishment of those responsible and including effective access for the relatives to the investigatory procedure'. Kurt v Turkey (1999)".Given that no one has been held responsible for the death, we feel that that statement is undermined.
I certainly think that effective access to information is an issue that the committee could follow up.
Like everyone else on the committee, I offer you condolences and support. You talked about being totally ignored and the fact that that aggravated your grief. The lack of communication concerns all of us—we hear about such problems quite often, unfortunately. I agree that the procurator fiscal's office is overworked and understaffed, but the family should not have to take the burden of that problem. We all agree with your aim of looking for recognition and dignity for Gillian.I do not think that anyone would disagree with the convener's comments about the local problem and the need to look for solutions to prevent such a thing happening in the future. At the very least, we must try to avoid the pick-and-mix approach to information and support, as shown in your case in the months leading up to what eventually happened in court. I hope that in what we do today we can begin to address your concerns. If the things that you seek had been in place before the accident happened, where do you think you would be now?
I feel that at least Gillian would have had some recognition and we would perhaps be able to continue grieving for her. It has been so horrendous losing her and there is no recognition. I understand what you say about the roads, but the roads are not our priority. Our daughter is our priority, just as your families are your priority. The roads must be looked at, but the recognition of innocent victims must be looked at, too. Roads can be fixed, but what happened to us cannot be fixed. People should never be treated in the way that Gillian has been treated. We will never get recognition for Gillian—it will never happen for her. However, if the next time such a thing happens to somebody the family is recognised in the charge, we will at least be able to say to Gillian, "Good night, hen. God bless. We couldn't do it for you, but no other family out there will suffer in the way we've had to suffer through the lack of respect for you."
I add that the road that the convener talked about is well signposted "Queueing likely".
The person who killed Gillian had a 400m clear view of the traffic ahead. Gillian complained about the road every night. She travelled on it every night and she would sit in the queue of traffic because, as the convener said, it is a bottleneck at the top, with two lanes going into one. She would always talk about the idiots coming up the inside and trying to squeeze in at the top. She said that every night. It is just unfortunate that she had to lose her life. The doctor who was first on the scene said that the only thing that the person who killed Gillian was interested in was cancelling her meeting, because she would not be able to get to it. That could have been due to how she was feeling, but she took Gillian's life and she has never said sorry. Nobody has ever said sorry for the fact that Gillian lost her life. If you go home tonight and you get a bump on your car, you would exchange insurance numbers and everything would be sorted. However, you lose your child and you are expected to accept it. Well, it does not matter what happens out on the roads—I know that there are lots of problems and lots of drivers—but the buck stops here. Somebody has got to put a stop to people being treated in the way that Gillian has been treated. We put our hope in the committee and we hope that you can make a difference. We will support anything that you want to do. All we ask is that somebody stops people such as Gillian being treated in the way she was treated, because she did nothing wrong.
Do members have any recommendations?
link
Mr and Mrs Curran make a persuasive case for the committee to consider. Committee members may remember that Enable—or somebody with Enable's support—brought a petition to us on the robustness of the process and the implementation of recommendations around a fatal accident inquiry. Although this petition raises a different matter, it strikes me that there is perhaps a wider issue of the need to review what fatal accident inquiries are all about, the circumstances in which fatal accident inquiries are held and the recognition that families and victims get. Given that interest in fatal accident inquiries, I wonder whether we should not write to the Scottish Law Commission, to find out whether it is conducting any programmes of work to review them; to the Lord Advocate, who has overall responsibility; and to the Minister for Justice, as the matter fits into the wider issue of access to justice for victims and their families.
Given that there has been an apparent breakdown of communication in the procurator fiscal's office—I say "apparent breakdown", as I am not sure what the guidelines are—the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service should be contacted to find out whether it has any plans to change the procedures or to reassure people that the guidelines are being adequately implemented.
I must say that I have a concern about that aspect of the matter. I hope that I am not digressing. I am dealing with another case concerning an incident that was perpetrated by a minor, who went through the children's hearings system rather than the criminal courts. That means that, in law, there is no victim, so the newly established victim information and advice unit in the procurator fiscal's office cannot deal with the family in the way that it should. The case raised in the petition sounds similar. Unless there is a victim, VIA cannot kick in with all the support that is required for the family. We have to ask about VIA's remit. What has to be established in order for the procurator fiscal to get the support services that are available to families such as the Currans, who—without apportioning any guilt or blame—are clearly victims? We must get some answers on that. If members have other suggestions, I am more than happy to hear them, but we have to ask that specific question. When does VIA start to give support, information and advice to the families of victims?
I agree. That is a good point. There are clearly many victims. Perhaps we could approach the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents, to see what its take on the issue is.
Okay. That is a good point.
When we write to the Executive, we should ask it to comment on the European convention on human rights aspect that Mrs Dekker highlighted.
Okay. We will write to all those organisations and we will keep the petitioners updated on the responses that we receive. We will progress the petition and keep you informed—I hope that we will not let you down in that respect. Thank you for talking about your petition this morning. I reiterate the committee's condolences and thank you for the dignity with which you have given evidence.
Thank you very much.
Thanks for listening to us.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 May 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 11 May 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 36
- New Petitions Petitions · 50
- New Petitions Petitions · 43
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Equalities Report Committee business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.