Petition PE616, which is from John Boyd on behalf of Wellpark Action Group, calls on the Parliament to investigate and assess the health and safety hazards caused by seagulls in urban areas. The petitioner is concerned about the threat to public safety in the Wellpark area of Kilmarnock caused by the marked increase in the number of seagulls that nest and breed in the area and their level of aggression during the spring and summer months.The committee considered the petition on 25 June and agreed to write to the Executive to request its views on the issues raised and to consult the Royal Mail about the action it has taken to protect its staff from attack by seagulls. Responses have been received, together with a letter from Fergus Ewing MSP, who supports the petition. The Executive has indicated that, as an interim measure, it will issue new guidance on the matter following discussions with local authorities. The Executive acknowledges that the problem has no easy answer, but states that it intends to commission research into the breeding cycles and feeding patterns of seagulls as a step towards identifying a long-term solution. The research will be completed in 2004.The Royal Mail indicates that the practice of issuing protective clothing to some of its staff in the Kilmarnock area to help to combat attacks from seagulls has been discontinued. It explains that although the practice offered protection from seagulls, it did not prevent the attacks. A solution was found that involved adjusting delivery times during the nesting season and no further problems have arisen. Fergus Ewing has supplied a copy of a letter that he sent to the Chief Medical Officer for Scotland expressing his concern that a complacent approach had been taken in assessing the public health risk caused by seagulls attacking humans. In the letter he suggests that the Executive take urgent and positive action to address the problem.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Seagulls (Health and Safety Hazards) (PE616)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 4
- Fergus Ewing SNP 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
- Sandra White SNP 1
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 1
The record
9 contributionsMy interest in the subject began years ago, before the day when I was out for a jog between Lossiemouth and Burghead and was dive-bombed by a seagull, which was not a pleasant experience. Over the summer, a number of mothers in Nairn were terrified and sought a cull of birds that were nesting in the vicinity of their homes after a number of incidents forced them to keep their children indoors. There is also the well-reported case, which I do not think has been mentioned, of Mr Wilfred Roby who, in July 2002, was swooped on by herring gulls while clearing a nest from his garage in Anglesey and died of a heart attack. I feel strongly that more and more people in Scotland are experiencing the nightmare of being dive-bombed by seagulls. Although physical contact is made only rarely, I am concerned that the elderly, the infirm or the very young might be at risk and that there might be fatalities in Scotland, as there have been south of the border, as a direct result.I have seen a briefing from the RSPB, which argues that no lethal control should be used. However, I understand that Allan Wilson recognised in a debate last year that there is a power under section 16 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 for licences to be issued for lethal control.In areas such as Nairn, where women are terrorised by seagulls to the extent that they cannot leave their house, local authorities should be able to employ lethal methods of control in the most humane way possible, which can include pricking the eggs—no doubt there are other methods. Local authorities have pest control departments that provide an excellent service in clearing lofts of rats, mice, squirrels and so on. It seems to me that there is a strong case for the Executive to say right now that local authorities should be tasked similarly and should be willing to act in cases such as the one in Nairn. I know that the ladies involved sought help, but they got no help from the RSPB or anybody else. I am not advocating a mass cull, because that is plainly impractical. However, action should be taken where there is a clear and present danger from seagulls during the nesting season, when, understandably, they are out to defend nests and chicks and they dive-bomb people, which is an horrific experience. If a dog behaved in that way, it would be regarded as unacceptable and the dog would probably have to be put down. If rats, squirrels or any other animal behaved in that way, they would be destroyed by local authorities. It seems rather odd that we treat seagulls entirely differently only because they are birds and perhaps because of the lobbying power of the RSPB.I am shocked at the Executive's complacency. It did not take action when I raised the matter in the first session. It seems that it is going to commission a report, but we already know what we need to know about seagulls and their habits; we do not need any more delays. There is a need to amend the Environmental Protection Act 1990 so that gulls are included in the definition of a statutory nuisance. That would give local authorities wider powers to act. As I have said, the existing powers should be sufficient for local authorities to step in, but that is debatable and depends on the interpretation of whether the birds constitute a threat to human health and safety or a threat of spreading disease or causing serious damage to crops and livestock. A wider definition of statutory nuisance would allow local authorities the scope that they need to act.I urge members to accept that seagulls pose a growing and serious problem all over Scotland. If we fail to act and a fatality occurs, today's debate will be looked at again by the family that submitted petition PE616. They might well ask us, "Why did you not act before it was too late?"
I do not think that any one of us takes the problem at all lightly. Those of us who have seen the problem, read the newspapers or watched news programmes know how serious the problem could become if action is not taken. However, the paper that we have on petition PE616 shows that the Executive is commissioning research and issuing interim guidance. Given that new guidance is to be issued and research is on-going, it might be appropriate for us to defer the petition until a future date. We could revisit it once we have seen the impact of the new guidance. If the guidance backs up what the minister said in the chamber not so long ago, it will be welcomed. I suggest that we agree that that is what we should do.
There is probably more of a problem with gulls in city centres now than there is on the seashore. Certainly, I seem to see plenty of gulls in the middle of Glasgow. One of the concerns that I raised, which I thought we were to include in our letter to ministers, was about the task force that was supposed to have been at work in 2002-03. The reply from the Executive does not address the task force and seems to indicate that the Executive is only starting out on some of the work that should have been done in 2002-03. However, the reply shows that there is at least movement in the right direction.I am not sure whether we should leave petition PE616 until we receive a further report from the Executive on the long-term solutions to the problem. One of the important long-term solutions is for councils to issue wheelie bins. The problem is far reaching. I am not sure that I would go so far as to say that a cull should be undertaken, but something needs to be done about the menace that seagulls pose.Given that local authorities are responsible for cleaning up areas and providing wheelie bins, perhaps petition PE616 should be referred to the Local Government Committee. I will listen to what the rest of the committee has to say on the subject. I would like the Executive to give us a reply on the task force.
We could do both. The Executive's response said: "officials have met with a number of local authorities' Directors of Environmental Health on this issue".We know that officials are hearing about the problems and learning more about councils' attempts to introduce solutions.We could do what Sandra White suggests and wait until the report is published. We could also ask the Executive for a periodic update on the meetings that its officials are holding to find out what progress is being made. That would allow us to keep on top of the information that is being issued by whatever task force has been set up. It would mean that we are not sitting waiting until a report is published at some point in the future. Do members agree that we should monitor the situation as it develops?
I agree with the convener's suggestion. I would be concerned if we simply left the issue ticking over, as the subject of the petition has to be dealt with. I am not persuaded that lethal methods are warranted. The RSPB response raises some serious issues in that respect that have resource implications in the long term. Even if lethal measures were taken, I am not sure that that would solve the problem, as the population of gulls is falling. The problem is where the gulls are, not how many of them there are. Measures need to be taken to ensure that the gulls are not attracted to urban areas. We need to tackle rubbish—including from outlets such as McDonalds—nesting sites and so forth. Although such measures are complicated, I hope that there is no delay in implementing them.
What I was saying in response to Sandra White's suggestion was that, in addition to the report that we expect to receive, the Executive is considering interim measures and new guidance. We could request the information when it becomes available and consider it to see what progress has been made to address the concerns that Carolyn Leckie set out. Ultimately, we will have the report. I hope that it reaches us in the near future. At that point, if we believe that a parliamentary committee should examine the issue, we could action petition PE616.
May I—
I am sorry, Fergus, but we are pushed for time. We have given the subject a good airing and do not need to seek further clarification or raise further points about seagulls. We are talking about what we will do with petition PE616. I think that committee members agree that we should ask the Executive for updates on the progress that it is making towards addressing the petitioners' concerns. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Oct 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 1 October 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 41
- New Petitions Petitions · 55
- New Petitions Petitions · 65
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- New Petitions Petitions · 17
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Convener's Report Procedure · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.