Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Falkirk Football Club (Promotion) (PE647)

Wednesday 25 June 2003 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 52 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

52 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I think that everyone is becoming familiar with our procedure. Petitioners have three minutes to discuss the purpose of their petition, after which there will be questions from members. The committee will then discuss what further action to take.I hope that what I am about to say will not colour the discussion, but we have to remember that we will be discussing a body of private groups over which the Scottish Parliament has absolutely no direct influence. We cannot order or instruct any organisation in that way. As I explained to the petitioners when they handed in their petition, I am very keen that an issue that affects many people in Scotland and can lead to petitions the size of PE647 should have light cast on it. I am also keen that light should be cast on the organisations that have a bearing on Scottish society. The Public Petitions Committee should hear the points that the petitioners will make.

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

Thank you, convener. What you just said has summed up a fair bit of our case. Being a Falkirk supporter, I am not used to such big crowds, but I am delighted to see our local MSPs here. They have been tremendously supportive of the club over the years. That demonstrates the community impact of our campaign.Three main elements should commend this petition to the committee. The first is that the petition and the campaign are for fans and are driven by fans. That does not only mean fans of Falkirk Football Club because, as members will have seen from the online sections of the petition, fans from virtually every football club in the United Kingdom have given us their support. There is a genuine sense of outrage that transcends club loyalty. People recognise that the decision is wrong, that it is against the concept of league football and that it rewards failure rather than success.The decision sets a precedent that can be used to damage football clubs that aspire to succeed on the park but which have not had sufficient time or opportunity to put in place the required infrastructure over the years. The fact that Falkirk FC does not yet know in which way we have failed to put in place the infrastructure required under the Scottish Premier League's criteria is one of the reasons why we are here.The second element is natural justice. If the decision is not overturned, the people who will suffer most in the coming season are the players and supporters of Falkirk FC. The fans have been disenfranchised. During the past season, we have watched our team compete on the park and gain the right to compete at the next level of Scottish football. The achievements of football teams should be determined by what happens between the white lines on a Saturday afternoon, not by what happens outwith them.Our players have earned the right to compete at a higher level, but they are being denied that right, which has resulted in the club losing players. We do not yet know what the circumstances are and why we are being denied promotion, but our club is being seriously damaged. We estimate that the decision to deny the club promotion could cost us around £1 million in turnover in the coming season. That is a tremendous amount of cash for a Scottish first division football club. Fewer than five years ago, the club was in liquidation, but the fans took the club out of liquidation within four months. That compares favourably with the situation in which certain clubs in Scotland have recently found themselves.It is hinted that the failure to meet the criteria relates to our inability to guarantee that we have a head lease on the Shyberry Excelsior stadium. I, and many other people, wonder whether North Lanarkshire Council has delayed the sale of Shyberry to ensure that such doubts could be raised. If so, that issue requires investigation. Given that we have secured the agreement of the Dudley Group Ltd, KPMG and North Lanarkshire Council officers, the failure to conclude the transaction raises some serious questions.The SPL's decision-making process is not acceptable in an open society. The decision will have a major impact on the principal leisure activity of thousands of people, but the SPL feels no obligation to explain, justify or defend its actions. I ask members to consider the outcry that there would be if the Parliament made decisions in the same way. The SPL's process is not open, reasonable or subject to scrutiny. It will be for the Office of Fair Trading to determine whether the SPL has acted legally in reaching its decision.We hope that the Scottish Football Association's appeal hearing, which should conclude tonight, will give us a positive ruling on the question whether football rules have been broken, not on the legality of the decision. However, it is important to understand that the matter will not stop there because the issue transcends more than this season and Falkirk FC. Questions will remain about the use of public funds—through grants, Scottish Enterprise and other means—by a body that is closed and secretive and which rewards failure. Those attributes are the antithesis of the type of Scotland that the Parliament has declared we should have. Falkirk FC supporters have the reputation of not going away when they get their teeth into an issue. Questions remain and we will continue to pursue the answers.The third element of the petition is that we have not had a reason for the decision. Members might find it difficult to believe that, despite the press coverage, interviews and the three-hour hearing at an appeal tribunal headed by a Court of Session judge, Falkirk FC has still not been given a reason why it fails to meet the SPL's criteria. The Parliament cannot force the SPL to take action, but it can ask the SPL to explain how the decision was taken and why it was taken in secret. The people of Scotland need an explanation.By means of a letter from my colleague Michael White, which we have circulated, we have, as you see, asked 10 questions of the SPL. It has, as yet, failed to give us a single answer. For the good not only of Scottish football, but of Scotland as a whole, we need answers. We need to stop such behaviour.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Thank you very much. If any MSPs want to make brief comments, they are welcome to do so, although I ask them to keep their contributions very brief.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

I will be brief. Would it be all right if I also suggested a course of action for the committee?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I have no problem with that.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

The situation is one of the biggest injustices in the history of Scottish football. Those who were members of the Parliament in the previous session will recall that I lodged a motion on the matter that was debated in the Parliament in March. That motion was supported by more than 70 MSPs and called on the SPL to "ensure that the champions of the First Division of the Scottish Football League are given the opportunity of promotion to the Scottish Premier League provided they have guaranteed use of a suitable stadium, whether through ownership or lease or a ground-sharing arrangement."Since that motion was lodged and debated in the Parliament, Falkirk FC has won the first division championship. It is adamant that it has met the SPL's stadium criteria in respect the new stadium at Westfield on the outskirts of Falkirk—on which work has already begun and which will be ready this time next year—and the temporary ground-sharing agreement at the Shyberry Excelsior stadium in Airdrie. I emphasise that there would be no disadvantage at all to Airdrie United Football Club in that ground-sharing arrangement. Nevertheless, SPL members decided by seven votes to five to deny Falkirk's bid for promotion. The decision was made behind closed doors and the SPL has failed to disclose any reasons for it. Therefore, as Stephen Bird said, Falkirk FC has submitted a complaint to the OFT and an appeal to the SFA. The appeal is due to be heard this evening, which is why the committee must move quickly if we are to be helpful. I suggest that the committee contact David Taylor today by e-mail or fax, send him a copy of the petition, tell him that the committee is concerned to read the contents of the petition—particularly the SPL's failure to disclose any reasons behind its decision to exclude Falkirk FC from the SPL, despite the fact that Falkirk apparently met the criteria for inclusion. I suggest that the committee ask David Taylor to bring the petition to the attention of the appeal body before it reaches a decision later today. I also ask the committee to consider expressing support for the contents of the petition, but if it finds that that is too difficult for it, the committee should at the very least ask that the petition be considered and that there be a fair hearing of the appeal and a detailed statement of the reasons for the decision.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

It is a pleasure to come along to a committee that has musical accompaniment from next door. I certainly endorse Dennis Canavan's comments. The SPL's decision to deny Falkirk FC entry into the Premier League was not only a financial blow to the club, as Stephen Bird has outlined, but a betrayal of the fans, who have supported their club loyally through thick and thin. The injustice that has been done to Falkirk fans this season could be done to some other group of fans next season if we do not find a way in which to resolve the issue. My concern is about the way in which the SPL arrived at the decision. I take on board the comments about it being a private entity and a private association, which arrived at the decision privately, as has been outlined. We do not even know which clubs voted which way. We have found out that information anecdotally from other sources, but there is no public record of it. There is no explanation from the various clubs as to why they voted in such a manner. Also, as Stephen Bird indicated, the club has had no explanation yet as to how and why the SPL arrived at its decision.I can understand that as a private organisation the SPL must work within its own constitution, but I would have thought that, in this day and age and given that the decision that the SPL made is so important, it would be reasonable to expect some form of explanation. We should keep in mind the fact that a number of the clubs that made the decision have benefited from public money in the past for their own stadia development and training facilities, and I am sure that they will seek public money in future. It is reasonable for a committee of this Parliament to try to find some way in which to make the SPL accountable and to examine how it operates to ensure that it becomes more transparent and accountable. That would be to the benefit of Scottish football and, in particular, to the benefit of Scottish football fans.

Cathy Peattie Lab Falkirk East
link

I will be brief. A lot has been said already. Falkirk football fans are frustrated, as are the folk of Falkirk in general. At a time when it is necessary to work to grow football by encouraging youngsters to participate and by involving local people, it is an outrage that the decision has been made behind closed doors. A form of glass ceiling is appearing for clubs such as Falkirk. As Michael Matheson and Dennis Canavan said, this is not just about Falkirk; it is about other football clubs in similar situations. I know that Falkirk fans are pleased that the committee is considering the petition. I support Dennis Canavan's call for action, and his recommendations on how to proceed.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I take on board Dennis Canavan's comments, which the committee can discuss, but before I open up the discussion, I have a question. The point about the criteria has been made, and I take it that you are aware exactly what the criteria are. Do you believe that the criteria have not been met? My view is that either the criteria are met or they are not met. How, then, can a decision have been made in which seven people believe that the criteria have been met and five do not? Do you believe that there are question marks over the delayed signing of documents, which, in black-and-white terms, means that the criteria have not been met?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

At the beginning of each calendar year the SPL writes to each first division football club, asking them to submit proposals on what would happen in the event of their being promoted. The SPL wrote to Falkirk FC as it wrote to everyone else. We replied and asked for a full set of the criteria listing what we would have to do. Having gone through those criteria, we submitted the documentation to the SPL at the end of March, before it was scheduled to make a decision on 31 March. The SPL decided at that point that it was not going to make a decision until later in the season.The SPL and its lawyers met Falkirk FC and our legal team at Brockville the following Wednesday, and went through the criteria. The SPL raised several relatively minor questions. For example, it asked about the quality of light at the Shyberry stadium. The stadium has been used for SPL fixtures in the past, so that should not be a problem. As far as I am honestly aware, the SPL did not raise with us anything of any substance.Our deal is with the Dudley Group, which is the property group that is the preferred bidder to take over the running of the Shyberry stadium. We were advised that in addition to the agreement with the Dudley Group, we should take a belt-and-braces approach and seek the same back-up from KPMG, as the liquidators, and North Lanarkshire Council. We proceeded to do that. The documentation has been on the Falkirk FC website for some time now.We have established that we met all the criteria, as far as we are aware. The week before the SPL made its decision, we were offered the use of another SPL-compliant stadium. We and our lawyers are absolutely confident that the deal we have in place at Shyberry is—as described by Donald Findlay QC—watertight. As has been alluded to, from the beginning of the year, representatives of certain football clubs have made public statements that Falkirk would not be promoted—end of story—regardless of the criteria that have been set down and regardless of what we do to fulfil those criteria. That is not acceptable. If the SPL lays down criteria under its own rules and we satisfy those criteria, we deserve to be promoted. Even during a three-hour appeal hearing last Thursday the SPL was unable to tell us how we—allegedly—failed to satisfy those criteria.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You will be pleased to hear that, being a Partick Thistle fan, I am used to huge crowds. I have a couple of matters that I want to pursue with you. It is worth putting on the record again that the SPL is not a public company but a private one. Therefore, some of the issues of transparency have to fall by the wayside. I am sure that some MSPs in the room will share that view. I watched as Partick Thistle threw up a new stand so that it could meet the criteria on capacity. It did so within a tight timetable; as far as I recollect, it had to be done prior to the March preceding the end of the season. Why was not your proposal sufficiently watertight? Why was there such a degree of uncertainty that the SPL deferred taking a decision?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

Without wishing to be flippant, if I knew the answer, we would probably not be here today. We have not yet been told by the SPL what the reason is.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

At the relevant point in March did you have the capacity and all the things that the SPL was looking for?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

Yes. We have an agreement with the Dudley Group for a head lease for the 10,000-capacity stadium at Shyberry. It is also agreed that we will have first access to the ground for all cup-ties within the SPL, the Scottish cup and the CIS Insurance cup, and any other access as and when we need it, if we give 24 hours' notice. Even if matches—cup-ties and so on—have to be abandoned or replayed, we have a watertight agreement. I do not know why the SPL has decided that we do not meet the criteria. That is one of the questions that I hope the committee can ask the SPL.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Let me press you further. I am conscious that there are issues of timing. Was the package tied down prior to the end of March?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

Yes. Had it not been, I have no doubt that on 31 March the SPL would have told us that we did not meet the criteria for this or that reason and would have thrown out our application. If we were told that we had done something that we should not have done, or that we had not done something that we should have done, that might have been painful but we could have lived with it. What we find unacceptable is being told that we do not meet the criteria but not being told why.

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

The SFA considered the appeal last week.

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

The SFA—the appeal was inconclusive last week. Tonight has been set aside for the appeal, which starts at 6.30 and ends at about 9.30; tomorrow night has also been set aside. The SPL has been unable to say, "There is something clearly lacking in Falkirk's capacity to meet the criteria." Were that the case, we would have been blown away a long time ago. The fact that five clubs say that we have fulfilled the criteria indicates the strength of our position. We heard a rumour that only five clubs voted against us but, like everything else at the SPL, we can neither confirm that nor knock it back because the SPL will not tell us who voted and why they voted in a particular way. For many of us who are involved in the game on a Saturday afternoon, football is not quite our life-blood but it is close to it. We need to know what is happening, and we are being deprived of a basic piece of information. That is fundamentally wrong.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

What is the relationship between the SFA and the SPL?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

Last week, that would have been a difficult question to answer, because the SPL was challenging whether the SFA had jurisdiction to hear an appeal against the decision. My understanding is that prior to the hearing's going ahead last Thursday night, all parties accepted that in football terms the SFA appeal is the end of the road. The SPL said originally that the SFA did not have jurisdiction over its affairs, because the SPL is a completely private entity. However, the SFA puts forward nominations for clubs to compete in Europe, and clubs have to be members of the SFA to be nominated. At the moment, it appears that the SFA has primacy.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

Were your appeal to the SFA successful, would the SFA have the legal capability to enforce its decision with the SPL?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

I understand that the SPL has given the undertaking that it will accept the decision. If the SFA says that we are at the end of the road and Falkirk has met the criteria, I sincerely hope that that will be the end of the matter. Time is pressing for the start of the new season.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

The SFA is the governing body for the whole of Scottish football. Every league in Scotland, including the SPL, must abide by the SFA's constitution and rules.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have a couple of questions. Am I right to think that both Falkirk FC and the SPL will give evidence at tonight's hearing?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

Yes, that is my understanding. Motherwell Football Club will apparently be represented as well, although I am not sure why.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I can understand that; if the decision goes Falkirk's way, Motherwell will be relegated. Do you anticipate that the hearing tonight will bring answers to the 10 questions that you listed? Will the outcome be made public in relation to the basis on which a decision was made?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

I do not expect that we will get those answers. The hearing tonight will consider whether the case that Falkirk FC put forward satisfied the criteria set out by the SPL. If we are deemed to have met the criteria, my understanding is that we will be promoted. If we are deemed not to have met the criteria, we will not be promoted. I very much doubt that the member clubs of the SPL will say that they decided not to vote for a particular reason. I also doubt that the SPL will tell us officially what the vote was.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have two other questions that concern the ground in Airdrie, which Jackie Baillie touched on to an extent. The question of 31 March is important, because the rules state that the conditions must be satisfied by then. Presumably one of the reasons for that is that the outcome of the league championship is not known so the date cannot necessarily be seen to serve one of the clubs' interests. Were the guarantees that you received put in place by the 31 March?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

Yes.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I understand that the ground in Airdrie is still owned by North Lanarkshire Council.

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

There is an arrangement between North Lanarkshire Council and KPMG, the liquidator. Dudley Group is the preferred bidder to operate the stadium.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Has North Lanarkshire Council given a written assurance that it will allow Falkirk to have the necessary primacy of use?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

We received letters from North Lanarkshire Council while it was no longer a political body, because of the elections. We received letters from the officers of the council saying that if for any reason the agreement entered into for the Dudley Group falls though, the council will ensure that any subsequent bidder has to honour the terms of the contract between the Dudley Group and Falkirk FC.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

The point is that the guarantees from North Lanarkshire Council were in place before 31 March.

Carolyn Leckie SSP Central Scotland
link

Mr Bird made reference to public money. Even if we do not have a legal locus in relation to the actions of the SFA and the SPL—although I think that we should have—the fact that public money is involved means that we have some moral authority. Does Mr Bird know how much public money has been received by the SPL, the SFA and the individual clubs?

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

No.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

Recently, sportscotland gave Rangers Football Club £0.5 million for the building of Murray park as a training facility.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I think that we are straying into areas where we should not go. As I said at the outset, we need to be clear about what the Public Petitions Committee should consider in relation to this matter. The petition concerns an organisation that affects a large number of people making decisions in a non-transparent manner. I do not think that the value of money that flows between one organisation and another has any bearing on that.

Carolyn Leckie SSP Central Scotland
link

I think that it is relevant in relation to what political pressure can be brought to bear and how the committee might exert such pressure. Would it not be feasible to ask the Executive how much public funding it has committed to the football bodies and whether it thinks that it should take into account their current actions when considering future funding?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

The issue before us is what we do today. There is no time for us to engage in correspondence with the Executive, given what has been said about the appeal.

Carolyn Leckie SSP Central Scotland
link

We could correspond with the Executive at a later stage. There is a strong moral argument in that regard.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I am conscious of time and—although I should let Carolyn Leckie's question stand because we have had an answer to it—I am trying to keep us focused on the situation that affects Falkirk Football Club today, bearing in mind that an appeal will be heard this evening and that we have no influence on that process.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

The points that Carolyn Leckie raised about public funding might be extremely relevant, especially if the committee decides to suggest that the Enterprise and Culture Committee should conduct a longer-term inquiry into the matter. However, immediate action is of the essence, given that the appeal will be heard tonight. If the Public Petitions Committee is going to be helpful at all, it should make a decision at this point to communicate with the SFA.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That was the point that I was trying to make. I appreciate your assistance, Dennis.What do members of the committee think we can do about the situation? Dennis Canavan has made a suggestion that could form the basis of our discussion.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

We should write to the SFA as soon as possible, as the issue is important for the economy and for the feelings of Falkirk's supporters. We should take on board what Dennis Canavan has said. I note the point about the public money that the bodies have received and I think that Carolyn Leckie is quite right to raise that issue, but we should not enter into that argument at the moment as time is of the essence.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

The terms of the letter that we write are crucial. We should note that we have no particular jurisdiction over the decision-making process but that, nonetheless, we would like the SFA to note the petition. We should let the SFA have a transcript of the discussion that the Public Petitions Committee of the Scottish Parliament has had and ask for our deliberations to be taken into account. I do not know how much more we can do.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That is the crux of the issue. The purpose of dealing with the petition today is to ensure that the issue has a hearing in the Scottish Parliament before the decision is made and to ensure that the people who will make the decision are aware of the strength of feeling of the people of Falkirk and beyond. We do not seek to influence the decision, as it should be made by the powers in Scottish football, but it is important that the organisations are made aware of the strength of feeling that has been expressed today in the Parliament. The committee should make them aware of that.

Stephen Bird Falkirk Supporters Society
link

It is also important to note that this is an issue not only for Falkirk. Having arisen this year, the situation could arise another year. Imagine that Ayr United Football Club were to find itself in the same situation next season as we were in this year and so entered into an agreement with St Mirren Football Club to secure access to an SPL-compliant stadium. Before submitting its papers to the SPL, the club might want to touch base with Falkirk Football Club to find out what went wrong with our bid to ensure that the same mistakes are not made, but we could not say what went wrong with our bid. It is important that the Public Petitions Committee points out to the SPL that it has a responsibility that does not end when the new season kicks off in August. Its duty, and the duty of the other football bodies, is to continue to look after the interests of Scottish football.

Dennis Canavan Ind Falkirk West
link

I do not think that it would be technically possible to send the SFA a transcript of this meeting before the decision is made as the appeal will be heard tonight. I suggest instead that, at the very least, the convener sends a letter summarising the views expressed at the meeting, appending a copy of the petition, which should be brought to the attention of the appeal body before a decision is taken. The letter should also ask for the outcome of the decision to be communicated to the convener along with a detailed statement of the reasons for that decision.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I have no problem with that, apart from the logistical problem of getting a 3,000 or 4,000-name petition to the SFA by tonight, although it would be useful if we highlighted the text of the petition to the SFA. We should also state that we are concerned about the impact of the football bodies' decision-making process on society. As Dennis Canavan suggested, we should ask the SFA to take cognisance of what has been said at today's meeting.Does the committee agree to follow that course of action?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 25 June 2003 (Morning) Petitions · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 4
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 92
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 53
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 84
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 52
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 19
  9. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 68
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  16. Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 6
  17. Convener's Report Procedure · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.