Good morning and welcome to the seventh meeting of the Public Petitions Committee in the second session of Parliament. We have a busy agenda, so we will crack on.The first petition that we must consider is PE644, on the Government's domestic abuse policy, in the name of Mr Keith Cowan, on behalf of Outright Scotland. The petitioners call on the Parliament to urge the Executive to develop its current gender-based policy on domestic abuse to include all other forms of abuse that take place in domestic settings. Keith Cowan and Brian Dempsey are here to give a brief presentation in support of the petition.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Domestic Abuse Policy (PE644)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Brian Dempsey Outright Scotland 9
- Michael McMahon Lab 8
- Mike Watson Lab 4
- Keith Cowan Outright Scotland 4
- John Scott Con 4
- Linda Fabiani SNP 3
- Sandra White SNP 3
- Jackie Baillie Lab 3
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 2
- Mark Ballard Green 1
The record
41 contributionsI declare an interest as a patron of Outright Scotland.
Thank you, Mike. That is important.I welcome Keith Cowan and Brian Dempsey, who have three minutes for their presentation. Members will then have the opportunity to ask questions on issues that are raised. Mark Ballard MSP is also here to speak.
Good morning. I thank members for giving us their time.I represent Outright Scotland, which is a small and unfunded lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender rights organisation that has a long history of successful campaigning in Scottish society.We would like to make four points about our petition, which members will have read. First, domestic abuse that women suffer at the hands of men is a serious problem in Scotland and resources are needed to tackle it—we have no argument at all about that.Secondly, every year, thousands of female victims of women, male victims of men and male victims of women report having been assaulted by their partners. Therefore, domestic abuse does not affect exclusively female victims of men.Thirdly, the operation of the current gender-based definition of domestic abuse has the unintended effect of marginalising other minority victims of abuse, which also leaves their children unprotected. Last, we believe that no victim of domestic abuse deserves to be made invisible in the fight to end domestic abuse in Scotland.We ask Parliament to consider such concerns, to consult on a way forward and to ensure that all victims of domestic abuse are recognised and supported. That consideration might be undertaken by a committee's taking evidence from LGBT groups, the police and experts in family law—perhaps one of the justice committees could do it. We are happy to answer questions and to be constructively involved in future deliberations.
Does Mark Ballard want to say something before we move to questions from committee members?
It is clear that the petitioners are not asking for replacement of the current policy. They have made it clear that they support the work of the Executive and organisations such as Scottish Women's Aid. Compared with men, 10 times as many women suffer from domestic violence—we ought not to underestimate the scale of the problem that is faced by women throughout Scotland. The petitioners call for provision that would tackle the problems that are faced by the small minority of men who face domestic violence. Such provision would be additional to current provision for domestic violence. I am here to support the petition, which would add to existing Scottish Executive policy rather than undermine or contradict it.
Good morning. I am losing my voice, so please excuse me if it goes. I remember from the short time that I was on the Equal Opportunities Committee that there was a commitment that LGBT issues would be considered in a much wider scope. I would have imagined that this issue would be part of that. Has the Equal Opportunities Committee considered any issues related to your petition?
We are not aware that it has. We raised our concerns with the Scottish Executive equal opportunities unit, which agreed that there is a problem that should be examined. All that we are aware of is that there has been an acknowledgement that research is needed.In the middle of 2002, the Executive conducted some research into domestic abuse against men in Scotland and only a small section of the conclusion to that research refers to LGBT people. It says:"Innovative research strategies will also be needed to adequately investigate the extent and nature of abuse experienced by men living with male partners."I am not aware that that has been acted on in any way. Because Outright Scotland is a lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender organisation, we are also concerned about lesbians, bisexual and transgender people who experience domestic abuse.The situation is different in England and Wales, where the Home Office has an inclusive domestic abuse strategy. The Home Office consulted widely on that and it paid an organisation called the Broken Rainbow Forum to conduct specific consultation and research in the LGBT community. That means that the Home Office's guidance on domestic abuse has, for example, specific reference to the needs of transgender people who experience domestic abuse. We are not aware of any similar guidance in Scotland.
You mentioned the research that was done by the Executive. I know that you are a voluntary group, so funding will obviously be difficult for you, but have you done any research into abuse and do you have any figures? I do not see any in our papers. You mentioned the example from England. Do you know how much that cost to set up?
We do not have the resources to do such research. The only statistics that we have come from a statistical bulletin that the Executive produces each year, which reports on recorded domestic abuse in Scotland. I think that a new bulletin is due out now; the most recent one that I have, which was published in October 2002, says that the vast majority of people who experience domestic abuse are women, as Mark Ballard said.In 2001, 32,509 women reported domestic abuse, although it is likely that there is huge under-reporting of such abuse. The number of men who experienced domestic abuse was 3,260; I argue that there is also likely to be under-reporting by men. The figures for same-sex domestic abuse are unclear. We know that there is under-reporting of all kinds of homophobic crime and that LGBT people have a history of under-reporting. We have not been able to do much research into the extent to which LGBT people experience domestic abuse other than to look at the figures—international comparisons suggest that levels are similar to those in heterosexual relationships.
You mentioned research that was done in England; there is obviously funding there for that. How much would it cost to set up that research?
I do not have those figures with me because I was not expecting to go into much detail at today's meeting. We are not looking for the Executive to fund lots of refuges and so on for people who experience domestic abuse. The abuse that women and their children experience will be different from the domestic abuse that men experience, although domestic abuse is experienced by men all over Scotland, no matter who the abuser is. All we are saying is that the domestic abuse strategy and the Scottish Executive's definition of domestic abuse need to be wider then they are.In having a cross-party group on men's violence against women and children, the Scottish Parliament is taking the approach that we favour. It is saying not that domestic abuse is only men's violence against women, but that although there is men's violence against women, other violence takes place in domestic settings. That is the approach that we favour.
I have a follow-up question to Sandra White's question. I am still trying to get a handle on the number of people who are involved. Can you estimate the scale of the problem? Are we talking about 50, 500 or 2,000 to 3,000 people in a year?
The statistical bulletin for 2001, to which Keith Cowan referred earlier, shows that there were 229 male victims of male perpetrators who reported to the police that they had been victims. There were 133 female victims of female perpetrators who took the trouble to report to the police. That is about 350 people, and I understand that the numbers have been fairly consistent over the years. We may be talking about a relatively small number of cases. If 350 gay men, lesbians and people in same-sex relationships have gone to the police, we may be talking about as few as 600 to 1,000 people in a year.We do not know how many of those couples have children, although some will, but those adults and children are excluded from some of the protections in law. A child who is living with mixed-sex parents receives greater protection from domestic abuse than a child who is living with same-sex parents, which seems to be unreasonable. I cannot speak for those people, but there is anecdotal evidence from groups in Scotland that there is a problem. Even if the number of victims is between 500 and 1,000 people a year, those people are still suffering to the extent that they report to the police. It may be a small number, but it is not a minuscule number.
You say that children who live with adults who are in same-sex relationships might not enjoy the same protection in law that children who live with people in mixed relationships enjoy. Why should that be? Why should they not enjoy the same protection under the law?
Are you asking what the justification is or what the factual basis is?
Both.
I do not think that there is any justification whatever for telling a child that, because their mother lives with another woman, they are going to be treated differently from a child who lives with mixed-sex parents. I see that some members are shaking their heads. However, I am doing a PhD on family law so I have some knowledge of the matter, although I am not an expert. The Matrimonial Homes (Family Protection) (Scotland) Act 1981—I think in section 18—excludes same-sex couples and their children from the protections in that act. That is primary legislation that treats the children of same-sex couples less favourably than it does the children of either married or cohabiting mixed-sex couples.
I am sympathetic to the aims of your petition and to your trying to identify a strategy and resources to tackle the problem. You want those aims to be included in the domestic abuse strategy. I am sure that you know that the political definition of gender-based domestic abuse was fought for vigorously so that there was recognition that there was a power relationship in society between men and women. That is really important for people who have campaigned for women. There are other issues: violence and abuse of elderly people, for example. Are you keen, for political reasons, to have the aims included in the domestic abuse strategy? Alternatively, do you wish simply to attract resources, draw attention, raise awareness and ensure that rights are protected, but not necessarily under the domestic abuse umbrella?You mentioned the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on men's violence against women and children. Is there an argument for a specific strategy? You said that some people who experience abuse might have different needs and might not require the same approach, involving Women's Aid. Are more specific strategies needed to deal with abuse of elderly people in the community? What is the emphasis? What is really important to you?
Both aspects are important, but it is difficult to say what comes first. We want all victims of domestic abuse to be included in awareness-raising campaigns, education and training for people who work in the national health service or local authorities so that they get recognition and support. We want people to have the recognition, support and services that they need. It should not be an abstract thing; we should not say, "We recognise you, but we don't give you services."There are ambiguities in the definition that the Executive has come up with and in how it is applied. All victims should be included in the domestic abuse strategy. We do not know terribly much about this area, but I know that in some discussions some Asian groups have said that the focus on individual male power over the woman does not necessarily reflect their life experiences, in particular those of young women, where the family is important. They sometimes feel excluded by the specific definition.I would like there to be an inclusive domestic abuse strategy that includes explicitly all victims of domestic abuse. Within that, the biggest and perhaps most important tranche or aspect would be a vigorous, gender-based understanding of the power of men and women in society. I would not equate that with the overall domestic abuse strategy. We have to have an inclusive overall strategy, within which the biggest aspect is men's violence against women, because that reflects the reality of society. It does violence not to include that in the overall strategy.
link
I know Keith Cowan from an earlier existence, but I have not met Brian Dempsey before.I have a number of questions. First, although what you said about the Matrimonial Homes (Family Protection) (Scotland) Act 1981 was accurate, it has nothing to do with the way in which children are treated in the first instance as a consequence of domestic abuse. Naturally, the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 is the act under which children are given the primary focus. We should be careful not to talk at cross purposes. However, I note what you said. I am pleased that the Executive is to introduce a family law bill during the second session of Parliament—you might need to relearn what you have learned already.The issue of scale is involved. I recognise the difficulty that you expressed about the figures' being imprecise—we are all troubled by that. The statistics to which you referred were collected for the first time. I understand that the research indicated and underlined that, in something over 90 per cent of cases, we are talking about males perpetrating violence against women.The remaining 10 per cent covered a variety of cases including those in which women perpetrated violence against men or against other women and in which men perpetrated violence against other men. We have rightly to pay attention to the scale of the problem. I am not saying that your problem does not matter because it is small, but acknowledgement needs to be made of where resources should be concentrated. Is the evidence base satisfactory or does more work need to be done?My second question is about definitions. You will be aware of the Executive's booklet "Domestic Abuse—There is no excuse", which has been reprinted several times. I would like your comment on the definition of domestic abuse that is included in the booklet:"It includes all kinds of physical, sexual and emotional abuse within all kinds of intimate relationships. Usually women are abused by men, but it also occurs in same sex relationships and in some cases men are abused by women partners.Is not that what you are asking for or have I got it wrong?
On the last point about the definition, with respect, I think that you have got it wrong. I understand that most violence is done by men against women and that some men suffer violence at the hands of women. As a lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender organisation, we are looking for recognition of the fact that women can be abused by women and that men can be abused by men. The definition that you read out is not acceptable to us.
link
As this part of the definition is critical, I will repeat it:"Usually women are abused by men, but it also occurs in same sex relationships and in some"—
Right. I beg your pardon. In that case, the definition appears to be acceptable. There has been a change in Scottish Executive documents over the past few years and perhaps lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender organisations can take some credit for that. A few years ago, the subject of domestic abuse was seen as being about what men do to women. Nowadays the Executive's position is that it accepts—perhaps reluctantly, I do not know—that domestic violence comes in other forms. The Executive tends to say that before immediately moving on. One example is "Preventing Domestic Abuse: A National Strategy", in which an oblique and somewhat cynical reference is made to other forms of abuse in one paragraph while the rest of the document talks about domestic abuse in terms of abuse by men against women. Such recognition needs to be more than a token. That said, I accept that the definition that Jackie Baillie gave sounds useful.
Jackie Baillie dealt with one of the areas that I wanted to speak about, which is the question of the scale of the problem. The figures that you quoted of 229 male-on-male victims of violence and 133 female-on-female victims might seem to be relatively minor. How much of the country do the figures cover? Is it Scotland as a whole or one part of the country?
They cover incidents that were reported to the police in Scotland as a whole in one year.
So you have done a trawl of Scottish police forces to find out what incidents were reported.
No. The figures are taken from an Executive criminal justice series statistical bulletin. I can read out the reference number if you would like that on the record.
No—as long as the figures are Scotland-wide. I missed that point when you gave the figures. We should draw that point to the attention of the Executive.I am aware of what the Executive has said. The petition asks for other forms of abuse to be included and I think that the Executive can say that it has done so. Jackie Baillie has demonstrated that by reading from the booklet on domestic abuse. I support what Keith Cowan said: this is not about displacing any current spending. However, there is clearly a need for additional spending. That is the hurdle that has to be cleared when making a case to the Executive.The Executive is doing work on children and vulnerable adults but this seems to be an area where the Executive is not doing any work. If figures are available for forms of domestic abuse other than male on female, we could make a case that the Executive should reconsider the issue. The Executive will be able to read the official report of the evidence that Brian Dempsey and Keith Cowan have given and we could ask it to comment.
I will take that as a recommendation.
I have read the petition and listened to your evidence, and they seem to be two different things. The petition is wide and not at all precise or focused; but when I listen to you talk it is quite clear—although you must correct me if I am wrong—that your main concern is a justified concern about LGBT relationships. Your petition does not specify that, so what exactly do you want to achieve?
In the first instance, through this committee, we would like there to be a short period of focus on the forms of domestic abuse that are not covered by the definition of domestic abuse as being gender-specific abuse. Our specific interest is in lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people. We argue that those people are being marginalised and made invisible, and we ask that some time, energy and resources be spent on the problem to discover its extent and to identify the awareness, training and services that are required.We do not come with a list of demands, saying that each local authority housing department must have this particular definition, or that the national health service must take that particular approach. What we are looking for is the support of this committee to find a way for Parliament and perhaps the Executive to spend some time—perhaps only a short time—considering the issue in consultation with LGBT groups and legal authorities such as Professor Norrie. That is what we are asking for today; as to what we will ask for further down the line—I do not know.
That answer reinforces what I was saying: your petition does not ask for specific things. If we were to send the petition to the Executive without any of the back-up information that we have learned today, it would not be at all clear what the Executive was being asked to do.
Mike Watson has recommended that we ask the Executive to consider the points that the petitioners have made this morning.
link
Mike Watson's suggestion is helpful; the petitioners have been helpful, too. I am aware that the whole area is imprecise. The petitioners refer to a national strategy on domestic abuse, but that idea is quite old and predates the domestic abuse policy. The Executive's thinking has, I know, moved on. We need to be clear about which documents we are referring to and when they came out.I pick up from what people have said that the subject is imprecise and that we need an accurate evidence base on which to formulate any kind of policy. It would be legitimate to return to the Executive to ask it whether it intends to follow up the research that it has conducted and which suggests that it should do more. That would develop the evidence base and allow us to decide whether, if a problem exists, something needs to be done about it. However, if the scale of the problem is not significant, at least we will know that. That would build on Mike Watson's suggestion.
I agree with the thrust of what Mike Watson and Jackie Baillie said—we must write to the minister. I understand from what has been said that the available funding is targeted at male-on-female domestic abuse. Therefore, there is a problem—although it is not huge—that I do not see being addressed, although others will correct me if I am wrong. That problem means that we should write to ask for the minister's views and to ask whether new funding might be made available to tackle the problem. Is that reasonable?
I invite members to comment. I think that the suggestion is reasonable.
I agree with Mike Watson that the problem exists no matter how small is, but I want the Executive's reply to include women's violence against men. It seems from cases that I have dealt with in surgeries and elsewhere that that is becoming more prevalent. I do not want the subject to be narrowed to include only same-sex couples. As Linda Fabiani was right to say, that is not what the petition asks for. I am concerned about the issues that have been raised, but also about women's violence against men within and outwith marriage. I want that to be included in any correspondence with the Executive and I back Mike Watson's recommendation.
All that I will add to what John Scott said is that the question is not only about resources. We need to develop policy on what is necessary. What resources are needed, and for what? For example, employment policy should ensure that people who are abused have the right to time off work to seek housing and it should ensure that they can transfer their employment. Development of such policies would help, although the needs are complicated and have to be explored.
Is everyone happy with the recommendation that, on behalf of the petitioners, we ask those questions of the minister, which we hope will progress the issue?Members indicated agreement.
I thank the petitioners for giving us their time.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Nov 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 12 November 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 41
- New Petitions Petitions · 52
- New Petitions Petitions · 61
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 17
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 83
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 1
- Convener's Report Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.