Petition PE650 is on terrestrial trunked radio—TETRA—communication masts. The petitioner calls on the Scottish Parliament to take the necessary steps to delay the installation of TETRA communication masts in Scotland until potential health risks have been properly assessed and the relevant planning guidance has been amended to incorporate mandatory health and safety standards.At its meeting on 1 October 2003, the committee agreed to write to the Executive and O2 Airwave. In its response, the Executive states:"In the light of the results of recent health studies we have no plans to change the guidance issued to planning authorities on this particular issue."The Executive also states that although it is not possible to say with absolute certainty that there are no health risks associated with the use of mobile telecommunications equipment, including TETRA handsets and associated base stations, the evidence to date has not shown a link between the technology and ill health. In its response, O2 Airwave emphasised that it, "as the company responsible for building and operating the Airwave service, plays no role in setting the safety guidelines that apply in the field of radio communications … Our responsibility is to ensure that we comply with those guidelines."The committee has also received several letters and an e-mail supporting the petition, which have been circulated to members. Mark Ruskell is here to comment.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Terrestrial Trunked Radio Communication Masts (PE650)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Mark Ruskell Green 3
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 3
- Helen Eadie Lab 3
- Michael McMahon Lab 2
- John Scott Con 2
- Mike Watson Lab 1
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
15 contributions
link
I will keep my comments brief.I have not had the opportunity of looking at the responses from the Executive or from Airwave and neither have the petitioners. I recommend that the committee takes swift action on the petition and designates a lead committee to consider the issue in a lot more detail.I have two reasons for saying that. First, there are still significant disagreements between scientists about the technical aspects of the system and the associated health concerns. For example, O2 Airwave maintains that its masts do not pulse, but on 24 October 2003, independent scientists found that one of the TETRA masts in operation on the Isle of Wight pulses. There are significant disagreements that have to be considered.Secondly, the system is being rolled out now. Hundreds of planning applications for TETRA masts in Scotland are being approved. That is a breach of the precautionary principle that the Stewart report on mobile telecommunications recommended for consideration of low-frequency systems such as TETRA. We should look before we leap and that is why a lead committee should consider the issue urgently. We have to be sure that the system is safe before we roll it out, not while we are rolling it out.
From previous briefings, and from the responses from the Executive and O2, it is clear that the sides are polarised on the issue. The precautionary principle should apply until further research has been conducted. I am certainly concerned to prevent planning applications being granted until then.The burden of proof that it is safe should be on the people who are trying to roll out TETRA, but it is impossible to prove that given the short history of the technology. We should do whatever we can to arrest the roll out until all the questions are raised.I do not think that writing to the petitioners to ask for their response to the responses will get us any more information than we already have. It is perfectly clear that they will disagree with the responses on the safety of the TETRA masts. The petition should be referred to a committee for a proper investigation of all the issues. The question is, which committee will deal with it? There are planning, environmental and health issues. I would appreciate hearing Mark Ruskell's opinion, but I am leaning towards the Health Committee because we have to determine the health issues and that can inform any legislation that is required by planning or environmental authorities. I am open to other suggestions.
I was on the Transport and the Environment Committee during the first session of the Parliament when the issue was discussed and investigated. Andy Kerr was the convener. The committee's view was based on the expert advice and opinion that we had at the time and was that health ought to be a material consideration when it comes to the planning framework. That was included in the committee's report.I say that with the knowledge that when we considered the European context, the experts that were working at European level referred to the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection guidelines, which set acceptable radiation levels. The safety threshold that those guidelines set has been lower than that set by National Radiological Protection Board guidelines.I know that the Executive is trying to balance the concern that exists against the need to ensure that we roll out the new technology across Scotland as swiftly as possible. However, there is a case for revisiting the question of whether health should be a material aspect of planning consideration. Parliament as a whole was not satisfied with the response that we received from the Scottish Executive the first time around. I cannot comment on TETRA, but my thinking is coloured by my having been involved in the major investigation that took place. The unanimous view of the Transport and the Environment Committee was that health should be a material consideration in the planning framework.
Helen Eadie has largely covered the issue that I wanted to raise. I intended to ask whether the issue was covered in the Transport and the Environment Committee report. The answer is clear from what Helen Eadie has said.
It is my understanding—Helen Eadie will correct me if I am wrong—that the Stewart committee said that there was no danger. The basis of the Stewart report was that the risks were well within the guidelines so there were no health considerations as such.
I must be careful about what I say here. I recall that the Stewart report was not as clear-cut as John Scott is suggesting. I am fudging the issue because I do not recall absolutely what the report said and would want to check it.
I appreciate that there are issues and genuine concerns about these and other masts. Notwithstanding what Mark Ruskell says, the weight of scientific evidence is that the masts do not cause health problems. I stand to be corrected.
What I say is based not just on the Stewart report but on the evidence of experts who appeared before the Transport and the Environment Committee. We focused specifically on this matter, as the Official Report of our discussions makes clear. An expert advisory group to consider the matter has been set up at European level and its work is continuing. One report that was issued at European level recommended that we should adhere to the precautionary principle. There are now on-going discussions and a further expert advisory group has been established. We need to be mindful of the fact that across Europe there are concerns about masts.No one is saying that masts are definitely harmful or not harmful. It is reasonable to say that the precautionary principle is being interpreted in a variety of ways. Some say that they will not have masts near hospitals and schools or in public locations where populations are very dense. Others say that it is okay to have masts in less populated areas. Because there is such a variety of views and because the jury is still out on many aspects of the issue, there is a need to monitor policy development at EU level on an on-going basis. As the "You and Yours" Radio 4 programme showed, last year Holland took a specific approach to the issue. It should be the task of someone, somewhere in the Parliament to draw together all that intelligence. That may be a matter for the Health Committee or for the Environment and Rural Development Committee.
link
I do not want to confuse matters further, but I suggest that this is an issue for the Communities Committee. I will explain why I believe that to be the case.Previously the Scottish Parliament acknowledged clearly the wider concerns of the general public. I would be disinclined to interpret and reinterpret here expert evidence that has been given elsewhere. We should refer the matter to another committee.I note from the Executive's response that it expects to publish a report early this year that deals with the effectiveness of the current regulations and that it will pass to the Communities Committee. Although the scope of that report is not as wide as I suspect that committee members would want it to be, I would have thought that, given the fact that the policy lead is a planning one, the Communities Committee is the most sensible place to deal with the petition—not least because, according to the Executive's letter, around 583 planning applications have been made for the development of TETRA masts in Scotland, of which 478 have been approved,. Things are moving quite fast, and the Communities Committee might be the right place for the petition to be sent.
link
I want to draw a useful distinction between TETRA and mobile communications systems in general. I am aware of the good work that was done by committee members during the previous Parliament in considering the wider issue of mobile telecommunications systems and the guidelines, which you mentioned. However, the petitioners' concerns are around the specific aspects of TETRA that are unique and different from conventional mobile phone technology.You mentioned the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection guidelines. To my knowledge, those deal primarily with the heating effects of mobile phone radiation, not with the pulsing effects. We should not disregard what Helen Eadie is saying, as there is important work to be done following the evidence that the committee took in session 1; however, there is a specific issue about the technology that is being rolled out. We should deal with that now, rather than have a huge inquiry, reopening the entire telecommunications issue.
Which committee should deal with that?
link
I do not know—perhaps the Communities Committee.
Mark Ruskell has addressed the issue of the jury being out on this technology. The truth is that the technology has not been around long enough for anybody to say one thing or another about it conclusively. We should all avoid pronouncing the safety of anything, which is why I support the application of the precautionary principle in relation to this. I am horrified by the number of planning applications that have been granted. If it is agreed that we refer the petition to the Communities Committee—the Health Committee may be the second committee, but that would be up to the committee to decide—I would be happy with that.
I suggest that we agree with Jackie Baillie's suggestion that the lead committee should be the Communities Committee and that it should refer the petition to both the Environment and Rural Development Committee and the Health Committee for their input. I agree that there is no point in our going back to the petitioner, as they are quite clear about their concerns. It is for a committee of the Parliament to pick up those concerns and reflect on the answers that are received from the Executive. I do not think that it is necessary for us to delay matters by referring the issue back to the petitioners. Are members happy with that?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Mar 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 3 March 2004 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 18
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 52
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 29
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.