Our next petition is PE709, in which the petitioner calls on the Scottish Parliament to initiate an inquiry into the health aspects of gulf war syndrome and the other devolved matters that relate to it.At our meeting on 17 March 2004, the committee agreed to seek the Executive's comments on the issues that the petition raises and to obtain an indication of whether it has any plans to conduct an inquiry of the nature that is proposed by the petitioner. Members expressed concern that some gulf war veterans appear to be having difficulties in accessing their medical records and, as a result, may not be receiving appropriate treatment for any medical conditions that they may have contracted. The committee requested comments on that and sought confirmation of what medical records on gulf war veterans are kept in Scotland. In spite of setting an initial deadline of 30 April 2004, the committee has yet to receive a response from the Executive. The clerks received a holding response from the Executive, which was dated 6 May, in which officials stated that they hoped to respond during May, if possible. Even though the committee issued a further reminder, it has yet to receive a response.Rosie Kane has joined us. Would you like to make some comments, before we start to discuss the petition?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Gulf War Syndrome (PE709)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 4
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 2
- Mike Watson Lab 2
- Jim Johnston 2
- Rosie Kane SSP 1
The record
13 contributionsI found out that the petition was on the committee's agenda on my way in, so I am ill prepared. I thank the clerks for giving me the paperwork when I came in this morning.I want to draw the committee's attention to the motion that I lodged on gulf war syndrome—motion S2M-1397. Alex Izett is a Scottish veteran of the first gulf war who is known to the committee. Like many other soldiers, he received nine vaccines in 24 hours during preparation for deployment. He now suffers from a number of illnesses, including autoimmune osteoporosis, which a court ruling in 2003 found was caused by a concoction of drugs.I did not get a chance to speak to Alex Izett before I came in today, so I cannot relay a message from him, but I have spoken to him in the past. He asks how Parliament can assist his request for an independent public inquiry into all aspects of gulf war syndrome.As members will know, Alex Izett went on hunger strike. He came off that strike because he felt that he was supported by the Scottish Parliament—he had had quite a positive response from some MSPs and my motion had received support. He also felt supported when an early-day motion was lodged at Westminster. However, he has suspended his hunger strike only until 1 July. I guess that I come here to plead on his behalf and to find out what positive news I can take back to him to encourage him not to go back on hunger strike.
I welcome the fact that Her Majesty's Government has announced that there will be an independent public inquiry.
It is not the Government that has announced the inquiry.
There is certainly going to be a public inquiry, which I think will be independent. We are very pleased about that. When I was first elected in 1999, constituents raised the issue with me. A power of research has been done on gulf war syndrome. Right from the start, the fact that the health issues needed to be addressed was pinpointed. It seemed that there was a variety of responses in different health areas throughout the country. That is why I am pleased that there is going to be an independent public inquiry.
It is important to put on the record that the Government has resisted the inquiry, which has had to be organised under pressure from the Royal British Legion. The inquiry is not only independent; it has been organised independently. Therefore, the setting up of the inquiry is not an indication that the Westminster Government or the Scottish Executive intend to take the issue seriously. This Parliament has authority over health and we have a duty to address the issue, because health professionals are out there grappling with and attempting to treat the symptoms that these veterans are presenting with. It is incumbent on the authorities to examine those illnesses and syndromes and to introduce guidelines that are similar to, for example, the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network guidelines for diabetes, and to set out best practice for treating them. The Government's intransigent refusal to recognise the syndrome or combination of illnesses is holding back proper and efficacious treatment of veterans and puts health professionals in a difficult situation.I am disappointed that, yet again, the Executive has provided no response to a politically difficult issue, which seems to have become the pattern. This issue has a real human cost, and Alex Izett does not want to hear the news that the Executive is rubber-earing us and slinging us a deefie. I believe that the members of the Public Petitions Committee are sympathetic to this petition and I hope that we will send Alex the message that we do not accept the Executive's lack of response, that we will harry it to ensure that it takes the issue seriously and that we will try to find some avenue to pursue these issues. I want to give Alex some hope that we are trying to pursue the matter.
The fact that we have yet again received no response from the Executive is unacceptable, particularly as we received a holding response on 6 May. Have the clerks made telephone contact to chase the matter up?
Yes.
But with no effect.
That is right.
We have gone through the same procedures again. As members know, we are having this additional meeting to consider outstanding issues and to deal with them before the recess. We decided to put some new petitions on the agenda because we felt that they had merit. However, given that we had already highlighted petitions as being urgent, and that we had received no response to our questions, the clerks and I agreed that we should try to achieve something before the recess. If the petitions are being kicked into the long grass during the summer months, we have to act as a kind of lawnmower to cut that grass down a bit.We must collectively reconfirm our view that the matter is urgent, that it should be addressed as quickly as possible and that we expect a response from the Minister for Health and Community Care to the very clear questions that we framed after hearing Mr Izett's views on the matter. We are not dropping the subject and will pursue it until we have a response. I agree with Carolyn Leckie—after all, Alex Izett has previously gone on hunger strike. As we cannot be seen to allow the situation to drift, we must seek clarification from the minister on when his response is due and what it will be. We must also make it clear that we need the response before our first meeting after the recess.
I am sure that it will be done anyway, but we should also write to Mr Izett to let him know that we have had this discussion, that we are all very concerned about the situation and that we intend to pursue the matter. Indeed, I want the committee to send him the positive message that, even though the Executive has not provided a response, we are pursuing the matter vigorously. I do not think that any of us want him to resume his hunger strike on 1 July.
Absolutely—we need to make that point. If signalling our intention to pursue the matter further encourages Mr Izett to take a positive attitude, we should do that this morning.However, as parliamentarians, we must also hold the Executive to account, which is the primary purpose of putting the item on our agenda. We have to go back to the minister and ask him for a response. Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Jun 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 29 June 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 54
- New Petitions Petitions · 16
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 13
- New Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 25
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 19
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Proposed Petitions Petitions · 1
- Proposed Petitions Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.