Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Tolls (Trunk Roads) (PE445)

Tuesday 5 February 2002 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 123 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

123 contributions
John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The principal petitioner for the first petition, which relates to charge tolls on the Skye road bridge, is Stella Anderson. Another of the petitioners, Robbie the Pict, will put the petition to the committee. The usual rules apply. You will have three minutes to make an opening statement, after which committee members will ask questions. At two and a half minutes, I will indicate that you have 30 seconds left.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

The bridge to Skye is publicly owned. Contracts allow any official inquiry. Charging a toll without authority is a criminal offence. A toll order, along with the special road scheme to which it relates, must be laid before Parliament and must be accompanied by an assignation statement by the Secretary of State for Scotland. Those statutory requirements have not been fulfilled.The assignation statement must identify the empowered concessionaire and his shareholders. It summarises the deal that has been done by announcing the total public debt. It is required to be printed for sale and the public have a right to expect it to be true when tolling begins.The relevant pages of type are undated, unsigned, unpublished and were untrue three years before tolling began. Although the pages cannot be lawful without a date hereof, the courts recognise no flaws and the Blair-sponsored high heid yin is trying to block any appeals.If the statement is in order, the public are entitled to think that the debt total—£23.64 million—is also correct. Highland Council's director of roads announced a final total of £23.65 million. The 1997 National Audit Office report revealed that the public contributed £14.6 million to the total, leaving £9 million to pay.However, the tolls are subject to a secret discounting formula. The handing over of £100 at the tollbooth represents a credit of only £37.64. The Bank of America keeps more than £62 per £100. This year the bank lifted about £2.3 million in bank charges. The NAO estimates the cost of servicing such a structure to be about £128 million.The local and private toll order that was issued by James Innes of the national roads directorate evaded parliamentary scrutiny of the details of the multiple index-linking formula.The Scottish public must be able to look to the Scottish Parliament for protection from paying £100 million in excess profits, £22 million in VAT and £27 million in bribes to Caledonian MacBrayne to stop it running competition. That represents a total of £177 million for a £7 million span.The Skye private finance initiative was an experiment by the UK Treasury 10 years before 1999. The Secretary of State for Scotland has declared that all restitution would have to come from the Scottish budget. The Scottish Parliament must reject imperialistic disdain and recognise its duty to protect itself and the Scottish public from an excise of about £34 per head—£170 for every family of five—for people throughout Scotland, which is being levied by a United States Senate-named money launderer.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Thank you very much. That was very clear. Irene McGugan will speak to the petition.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

I will not speak to the petition in a formal sense; I will simply support it. As most members know, I have been involved in the legal challenges to the competence of the toll order and its accompanying paperwork. I have felt frustrated by some of the courts' decisions, particularly on the validity of the documents, which I am convinced are fatally flawed. I am keen for the Scottish Parliament to take a careful look at the operation of the Skye bridge tolls. It would be appropriate if we could persuade one or more of our committees to examine in particular the financial arrangements of the Skye bridge PFI.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I am aware that the petition relates to the tolls. I wonder whether the petitioners share my view that the whole bridge project was not in order, because, when the public inquiry was held initially, a contract with Miller had already been signed.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

That is correct.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I raised that issue many years ago and I still have the correspondence about it. The fact that a contract was awarded before a public inquiry had been held on whether there should be a bridge is not disputed. In legal terms, the bridge is invalid. Although I am a lawyer and therefore should not murmur judges, I find it extraordinary that judges should recognise an assignation that is unsigned and undated. A House of Lords appeal might have to be considered.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

We do not need to leave the country to try to obtain basic justice at the level of Scots common law. We are dealing with a document that is not in probative form. A probative document has four fundamental aspects. The assignation statement meets two of the necessary requirements. It is a document—something that can be written on—and it has a topic. However, a probative document must be signed and it must be dated. There is no sign of Ian Lang's name in the signature block of the relevant document—there is no signature at all. Although the document begins "As at the date hereof the following bodies are held to", there is no date. That is legally impossible. The document does not evidence anything; it is not probative at common law. Are we rewriting the rules? For example, the final printed words on voter registration forms—on the back of the reply envelope—are: "Have you dated and signed this document?" We are dealing with a new low in standards. Are we to stoop to that level? Is it not necessary to sign cheques or driving licences any more? That interpretation should not be imposed on the courts. The Executive claims that the assignation statement is still valid. In what sense is it valid?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Before Rhoda Grant and Dorothy-Grace Elder ask questions, I want to clarify something. We are told that the court of appeal found against your case—it said that the document was legal. I understand that the Statutory Instruments Reference Committee—a very obscure committee in the Houses of Parliament at Westminster—was convened and that it, too, found against your case, saying that the document was legal. How do you respond to that?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Let us clarify that. Two courts of appeal have supposedly considered the matter. The first ruling, which was by Lord Sutherland, makes no reference to the four appeal challenges. He has not exhausted the references. I have tried to take that matter to the nobile officium as a petition, simply to say, "You haven't answered my appeal points." The same has happened with regard to the attempt to interdict, which went to the civil court of appeal. Lord Johnston simply refused to address the question, on the basis that there was an ouster clause, which prohibits any consideration of the matter. That is all very well, but such clauses apply only to statutory instruments. Although the issue is about making a political statement, there is still a statutory requirement. On the basis of an imagined ouster clause, which would apply only were the toll order and the special road scheme in proper order in the first place, Lord Johnston refuses to discuss the assignation statement. The courts have run a mile from the matter. It is sad but, in effect, they have been political prostitutes and are turning a blind eye. The Statutory Instruments Reference Committee seemed to offer a hopeful avenue, but it has restricted its remit to classification, and that is it. It will not speak beyond that. I have sent it an appeal, pointing out that statute demands that the documents should be laid before Parliament. It responded that that was beyond its remit. That is a wee bit precious. No wonder the committee meets only once every 25 years; it is not up to speed, to be honest.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I was 15 years in the House of Commons and I had never heard of it until recently.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Exactly. It hardly meets every week, whereas we have been pursuing this matter every day for six years. We would not come to the Public Petitions Committee and make fools of ourselves. We have read the statute inside out, chapter and verse, and have checked it with the top academics in this country. There is no doubt—statute is quite clear—that the toll order must follow the path of the special road scheme. In Scotland, the special road scheme must have an alternative route and the paperwork must go before Parliament.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

That relates to the question that I was going to ask: why has the matter not been dealt with through the courts if it is so clear that there is a case to answer? Was the type of clause that you mentioned called an "ousting clause"?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

An ouster clause was cited.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

An ouster clause is a protective measure in statute. Its intention is to avoid revisiting a statutory instrument once that instrument has been made, which means that whether it has been properly made and laid before Parliament in the first place is a key question. The clause is designed to ensure that the instrument cannot be questioned and that its details cannot be challenged in any subsequent court proceedings. Judgments by Lord Cameron of Lochbroom question how democratically responsible an ouster clause is. If there is any indication of bad faith, that matter might want to be reconsidered. I think that what we are discussing amounts to £100 million of bad faith. The relevant documents were not made in the first place and do not deserve the protection of an ouster clause. That clause is therefore an artificial and wrongful device for not discussing the subject matter.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

So you are saying that that clause protects all statutory instruments from a legal challenge.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Yes—if they are made in the first place. As far as the courts are concerned, the real answer is probably the Lord Advocate. He sits in Cabinet and orchestrates prosecutions. This issue means a big red face for the Crown Office, which has adopted the Scottish Executive's paperwork and is attempting to prosecute the public on that basis. It has embarked on 496 public prosecutions, 124 of which have resulted in convictions. It seems that it would rather land the protesting public with criminal convictions for life than admit that its paperwork is not in order. The paperwork is not competent; it is a joke.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

Thank you very much for an excellent presentation and for the months of research that you must have put in.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

Indeed—years. The matter of the unsigned piece of paper is absolutely extraordinary. How could anyone prove the validity of an unsigned will or a marriage certificate? People are required not only to sign but to have witnesses to all important documents. Has the former Scottish Office minister concerned ever been asked why he did not sign the document? Was it Lord James Douglas-Hamilton?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Ian Lang was responsible for signing the assignation statement; Lord James Douglas-Hamilton should have signed the toll orders, but those documents were passed through as local and private non-prints, despite the fact that they were issued by the Secretary of State for Scotland. A local and private non-print is not required to be sent to Westminster for scrutiny. If the document had gone to Westminster and the local MP had been alerted to the fact that a Skye matter was involved, the MP would quickly have been able to assess the details of the toll orders against the assignation statement details and would have found that one said £23.64 million whereas the other gave a formula that equated to more than £128 million. If, on one project, two of the four documents contradict each other to that extent, there is a problem. The people of Skye should not be given criminal convictions on the basis of this shambles.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

It is a blind debt.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

I must repeat my question: has Lord James Douglas-Hamilton—now a member of this Parliament—ever been asked why on earth he or another minister did not sign documents of such importance?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Interestingly, the National Audit Office approached neither Lord James nor Ian Lang. There are no ministerial signatures anywhere in the Skye bridge documentation. Nowhere does any ministerial signature, or even name, appear.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

A deputy roads engineer, a man called James Innes, signs everything. He has been dealing—apparently directly—with the Bank of America. The contract was signed with the Bank of America; it was not even signed with Miller, which was the company that—

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

With the bank?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Interestingly, the civil contracts bear the seal of the secretary of state, as properly witnessed by David Nash, the chief solicitor for the Scottish Office. The deal with the Bank of America, where the money is involved, received proper treatment. However, in the case of the one statutory requirement, whereby the people need to be told what deal has been done on their behalf and who has been given state powers to appear on the A87 to demand money—powers that the police do not have—the relevant document is in the form of the papers that I have with me here. This is a John Bull mock-up. A better job could have been made with a John Bull outfit—

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Definitely.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

The Bank of America was shown enough respect for the seal of the Secretary of State for Scotland to be used, whereas documentation involving the people of Skye could go through without a proper signature.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

That is a tragic truth. US Senate-named money launderers were given full respect, whereas the people of Scotland were given no respect and are being criminally convicted for objecting.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Good morning, Robbie. I suppose that I should declare an interest, as I have been campaigning over many years to get the Skye bridge tolls abolished. That is the position from which I approach this issue. I accept your evidence on the assignation document. The issues around that have been well rehearsed and researched, despite the best efforts of the legal profession to discredit the argument. Was the contract for the bridge the first PFI contract of which we are aware?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Yes.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Are you aware of any other similar contracts for which the documentation has been properly signed?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

The only other project that has been set up under the same legislation—the New Roads and Street Works Act 1991—is the Birmingham northern relief road, commonly known as the Birmingham bypass. In contrast to what the Statutory Instruments Reference Committee said, the paperwork for that project was published. There is a procedural discrepancy within the United Kingdom, for a start. The Birmingham road is the only available comparator. The documents were published for the English; the Scots were not properly told, we might say.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Was the documentation for the Birmingham bypass accepted to be proper and correct, in considerable contrast to the documentation for the Skye bridge PFI?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Yes. I would want to ask further questions about the Birmingham bypass, although that is not a matter of concern to us. Perhaps we could get the Skye bridge matter out of the way first and then have a wee look at the situation in Birmingham. If they fly me down there and pay my expenses, I will sort it out.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

You are probably aware that there was a little local difficulty with the tolls on the Erskine bridge, which were suspended because the documentation was not properly signed at the time. Does that have any relevance to the Skye bridge case?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

The only relevance is that an illegal act was carried out to preserve the tolls on the Erskine bridge. What the Scottish Parliament did was wrong in law. The toll period had expired and an artificial extension was granted. History will revisit that Erskine bridge smother-up. The question was not that a civil servant failed to renew the toll period; the toll period had expired. An extension was permitted for up to 20 years. That was the end of it. Tolling was mysteriously and unlawfully resurrected in the Erskine bridge case. The one significant point about that case is that it demonstrates that a toll order must be ratified by Parliament. That was done to repair the situation; a parliamentary initiative was taken. The one point that we can draw from the Erskine bridge case is that, as toll orders regulate the use of a road, they must, by statutory definition, be approved by Parliament. That is in section 1(2), I think, of the Road Traffic Regulations Act 1984.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

If persistence were a measure of injustice, would you have won the case a long time ago?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

That is what must happen. The north British were called Picts because they negotiate the arrogance of imperialism. They know patience and determination and that the question is more the power of law than the law of power.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

That was slightly off the mark. I ask you to think back to 1997. What was the stance of each political party on the issue at the time?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

In 1997, the Tories were in denial. I put a file to the then Lord Advocate, Lord Hardie, with a tactful note that said, "Before you pronounce on this, it might be worth checking how vulnerable it is constitutionally." That was ignored completely. He continued to prosecute protesters, although he abandoned prosecutions against large numbers.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I am sorry: we are going slightly off the mark. What was the stance of the political parties immediately before the 1997 election? The Tories must stand up and say that we imposed the tolls, so we were arguing for them. What were the other political parties arguing for at the time? Can you remember?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

We are entering into the politics of politics, which is not really my speciality. However, I remember a Labour candidate in the neighbourhood saying that the tolls would be removed as soon as was practically possible. The Labour party denied that. The SNP and Liberal Democrats wanted the tolls removed. Those two parties agreed that the argument was particularly strong because of the state of the paperwork. They accepted that the paperwork was flawed. The Labour party never really acknowledged that. Its candidate reneged on the impression that he gave in Skye, I would say. He paid the price.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I asked that question because, since then, the issues have been addressed by the courts of law, which have not found in your favour. That is why I feel that the issue now becomes one of political will. Do you agree?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Had there been a finding by the court, I could agree, but the court has not found. That is dereliction of its responsibility and duty. Can we have a finding, please? Will Lord Sutherland, Lord Cullen or Lord Coulsfield please say something about the documents? If they do not, they will be credited with saying that an unsigned, undated document is now perfectly acceptable in Scotland. They have simply not dealt with the points of appeal; they have not exhausted the references.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I might have the wrong impression on that. My understanding is that those three law lords determined that, even although the ministers had not signed the documents, they had signalled their intent and the document was legal on that basis.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Indicating intent would not get someone off who had not signed their driving licence. They could not say, "Oh, I intended to sign it." The law deals with facts. The documents are not signed; they are not in probative form.You are repeating the spin that the Scottish Executive has tried to put on findings in courts of law. I do not think that Lord Sutherland would be comfortable with such words being put in his mouth or with having established a new standard of criminal proof in which a document can be unsigned, undated, unpublished and untrue. The document is fundamentally untrue. It names people and companies, such as Miller Construction, that had nothing to do with the consortium. The three shareholders who are named in the document had shares of £1 each. A £3 front company won the multimillion-pound Skye bridge contract. It is a scandal. We are dealing with a major scandal. I ask the committee to protect the Parliament and the Scottish people from having to pick up the financial fallout, because the compensation will be more than £100 million. This is not Scottish parliamentary business; it is a United Kingdom Treasury experiment. However, John Reid, when he was Secretary of State for Scotland, said that the compensation would have to come out of the Scottish budget. Helen Liddell says no different. We must reject that totally. The matter is a UK Treasury experiment and the Treasury must pay its dues for not putting it in proper order.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I accept that. I was not extending the Executive spin; I was asking you a question about it. I emphasise that point.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I certainly do not think that benefits claimants would be allowed to indicate their intention to sign on. They would be required actually to sign on.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

You mentioned the nobile officium of the Court of Session, which is meant to be a reserve power to correct injustices and is not often resorted to. Is there any hope in that?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

I have petitioned the court on the case using the device of nobile officium, which, as you say, is a last resort to correct a miscarriage of justice. I have been told by the Lord Justice General that the case is not sufficiently extraordinary to merit consideration under the nobile officium.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

I understood nobile officium to translate as "the noble office". If a problem has slipped through the net and an injustice remains, it provides an avenue to address the injustice. I combined the petition with a human rights objection to the nobile officium and was refused right of signature—I was not allowed to sign the petition. It was not allowed off the ground for consideration at all.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Will you explain that a bit further? What does it mean?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Right of signature simply means that I put my name and the date at the bottom of the petition. I have been refused that right.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

So your application was

not even considered.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

It was not. It was blocked by a technical hurdle. The petition is a challenge to the court's competency, but the court will not admit it. Where does the statutory right to refuse a person right of signature come from? The petition at nobile officium is a right at common law. If there has been a miscarriage of justice, the complainer has a right at common law. That is especially the case since the introduction of the Human Rights Act 1998, which gives the right to a fair hearing. We are not even being allowed to sign a petition. That is obstructionism. That is why I use the term "political prostitution" and I mean it.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I put on record a point about Phil Gallie's comments: I am disappointed that he has tried to change the issue into a party-political one, which it is not. The Labour party did not give a manifesto commitment to withdraw the tolls on the Skye bridge. If the Conservatives had delayed building the bridge until it could obtain objective 1 funding, we would not be discussing the matter today.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We can leave that for the debate afterwards.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I have one question on nobile officium that I must clarify in my mind. You mentioned the Human Rights Act 1998. Did you perhaps muddle your appeal to the nobile officium by bringing in the European convention on human rights? Did you give the court an excuse for a technical block?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

No. I was very clear about my presentation. As a preamble, I said that it was, incidentally, also a human rights consideration, as of 2 October 2000. I asked the court whether it was in any way compromised by section 37 of the Scotland Act 1998, which allows for the terms of the Act of Union 1707 to remain in force, but subject to the terms of the Scotland Act 1998. I said that the court did not need to be obliged by that, because its independence and integrity were guaranteed by article 19 of the Act of Union 1707. I pointed out that the Scotland Act 1998 was not called "the Scotland (Scotland) Act", and was therefore a UK statute and fair game. The court said that it was not affected by section 37 at all, that that was not part of the considerations and that there was no UK obligation. In general, the terms of the Human Rights Act 1998 have not really sunk in in the courts. I think that they do not understand that section 6 of that act obliges them to deliver a fair hearing. If one is not even allowed to sign a petition and put it into process, how on earth can one get a fair hearing for it? The test is an extraordinary miscarriage of justice. How extraordinary do you want it? With 124 innocent people convicted of a crime, 496 people on Skye put their head in the criminal noose to try and draw attention to the affair. It is a sordid affair, and it is about time that people started having an honest look at the situation and giving the matter a fair hearing, rather than just shutting the door. The situation will not be covered up; it is a scandal.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

You said that, today, £100 handed over in tolls represents a credit of only £37.64 towards reducing the debt.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

That is correct.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

If the contract on the bridge were to run to its ultimate conclusion, what would be the value of £100 at the end of that term?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

That is an excellent question and I thank you for asking it. You will be astonished to learn that it would be 7p. The bank charges are so viciously geometrically progressive that they would be regarded as loan-sharking in any other circle. In the final year of tolling, £1 handed over would be worth 7p, and £100 would be worth 70p.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

That is frightening. It is an alarming amount. Does that include VAT?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

The public are paying the VAT at the moment, although they do not realise it. The Government—as a public relations exercise, I suppose—has withheld application of VAT at point of sale, but the VAT will still have to be paid, because Europe wants its percentage. The VAT is being quietly paid for at Edinburgh, but it is still coming out of the public purse.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We have asked lots of questions and other petitioners are waiting, but I would like to be absolutely clear about something. Are you contending that the toll order and assignation document in respect of the charges went through in local non-print form in order to avoid parliamentary scrutiny?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

One begins to suspect that. After a while, one gets a picture of why on earth it was not done properly. It is interesting that all the paraphernalia took place, such as the six-week public notices for objection and the publication of notices in the Edinburgh Gazette. All the things that would normally happen with a statutory instrument that was going before Parliament did take place. The illusion was given that everything was in proper order, but the document itself is a John Bull job. It would be better applied to tarring a school playground in Portree. Private and personal local non-prints are usually in plastic bags tied to lamp posts. All the paraphernalia was gone through, but the orders and schemes themselves were not in proper form and were not laid before Parliament.When one sees a discrepancy in two of the documents relating to the same scheme, questions have to be asked. The Audit Committee might want to have a look at the matter, rather than being lumbered with the restitution and the cost of compensation. The justice committees might want to read the statute; other people are refusing to do that. We are not really protesting; we are just reading statute out loud. We did not know exactly what had to happen but, just as Genesis, chapter 1, is there for everyone to read, section 1(1) of the Statutory Instruments Act 1946 is there for everyone to read. "Exercisable by statutory instrument" means that an order is laid before Parliament and published as a general print. That is as clear as a bell, if one is not looking at the emperor's new clothes.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are you also contending that neither the court of appeal nor the Statutory Instruments Reference Committee at Westminster addressed that central problem?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

The Statutory Instruments Reference Committee stopped short at classification and would not step beyond that remit. I have now referred the matter to the Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments, which is considering whether it should be laid before Parliament. Consideration is still taking place at Westminster. The courts in Edinburgh have not addressed the subject and are refusing to permit petitions about a miscarriage of justice to be signed. That door looks closed. There are one or two avenues or devices that we will pursue, but things are definitely slowing down. We have to consider the Lord Advocate and a conflict of interests.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am advised that, if the petition is still subject to court proceedings, or is likely to be subject to court proceedings of any kind, it may be inadmissible.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Which petition?

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The one that we are considering today. Is it likely to be subject to court proceedings at any time in the future?

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

I do not see why it would be. Today's petition is a political petition.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Thank you for your evidence. That was fascinating.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

I am obliged. Thank you for your time.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Two courses of action are available. We could take the position that the courts and a parliamentary committee have dealt with the matter and agree that no further action is required, or we could take the view that serious questions, which need further inquiry, have been asked at this meeting.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

What is the committee's position on the right to murmur judges?

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

When one attacks a judge publicly, one is said to be murmuring a judge. I would very much like to murmur Lord Cullen, Lord Coldstream and Lord Sutherland for what seems to me to be improper decision making in this case. They appear to have ignored the law of the land and the law of probative documents and to have imputed the Secretary of State for Scotland's consent. I have never heard that the Secretary of State would dream of allowing his or her consent to be imputed. I wonder what the committee can do. Perhaps we should declare that we think that those three judges did not do their job properly.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The wisest move might be to ask the Executive and the Lord Advocate for their views before we reach a decision.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

If we did that, could we also ask why it appears that the nobile officium, which is supposed to exist for such situations, was simply tossed out?

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I would like to pick up on Winnie Ewing's point about murmuring the judges. Robbie the Pict made the point that perhaps words were being put into the mouths of those judges, so I would not want to go as far as Winnie suggests. However, I would like a specific answer to the point that has been made. We heard that there has not really been an answer and that nobody has concentrated on the validity of the documents that have been referred to. It would be fair for us to ask the Scottish Executive to investigate that question and give us a full and proper answer.I have seen the figures that were presented to us before, but I have never seen an answer from the Government about them. I tell Rhoda Grant that I recognise that this could well be a criticism of my own party, but I do not want to score political points. I would like an open and frank assessment of the figures. That would be in the public interest in the longer term. I would like the committee to ask for such an assessment and for a proper answer to the legal point that has been made.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

This is a classic example of the establishment dropping a cage over honest and highly intelligent protesters. It is obvious that multiple injustices are going on. It is like babushka dolls—one is opened up and another one is inside.We should write to the individual judges, not just to the Lord Advocate. No one should be able to hide behind their decisions. Judges are paid public servants and their decisions should be challenged. The issue of the noble office should be referred to one of the justice committees, as should the matter of unsigned documents. The Skye bridge is not just a financial scandal; the appalling way in which honest protesters have been treated hits at the basics of democracy in this country. They have been given brush-off after brush-off, right down the line. People on Skye and elsewhere have put many years of their lives into the campaign, and it has caused so much stress that they deserve direct answers from the judges and everyone else. We will show the judges respect only if they merit it.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am advised that a committee of the Parliament may approach only the Lord Advocate, who is accountable to us on behalf of the judges.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I am advised that clerks of the Parliament are not allowed to do that. They have to approach the judges through the Lord Advocate, who is answerable to the Parliament for the behaviour of the judges and the legal system. That is the proper procedure.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

The Lord Advocate is a political appointee, whereas, allegedly, the judges are not political appointees.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

The judges in the court of appeal must be challenged over their failure to find on the petitioners' basic complaint and over their blocking of the nobile officium to allow people the right to protest against their decision. In the first instance, the Lord Advocate should respond to those allegations.Somebody has to answer for the failure to treat the orders properly and to subject them to parliamentary scrutiny. Had the orders been subjected to parliamentary scrutiny, it is highly doubtful that the bridge and the package would have gone ahead in the form that they took. This morning, serious allegations have been made, which need to be investigated thoroughly. We must get the Executive's response and the Lord Advocate's response to this meeting before we can decide on further action. We must give the Executive and the Lord Advocate the chance to respond before we do anything else.

Dr Winnie Ewing SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I mentioned the original illegality when the contract to build the bridge was awarded and signed by Mr Lang before the public inquiry was finished.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That is on the record. We can ask the Executive and the Lord Advocate to respond to that and all the issues that the committee has raised.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Quite a lot of statutory instruments that come before the Parliament have a commencement date that is prior to their presentation to the Parliament. If that was the case with the Skye bridge order, it would have been difficult for the Westminster Parliament to do anything about it.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

As I understand it, the order never got to the Westminster Parliament in that form.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

It would still have had to go through the Parliament, just as it would here.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

Are we agreed to approach the Lord Advocate and the Executive and to reconsider the petition when we receive their responses?Members indicated agreement.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will have to wait for the responses before we decide what to do with the petition. We can send it to one of the justice committees for information at this stage.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We will wait for the responses and then decide which committees we should try to involve.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

It has been a long battle. At least the issue is on the parliamentary agenda, which it never was at Westminster.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

The Scottish Executive, the Lord Advocate and the Crown Office are in corporate denial over the matter. They will simply reiterate that there is no requirement in statute for the instruments to be placed before Parliament, which is a lie. Keith Main, who is a spin doctor, wrote to me recently:"I refer to your letters … to the Minister for Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning and the Solicitor General for Scotland about the tolling regime at the Skye Bridge. I have been asked to reply".A spin doctor is replying on behalf of the newly appointed Solicitor General. "Wait a minute," we should be saying, "you're the new broom. Will you please have a look at this?" The same old spin doctors are blocking everything. We just get porkies—they just tell lies.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

We are a committee of the Scottish Parliament. Unlike the chairman of Enron, the highest offices of this land have to answer to the Parliament in Scotland. We will make sure that they do.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

Good luck.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

I have a suggestion that might be helpful. I and, to some extent, John Farquhar Munro have asked an enormous number of parliamentary questions on this matter and have tried to tease out some of the issues that have been discussed today. It might be useful for the clerks to retrieve the answers to those questions. That would produce a body of evidence to show the responses that the Executive and the Lord Advocate have given on some of those issues.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

That would be useful. We can arrange for the questions and answers to be circulated to members so that they have them by the time that we get the responses from the Executive and the Lord Advocate.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

That is a good suggestion. I would appreciate that.

Robbie the Pict Scottish Peoples Mission
link

I am obliged to the committee for its time. Wendy Alexander needs to be told that there should be two lanes on the A9 between Perth and Inverness. I came down that road last night and it was torture.

John McAllion Lab The Convener · Dundee East
link

I sense a second petition coming on.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 5 February 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 6
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 123
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 52
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 54
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 21
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 14
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 16
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  13. Inadmissible Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Convener's Report Procedure · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.