The next petition is PE671 on the education of children at Dungavel detention centre. The petitioners call on the Scottish Parliament to oppose the detention of children at Dungavel detention centre and to ensure that the Scottish Executive honours its statutory commitment to provide mainstream education for all children in Scotland.At its meeting on 12 November 2003, the committee agreed to write to the Home Office, which stated in its reply:"we take the view that the provision of education to children detained with their families at Dungavel under the Immigration Act 1971 is, in essence, a reserved matter."The Home Office also stated:"Although the education authority provides advice and assistance, it is not the service provider and does not fund the educational provision."The letter continues:"We very much welcomed the publication of both reports and, in particular, HMIP's conclusion that Dungavel is a place of safety where detainees receive a good standard of care in a positive and respectful environment. In relation to educational provision for children at Dungavel, we were happy to accept all three recommendations made by HMIE."Do members have any comments?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Dungavel (Detention of Children) (PE671)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 13
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 5
- Jackie Baillie Lab 3
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Sandra White SNP 2
The record
29 contributionsI am sure that you would expect me to comment. I draw attention to the letter from Beverley Hughes at the Home Office. Essentially, the contradictions have not been addressed. There is a political question, and this is clearly a political hot potato. It is a political decision whether people are happy to discuss it, either in the Parliament or in committee, and I feel strongly that we must discuss it. There is possibly a legal basis for that. On the one hand, the Home Office and the Executive say that the issue is reserved and is not a matter for the Scottish Parliament, but on the other, Beverley Hughes's letter says:"Within this context, the local education authority may retain certain statutory functions in relation to ensuring that the educational provision is satisfactory for the children concerned."The Home Office acknowledges in that sentence that the local authority has some authority in relation to certain aspects of the education of children who are detained at Dungavel.Beverley Hughes's letter also says, in relation to the recommendations that HMIE made:"We will be taking these recommendations forward with Premier Detention Services in consultation with the local education authority and HMIE."The local education authority has an input into the education of children who are detained at Dungavel in relation to the supervision of standards—as Beverley Hughes's letter acknowledges—and in relation to assistance with enhanced provision for certain children. Given that local authorities must be democratically accountable for their actions and that the education authority is clearly within the locus of the Scottish Parliament, how can that democratic accountability be exercised? How do the people who vote for the local council hold it accountable for its role in the provision of education to children in Dungavel? How can the Parliament hold the Executive accountable for its role? Clearly, the Executive is involved in discussion and dialogue and resources are being applied to the matter.There are further questions to be examined and we should make those points to the Executive and the Home Office. We have a locus in relation to the children who are detained at Dungavel. We should call for the closure of the centre, because it is inappropriate, and we should exercise our democratic accountability in relation to the provision of education to those children.
I agree with Carolyn Leckie that this is a political issue. For that reason, it is even more important that it should not be a matter for the Public Petitions Committee. It was our responsibility to consider the facts of the matter and the committee tried to establish those facts by seeking independent legal advice. On the basis of the advice that we received, we wrote to the Home Office at Westminster and we have now received a response, which states that the matter is reserved.I am not trying to close down the debate on the issue—it is obvious that the Parliament can debate the matter and has debated it. I just do not think that Carolyn Leckie's suggestions reflect what the petition asked us to do. The committee has established where the locus is in the matter. Members can debate the issue and make points about what they would like the Scottish Parliament to do, but that is not a matter for the Public Petitions Committee and I really think that there is nothing else that we can do with the petition on the basis of the legal advice that we have been given and the response from the Home Office. I would welcome other members' comments.
link
I entirely agree with the convener. We have been told by the Parliament's authorities, the Executive and the Home Office that the matter is reserved. That does not diminish some of the substantive issues that have been raised, but we cannot proceed any further with the petition.
Carolyn, let me read the exact terms of the legal advice—
I have read the legal advice, but I stress that Beverley Hughes's letter contradicts the legal advice. Her letter clearly says:"the local education authority may retain certain statutory functions in relation to ensuring that the educational provision is satisfactory for the children concerned."One of the petition's demands is to call on the Parliament to ensure that"the Scottish Executive meets its commitments under the 2000 Standards in Scotland's Schools Act, to provide mainstream education for all children in Scotland".The Executive and local authorities are under a legal obligation in relation to the provision of education at Dungavel, which Beverley Hughes acknowledges in her letter. The issues should therefore be further examined by another committee of the Parliament and I propose that we refer the petition to the Education Committee.
I agree with the convener and Jackie Baillie. It is all very well for each of us to quote parts of Beverley Hughes's letter; I quote a part that I think is relevant:"Although the education authority provides advice and assistance, it is not the service provider and does not fund the educational provision. The service provider is our contractor at Dungavel, Premier Detention Services Ltd, who are funded through their contract with the Immigration and Nationality Directorate (IND)."The letter makes it very clear that the provider is accountable, not to the local education authority, but to the immigration and nationality directorate.
That is a valid point. I will back it up by pointing out that the conclusion to the advice that we received states:"the education authority may have some statutory functions in relation to the education of such children but this is entirely a matter between the education authority and the Home Office".We sought an answer and that is the answer that we received. Carolyn Leckie is more than entitled to take up the matter elsewhere—I am not saying that she should not discuss the issue—but the committee must bear in mind its functions. We sought information from the legal adviser and the Home Office, which we now have. I recommend that we do nothing further with the petition.
I want to vote on the issue.
We need a recommendation.
link
I suggest that we close the petition.
I propose that the petition be referred to the Education Committee.
Do you want to vote on whether we should refer the petition to the Education Committee?
Yes.
Can I say something, convener, as I put my hand up to speak directly after Carolyn Leckie put up hers?
Yes.
I was going to say that there appears to be a stalemate. The Scottish Executive and the Home Office say that the issue is reserved, but given the legal advice that we received previously and the various letters, it is not clear—at least to me and some others—whether the issue is reserved. I understand the issue about the Public Petitions Committee's powers and about what is reserved and devolved. Obviously, I do not like the fact that such issues are reserved. I back Carolyn Leckie's proposal that we send the petition to the Education Committee. I do not think that we can simply leave the petition.I take on board what you say, convener, about the committee's powers, but the issue is too important to leave the petition. We must push the petition up to the Education Committee, given that the education of kids is involved. I point out to Helen Eadie that Beverley Hughes's letter does not say that the education of kids is a reserved matter; it states that the services provided by the private security company, Premier Detention Services, are paid for by the Home Office, not the education authority. It would have been good to get reports from South Lanarkshire Council about how it is dealing with the issue.
I take your point, Sandra.The question is, that Carolyn Leckie's proposal that PE671 should go to the Education Committee be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForLeckie, Carolyn (Central Scotland) (SSP)White, Ms Sandra (Glasgow) (SNP)AgainstBaillie, Jackie (Dumbarton) (Lab)Eadie, Helen (Dunfermline East) (Lab)McMahon, Michael (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab)Scott, John (Ayr) (Con) Watson, Mike (Glasgow Cathcart) (Lab)
The result of the division is: For 2, Against 5, Abstentions 0.That proposal is not agreed to.Do we have a proposal that we close the petition?
link
I suggest that we close the petition.
I second that.
The question is, that we close consideration of PE671. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForBaillie, Jackie (Dumbarton) (Lab)Eadie, Helen (Dunfermline East) (Lab)McMahon, Michael (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab)Scott, John (Ayr) (Con)Watson, Mike (Glasgow Cathcart) (Lab)AgainstLeckie, Carolyn (Central Scotland) (SSP) White, Ms Sandra (Glasgow) (SNP)
The result of the division is: For 5, Against 2, Abstentions 0.It is agreed that we close consideration of PE671.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Mar 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 3 March 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 18
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 52
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 29
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.