PE446, on behalf of the Consumers Association, is about extending food licensing to all food premises. We welcome Julia Clarke, from the Consumers Association, to address the committee in support of the petition. She is accompanied by Mr Crawford Morgan, the head of protective services at North Lanarkshire Council. Ms Clarke, you have the usual three minutes to make an initial address, after which committee members will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Food Premises (Licensing) (PE446)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Crawford Morgan North Lanarkshire Council 16
- John McAllion Lab 9
- Julia Clarke Consumers Association 7
- Phil Gallie Con 7
- Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP 6
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 4
- Rhoda Grant Lab 3
The record
52 contributionsThank you. I am here to ask the committee for its support for the introduction of food licensing. Many types of business are licensed nowadays, from window cleaners to scrap metal merchants. Amazingly, with the exception of butchers' shops, food premises are not licensed, although most members of the public think that they are and believe that they should be. A recent Consumers Association survey found that two thirds of consumers believe that all food premises should be licensed.Currently, food premises are not usually inspected before they open. There is a danger that we will not know that there is a problem until it is too late and public health has been endangered. There is a registration scheme, which we think is completely ineffective. Registration does not require compliance with food safety legislation, it is always out of date, there is no power to refuse registration and there is not enough protection for consumers. That completely undermines public confidence in food production.Licensing is important because Scotland has high levels of food poisoning. There are twice as many E coli cases in Scotland as in the rest of the UK. Nobody knows the real extent of food poisoning because so much goes unreported but, in 2000, 96,000 cases were officially reported. That is just the tip of the iceberg. The Food Standards Agency estimates that, in England alone, there may be as many as 4.5 million cases of food poisoning every year.Butchers' shops in Scotland were licensed in October 2000, following an outbreak of E coli 0157 in 1996, which claimed 21 lives in Lanarkshire. As far as I know, that is still the world's worst outbreak of food poisoning. At the time, Professor Pennington of the Scottish food advisory committee said that other food premises, such as carry-out premises, bakers' and other catering establishments such as delicatessens, could pose equally high risks to the public. There is evidence from the University of Birmingham to suggest that the licensing of butchers' shops has been a great success and has resulted in a marked increase in food hygiene standards. The Consumers Association believes that the system should be extended and rolled out across all food premises.Many major food manufacturers and retailers agree with us that they should be licensed. For example, companies such as Safeway and the National Federation of Meat and Food Traders agree. The Chartered Institute of Environmental Health, the Scottish Food Co-ordinating Committee, the Local Authorities Co-ordinating Body on Food and Trading Standards and councils such as North Lanarkshire Council—which is represented here by my good friend, Crawford Morgan—and East Renfrewshire Council support the change.Food safety is a devolved matter, and the Food Standards Agency Scotland is investigating the issue, as are a variety of other agencies and interested organisations, including the Royal Environmental Health Institute of Scotland. The Food Standards Agency Scotland will report in the next three or four months, and we feel that this is the right time to consider the issue of food licensing. We appreciate your time and consideration.
Thanks. Members of the committee will now ask questions.
Is it not true that legislation requires food premises to reach certain standards? Would licensing run side by side with that or would it simply add another layer of bureaucracy?
It is commonly accepted that the registration scheme merely involves the owner of the premises telling the local authority what their plan is. As far as I am aware, there is no prior inspection and staff do not need to be properly trained in hygiene. The public believe that they have a right to be protected in matters of food safety, but none of the things that would deliver that are in place. When we go into a premises, we do not know what the kitchens are like or whether the staff are trained. Until we hit a problem, we have no way of knowing what is going on behind the scenes. Sadly, as we have seen, that can be too late.
Are not regular inspections of food premises carried out?
Yes, they are, but we think that that should happen before the premises opens. We should ensure in advance that the staff are properly trained. We should not leave it to chance.
Could that be done as part of the planning procedure when someone asks for a change of use or permission to set up a food-related business? Should the council be able to say that one of the conditions attached to the planning consent is that there should always be trained staff?
I am not entirely sure, but perhaps Crawford Morgan might be.
As has been said, there is a registration scheme, but there are several problems with it. It is simply a paper exercise for local authorities. Speaking from practical experience, I can say that the scheme does not require compliance with food safety legislation and that, by its nature, it is always out of date, since people often do not register—local authority environmental health officers have to put forms in people's hands, which defeats the purpose of having the registration scheme in the first place. The registration scheme is confusing for the public, who assume that there is already a licensing scheme and that certain standards have to be complied with before registration can be granted. In fact, local authorities have no power to refuse registration.The scheme provides inadequate protection for consumers and does not deserve public confidence. No procurator fiscal would look favourably on a request from a local authority that someone be prosecuted for failing to register, since that is unlikely to be regarded as being in the public interest. There are practical difficulties with the registration scheme. On the other hand, the licensing scheme would help to improve public confidence since the scheme that most members of the public already think is in place would be put in place. It would also help to reduce food-borne illness. As the committee has heard, tens of thousands of cases of food-borne illness are recorded in Scotland but there are probably hundreds of thousands each year. If that number were reduced, as it could be under the licensing scheme, there would be considerable social and economic benefits.It would be a major safeguard if local authorities could insist on compliance with food safety regulations before a business started operating. The scheme would ensure that, before a business opened, it had in place a programme of food safety training, which is fundamental to efforts to reduce the number of cases of food-borne illness, and had identified critical points for food safety. As a spin-off, the scheme could help to provide revenue to cover the administrative costs.Professor Pennington said, in his report on the central Scotland E coli outbreak, that the risks are the same wherever raw meat is handled in the same place as ready-to-eat foods, but his remit did not allow him to recommend the extension of food licensing beyond butchers' premises. That is what we are asking the committee to consider today.
How onerous do butchers find the requirement to pay for the licence? I have just come from the isle of Whalsay in Shetland, where I ate in a brand new eating establishment called Oot Ower. The food was delicious and the premises seemed as clean as a whistle.Is registration ever refused? Do many people fail to register? If they register, do they put up a certificate that the public can read? What would it cost a small enterprise such as Oot Ower to register? I take it that you believe that the licensing scheme should be extended to restaurants and cafes where food is prepared, but would counters in supermarkets that sell cut meat have to be licensed as butchers? If there is to be training, who would pay for it? Where would people be trained?
The cost of licensing will be subject to an in-depth study by the Food Standards Agency Scotland. As recently as a few weeks ago, it issued a contract to Verner Wheelock Associates to carry out a study that is due to report around June this year. Among other things, the study will examine the perceptions of the local authorities, the butchers and the public of the licensing scheme and will deal with the implementation costs.The University of Wales conducted a study into the resource implications of implementing the hazard analysis and critical control point system—HACCP—which is a fundamental part of the butchers licensing scheme. The average cost arising from the implementation of HACCP was estimated to be £890 per business. Obviously, there was a wide range of costs, but for 75 per cent of businesses those costs represented less than 25 per cent of one week's turnover. That cost compares well with the cost of picking up the tab after things go wrong.I confess that this is an extreme example, but the costs of the 1994 milk-borne outbreak of E coli 157 in West Lothian were estimated to be around £12 million over 30 years, which is an average of £168,000 per case. After that outbreak, the conclusion was that every effort should be made to contain and prevent the disease. I have spoken about only the economic costs, but there are the social costs of having people on dialysis for the rest of their lives and having to give their kidneys to their children to help them overcome the effects of this crippling disease. That is why we need extra food safety controls.People are legally required to register, but many people fail to register and local authorities have to chase them up. However, the registration certificate is not worth the paper that it is written on. The register is an administrative burden that we would be glad to see the back of. People are not required to display a registration certificate, but I think that they should be required to display the licences, if a licensing scheme were introduced.Local authorities have taken different approaches to training, which is to be covered by the Verner Wheelock Associates' study. Most local authorities have contributed towards the training, often in collaboration with local colleges. In some cases, the training costs were shared between the local authorities and the companies.On the issue of counters in supermarkets, any business other than a catering premises that sells raw meat in association with ready-to-eat food needs a butchers licence. In the middle of 2001, there were 1,334 licensed butcher premises in Scotland. The most recent figures from the Food Standards Agency Scotland, which are for 2000, suggest that, if the scheme were extended to all the relevant premises in Scotland, it would cover 54,121 premises, of which 32,710 would be in the food and catering sector.
You referred to the fact that much money can be saved by eliminating risk. If the licensing scheme were brought in, would you guarantee that that risk would be eliminated totally and that all the costs to which you referred would be saved?
I think that the member knows the answer to that question. Obviously, the answer is no. There are no guarantees—we are talking about risk reduction. There is no guarantee and no one could give you such a guarantee.
The cost equations that you made are therefore not accurate.
No—the matter is all about risk analysis. There could be an analysis of the likely savings, but that is all it would be. As with anything else in life, we must try to evaluate what the costs would be of implementing the scheme and balance that against the lives that are saved, and we must try to evaluate the savings in costs because people did not require to attend for treatment.
Do you accept that for many small catering businesses—many of which are not VAT registered—£870 from their turnover would be a major sum?
It would be a significant sum for some businesses. Again, the matter comes down to making evaluations or judgments about the costs of implementing the scheme, and the costs for business versus the health benefits that could result from implementing the scheme.
What powers currently exist? My impression is that many small businesses have a great respect for environmental health and would certainly not turn their backs on advice. As far as we are aware, environmental health officers have free access to such businesses. Is that correct?
Environmental health officers have powers to access all food premises throughout the United Kingdom. One of the major advantages of a licensing scheme is that new businesses would need to produce plans for training and HACCP plans. Those plans would need to be agreed and implemented prior to businesses' being set up. Control would therefore be tighter.We should consider a scheme that is like the butchers licensing scheme. That scheme might not be the exact model that we should use, but it could be considered and adapted. That scheme has suspension powers that would not be available if there was no licensing scheme
Finally, you referred to new buildings as being of particular interest. If someone was to set up a food catering facility, they would almost certainly have to apply for change of use, go through the planning process and bring in building controls. Do current building controls or change-of-use conditions involve environmental health advice?
They do, but that only helps to get the structure correct. The difficulty is that most of the problems that we see daily are not caused by the structure of premises, but by the method of operation of the premises; they are caused because management or the people who work in the premises do not carry out basic food hygiene controls.
You said that it is difficult for new operations to establish and evaluate their longer-term operational regimes. I do not know whether licensing the operation right at the beginning of the process would solve the problem that you are trying to address.
In my view, it would. That is a fundamental issue. Let us take butchers licensing regulations as an example. Three things need to happen before butchers can be licensed: they need to comply with the existing general food hygiene and temperature control regulations; they need to comply with management and staff training requirements; and they need to comply with HACCP plans. The local authority must see and approve those plans and would have to be satisfied that the staff were trained adequately in food hygiene before the business could start. The introduction of that to all food premises would be a fundamental change and a big benefit, which is one of the main reasons why I believe that licensing should come on stream.
I thank Julia Clarke and Crawford Morgan. I point out to the committee and to the public that both Julia Clarke and Crawford Morgan have long-held and distinguished reputations in consumers' rights. They are absolutely genuine and are not from the extreme wing of the hygiene police, who we sometimes get a bit tired of. That is why they are trying to home in on some reasonable and sensible proposals.However, I wonder whether the evidence about environmental health should be clarified. Should environmental health officers come in at the fire-fighting stage when somebody rings them up and says "There are cockroaches in this kitchen"?
Unfortunately, that is the situation at the moment. We might not know the situation in a particular kitchen until it is too late. As we saw in Lanarkshire, we cannot afford to wait until that point. For most of us, food poisoning might merely be having a gyppy tummy for a couple of days—we all get that from time to time. However, it is sometimes a matter of life and death for the elderly, the very young and for other vulnerable people. People deserve a basic right to environmental health and the only onus that we would put on businesses is that they observe proper methods of hygiene and training.
Is training the most important element? Should shops such as small corner shops or small restaurants be the businesses that most fear having to alter their premises, which might be very expensive and could put them out of business? Would it be better to concentrate on training staff? Once that is right, even if the premises are awkward or old, they will be clean premises that employ good practice. Would it cost less than £870 to train staff, rather than change the layout of premises?
The process is a parcel, but training is extremely important. In many cases, it might come down to common sense. As I know from Crawford Morgan and his colleagues, they work hard to help business owners to meet standards.
Although the structure is less important than management and hygiene, there are basic elements within premises' structures that need to be considered, particularly in relation to avoiding cross-contamination. Provided that the basics are correct, I accept the point about training.
I am thinking back to the time when the European Union ordered bakers to install chill counters, despite the fact that bakers in Scotland had not poisoned anyone for decades. Bakers were innocent, but had to install £30,000 chill counters. That put some small bakeries out of business. I return to the question whether, overall, we should be going for training. Could that cost of £870 be reduced?
The biggest single aspect of the matter is that managers of businesses are required to provide an HACCP plan—to which I keep referring—in addition to training. The two go hand in hand. I would not like to put a figure on the costs, but I remind the committee that a study is under way that will report by June. If the committee was minded to proceed with the matter, it might be worth its while to consider the outcome of the Food Standards Agency Scotland's study. That study will give the committee valuable information about what the public, butchers and local authorities think about licensing of butchers.There is also debate going on within the profession through the Royal Environmental Health Institute of Scotland and the Food Standards Agency about the merits of the scheme and how it might work in practice. I do not advocate use of the butchers licensing scheme as it stands, because annual licensing might be overly onerous. Costs might be reduced if the scheme were extended to a three-year licensing scheme. My preference is a prior-approval scheme.However, the mechanics of the scheme can be worked out. We are asking the committee to consider the principle of the extension of licensing to other food premises.
The major idea behind that appears to be that although the public believe that they are protected by regulations in food shops and restaurants, they are not—except in a fire-fighting sense.
Exactly. When we buy a sandwich or eat out at the weekend, we believe that we are in a safe environment and that we are properly protected. The bottom line is that we are not protected. That is not good enough.
I will clarify North Lanarkshire Council's position, because I do not agree entirely with that. We are looking for controls to supplement those that are already in place. Local authorities are obliged to inspect premises in accordance with the FSA Scotland's code of practice. The frequency of inspections is laid down in an appendix to that code of practice, but frequency of inspection can vary; it can be six, 12, 18, 24 and 36 months or five years, depending on the risk rating of the premises. As I said, local authority environmental health officers already inspect premises and some controls exist, but we are asking for those controls to be strengthened in order to reduce and minimise the risk of food-borne illness.
The angriest meeting that I ever attended—I have attended many angry meetings—was on travelling shops in the Western Isles. Are you suggesting that a travelling shop should have to pay £870? Those shops provide a social service; they allow old people to remain in their homes because they can run dozens of messages for them. However, travelling shops could not afford such fees.
Travelling shops that are also butchers' vans already require licences. They are premises that, under the regulations—
Not all of them are butchers.
The present cost of a license to an individual is £100. I would not like to put a figure on the cost of administering the scheme, but it is in excess of £100 per individual. If risk exists, we should seek to minimise it.However, I accept Dr Ewing's point. We could examine the mechanics of implementing our proposals, because it might be possible to establish a scale of fees—perhaps we could associate the level of fee with the type of premises. The mechanics are important, but we can work through them. We hope to establish the principle.
I will make a final attempt at quantifying the problem. How many cafes, restaurants, carry-out premises and fish-and-chip shops are there in North Lanarkshire and how many cases of food poisoning involving those premises were there last year?
I can give you a broad idea. In 2000, there were 2,500 such premises in North Lanarkshire, of which 63 were manufacturers, 56 were distributors, 880 were retailers and 1,462 were restaurants and caterers. Off the top of my head, the figure for reported cases of food-borne illness might be about 500 to 600 cases a year. However, the actual figure is likely to be well in excess of 500 to 600 cases, because the reported cases are the tip of the iceberg—I do not want to speculate about whether the ratio is 1:10 or 1:100. Research evidence is available and can be provided if the committee is interested in seeing it.
We know that North Lanarkshire Council and East Renfrewshire Council strongly support the petition. What is the position of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities?
When North Lanarkshire Council's planning and environment (environmental health) sub-committee met on 4 December, it agreed to write to COSLA, to the FSA Scotland, to the Minister for Health and Community Care, to Sir John Krebs—the chair of the FSA Scotland board—and to Sir John Arbuthnott, who is the chairman of the Scottish food advisory committee, to ask them to support the principle. We are awaiting responses from some of the people to whom we wrote, but I hope that COSLA will support it. On 31 May last year, I spoke on the subject of food licensing to my colleagues at the annual congress of the Royal Environmental Health Institute of Scotland. On a show of hands, all but one local authority agreed that the principle of licensing should be established.
Were the council representatives who attended the congress officers or councillors?
They were a mixture of officers and councillors. Next month, I will debate the subject again. The environmental health institute and the FSA Scotland hold an annual three-day event in Dunblane—this year, it will be held from 14 to 16 March. If members want to attend, we will be happy for them to get involved in the debate. I will argue the case for licensing and one of my colleagues will argue the case against licensing. Thereafter, there will be a discussion about the mechanics. Our colleagues in England and Wales have supported the principle for many years and the profession in Scotland is gearing up for licensing. We are now having a full debate in Scotland and I believe that most of my colleagues support the principle. Next month's debate will help to galvanise opinion. I would be surprised if my colleagues—and COSLA—did not support the principle.
I thank you for your interesting evidence. You may remain while we discuss what to do with your petition. The recommendation is that the committee write to the Scottish Executive to seek its views on the petition, and that we seek specifically comments on the practicalities and costs involved in the implementation of a licensing scheme of the sort that is proposed. It strikes me that we should write directly to the FSA Scotland. We would get a quicker response because, no doubt, the Executive would simply pass our letter on to the FSA Scotland and ask it to respond to us.
Could the letter mention the problems that are faced by remote and fragile communities? The potential costs could put travelling shops out of business and prevent them from performing what is in many cases a social service.
We will ask the FSA Scotland to address in particular the implications for remote and fragile communities of a licensing system.As members have no further comments, I confirm that we will write in those terms to the FSA Scotland. Once we have received a response, we will decide what to do with the petition.
Could you send a copy of the letter to the Scottish Executive, in case it wishes to comment?
Sure. I should also have said that we will pass—for information only at this stage—a copy of the petition to the Health and Community Care Committee.
The convener and members of the Health and Community Care Committee will be interested in the petition.
Do members agree with the suggested course of action?Members indicated agreement.
I thank the witnesses again for their evidence.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Feb 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 5 February 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 123
- New Petitions Petitions · 52
- New Petitions Petitions · 54
- New Petitions Petitions · 21
- New Petitions Petitions · 14
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 16
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 19
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 3
- Convener's Report Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.