Petition PE616 is from John Boyd, on behalf of Wellpark Action Group.The petitioner is calling on the Scottish Parliament to investigate and assess the health and safety hazards caused by seagulls in urban areas. The petition is prompted by the petitioner's concern about the threat to public safety in the Wellpark area of Kilmarnock caused by the marked increase in seagulls nesting and breeding in the area and their level of aggression during the spring and summer months. The petitioner claims that, last year, there were at least two incidents of direct attacks by seagulls on residents and that there were problems with postal deliveries being disrupted to the extent that the Royal Mail issued staff with sticks and protective headgear. Concerns have also been expressed that the presence of seagulls is preventing smaller birds that are normally present in residents' gardens from raising their young in the area.I invite Fergus Ewing and David Mundell to comment on their knowledge of the situation, so that we can proceed to a discussion.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Seagulls (Health and Safety Hazards) (PE616)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 3
- Sandra White SNP 3
- David Mundell Con 2
- Fergus Ewing SNP 2
- John Scott Con 1
The record
11 contributionsI came along today because I secured a members' business debate on broadly the same issues on 7 November last year. The debate was primarily based on difficulties that had been encountered with the seagull population in and around Dumfries. During the debate, members from all parties and representing all parts of Scotland spoke about the serious issues that many communities faced. One of the difficulties is that the subject is often trivialised: people think that it is a bit of a joke. However, for those people who are directly affected, the issue is very serious. When he summed up at the end of the members' business debate, the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development, Allan Wilson, specifically undertook to consider the ability to provide national guidance on how to deal with seagulls that affect communities. At the moment, it seems that each individual local authority is being left to come up with its own solutions, even though it is clear that the problem affects communities throughout not only Scotland but in the United Kingdom and elsewhere. Regrettably, it is clear from correspondence with the Executive and some local authorities, including Dumfries and Galloway Council and East Ayrshire Council, that no progress has been made on national guidance on how to tackle the issue. There has also not been much progress on the related issue of waste management, which needs to be addressed. Many aspects of the problem concern food. Gulls have moved into urban areas because food from takeaways and in domestic rubbish is much more readily available than food from the sea. Who would blame a seagull for picking up a ready-cooked fish supper, rather than diving into the ocean to try to find a live fish? I hope that the committee can inject a degree of urgency into the commitments that the Executive has made to tackle the issue. I hope that members feel able to underline the fact that the issue is serious, and is not trivial to those who have been affected. As members might have heard on the radio, the people from Wellpark in Kilmarnock do not find it trivial. I have met some elderly people who have been trapped in their homes. They do not find the matter trivial. Shopkeepers in the centres of towns such as Dumfries and Kilmarnock do not find the problem trivial, because people are put off from going into those shopping areas. It is a serious issue for them. The problem cannot simply be left to individual local authorities to tackle. We require someone to take a view of the problem for the whole of Scotland. As was pointed out in a previous discussion, moving the seagulls out of Kilmarnock might result in them going to Ayr—as Mr Scott might suspect—or across to Hamilton or Bellshill. If the issue is not dealt with nationally, it will just move around.
I agree with a great deal of what David Mundell has said. I am sorry that Mr John Boyd is not here to describe the two attacks that took place. I can appreciate the problem. As the convener might know, Margaret and I stay in Lossiemouth, where seagulls are called gows. One day, I was out for a run between Lossiemouth and Roseisle, when I was attacked by a seagull, which dive-bombed me from the rear. I am happy to say that the seagull missed—I hope that members feel that that was a happy conclusion. It was an intimidating experience—far more so than questioning the First Minister. I read subsequently of a senior citizen in England who was attacked by a dive-bombing seagull while he was halfway up a ladder doing some work on the outside of his house and, as a result, fell off the ladder and died.The petitioner is asking for an investigation into whether there are risks to human safety. I believe that there are. However, in the debate to which David Mundell referred, Allan Wilson said that the chief medical officer says that there is no risk to health and safety. The chief medical officer should take affidavits from the individuals to whom Mr Boyd refers. I am not convinced that the CMO is correct. Although the topic has a humorous side, as do so many things, we are talking about a possible risk to human life.The problem of seagull control has been tackled piecemeal around Scotland by each local authority. That is not good enough. There should be a national strategy, which should deal with the control of waste and should make bins gull-proof, although then there is the problem of displacement. One option is to have a policy of legal control. The law permits control of gulls, but only where there is a proven risk to human health and safety. Local authorities should consider the matter and form a conclusion. Where control is necessary, I hope that we all believe that it should be done humanely. That could be achieved by local authorities instructing pest-control officers or by adopting an alternative, the pricking of eggs, which the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals proposes and which might be the most humane method.I am satisfied from trips around Scotland that the gull population is at worryingly high levels; in areas where we did not see them before inland they are now there aplenty. I worry that a serious incident might take place that affects human health—it could result in a fatality and the victim might be a young person. The only thing that we should not do is do nothing.
I had better declare an interest, as my husband has a pest-control business, and seagulls are certainly a pest. I know a wee bit about the nuisance that they cause and how to get rid of them.I am glad that Fergus Ewing mentioned a national strategy, because I was going to ask about that. We should consider a national strategy. He also mentioned that gulls are coming inland. That is true. I live in the middle of Glasgow, just off George Square, and we are pestered by seagulls there.Do David Mundell and Fergus Ewing believe that the Public Petitions Committee should write to the Executive to ask it to write to local authorities or to ask it to start up a national strategy in conjunction with local authorities? What would you like us to do with the petition, apart from write to the Executive, so that the petition has some impact on a national strategy?
The minister is already committed to developing a national strategy in conjunction with local authorities, which clearly is how it must be done. The committee should gee him up to move that forward, because little or no progress appears to have been made. Extensive research is taking place to try to track the number of birds, where they are and what are the patterns. I understand that the total number of some species of gulls is dropping, which is why certain protections exist, but now seagulls are not just on the coast, they are in urban communities. That is one of the challenges in dealing with the problem. There is still a lot to find out about how gulls move about and suchlike. For example, in the Dumfries area, it was suspected that the gulls were in the town because there is a landfill site relatively near to the town. However, research showed that a different colony of gulls inhabited the landfill site from that which inhabited the town. The research showed that dealing with the landfill site would not have dealt with gulls in the town.
I am sorry, but the reason why I asked the question was to hear whether other members would say that we should be geeing up the Executive to produce results from the strategy.
I do not think that there is a national strategy. However, David Mundell rightly said that the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development stated on 7 November: "the seagull problem is very real and … it needs action." The minister went on to say that he would"ask officials to develop the proposition with some urgency and to consult the RSPB … on how best to act."—Official Report, 7 November 2002; c 15168 and 15170.We should ask the deputy minister what happened after he made that statement.The petitioners are not at the committee today, but their petition relates to matters that we should investigate. PE616 raises the prospect of people being killed. If we do not investigate that possibility, what are we here for? Mr Boyd should be asked for further details about what happened. It would be useful if the chief medical officer could be asked to make contact with the petitioner to ascertain the details and perhaps also to obtain affidavits. The Royal Mail appears to have a policy of issuing safety gear and it should also be contacted. It must have discussed the matter at senior level and decided that the problem was sufficiently serious for safety gear to be issued. If the Royal Mail is issuing safety gear for its posties, what about everyone else who works outdoors? Those people lack safety gear and so must be at risk.My overall worry is that the chief medical officer has said that seagulls do not pose a risk to public health and safety. I want to know on what basis that conclusion was reached. What evidence does he have? Does the CMO feels that it is time to reconsider the issue in the light of PE616 and any other available evidence? We need to ask him whether a national consultation is called for and whether a national strategy is required to secure national safety. If so, we need to ask about its composition, implementation and funding.
I agree with Fergus Ewing and David Mundell. I represent a maritime constituency and my constituents share the petitioners' problems. We have a particular problem in McCall's Avenue in Ayr, where there has been a huge problem for a number of years.It is vital that we establish the scale of the problem and ascertain whether it is seasonal. The birds' aggressive behaviour would seem to be tied to nesting. We need a national debate to establish the risk and find out whether lives are at risk—as Fergus Ewing mentioned—and we need to urge the Executive to produce guidance on the matter.
Do committee members agree to those suggestions?
We should remind the Executive that it said that it would consider a strategy in conjunction with the local authorities.
We will ask the Executive where it is with the strategy. We will ask the CMO for the evidence on which his conclusions were based and ask the Royal Mail to input to our discussions. Are we agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Jun 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 25 June 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 92
- New Petitions Petitions · 53
- New Petitions Petitions · 84
- New Petitions Petitions · 52
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions Petitions · 19
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 68
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 6
- Convener's Report Procedure · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.