The final petitioner who will speak today is Mr Rob Kirkwood, who has submitted petition PE517, on water treatment plants. I would also like to deal with the Peterhead petition before the end of the meeting. We have to be out of here because another committee is meeting here at half past 1.Mr Kirkwood, I apologise for the rushed nature of today's business. We have a strict time limit. Would you like to make a brief introduction?
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Water Treatment Plants (PE517)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McAllion Lab 6
- Rob Kirkwood Leith Links Residents Association 3
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 2
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
12 contributionsYes. I shall try to be quick.The smell that is made by the water treatment plants in Edinburgh has been made internationally famous by Irvine Welsh, in his book "Filth". He describes it as the "Dame Judy" at Seafield. Down in Leith, we have more colourful ways of describing it, which I will not go into now. I will use Leith's experience to illustrate the wider issues of odour problems that are caused by water treatment plants.The problems of odour occur when key items of equipment fail at water treatment plants. On such occasions, there is a build up of raw sewage in the primary tanks. Because that raw sewage has nowhere to go, it is allowed to lie in the tanks for weeks or months on end and to grow septic and create odours. That problem could be prevented in the following ways. First, there could be early intervention when equipment goes wrong, to prevent the build-up of sludge in the tanks. That is not happening at Seafield. Since the introduction of the private finance initiative at that plant, there have been cutbacks in staffing, training and equipment. For that reason, the odours have grown steadily worse in spite of promises that the situation would improve.Secondly, the primary tanks should be conical in shape. When key items of equipment break down, sludge builds up in the tanks. If they are conical, the sludge continues to slide down the sides towards an exit pipe.At Seafield there are 40-year-old flat-base tanks that have long been rejected by the water treatment industry. Those tanks allow sludge to form a carpet on the base of the tanks. The carpets of sludge grow steadily thicker, become septic and float to the top. That is why Seafield is associated with a stench. Furthermore, the sludge can be removed only by draining the tanks and digging it out. When draining takes place, the community is exposed for months on end to the most obnoxious odours.If possible, the primary tanks should be positioned far away from community areas. At Seafield, the six primary tanks are less than 200m from the nearest houses, shops and a new McDonald's outlet. The community lives regularly in clouds of obnoxious odours.If tanks cannot be moved away from community areas they should be covered. At Seafield, the problem has existed for more than 40 years. It is unacceptable that members of the community have been regularly driven from their streets, gardens and, on occasion, from their homes. It is also unacceptable that we have had cases of children and adults vomiting in their own homes when forced to live in the clouds of hydrogen sulphide.There is a need for extra investment. Unfortunately, most of the investment—£1.8 billion—is already legally allocated to upgrading water treatment. Therefore there is a clear need for extra investment to be focused solely on the problem of odour. There are good reasons why the investment programme should begin in Edinburgh. There has been massive underinvestment in Seafield for more than 40 years, which is why it is one of the few water treatment plants that still operate using flat-base tanks. At a recent community meeting, Gerry Winterbourne, the general manager of Thames Water, conceded that the 40-year-old primary tanks are the prime reason why he is unable to control the odours at Seafield. The communities surrounding those tanks suffer more regularly from noxious odours than other communities. Most recently, the community was forced to live inside a cloud of hydrogen sulphide for the whole month of May.It is unacceptable that Edinburgh, one of the most prestigious cities in Europe, should be associated with that smell. The problem needs a prestigious solution. Edinburgh is one of the fastest-growing cities in Europe, which suggests that the problem of sewage odour could be equally fast growing.
Thank you. I am very sorry that we have only a short time to discuss the matter. Susan Deacon, who is off on maternity leave, has written to the committee. I will quote one section from her letter, which says:"While my primary and immediate concern is to rectify the problem which my constituents face, I am bound to say that the case highlights a number of issues of wider concern. It seems to me there are serious questions to be asked about where responsibility and accountability on such matter lie. Indeed, the very fact that it has proved so difficult for a community's concerns to be listened to and acted upon would seem to me to be proof positive of inadequacies on the current arrangements."We do not have time to ask many questions. Does anyone have a burning question on the petition?
I agree with the suggested action.
There is tremendous sympathy throughout the Public Petitions Committee for the petitioners. It is suggested that we agree to write to Scottish Water, asking it to detail the measures that are currently being used to tackle the problem of noxious odours and bacteria from Seafield and other similar sites in Scotland, and to indicate whether it has any plans to introduce the new conical primary tanks and other measures that are suggested by the petitioner. It is also suggested that we write to Edinburgh City Council asking for its comments on the petition and to the Scottish Executive asking why it thinks that environmental protection and planning enforcement legislation seem insufficient to resolve situations such as that at the Seafield plant. If members agree to that action, we will keep the petitioners informed of any responses that we receive and thereafter take a formal decision to refer the petition onwards.
Mr Kirkwood referred to the PFI. I do not know what the PFI contract covers. It might be operations and maintenance. Ultimately, Scottish Water is responsible. Could we also ask for comments on the conditions of the contract?
We should ask those questions addition to Susan Deacon's questions.
Yes. We will ask for comments on the contract and we will ensure that Susan Deacon's questions are asked.
I had a meeting recently with Dr Hargreaves, the chief executive of Scottish Water. His view was that he has a duty to keep water rates as low as possible. He is unwilling at this point in time to concede that conical tanks are required and that covering of the tanks is required. He maintains, as the company has for three years, that he can solve the odour problem with the old tanks. I am sure that the committee will get the same response. I ask the committee to disregard it and to point out to him that for three years those promises have been made, but they have not been met.
Certainly. I suggest that we write to Scottish Water and make it clear that the view of the committee is that Scottish Water should actively consider conical tanks.
Could I also add that they should be covered? It is not enough just to have conical tanks.
They should be covered conical tanks.I am sorry about the rushed nature of the business. We are trying to get on to the Peterhead petition, before we are thrown out of the committee room.Do I have members' agreement that all the other petitions be held over until our next meeting, and that we move now to the Peterhead petition? It is urgent that we move forward on that today.Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Jun 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 18 June 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 114
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 21
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.