Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Traffic Calming (PE840)

Wednesday 11 May 2005 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 36 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

36 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Good morning. I welcome everyone to this morning's meeting of the Public Petitions Committee. We have received apologies from Campbell Martin.The first item on the agenda is consideration of new petitions, the first of which is PE840 by Judith McCrorie. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to review its policy on traffic calming measures such as road humps and road cushions to address adequately their impact on disabled users and the elderly.Judith McCrorie will make a brief statement in support of her petition. She was due to be accompanied by James Page, but we understand that he is in hospital and cannot attend the meeting. Please pass on our best wishes to Mr Page. After your opening remarks, we will discuss the issues that you raise.

Judith McCrorie
link

Although the aim behind installing road humps, cushions, H-humps, zebra crossings and pads is laudable, they present unforeseen consequences for people who have medical conditions, elderly people and disabled people. Enforced jolting independent of speed not only causes pain, discomfort and potential deterioration of condition, but has wider repercussions for the general public's health and for those who are involved with emergency services.I will outline five principal issues that highlight how speed humps and cushions force the aforementioned groups to be selective in their journeys, which eliminates the possibility of their taking certain routes or reaching certain destinations. Indeed, such discrimination was established in the Disability Rights Commission's submission to the Cabinet Office consultation on transport and social exclusion on 19 March 2005, which said that"there have been recent initiatives to reduce traffic speed through the installation of traffic calming humps. Positive though this is, the uninformed design of the humps can cause pain for disabled drivers and passengers as jolting occurs when driving over them.According to the 2004 pain in Europe study, 18.1 per cent of Scots are believed to suffer from chronic pain.Secondly, humps and speed cushions are being overused as gateways in a desire to turn residential streets into 20mph zones. Moreover, their use creates barriers for disabled motorists, pedestrians and wheelchair and electric scooter users. Frequently, pavements are too narrow for passage, and bus shelters and street furniture can reduce pavement width further and force disabled people on to the road, where they face new problems because of a lack of dropped kerbs and because of cars being parked at kerbs. According to the Department for Transport, gateways do not have to be humps.Thirdly, Janet Kennedy, one of the authors of the Transport Research Laboratory report TRL614 "Impact of road humps on vehicles and their occupants" for the Department for Transport, told me that common sense should be employed in the selection of humps and cushions over other forms of traffic calming, especially on accident-free streets. She also said that we should not ignore the report's recommendation that"Vehicles should be prevented from parking near to speed cushions to enable buses and ambulances to straddle the cushions (since discomfort is greater when such vehicles are forced to mount the cushions)."However, contractors for one Scottish region have stated that as humps and cushions have been installed in residential streets, people cannot be prevented from parking by or on them.Pain is subjective, so the researchers were unable to include disabled people in their research and their findings are applicable only to healthy persons. The humps and cushions that were tested were made of flawless concrete to a tolerance of plus or minus 3mm, since quite small deviations can adversely affect the comfort of a vehicle's occupants.Fourthly, a lack of standardisation of design means that materials such as granite setts and concrete bricks are being used in Scotland in the construction of humps, cushions, kerbs, ramps and crossings. Such materials increase the severity of the pain that occupants experience. Granite setts and aggregate are also problematic for people who have walking difficulties, and for wheelchair and scooter users. Lips and humps, cushions and pedestrian crossings also cause discomfort and difficulty, and tactile slabs—although they are beneficial to blind people—are problematic for wheelchair and scooter users. Wheelchair and scooter users cannot cope with lips as high as 2in or inclines greater than 8.5 per cent. The London Ambulance Service has requested that proper research into traffic calming schemes be initiated because out of 7,500 to 8,000 accidental deaths a year, at least 5,500 are caused by heart attacks or cardiac arrest. Road deaths in comparison account for 280 to 300 deaths. It is claimed that a one-minute reduction in response times could save 500 lives a year and that response times, chances of survival, treatment and discomfort levels en route to hospital would all be affected. The fire services also experience delays. How will the explosive growth of traffic calming measures affect future emergency statistics in Scotland?There is a distinct lack of research about the impact of traffic calming methods on the emergency services and on the health and well-being of elderly, frail and disabled people. Road humps and cushions discriminate against that section of society, so greater consultation of disabled people should be a prerequisite in consideration of all future transportation issues. The Disability Discrimination Act 2005 places a duty of care on public authorities to eliminate unlawful discrimination against and harassment of disabled persons, in order to promote positive attitudes and to encourage such people's participation in public life. Those duties should be honoured. I will read out what Mr Page wanted to read out, if I may. James Page is the transport spokesman for the Fife independent disability network. He says that problems are caused by traffic calming devices, raised kerbs, granite setts, paving slabs with knobs on, narrow pavements, the absence of dropped kerbs, gradients steeper than 8.5 per cent, obstructions, doors hinged so that they require to be pulled open, second-hand public transport vehicles and limited provision of disabled facilities. The fundamental problem is that designers work to a limited model of disability, using statistics that are an average across the whole United Kingdom.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Rather than ask a question, I will make a comment in support of Judith McCrorie. I have been working with her to try to bring this matter to a successful conclusion. I have been struck above all by the fact that the Department for Transport has not conducted any research into the effect of speed humps; that is a major concern. Having suffered from a dislocated shoulder four years ago, I remember vividly two things about my experience. One was that when I was in the ambulance going over the many cobbles and speed humps on the way to the hospital, it was excruciatingly painful. Then, after my dislocated shoulder was restored, I travelled by taxi and train to Parliament. There is a speed hump at the exit of Waverley station and each time I went over it, I was in absolute agony. I empathise with all sufferers of back injury, arthritis or whatever the disability is, because such speed humps are a problem for them. That is not to say—Judith McCrorie said this eloquently—that we are against traffic calming measures. We are in full support of such measures because in Fife last Friday, we had three road deaths in the space of 20 minutes. We are not sure of all the circumstances yet, but there is a suggestion that one of the deaths might have been caused by speeding in the driver's locality. Therefore, I am absolutely behind attempts by local authorities to introduce speed-reducing measures, but the petition is about the types of measures that are put in place.PE840 is an extremely good petition that raises an important issue. I hope that at the end of the day we will be able to help Judith McCrorie and other sufferers across Scotland to reach the amicable solution that we all want. I congratulate Judith McCrorie on the extensive and tenacious work that she has undertaken.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

The issue is important. I am struck by the additional information that members have had placed on our desks this morning from the London Ambulance Service. London is not typical of England as a whole and it is certainly not typical of Scotland, but there are a couple of revealing statistics. The document states that, despite the fact that traffic calming measures were introduced from 1995,"the number of road deaths in the capital actually increased from 217 to 280 a year"and that the 280 road deaths in London in 2002 contrasted with approximately 8,000 cardiac arrests. The London Ambulance Service concludes:"a reduction of one minute in average ambulance response times could save in the region of 500 lives a year."That information must be taken in context, but there must be some read across to Scotland, even if the figures here might be smaller.The Scottish Ambulance Service has the right to object or, at least, to comment when proposals for road bumps or other traffic calming measures are introduced. Do you know the extent to which the service does that and how much notice is taken of the objections, with the result that traffic calming measures are either not proceeded with or are mitigated in some way?

Judith McCrorie
link

I was not aware of that. However, I have spoken to Mr Daren Mochrie, who is head of the Scottish Ambulance Service's accident and emergency services in Edinburgh. He stated that traffic calming measures delay ambulances, which has a knock-on effect on care and treatment for patients and on life saving. For someone who has a heart condition, an extra minute of delay can result in their being brain damaged. A similar point applies to people who suffer spinal injuries.Mr Mochrie stated that ambulances suffer damage from humps, especially to their tailgates.

I was told to contact Mr Michael Jackson, who is the general fleet manager for Edinburgh. I asked him whether research has been carried out in Scotland into prolonged journey times, the ability to treat people while ambulances are traversing humps and the number of deaths that arise from road accidents compared to those among passengers in ambulances. He said that, as far as he is aware, no research exists on those issues, but he confirmed that ambulances get damaged, especially the tailgates and the steps.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

That must be the case. It would be interesting to find out from the Scottish Ambulance Service the extent to which it objects to such measures and the extent to which its objections are acted on.Have you had a sympathetic hearing from Fife Council? Local authorities are ultimately responsible for deciding whether to go ahead with traffic calming measures. I have been involved with such issues in Glasgow, although not from this angle. Has Fife Council been sympathetic to the issues that you have raised?

Judith McCrorie
link

Fife Council's transportation department is divided into different districts; I have been given slightly different information from the different units but, for my own area, the answer must be that the council has not been sympathetic. During a consultation, I asked what allowances the council made for disabled people in deciding on traffic calming measures; I was told that it makes no allowances. I have requested that the humps on our road be reduced and that some other form of gateway be allowed on our road, given that where the existing gateway has been placed, there are disabled parking spaces and, usually, parked cars, so people cannot speed at that point anyway. However, the request for different measures was rejected by Fife Council's transportation department.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

I find it surprising that Fife Council can take no account of people who have disabilities, because the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 would surely cover that issue. I am sure that the committee will want to follow that up.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

Like other members, I think that the petition is good and timeous. Mike Watson asked about ambulance response times, but do you have any figures on fire brigade response times? As you mentioned in your opening remarks, time is also critical in fire brigade call-outs.

Judith McCrorie
link

I am afraid that I do not; I have just hearsay. People have told me that ambulances take longer to arrive. In Glenrothes, for example, I believe that each hump adds at least 10 seconds to journey times. One road has so many humps that ambulances and fire services tend to avoid it if they can.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

Do you have any evaluation of speed humps? Are they common elsewhere in the world or have they been tried and rejected abroad?

Judith McCrorie
link

Unfortunately, I have no internet connection at home, so I cannot research matters as thoroughly as someone else might be able to. I know that people are appealing against road humps in many countries; a person in America who is campaigning against road humps has contacted me and, I believe, road humps are being removed from some areas of America for the benefit of people with disabilities. People all over Europe are also campaigning against road humps because they feel that disabled people, people with poor health and elderly people have been ignored in respect of installation of humps.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

That is a good point. The petition is certainly thought provoking.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

I support very much what the petition brings to Parliament. It raises many issues and several points have been teased out. In my area—Govanhill—road humps were installed a couple of years ago.I will respond to John Scott's question about fire engines. I saw a fire engine being damaged by hitting a road hump at the speed at which it had to travel to reach a fire, which stopped the engine. A new engine had to be brought as a result of the damage. A record of that major problem exists.The Scottish Ambulance Service's letter provides a balance to the supposed improvements that result from road humps because fewer accidents occur. I imagine that that is the case and that, in the long term, fewer people will be disabled as a result of road accidents. However, road humps in areas that are further away from hospitals, such as Drumchapel, slow ambulances and fire engines, so people are even more disadvantaged in obtaining speedy treatment and reaching the emergency services.We all seek to slow traffic and we should do that more in built-up areas and around schools. We must remember that children do not just appear on the road next to a school, but in its whole area. I wonder whether road humps were experimental and could be seen to have failed. A measure that has cross-party support and which has been tried and tested is the 20mph zone. Do you agree that such zones should be made mandatory? In areas that seem to need road humps, the humps could be removed and replaced with mandatory 20mph zones, which would calm traffic in such areas and beyond. The committee might agree that, in the long term, that would generally slow traffic and therefore improve the environment and communities. Could humps in built-up areas be replaced with mandatory and broad twenty's plenty schemes?

Judith McCrorie
link

I think so. People's mindset must be changed. Our whole village has become a 20mph zone, but that is not affecting people's speed hugely—they speed up after travelling over humps or cushions. Even a general practitioner has told me that his car can travel over some humps without slowing—the ability to do that depends on the form of transport—and that he avoids areas where humps cause him discomfort. If you stand beside a hump or platform to record the number of people who slow down, you will see that the number is low. A change in drivers' mindset and, perhaps, more police to reinforce speed levels are needed.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

You talk about a change of mindset for drivers; I agree that that is necessary. In the areas where a twenty's plenty scheme has been advisory rather than mandatory, green signs have been put up—you may have seen them. When drivers found out that the 20mph limit was not mandatory, they began speeding up again; drivers also speed up between humps. I wonder whether any other members of the committee support my suggestion, which is that traffic be slowed down to 20mph in areas where that is required. Although traffic in general would be slowed down, ambulances and fire engines would not be deterred, which would mean that people who had disabilities or other difficulties would not be dragged over bumps. Do you see what I mean?

Judith McCrorie
link

I do. I have discovered that a new form of hump has been trialled successfully in London; I will leave information on it with the committee. If a car or an ambulance goes over the hump at 20mph or less, it apparently has no effect, so the driver can maintain their slow speed. However, if someone is going at more than 20mph, the hump inflates itself and gives the vehicle a bump. As well as having been trialled successfully in London, the hump has been used in other parts of England. Provided that its use is tested for disabled people, it might offer the way forward. It is claimed that the system pays for itself within six months.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

That, too, would be a good idea, but I imagine that the cheapest, smartest and easiest measure might be to slow down traffic completely. Thank you very much; I support your petition.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I have had experience of the twenty's plenty scheme. North Lanarkshire was one of the first councils to pilot it and I was able to help the council to verify that it was entitled to bring in mandatory 20mph zones. As far as I am aware, North Lanarkshire was the first local authority to have such zones, although other councils might have followed its lead. The introduction of the scheme has resulted in a reduction in accidents. That shows what can be done; the issue is not reserved.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Good morning. The petition that you have submitted has two sides to it. As well as addressing the problem of speed restriction ramps, it examines the installation of street furniture and that furniture's proximity to the kerb. The petition has two thrusts.

Judith McCrorie
link

Yes. I included both elements because the more people I talked to, the more it became obvious that in some areas a hump and a speed cushion are not just a hump and a speed cushion. In some places, they are combined with zebra crossings. In some places, when a hump is created, the road level is raised, which means that wheelchair users can cross from one side of the road to the other without going on to the road. However, I have been informed by some wheelchair users that such humps cause problems, not only when they drive over them, but when they use them to cross the road. That is because lips are formed on the edge of the pavement when such installations are created.The second part of the petition was included to address all the factors that seem to be being built into traffic calming. Even pavements are affected. In George Street, granite setts are being used in the centre of the road, in the parking areas. For many disabled people, they are impossible to traverse. Granite setts are also being used to make humps at road junctions in Edinburgh, which are extremely painful for disabled people.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I quite accept that, but the main thrust of your petition is to address the problem of speed-restriction ramps.

Judith McCrorie
link

That is right.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

You have made a good case. It is not the first time that we have heard about the difficulties that speed ramps create. As motorists, we sometimes complain about them because of the problems that they cause. However, what is the alternative?

Judith McCrorie
link

Someone from the Disability Rights Commission told me that, in England, boxes with flashing lights that warn people to slow down have been found to be highly effective. Someone else told me that, on the continent, there is a system whereby if someone is caught exceeding the speed limit where there is a camera, they are brought to a halt at a set of traffic lights slightly further on. However, the Department for Transport and the DRC have told me that that other measures, such as rumble strips and notices of intended prosecution—NIPs—are often as effective.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I have seen an alternative to the speed ramp in some areas: a chicane is constructed in the road to slow down the traffic, which would eliminate the sort of problems that we are discussing.

Judith McCrorie
link

It would indeed, but Fife Council has said that speeding youths will just zig-zag through them anyway. If speeding youths are going to fly round or over something, they will do it in any case, as I have witnessed.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Is your main priority the traffic calming measures or do you want your petition to be associated just as strongly with street furniture and pavement space?

Judith McCrorie
link

Our main priority is the discomfort and pain that is caused to people who go over humps. However, when I talked to many of those who signed the petition and to others, they illuminated for me the problems that relate to the design of the humps and the pavements beside them, which is why I included those other issues. They are important for wheelchair users or people who have to use electric scooters. Even if a chicane is created, we still need dropped kerbs and they still need to be at the right gradient for wheelchairs to get up them. As I say, the tactile slabs that are used for blind people cause wheelchairs to slip, but they are being placed across entire crossings. I know that that is a difficult issue, but those matters all need to be taken into account as well.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

For the avoidance of doubt, I place on record my strong support for Fife Council's endeavours to slow down traffic throughout Fife. It has tried every variety of traffic calming measure. The petition is concerned with the need for all local authorities in Scotland to ensure that any speed humps or any other traffic calming measures are designed to cause no pain or discomfort to people who suffer from disabilities. That is essential. From the research that the team in my office has undertaken, we can see that a great many advisory leaflets are provided on the design and style of road humps, but minimum regulations should be laid down requiring a local authority that chooses to run with speed humps to ensure that they are designed to cause no such pain or discomfort. There are other measures; Fife Council has developed slow-down signs with solar-powered lights that are controlled by radar intelligence and which flash automatically at motorists to tell them to slow down when they approach a village. That is a good and welcome measure.I recommend that the committee agree to seek views on the petition from the Scottish Executive—it is important that we get the Executive's views—and from the Disability Rights Commission, which ought to have input on such an important issue. The information that we have from the Disability Rights Commission is not nearly specific enough, so I hope that it will be able to clarify matters further. Perhaps we could also involve other organisations, such as Capability Scotland, some of the motoring organisations—such as the Scottish Road Safety Campaign and the Automobile Association—Age Concern Scotland and the Mobility and Access Committee for Scotland. We could approach all those organisations, ask for their views, get their feedback to the committee and let Judith McCrorie and other campaigners know the outcome and what more we can do to help.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

In our letters to the Disability Rights Commission and to the Executive I would like to ask about the DRC's consultation paper, some points from which are detailed here, and to ask what the Executive is doing in response to that. I mentioned earlier that a letter should also be sent to the Scottish Ambulance Service, specifically to ask how many objections they make to any proposed introductions of traffic calming measures and how successful they are either in having those proposals withdrawn or in having them mitigated in some way.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

If we are to write to the Scottish Ambulance Service, we should also write to the Scottish fire brigades.

Rosie Kane SSP Glasgow
link

I do not know whether Helen Eadie mentioned the Scottish Road Safety Campaign, but we should seek some advice on its experiences. Would anything be gained from asking traffic police for their experience? I am sure that they have a lot of knowledge.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Judith McCrorie has brought before us a wide-ranging issue. You have received a lot of support from the committee, and we will seek out as much information as we can on the way forward. Once we get responses back from all the suggested organisations, we will keep you updated and we will continue to discuss the issue until we can conclude—I hope successfully—on your behalf. Thank you for bringing your petition to us this morning.

Judith McCrorie
link

Thank you.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I welcome to the public gallery a delegation from Blyth Valley Borough Council, which is interested in the work of our committee. I hope that the delegation will be able to take away some useful information.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 11 May 2005 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 36
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 50
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 43
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 13
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. Equalities Report Committee business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.