The next petition, PE670, is from the Public and Commercial Services Union. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to investigate the decision by the Scottish Executive to relocate the headquarters of Scottish Natural Heritage to Inverness.Members should note that PE670 is the first petition to have been submitted via the Parliament's e-petitioner web page. The petition gathered 2,253 signatures, almost 600 of which came from outwith Scotland. As you know, the e-petitioner system provides a forum for online discussion of the issues that are raised in a petition, and 24 comments have been entered on the subject of PE670. Most commentators appeared to support the petition; the few that did not focused on the general issue of decentralisation, rather than on the particular matter of the SNH relocation.We have Philip Immirzi with us this morning. He is a union member at SNH, and I welcome him to the committee. You have three minutes, after which we will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Scottish Natural Heritage (Relocation of Headquarters) (PE670)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Philip Immirzi Prospect 18
- Michael McMahon Lab 11
- Mike Watson Lab 5
- Carolyn Leckie SSP 4
- Jackie Baillie Lab 4
- Fergus Ewing SNP 4
- Sarah Boyack Lab 3
- Mike Pringle LD 3
- Susan Deacon Lab 2
- Helen Eadie Lab 1
The record
55 contributionsI preface my main remarks by saying that Alan Denney, the national officer of Prospect, who is acting on behalf of both unions involved in this case, was unable to attend today. He would have been presenting the petition but he has, apparently, broken his leg.Thank you very much for inviting us to present the petition today. Members will no doubt be aware of the considerable interest that the decision to relocate SNH's headquarters to Inverness has aroused. Given the time constraints, we do not propose to rehearse all the background information, much of which is already publicly available. Rather, we wish to concentrate on a number of key issues and on what we believe should happen.Since the decision was announced in March, we have witnessed a number of developments that seriously question its logic. The relocation could cost something like £30 million, which is about £10 million more than was originally estimated. The SNH board did not believe that that represented good value for money and had deep reservations about it. There is a possibility that Scotland's leading environmental agency could be relocated on a greenfield site.Throughout the process, ministers appeared to be unaware of the fact that staff in non-departmental public bodies do not have the same rights as civil servants and cannot be transferred to other parts of the civil service. Finally, and importantly, the loss of a large number of key staff will seriously damage the operational efficiency and effectiveness of SNH for the foreseeable future. That demonstrates that the decision appears to have been taken without properly considering the full consequences. The review that was conducted by SNH did not, in fact, support the idea of moving to Inverness; indeed, the consultants, the management and the board discounted its being a viable option.The Executive policy on relocation lays out a number of criteria, central to which is the need to ensure that any such move does not impair the operational effectiveness and efficiency of the organisation. It is mystifying, even to the well-informed observer, that the decision can apparently satisfy that criterion, given that 80 to 90 per cent of staff will not move to Inverness.The PCS and Prospect entered the exercise with two aims in mind: first, to protect members against redundancy and compulsory transfer and secondly, to assist with any necessary dispersal of jobs from Edinburgh to other parts of the SNH estate, taking into account concerns about operational efficiency and about redundancy and compulsory transfer. The unions believe that it is important for civil service jobs not to be centralised in Edinburgh, in the same way that they did not in the past want them to be centred in London. However, for dispersal to work, it has to be done properly, through consultation and involvement. It cannot be forced through with the threat that staff will lose their jobs. Dispersal must also ensure that services are not merely maintained, but improved. For the foreseeable future, it looks as though they will, in fact, be impaired. Dispersal must be done in a way that balances costs and benefits. It would also help if decisions were made with full knowledge of where an office could be built, and indeed of whether one could be built.Our concern is that the Executive has not followed its own policy, which puts that policy at risk. We believe that to look into what has happened with SNH over the last six to nine months would teach us some very valuable lessons. Ministers have not so far shown willingness to re-examine the decision and seem to be confused about some key aspects. We therefore call on the Parliament to scrutinise the decision, to get it seriously moderated or reversed and to ensure that the policy works in future. All parts of Scotland could and should benefit from the dispersal of public sector jobs, but the cost of the SNH dispersal—almost £100,000 per job, which is what the £30 million equates to—does not convince us that the policy is being followed properly.
On behalf of the committee, I put on record our best wishes to Mr Denney for a speedy recovery.We are joined this morning by Sarah Boyack, Susan Deacon, Mike Pringle and Fergus Ewing, who have indicated that they are interested in speaking to the petition. However, I invite committee members to ask questions first.
I am sympathetic to the petition as far as the threat of compulsory redundancy and transfer is concerned. I want to understand a bit more about the composition of SNH staff throughout Scotland—my understanding is that a number of workers are already located throughout the country. Will you give me a bit more information about what sorts of jobs are located throughout the country, the current skill mix and the current balance between jobs in Edinburgh and jobs elsewhere?
A lot of that information is in the report by DTZ Pieda Consulting Ltd, which is available on the SNH website. However, I will give you a rough-cut impression of how SNH is organised. We have a head count of some 850 staff, of whom 70 per cent are based outwith Edinburgh. Within Edinburgh, we have a complement of about 270 people. The staff in Edinburgh are largely headquarters functionaries, support services staff—information technology services, personnel and various other corporate services or common services—and a substantial proportion of the research, scientific and technical staff who provide support services to our operational areas. That said, some 40 per cent of our headquarters staff are already located outside Edinburgh. To talk of Edinburgh as the headquarters is, therefore, perhaps a misnomer.
When the decision to relocate the Scottish Natural Heritage headquarters was taken, I was a minister. I was party to the decision, although I was not a minister in the relevant department. I was in favour of the decision then and still think that it was the right thing to do, but I have concerns about some of the points that are made in the petition. We are told in the background information to the petition:"Despite assurances by Ministers, SNH has not been free to enter negotiations with unions to avoid the need for compulsory redundancies."With whom have discussions taken place in terms of the normal employer-employee relationship?
The decision was made by ministers. SNH consulted staff fully during the process up to the point that its advice to ministers was made. SNH's record is pretty good on that point. I believe that there was then a long hiatus in which it was not possible for the unions to discuss matters pertaining to the decision. I believe that that situation has recently changed and that the unions are now in negotiation with management.
Are they in negotiation on the question of compulsory redundancies?
Yes. That is a recent improvement in the situation.
You also said that the unions accepted the basic policy of dispersal—I have noted this down, so I hope that I am quoting you accurately—but that the policy cannot be forced through using the threat of jobs' being lost. What did you mean by that? Is it simply the rather blunt point that someone who is not willing to move to Inverness will lose their job? Has the matter been as black and white as that?
Quite simply, yes. We are public servants, we are not civil servants. SNH is a quango, and its staff do not have the right of transfer to other parts of the Executive. That means, in effect, that we will be made compulsorily redundant if we are unwilling to move.
What about relocation within other parts of SNH? You have said that the organisation is already fairly well dispersed. There must be other possibilities for staff dispersal within existing offices in other parts of Scotland.
To its credit, SNH has pursued that policy for many years, although perhaps not as explicitly as it could have done. Although we have a system of some 40 offices around the Highlands and Islands of Scotland, all those offices have a critical mass of people. It would therefore be difficult to effect a move of that scale over such a short time frame, but it is a possibility.
I have a final general point that relates to what you have said. Historic Scotland is an executive agency rather than a quango. Would such status be more appropriate for SNH, as it would give staff the right of transfer?
I do not want to pass judgment on that, as I am not mandated to do so.
link
I apologise for the fact, of which I gave the convener notice, that I have to attend a meeting of the justice committees on the budget this morning, so I have come hotfoot to this committee for this petition.I apologise for missing your opening presentation, but I would like two issues to be clarified. First, you talked about recent meetings with management. I make a distinction between the management of SNH and ministers. What meetings or discussions were had with ministers, given that the decision was political until it was announced?Secondly, I take your point that SNH does not have headquarters per se and I am conscious that many of its employees work in Clydebank. If the headquarters is moved to Inverness, is that likely to have an impact on employees in Clydebank? That would mean that repercussions were felt well beyond Edinburgh.
I believe that Ross Finnie gave the unions a hearing before the decision was made some time in March. That was the unions' only opportunity to talk formally with a minister. The unions have made several informal approaches, but another formal meeting has not taken place. Does that answer your first question?
link
Yes.
As for impacts on other parts of SNH, if the logic of relocation and all its possible consequences are followed through, an impact on other offices is likely. The unions are particularly concerned that such changes need to be factored into the equation.
I thank the convener for letting me speak at the meeting. I am interested in the issue as a constituency representative because, last October, I started to receive floods of letters from concerned staff who were hearing rumours about a move. I have followed the matter carefully and read the consultants' report. Having read the consultants' report, do the unions have views on why the decision was taken? I understand that other options were considered in the context of the dispersal policy, but the staff to whom I have spoken are not clear about why the other locations were picked and why the final decision was made, given its cost implications. The sum of £30 million is substantial and ministers have yet to clarify who will pay that.I would like a point about redundancies to be clarified. You said that a meeting was held with ministers, but I am conscious that the First Minister made a statement that no compulsory redundancies would be imposed. Have the unions been able to follow that up? That was of potential reassurance to SNH staff, but I have seen no clarification of that comment's status or effect. You said that your members are not allowed to move to other parts of the civil service, but I think that the First Minister reassured my constituents about that. Have you carried out a survey among your members on the potential impact of the move? I have received some heart-rending letters about people's family circumstances and the time scale.How do you feel about the ministerial directions to the board of SNH and the chief civil servant overseeing the move? What will the organisation's future mean for the staff? The time scale is short and there are real concerns about the effect on SNH's operations in what has already been a year of great uncertainty for staff.I will stop there as I know that other members have issues to raise as well.
I will answer those questions in reverse order and you will forgive me if I forget what the first question was by the time I have answered the later ones.The ministerial direction imposes a fairly rigid time scale for the project. That is obviously a big concern for staff because opportunities for consultation and involvement will be compressed into a very restricted time. I have a great deal of sympathy for managers who have to act on the decision within such a rigid time scale. The unions remain concerned that the time scale will not permit full consultation with, or involvement of, staff.You mentioned that the First Minister had given a reassurance that efforts would be made to minimise compulsory redundancies. The union remains completely unassured that that can happen—because of the way that a non-departmental public body is structured. We are public servants not civil servants. We have no rights of transfer. We are mystified as to how compulsory redundancies can be minimised—unless there is some new idea that has not yet been shared with the unions. I cannot speak on behalf of management, but I do not believe that such an idea has been shared with management either.That leads me to the first question.
Do you need a quick reminder? SNH's headquarters is in two buildings in Edinburgh, not one. The consultants' report gives five different options: relocation to elsewhere in Edinburgh and four other options. As I understand it, the Inverness option was the least popular among staff during the consultation process and the most expensive by a significant amount. What are your views on the robustness of the selection process and the criteria used by ministers in reaching the final decision?
The report contains many interesting facts and alternative interpretations are possible. However, fact number 1 is that Inverness was, taking financial and non-financial criteria together, the worst option. On financial criteria alone, Inverness was not one of the best options—the do-nothing option was significantly better.There were problems in undertaking a steady-state cost-benefit analysis of the options. Certain assumptions had to be made. However, the sensitivity analysis in particular showed redundancy costs to be the critical factor making any move from Edinburgh seriously uncompetitive. The sensitivity analysis was overlooked and that was a deep concern.We should bear it in mind that SNH wished to undertake an analysis of locations where it could meet its remit efficiently, effectively and economically. Ministers obviously had to base their decisions on a number of other considerations. However, we are concerned that those considerations were never made public, which means that we do not know the basis of the decision in terms of economic development. We have demonstrated on the grounds of operational effectiveness and efficiency that it would be unwise to move very far beyond Perth. We are mystified about how the decision was reached. There has been a complete lack of transparency.
I am grateful to the committee for the opportunity to speak and will preface my questions with a few comments. First, I should note for the record that the petition is supported by a substantial number of MSPs from all political parties and none. The fact that not all those MSPs are Edinburgh members reflects the degree of concern on this matter.Like Sarah Boyack, I have taken a very close interest in the issue not only because my constituency is directly affected but because I was involved in drafting the dispersal policy in the early months of the first parliamentary session. Indeed, Sarah, too, was a minister at that time. As a result, it is important to stress that many of us who support the petition are also enthusiastic supporters of the dispersal policy. Our concern centres on whether the policy is being implemented effectively on this occasion. It is my considered opinion that both the substance and the handling of the decision are very badly flawed and the fact that there have been two ministerial directions—one to the SNH board and the other to the senior civil servant involved—which is quite unprecedented, speaks volumes.I was particularly interested to hear the union's concern that the wider policy might be undermined because of the way in which this decision has been handled. How will the experience impact on the significant number of potential relocation decisions that are now pending? I understand that in the light of recent experience other trade unions and indeed the Scottish Trades Union Congress are taking a close interest in the matter and I would be grateful if you could add any information.I would also welcome further details and clarification about the nature and timing of decisions that remain to be taken. I am aware of the widespread perception that because the ministerial direction has been made the decision has been finalised. However, as far as I understand it, the ministerial direction still requires the SNH board to draw up a plan for the move. Will you elaborate on whether there is scope within the plan for any change of heart or direction on what has been stated?Finally, I have heard people explicitly justifying the relocation by saying that Inverness is a suitable location for an environmental agency because it is rural and so on. However, I am aware that people who work in the field rail against such a caricature because a substantial effort is being made to deal with the natural heritage of urban as well as rural Scotland. As someone who is directly involved in that work for SNH, will you comment on that?
You have asked three big questions. As I can speak on the relocation issue only from my personal experience and exposure to it as an SNH Prospect representative, you will forgive me if I give the union's perspective on things.The SNH decision and the lack of transparency with which it has been made cast serious doubt on how such decisions will be made in the future. That is a key reason why we are taking this forward as a generic issue as much as a specific issue about SNH. We want the rationale for such decisions to be examined to ensure that future decision making delivers the objectives that it sets out to achieve. We believe that the impact of the decision seriously undermines the policy. On that basis, we want the decision to be examined in greater detail.Given the direction's immediate requirement on SNH management to develop a fairly worked-up proposal to effect the move in order to get sufficient resources to make the move happen, I believe that the time scale is exceedingly tight. I have already alluded to the fact that sufficient time has not been given for proper participation by staff and unions in the process. I am sure that SNH management is committed to being as helpful as possible—that has been our experience—but the time constraints are so serious that they frustrate that ambition to be fully participative and to involve staff.Within your question was an embedded question about whether the move could be in some way moderated and whether we could somehow find a happy medium. We see no evidence that any fewer than some 220 staff, or 220 posts, will be moved to Inverness. As far as I am aware, that is the basis on which the management is preparing a project proposal. There is no indication whatever that the decision can be moderated at this stage.Finally, you asked for comment on the wider perception that SNH, as an environmental agency, may have a better fit with Inverness than with Edinburgh, Perth or Stirling. Interestingly, the majority of people in Scotland live in urban areas and it is their behaviours, decisions and patterns of living that have an impact on the environment out there—whether that is in the Highlands and Islands or closer to home. The people whom we want to influence are as much in the central belt as in the Highlands and Islands.To SNH's credit, it has architected an organisation that is close to the communities that it serves. We have offices in the Highlands and in many of the islands where other public agencies are not present. In effect, it does not really matter where the headquarters is, because we are out there, close to the communities that we wish to serve. The decision seriously undermines some of the objectives behind that important ideal.
Mike Pringle has a question, and he will be followed by Fergus Ewing. We need to start getting recommendations on what to do with the petition as we have discussed the issue for some time now.
I thank the convener for allowing me to speak, although some of my questions have already been raised. Let me start by saying that both Jeremy Purvis and Margaret Smith, who would have liked to have been here today, apologise for not being present as they are both at other committees. One of them is at the committee that Jackie Baillie has just come from.I will ask a couple of questions and then make a comment. I reiterate what Sarah Boyack said. The SNH headquarters is in my constituency, so I have received a number of letters from constituents that are really heartfelt pleas asking us to do as much as possible to keep those jobs here. Members should see the letters.I will focus on staffing. I understand that management did a survey some time ago to investigate how many staff would not relocate. I do not know whether you have that figure. Could you tell us a bit about that?The other point that we discussed was the unions' meetings with ministers. I do not know whether you can answer this question. Do you have any idea about the meetings that management has had in the period before and since the election? Also, could you give an opinion about the effect that the exercise will have on the lives of staff?
I will take the first question first. The DTZ report, to which I alluded, provides all the evidence that you need to know how many people have indicated that they will not move to Inverness. One figure that is being used is that 75 per cent of staff have indicated that they will not move. That statistic deserves closer scrutiny, because another figure is portrayed in the same report in relation to the Scottish Public Pensions Agency. It indicated that a high proportion of those who said that they would consider moving did not move. That is why you will see figures that show 80 per cent to 90 per cent of staff indicating that they will not move. The figure for staff who have indicated that they will not move is clearly somewhere between 75 per cent and 90 per cent. That is a clear statement of the staff's feeling about where they want to work.The second question is a little more difficult for me to answer because I am not privy to all the meetings that have taken place. My feeling—it is very much a feeling rather than factual evidence—is that insufficient dialogue took place before and after the decision was made. I will leave it at that.
Having had a number of meetings with managers I would say that that is certainly their view.What effect is the decision having in terms of the employment of staff at SNH and staff leaving?
It is difficult to put a finger on the number of staff who are leaving, but I can certainly make a comment on staff morale, which is at an all-time low. The outlook is very gloomy and staff are uncertain about their future. A good half of the staff have made a career in nature conservation and the environment and they are not sure what will happen to them and their families.
I will make a brief comment about the ministerial direction. I understand that the direction to the senior civil servant and to SNH is a unique event; it has never happened before. The cost is estimated to be £30 million—I am sure that we are all aware of a current project that has started at £40 million and has ended up at £400 million. I have always suggested that the estimate of £30 million is seriously on the low side for the impact that the move will eventually have, in view of the fact that SNH is having problems finding a new headquarters in Inverness. Inverness's economy is almost as overheated as Edinburgh's is.I wrote to Robert Black, the Auditor General for Scotland, to ask him to investigate the decision taken about the public money that will be spent on this exercise. It seems to me to be ludicrous that he cannot investigate the use of public funds until the money has been spent. I would have thought that there must be some way for the Auditor General for Scotland to ask whether spending money on this exercise is in our best interests, but apparently the money has to be spent before he can say that it was a bad decision. That seems to be a mixed-up way of going about things.
I start by saying that I entirely respect the views of the constituency representatives whom we have heard sticking up for their constituents' interests. As a matter of courtesy I have sought to reply to employees from Edinburgh who have written to me, although I would of course never take up their case.I am sure that no one has meant to criticise Inverness, but it seems that a pall has hung over the conversation so far. I reassure members that Inverness is not Scotland's gulag. It is not ice station zebra and I have not noticed any salt mines there. Inverness is a great place in which to bring up children and to live—all of human life is there.A long time before this decision was taken—during the review process—I met the chairman and chief executive of SNH and argued that functions such as the new outdoor access code should be relocated. I did not argue for relocation lock, stock and barrel. However, as the constituency MSP, I support the decision that has been taken. I hope that the 75 per cent of staff who said that they would not move from Edinburgh will find a warm welcome in Inverness, should they decide to come.I want to ask one question that seems fundamental to the issues that have been raised this morning. What explanation and justification exist for the decision that has been taken? From the consultants' report, we know that Inverness was not the recommended option. We believe that the civil service did not recommend Inverness and we assume that it recommended that SNH should not move there. As we all know, there are suggestions that the decision was taken shortly before the election for entirely party-political reasons. Does the PCS believe that there should be full disclosure of all the civil service advice and documents that were given to ministers, and of internal memoranda and other documents—that is to say Cabinet papers? Only such disclosure will allow us to see why the decision was made. Would the PCS support such a move in order to arrive at the truth? If so, the documents could be made available to the Finance Committee, which is shortly to investigate this matter, as I am sure the witness is aware.
Both unions—the PCS and Prospect—would find full disclosure most helpful. No stone should be left unturned.
The difficulty is that access to this information is governed by a code that states that such documents—namely, civil servants' advice and ministerial and Cabinet papers—should normally be kept confidential, to ensure the candour of internal discussion. However, there is a discretionary power, which has never been used, for the Scottish Executive to open up the books and make public all those documents. For there to be such disclosure, the Scottish Executive—the Labour-Liberal coalition—would have to say positively that public interest in this matter is such that the risk of any harm resulting from disclosure is vastly outweighed by the concerns of the people whom you represent. Do the unions believe that the Scottish Executive should use its discretionary power in this case, open up the books and make public all the documents involved?
The simple and short answer is yes. We think that the principle of open government should apply to all decision taking.
I apologise to the petitioners for arriving late. I had a prior meeting to attend and intimated to the convener that I would be late.I signed the motion that was lodged by Sarah Boyack because I, too, have constituents who are very concerned about the issues that we are discussing. I support whole-heartedly the Scottish Executive's policy of relocation, but I have profound concerns about the way in which the relocation of SNH has been handled. I refer to the handling of the matter by ministers, rather than by SNH or Scottish Executive officials. It smacks of the worst kind of industrial relations that we have seen in this country for a long time. We have to have profound concerns when we see employees being handled so unsympathetically,The PCS has a long history of negotiations in the civil service. How do you rate the handling of this situation in the context of all the other negotiations with the civil service that have taken place in recent years?
I am an employee of SNH rather than of Prospect or the PCS. I have taken a particular interest in the issue of the consultation, involvement and participation of employees in decision making and the impression that I have formed is that this decision is one of the worst.
I will take a final question from Carolyn Leckie and then ask for recommendations as to what we do with the petition.
I will finish off by making a recommendation, to save you coming back to me. I would have the same concerns about the work force if we were talking about workers in Inverness being transferred to Edinburgh. The issue is not about the merits or demerits of a particular city, town or village; it is about employment rights and that has to be our major concern.We need to address the contradictions in ministers' statements that have been made in the past and seek clarification. We also need to seek the Executive's response to the prospect of 200 people not moving to Inverness and what that would mean for the future of SNH and its ability to function, if this disaster were to unfold. I support the call for the petition to be referred to the Finance Committee. In view of the urgency of the situation, we also need to make strenuous representations to the Executive to tell us what it thinks, particularly with regard to previous guarantees that have been made on compulsory redundancies and transfer into the civil service. We need to pursue that.
I will comment briefly. We have laboured the point about the financial costs, but there are huge intangible costs as well. There is no doubt that SNH's reputation will be affected. There are costs in relation to human resources. Experience has been built up over the past decade to establish an organisation that is pretty effective. We have good evidence that SNH is respected among key stakeholders and partners. The move will be particularly damaging in terms of the loss of scientific and technical expertise. A lot of that is intangible and a price cannot be put on it. There is no doubt that the move will be damaging to the organisation's future operational effectiveness, from two years before the move until three years after it. The organisation will have to build a completely new culture and that cannot be done overnight.
link
I have a couple of suggestions. I echo Carolyn Leckie's point that the issue is not about constituency interests; it is about whether the move is the correct strategic decision and whether it represents value for money in the pursuit of the dispersal policy. There is the specific issue of SNH and the much wider issue of the general policy of dispersal, for which a number of members, including me, have indicated support.The Finance Committee is investigating the general policy and it is appropriate for us to refer the petition to that committee, given that what has happened with SNH could be an example of how not to do things. I wonder whether the Audit Committee might also have a role in considering the petition. I heard what was said about the Auditor General, but there must be an opportunity to scrutinise the specific decision in terms of the ministerial directions, which are unique. After all, the budget process is open to scrutiny the minute that the Executive starts to spend money rather than only after we have completed the budget.
I suggest that we condense the issues that Carolyn Leckie and Jackie Baillie have raised. The Finance Committee has shown an interest in considering the petition. However, I am concerned about muddying the waters by writing to the Audit Committee to ask it to consider the petition and by writing to the Executive to ask questions. Would not it be better if we asked the Finance Committee to consider the petition, specifying the questions that we would like it to ask the ministers? We could also ask the Finance Committee to ask the Audit Committee to have a look at the petition. In firing off letters to different committees and personnel asking for responses, we might create a crossover that would not, ultimately, be helpful. Instead, we could contact the Finance Committee with recommendations on the specific points that have been made today, asking it to investigate the matter.
link
I find that acceptable on the understanding that the Finance Committee would not just take SNH as an example, but focus on the case of SNH.
I support that. From what I have heard, the Finance Committee is interested in the overall policy and, like other members, I believe that that is the right approach. However, there are substantial questions about the process that is being applied and whether ministers have, in issuing their directions, met the criteria that have been set for the Executive on efficiency and effectiveness. As long as our recommendations are clear, that course of action will be helpful to everybody concerned.
As a member of the Finance Committee, I know that it is looking forward to studying the general principles and criteria that have been set out as well as the individual case of SNH. The minister will, no doubt, appear before the Finance Committee and members of the Public Petitions Committee will be able to come along and add to the general grilling.I have a specific suggestion that arises from the very clear and unequivocal response from the witness to my questioning. Without an explanation of why the decision was made, we will be in the dark. Only if there is full disclosure of documents that, hitherto in the history of the Scottish Parliament, have been kept under wraps will we have any chance of finding out why the decision was made. I suggest that, in the light of the evidence that has just been taken, the committee encourages the Executive to think seriously about the recommendation that I made—which has been adopted by the union that is representing the work force—that there should be full disclosure, so that we can find out why the decision was made. That would, no doubt, provide the Executive with an opportunity to dispel any suggestion that party politics played any part in it.
As you are a member of the Finance Committee, Fergus, you could ask the minister that question.
I certainly will, but we want to get to the truth and the Public Petitions Committee has the option of making that recommendation. I am putting it to the committee that it should consider doing so. It is up to the committee to decide, but I cannot help feeling that no progress will be made on the issue unless we have sight of those documents. We all know that that is the case.
The responses that members have received from the petitioner have raised issues that we would want to recommend should be raised in any inquiry. That is a legitimate course for the committee to take. However, as a member of the Finance Committee, Fergus Ewing can pursue the specific interest that he has in the matter. It is not for the Public Petitions Committee to tell the Finance Committee—or any of its individual members—to pursue that specific interest. The committee's recommendations should focus on the questions that Carolyn Leckie and Jackie Baillie have raised and on the possibility of asking the Audit Committee to consider the petition. The recommendation is that we ask the Finance Committee to investigate the matter in the light of the information that we have received.
I hope that the Finance Committee will aggressively pursue all documents that relate to the issue.
I would take that as a given.
I am relaxed about who raises questions where, but I agree with everyone who has spoken about the urgency of the matter. We are at the end stage of the process of making the decision. Whether it is this committee or the Finance Committee that takes action, I want to stress the point that we should tell the Finance Committee that, in the context of its on-going investigation, it is critical that the Executive be made aware in the next few weeks of concerns such as those that have been raised today. The Executive should be asked, if not to make a full disclosure, at least to give an explanation of its decision soon. If not, further milestones will be passed.
I suggest that we write to the ministers not to ask specific questions but to advise them of the questions that have been raised this morning.
I thought that Susan Deacon suggested that we ask for the Executive's initial comments and stress the urgency of the situation.
I have no difficulty with that. If we make the Executive aware of those questions, I would expect to get a response. Are members happy to proceed in the way that has been outlined?Members indicated agreement.
For the record, I should state that, although Dennis Canavan could not make it to the meeting this morning, he asked us to forward the petition to the Finance Committee.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Oct 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 1 October 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 41
- New Petitions Petitions · 55
- New Petitions Petitions · 65
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- New Petitions Petitions · 17
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Convener's Report Procedure · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.