The next current petition is PE477, which concerns aftercare programmes for those who suffer miscarriages of justice. Additional information on the petition has been passed to members.The petition is in the name of John McManus, on behalf of the Miscarriages of Justice Organisation. The petitioners call on the Parliament"to urge the Scottish Executive to provide assistance in setting up an aftercare programme in the form of a half way home to help people who have been wrongfully incarcerated and have served long terms of imprisonment or whose conviction has been annulled at the appeal court".They are concerned about the long-term effects of periods of incarceration in prison on people who have been wrongly convicted of crimes, and about the absence of aftercare provision when such people's convictions are quashed by appeal.We considered the response from the petitioners on 3 September, when we noted that their application for funding for the development of MOJO Scotland had been turned down by the Executive. We agreed to write to the Executive to seek clarification of the level of support that is provided on release, specifically to those who have suffered a miscarriage of justice. A response has now been received, together with further letters from the petitioners.It is clear that the petitioners and the Executive are at cross-purposes on the issue. The Executive considers that the services that are available to ex-prisoners, which include the enhanced throughcare system that is about to come on stream, are also available to those who have suffered a miscarriage of justice and that, therefore, those people do not require targeted support. That argument hinges on the fact that those services are designed to address a wide range of difficulties that ex-prisoners and their families may experience, regardless of the circumstances of their release.The Executive states that a report on the joint Home Office and Citizens Advice pilot to assist ex-prisoners who are released on successful appeal against conviction in England and Wales will be published by the end of the year. A copy of that report will be passed to the committee as soon as it is available.The petitioners are concerned that the committee agreed to ask the Executive for clarification of the level of service that is provided; they argue that they have made it clear that no services, help and support are available. They claim that prisoners who are released on appeal are not given counselling before release, because they have not been on probation programmes. They state that the type of counselling that they propose would be specialised and tailored to the needs of those who have suffered wrongful incarceration.The petitioners are concerned that those who suffer a miscarriage of justice appear to be classified as ex-offenders. They remind members that a member of the committee in the previous session expressed concern about the justice system and prisons providing aftercare for individuals whom that system had failed. The petitioners also question the adequacy of the counselling that is available as part of the Home Office and Citizens Advice pilot project.Do members have comments?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Miscarriages of Justice (Aftercare) (PE477)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 5
- Linda Fabiani SNP 2
- Mike Watson Lab 2
- John Scott Con 2
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 1
- Tommy Sheridan SSP 1
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
14 contributionsThe Executive's response disappointed me. It gave only the facts, so I am disappointed that no services are provided specifically for people who suffer miscarriages of justice and that such people are dealt with in the same way as ex-offenders are. That is sad.I would like to see the results of the pilot and to go a wee bit further. I would be happy for us to pass the petition to one of the justice committees, along with the report of the pilot when it is issued, and to ask a committee to investigate the matter.
I will take that as a recommendation.
I endorse the recommendation. I, too, am disappointed with the Executive's response. I would not say that it is flippant, because it runs to two and a half pages, but the Executive has failed to grasp the seriousness of the issue. Sharon Grant's letter says:"As the enhanced throughcare service being developed in Scotland will be available to those suffering from a miscarriage of justice we do not consider that they require specific and targeted support."I am astonished by that.A few minutes ago, we were handed a revealing article from the Toronto Star that contains comments from Dr Adrian Grounds, who is a forensic psychiatrist from the University of Cambridge. He makes a couple of points that are obvious when they are read, but perhaps we did not think of them.Most prisoners probably proclaim their innocence, but those who were wrongly convicted are telling the truth. They carry that burden all the time that they are in jail, which puts them in a different frame of mind from people who say, "Okay, I did it, although I may claim that I didn't because it might make me or my family feel better." Those who know that they are innocent carry that burden.Let us say, for the sake of argument, that two people are each given sentences of 10 years. The person who committed the crime knows that he will stay in prison for that period and will gradually prepare for release. He may or may not have remission, but he will know well in advance when he will leave prison. However, a campaign could be conducted for the individual who was wrongly convicted and is also in prison for 10 years, and he might be told with just days' notice that he is free to go. That individual would have had no means of preparing for release and his situation could not be compared, even broadly, with that of someone who was put in prison for a crime that they had committed.I am concerned that that has not been taken into account. The comments from Adrian Grounds highlight the issue. He says that, sometimes,"the wrongly convicted suffer the kind of trauma experienced by victims of war crimes."We should not forget that such people are victims. The Executive's response fails to comprehend that we are dealing with different situations.The letter by Kirsten Davidson of the Executive, which dates from April, talks about reducing the risk of reoffending. How can people reoffend when they did not offend in the first place? That shows the level of misunderstanding that exists in the Executive. We should refer the petition to one of the justice committees and highlight in the strongest terms those points and others that members may want to raise.
I apologise for not mentioning at the outset that Tommy Sheridan is here to speak about the petition.
I concur with what Mike Watson and Linda Fabiani have said. Petition PE477 was submitted some time ago and there is no need for further delay. The petition should be referred to one of the justice committees. When one of those committees considers the petition, it might want to take account of the Home Office investigation in England and Wales.The Executive has failed miserably to acknowledge the specific situation that is the subject of the petition. An assessment needs to be made of what support is necessary in cases that involve a miscarriage of justice. Because the people in such cases do not admit guilt—they are innocent, so why should they admit guilt—they do not get the rehabilitation and support services prior to release that would allow them to plan for their release. It is a complete and utter insult to suggest that those services should form part of the same strategy as the one that applies to offenders.I am really quite upset on the petitioners' behalf. I imagine that the Executive's response to petition PE477 has compounded their suffering. It is a disgrace. Like other members, I argue strongly that we should move forward on the petition. We need to find a solution. A disservice has been done to these people in the past and that needs to be corrected.
I have nothing to add to what has been said so eloquently by other members, other than to say that I, too, am dismayed by the surprisingly unsympathetic response from the Executive—it is almost bizarre. I endorse totally what other members have said. We should refer petition PE477 to one of the justice committees.
The disappointment in the Executive's response can be contrasted with the positive comments from the committee. It is definitely helpful to hear those comments. In a previous life, I had occasion to spend four months in a training-for-freedom unit in a prison not far from this committee room. It is interesting to note that the training was called "training for freedom". It was aimed at prisoners who had been convicted, had accepted their guilt and were being trained to be reintegrated into society.What about the people who are innocent? What happens when they are released as the result of an appeal decision or a campaign? The term "training for freedom" does not apply. People including Robert Brown, Joe Steele, Tommy Campbell and Stuart Gair were detained for crimes that they did not commit. Mike Watson highlighted the most important paragraph in the Executive letter. The Executive says there is no need for "specific and targeted support". It is incredible that it can say that.If a miscarriage of justice takes place—unfortunately it is a fact of life that that happens—surely we must have a package of aftercare to target those who have been the victims of miscarriage of justice. I am pleased by the response of committee members, but saddened by the Executive's response.
I think that there is unanimity around the table with regard to our disappointment at the Scottish Executive's position. We have to convey that to the justice committees when we ask them to look into the issue quickly and forcibly. It is certainly an issue that needs to be addressed.
Our recommendation should include the suggestion that we should write to the Executive again saying that we note its response but that we are not content with it.
There may well be an issue about that but, if we write back to the Executive, we should split what we say into two parts. We asked for the facts about what was in place and the Executive gave us the facts. However, from the way in which the Executive responded, the language that it used and the suppositions that it made it appears that it completely misunderstood the point. The Executive has to take that on board.
link
I support what Linda Fabiani said. The Executive's response was unhelpful; it missed the point substantially. We have therefore not been able to progress our consideration of PE477. The recommendation that we should send the petition to one of the justice committees, along with a copy of the report from the pilot project that the Home Office is conducting, is sensible. There would be no harm in writing to the Executive in the terms that have been outlined.
When our clerk writes to the justice committees and the Executive, I ask that he specifies the comments that members have made.
It is standard procedure for the clerks to write back to the Executive to say what the committee has done with a petition. It would be worth pointing out to the Executive not only that it missed the point, but that that was the second time that it had missed it—the matter has been before the committee and been pursued previously. All the comments that members have made and members' strength of feeling will be conveyed in the letter to the Scottish Executive, which will emphasise the points that have been made about the extent of the correspondence and members' disappointment with the responses that have been received.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Nov 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 12 November 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 41
- New Petitions Petitions · 52
- New Petitions Petitions · 61
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 17
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 83
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 1
- Convener's Report Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.