The first new petition is PE508 from Mr Philip Graves on behalf of Strathblane community council. Mr Graves wishes to make a brief presentation, but I did not see him coming in. Is he here?
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Planning Process (PE508)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McAllion Lab 8
- Philip Graves Strathblane Community Council 8
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind 2
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 1
The record
21 contributionsI am here.
You are welcome. You have three minutes in which to make a presentation, following which I will open up the meeting to questions from members.
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to question the implementation of the Environmental Impact Assessment (Scotland) Regulations 1999. I intend to deal only with the main points in the petition. I will speak about how the EIA regulations are supposed to work, and how that process has failed in practice, and then I will offer a few tentative solutions. I make no apologies for using the West of Scotland Water application for a water treatment plant in Milngavie as my example, because I know the application well. The project is of a national scale—it will cost about £100 million—and has spawned a raft of independent reports and much criticism that the environmental issues have had to play second fiddle to engineering issues and cost. The EIA regulations and planning advice note 58, which supports them, clearly state that environmental issues should be considered at the earliest stage of any project and should influence the alternatives that are considered. Local people and other interest groups should be brought into the discussions as soon as possible—certainly as soon as the scoping exercise is established. That crucial stage is when the terms of reference and the identification of significant issues for the EIA are agreed. I believe that WSW has failed in many respects. The application has been bogged down in East Dunbartonshire Council planning department all year, with much to-ing and fro-ing between the two organisations. That suggests to me that the scoping exercise was not tight enough and that East Dunbartonshire Council, at great expense of time and money, has had to commission three or more independent reports to fill in all the gaps. Local consultation has been poor. The first that Strathblane community council knew about the application was in August last year, when it appeared in the local papers. We believe that, by that time, WSW had already completed the selection process and had decided on its chosen site. Since then, many local concerns have emerged, including concerns about traffic and the loss of recreational amenities around the reservoir. Those concerns have forced WSW rather belatedly to complete a traffic impact survey, in February of this year, and a leisure use survey, which was completed in August of last year. With that in mind, we suggest that a full review of the EIA regulations is required. To be specific, we feel that the local planning authority should set the final terms of reference in the scoping exercise. A statutory requirement to consult local communities should be introduced, akin to the consultation code that has just been introduced in the Water Industry (Scotland) Act 2002. We should consider introducing an independent EIA-qualified consultant, or consultancy group, to head up EIAs. They would be appointed by the local authority but paid by the developer. Finally, we should consider appointing a commissioner to scrutinise the entire process followed in each application. That might avoid the inconsistencies and lack of transparency that all the independent reports claim bedevil West of Scotland Water's environmental statement.I finish by quoting from the independent report of Scottish Natural Heritage, which has produced an excellent report on the process:"We do not consider the site selection process and the landscape assessment under taken as part of the EA process adequately demonstrates the best practical environmental option has been selected."
I now open the meeting to questions from committee members.
I was interested in Philip Graves's point about the independence of the local authority when it appoints the environmental impact assessors. Will he explain the rationale behind giving developers the responsibility for appointing the environmental impact assessment consultants? I share his concern about the lack of independence. We all know that when we appoint a consultant, we usually appoint the one that we know will give us the answer that we want.
I cannot answer that. Common sense suggests that you are right. Why should the developer be allowed to appoint the consultant? As we all know, the person who pays the piper calls the tune. It is difficult to answer the question. It is a question I am asking the committee.
You refer to European directives. Have you considered taking your case to Europe? Winnie Ewing will be the expert, but it is my understanding that the environmental impact assessment regulations date well back, to the 1980s, and were improved and updated in the late 1990s. I also understand that certain countries are interpreting the directives too widely. Next month, I have to take to Europe a case that brings in environmental impact assessment. Have you considered going to the European Parliament's Committee on Petitions as well as to the Rural Development Committee?
I have certainly considered it. It would mean a big sacrifice of my time and effort. I have a 9-to-5 job and I am not a legal mind. I would be happy to assist anyone else that has the resources to do that. Scotland has accepted the regulations and the quality standards were encompassed in the Water Supply (Water Quality) (Scotland) Regulations 1990. However, anyone who has been to Loch Katrine, for example, where the water for the treatment project comes from, will see that the water is as clean as it gets. I would not hesitate to drink straight from the loch, yet here we are about to spend £100 million in a bid to make it even cleaner. That strikes me as absurd.
Has a scientific assessment been done?
Within the environmental statement, there is very little about why the water needs to be cleaned, how dirty it is and how thorough the filtration process that has been chosen is. The Arup Scotland report, commissioned by East Dunbartonshire Council, questions whether the plant will work—whether it is 100 per cent certain that it will rid the water supply of cryptosporidium. I wonder how they can go ahead with the project when there is no scientific evidence that the plant will work.
I was listening to what Dorothy-Grace had to say about Europe. Taking the case to the European Committee on Petitions, on which I used to serve, is a possibility. It would only mean a day trip to Brussels and you do not have to have legal representation, so it might not be that expensive. However, we should follow the suggested action first.
You referred to the consultation code in the Water Industry (Scotland) Act 2002. Has the code not been published yet?
It has not been published, but there is plenty information available about what it will and should include. Des McNulty, one of our local MSPs, has done a lot of work on ensuring that plenty local consultation is included in the code.
Do you believe that the project would have gone ahead if the consultation code had been in place?
There would have been far more discussion early on and some of the issues would have come to the fore much earlier, which would have saved a lot of time. I like to think that the proposal would not have gone through; in any case, it would not have become bogged down for months in the planning department.
Were members of the public consulted before the decision on the preferred site was reached?
That issue is somewhat controversial. One or two suggested areas for the site, one of which is called Baldernock, had been consulted well before Strathblane community council was consulted. I represent a little village outside Strathblane called Mugdock, which overlooks the reservoir. Although two or three of the residents will be most affected by the development, none of them was consulted. Indeed, we were not officially informed before we saw the application in the local paper. Baldernock community council was consulted perhaps a year before.
Thanks very much. You are free to listen to the discussion about what should happen to your petition.I should stress that we cannot become involved in the individual planning decisions that prompted the petition. However, it is suggested that we agree to write to the Executive, to seek its comments on the general issues that the petition raises and, in particular, to ask whether it has any plans to review the Environmental Impact Assessment (Scotland) Regulations 1999 and the guidelines, along the terms that the petitioner has suggested. Moreover, it is suggested that we seek clarification about which body is ultimately responsible for overseeing the scrutiny of the environmental impact assessment process in circumstances in which Scottish ministers can become involved. We might also want to write to Scottish Water, seeking its comments on the petition, with a specific request for details and an update on its new consultation code.
I support the suggested action. I underline the importance of Mr Graves's proposal that independent consultants should be appointed to carry out EIAs, even though they might be paid to do so by the developers. The Parliament should take forward that issue. I hope that the Executive will respond positively to it, because it is vital to so many developments in Scotland.
We will certainly make that clear when we write to the Executive. Do members agree the suggested action?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Jun 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 18 June 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 114
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 21
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- New Petitions Petitions · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.