Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Commonwealth Games 2014: Progress report on planning for the delivery of the XXth Games”

Wednesday 2 December 2009 Public Audit Committee Committee business 72 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

72 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Item 3 is on a further section 23 report. I invite Caroline Gardner to brief us.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

This progress report on planning for the 20th Commonwealth games was published on 19 November. It is the first in a series of reports that we plan to produce on preparations for the games, and it provides an early indication of progress up until August 2009. We prepared it on behalf of both the Auditor General and the Accounts Commission.The games are due to start in July 2014, which is just under five years from now. They are a major event for Scotland, and they will affect its international reputation and profile significantly. They bring particular planning challenges, which need to be managed: the deadline, which cannot be moved; the involvement of many different partners from across Scotland and further afield; and the vulnerability of the games to environmental conditions, including our unpredictable weather.Hosting the games involves significant amounts of public money, together with investment from the private sector. Since Glasgow won the right to host the games in 2007, there has been a major decline in the global economy, and funding is much tighter and harder to come by.The arrangements for delivering the games are complex, and I will run through the four strategic partners. First, the Scottish Government is responsible for introducing the legislation that is needed for the games, co-ordinating national security and delivering the legacy for Scotland as a whole. Secondly, Glasgow City Council is responsible for delivering most of the venues that are needed for the games. Thirdly, Commonwealth Games Scotland is responsible for preparing and selecting the Scottish team for the games. Finally, Glasgow 2014 Ltd, also known as the organising committee, is responsible for everything else that is needed to plan and deliver the games.The organising committee holds the games delivery budget. It was initially set at £373 million, and it was increased to £454 million on 16 November, following a detailed budget review. Our report refers to the initial budget, rather than the revised budget, which was agreed to after our report was finalised and went to print.The Scottish Government is contributing 80 per cent of the public funding—which is now estimated at £297 million—and Glasgow City Council is contributing 20 per cent, which is now £69 million. The organising committee expects to raise the balance, which is currently estimated at £88 million, from broadcasting rights, licensing, ticket sales and sponsorship. The Scottish Government is the primary guarantor for the games and has underwritten any potential shortfall in the budget.Over and above the £454 million budget for the games, further investment of about £1.9 billion is being made in a range of infrastructure developments, including new and existing venues and transport infrastructure improvements such as those to the M8. That does not include the cost to the private sector of constructing the athletes village, which is still to be agreed as part of the contract.There are five areas of findings in our report, which I would like to run through briefly before we answer any questions that members have.First, we found there to be a complex but very clear high-level governance structure, and the strategic partners that form it understand their responsibilities. That is set out on page 9 of our report, in exhibit 2. The structure is headed by a strategic group, which has representatives from each of the four partners and which is chaired by the First Minister. The group is responsible for monitoring the spending of the games delivery budget. As part of the governance structure, the strategic partners have set up a number of joint working groups, but their status, responsibilities and decision-making powers have not all been formalised, and the partners cannot yet demonstrate how they all fit together as part of the wider governance structure.Secondly, we found that the partners are learning from the experience of previous games in a number of ways for what is a big and complex project. That includes the use of specialist consultants who have been contracted by the Commonwealth Games Federation, as well as liaison with people who are doing similar work in the organising committee for the 2012 Olympic games in London and with staff who have been involved in other Commonwealth games. We know from experience elsewhere that there is a high risk of losing experienced staff in the run-up to the games, particularly people who are on fixed-term contracts, so it is important that the partners have contingency plans for managing that risk as we head towards 2014.The third area is programme management. The four partners are developing programme plans to manage their separate responsibilities for the games. They are at different stages, although they are all due to be finalised by March 2010. At that stage, the Scottish Government intends to consolidate the key milestones from the four separate plans into an overall programme plan and use that to monitor and report on progress. The overall plan will need to take account of interdependencies between the plans. For example, Glasgow City Council is responsible for constructing or refurbishing most of the venues, and that work needs to be completed in time for the organising committee to make any other changes that are needed specifically for the games to take place. The links between the plans need to be built into the overall plan.Fourthly, the organising committee is co-ordinating risk management overall and has involved the other partners in setting up an overall games risk register. The organising committee still has to refine the risk register and particularly to cost the actions that are agreed to manage each risk. The partners must ensure that they each have their own internal risk management systems, which are at different stages of development.The fifth and final area is costs. The Scottish Parliament approved the organising committee's initial budget of £373 million to deliver the games in January 2008. That budget was based on 2007 prices, and our report as published highlights the risks that the budget might be insufficient to deliver the current plans for the games. That was the top risk identified in the games risk register when we carried out our audit. Since then, the partners have increased the games budget by £81 million to £454 million, which is also at 2007 prices.I mentioned the additional £1.9 billion of mostly public money that is being spent on infrastructure projects, but there are indications that the initial cost estimates for some of those venues were too optimistic. That is summarised on page 26 of the report, in exhibit 6. Any further increases in the budget will be challenging for the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council, particularly in the current economic climate. It is crucial that the partners establish very tight control over the budget to minimise the risks of that happening in the next five years.As ever, we are happy to try to answer any questions that the committee might have.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

The project is of huge significance to Scotland, not just for 2014 but, we hope, beyond that—we all hope that there is a legacy, as has been discussed in the past few years.I have two questions on the budget. You spoke about your worries about the risk to the budget and said that an additional £81 million has been added. Is that amount sufficient to allay the fears or worries that you had?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

The increase of £81 million that was announced last month followed a detailed budget review that was carried out by the organising committee. Early in 2009, it reviewed at a high level the plans that had been put in place for the 2007 bid and then commissioned a detailed review that reported back in October. That review identified areas in which more detailed information led the organising committee to change the estimates.At this stage, the process looks robust, but it is not possible for us to say that there will not be further changes because, five years from the games, there are significant areas of uncertainty. You will have seen detailed media coverage on issues such as the value and cost of broadcasting rights. That process is not yet complete so we do not know what the cost might be. Similarly, the contract for the athletes village has not yet been let and we do not know what the public spending commitments on that might be.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I think that you said that the estimates for the infrastructure costs of some of the big building projects that are associated with the games were optimistic. Is that right?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

That is right. I referred to page 26 of the report, where we set out the changes that have been seen since the bid was put together in 2006 and agreed in 2007. There are both some cost changes and some changes to the timing of venues, which are important. There has been some slippage. None of the venues is yet behind schedule, but several are closer to the deadline of 2014 than they were when the bid was originally put together.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Do you think that the stated figures are optimistic?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

The estimates that are being worked on currently vary in certainty between projects. Some of the venues are now complete or close to completion, but others are much further from completion. The further from completion they are, the more uncertainty there is. That makes it hard to be certain about the quality of the estimates.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I echo what has been said about the importance of the project, which everyone wants to be a great success. At the same time, we are anxious to keep a tight lid on costs. The convener asked about the risks to the budget and mentioned the additional £81 million that was allocated just two weeks ago.I was struck by footnote 39 on page 23, which provides figures for the increase in operating costs of similar projects. It states:"Manchester Commonwealth Games 2002 increased by 120 per cent, Delhi Commonwealth Games 2010 latest forecast increase of 280 per cent … and London Olympics 2012 latest forecast increase of 300 per cent."Those figures are terrifying. Paragraph 64 of the report states:"there is a high risk that the budget may prove insufficient."I want to probe further in relation to the £81 million that the convener asked about. How would you categorise the level of the risk that further increases in the budget will be required? Is it high, medium or low?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

The context that I can provide will help you to draw a conclusion about that. The first important point to stress is that the Commonwealth Games Federation says that it put in place a much more rigorous bid process for the 2014 games than for any previous games, partly because of the concerns that you have outlined from footnote 39 of the report. It is in no one's interest for cities and countries to bid for games without a clear picture of the cost. The federation has tried hard to reduce uncertainty for the future, so the starting point should be better.The increase of £81 million in the budget reflects a two-stage review that was carried out during 2009 on behalf of the organising committee. The review tested the figures in the bid against the current economic circumstances and experience to date of letting contracts and so on. There is a good chance that it has identified the most significant areas in which there has been change since 2007.However, we know that the global economic climate has changed significantly since October 2008. It is still possible that that will affect cost and income, both upwards and downwards. For example, if in 2014 we are still facing reductions in visitor numbers on the scale that we have seen this year, that will have a significant impact. There is also uncertainty about the BBC's willingness to enter into long-term commitments in relation to the costs of broadcasting and broadcasting rights. I am not sure that much more can be done to pin down those elements of risk at this stage. We are satisfied that the processes in the budget review and reaching the figure of the additional £81 million were robust, but there are still five years to go. A great deal can happen in that period.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Although you did not say so explicitly in your answer, it sounds to me as if the level of risk is high. You may wish not to comment on that.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

I am not sure that it would be helpful for us to give you such an estimate. All that I will say is that, over a five-year period, there is a lot of risk that simply cannot be managed. We think that the risk that is being managed is being managed reasonably well, but there are big uncertainties that have not yet been pinned down. I have mentioned broadcasting costs and rights and the athletes village, both of which have the potential to have a significant impact on the overall costs of the games.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Has it been possible to quantify a worst-case scenario of what would happen if all the aspects that you mentioned were to come together at once?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

We have not done that at this stage. We plan to carry on monitoring the games and report back to you on at least one occasion before 2014 because we know that the risks will keep on changing. A better question to ask of the strategic partners might be about what planning they are doing for 2014 in that regard.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have just one more question. For interest, when do you intend to do your next report on spending?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

We have not set a date yet, but 2011 feels about right. We do not want to keep pulling up the plants to see whether the roots are growing, but a couple of years feels like long enough to see what the risks look like at that stage.

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow
link

You mentioned in your preamble that the loss of key staff in the organisation could prove problematic. I think that it is mentioned at least three times in the report that that is a possibility—on pages 6 and 8. It says on page 6 of the "Key Messages" document that strategic partners should"develop and continue to review plans for managing staff continuity and ensuring that knowledge is retained in the organisation following any changes in key staff."That does not appear to have been done across the board as yet, and strategic partners are not necessarily working in partnership on that.Paragraph 32 on page 12 of the report states that the programme management office of Glasgow City Council"has introduced measures to retain knowledge in the event of staff changing within the PMO. This includes overlapping the responsibilities and tasks of individuals so that all activities can be covered by someone else."Considering the potential risk for something to go wrong if key members of staff are lost, has there been any move among the strategic partners to ensure that they are taking advantage of best practice and cross-cutting management techniques that will ensure that the whole programme is not landed in a bit of a mess if one or two people leave for job opportunities elsewhere?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

We do not think that that is happening yet across the four strategic partners. Each of them is at a different stage of development. As you picked up from the report Glasgow City Council is doing particularly well in that regard; the other partners are developing their plans to do the same thing and ensure that knowledge is shared effectively and they are not reliant on just one person for critical functions.It is true to say more generally that the next step is for the plans and ways of working of all four partners to come together so that they work more effectively as a team. We expect the Government to pull together the overall plan for the games next March, and what you mention is one important element of that.

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow
link

Are the full-time staff for the Commonwealth games going to be the focal point for drawing all the work together or, as the programme emerges, will strategic partners still work on their own areas to the exclusion of drawing together? I think that the staff will number up to 300 or so people. Will they be the control room for everything that takes place?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

I will ask Carolyn Smith to offer a bit more detail on that, but it is worth noting that under the structures for governance the partners have clear separate responsibilities as well as shared ones. It is important to make it clear who is doing what.

Carolyn Smith Audit Scotland
link

The overall plan that is being pulled together will not contain every single detail of every one of the partners' responsibilities; it will focus more on the high level and be used for monitoring the partners' planning for the overall programme. Each of the partners will be responsible for their own more detailed plans, which should also link in with other partners at an operational level to make sure that they liaise on anything that crosses over.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I understand that the extra public sector spending, particularly the extra Scottish Government funding, is more than £50 million.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

It has gone up by £59 million.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

That information was not included in the announcement and we have not looked at it yet; it was announced on 16 November.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

When new cash is found by the Government in that way, when do you expect to be told where the funds are coming from?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

The Government does not and is not required to tell us about every change in its spending plans at the highest level. That comes through the Parliament's budget process. We would expect to look at the gains as part of our continuing monitoring, in particular as part of the next update on progress in a couple of years' time or so.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

The Government—rightly, in my view—has criticised the United Kingdom Government for pulling the additional funds that have been made available to the London Olympics in 2012 from budgets that would have been invested in sport in Scotland and in other projects that affect children and young people in Scotland. I would be very concerned if the Scottish Government was pulling funding—at the current stage confidentially, without any public scrutiny taking place—from sport across other parts of Scotland to invest in the 2014 games.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

We have not looked at that at this stage.In line with Lord Foulkes's earlier comment, £59 million is not a huge shift in the Scottish Government's overall budget across the timescale that we are looking at. When we next examine the matter we will look at where the funding has come from, but at this stage we would not expect to have been consulted on what funding streams were being changed to identify the shift. You may want to follow up the issue with the Government, but we have not done that so far.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

However, it could be a huge shift in funding for sport in Scotland. For example, it is more than the total annual budget of sportscotland; it is a significant amount of money and we do not know where it will come from.Is it not a nonsense for the costs to be based on 2007 prices when the games will take place in 2014? Why do we keep doing that in public projects? We know that the 2007 costs will not be the real costs.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Broadly, there are two ways of managing costs for long-term projects. The first method is to start with a cost base at the original price base and inflate it up; the other is to start at where one expects to finish and bring it down again. The Government and the partners have chosen to stick with 2007 prices for now. One consequence of that is that we know that when we reach 2014 the cash price will be higher, simply because of inflation, if nothing else changes. Treasury guidance is generally that inflation should be built into the cost estimates, but that has not happened in relation to the project. That is one of the reasons why tight cost control becomes all the more important.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So, on this project, Treasury guidance has been ignored or set aside—or, to put it in perhaps a more neutral way, it has not been followed.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Treasury guidance has not been followed in relation to the treatment of inflation.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

On a more positive note, there are currently lower construction costs. I am told that, across the public and private sectors, bids are coming in about 10 to 15 per cent under estimate on major capital projects. Has that been factored in to the new costs for the Commonwealth games?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

It is one factor that has played into the detailed budget review. As I suggested in response to Mr Fraser's question, the effect is not straightforward. It is certainly true that there is evidence that some construction contracts are coming in lower than the original estimate, but in the current climate there is also a higher risk of contractors going into liquidation. Taking account of both the upside and the downside risk, I suggest that there is not a straightforward effect on the budget as a whole.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

It is one of the factors that we understand the organising committee's review has taken into account; it looked at the likely impact of that factor on the outturn costs come 2014. That has led to the budget increase of £81 million that has been announced. I think that it has also taken account of the downside risk associated with the current climate.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Despite the better bidding climate for the pricing of major capital projects, the cost has still gone up by £81 million.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

It is worth me making it clear that most of the venue costs are being met separately from the £454 million budget cost at the moment. Those projects were planned by Glasgow City Council and others in advance of the bid, so changes in that regard will not make a tremendous difference to the games bid.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Yes, because it is big and because the contract is not yet let.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

As usual, the Audit Scotland report is as helpful as it is wise. It contains quite a lot of positive comments about the project management and risk management processes that are being undertaken.I draw members' attention to exhibit 2 on page 4 of the main report, which highlights three facilities for which the completion date is only a few months before the games are due to begin. That might be sailing a bit close to the wind. I understand that constraints might apply to getting Hampden park ready for the games, but I am not sure why the other two facilities are sailing so close to the wind with regard to completion dates. I think that one of them might be the games village. Do you have any information to suggest that they might be begun a bit earlier to ensure that there is no slippage?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

That is a question about detail, which you might want to think about directing towards the organisers. Our understanding is that those facilities were always intended to be completed reasonably close to the start of the games. There is a detailed project plan for getting the entire infrastructure in place, because there are interdependencies and knock-on effects around it.Our concerns are about three of the smaller venues that have already slipped by some way. They are the Glasgow Green hockey complex, Cathkin Braes cycling course and the swimming centre in Glasgow. They have slipped since the bid was put together. At this stage, none of them is expected to slip beyond 2014, but clearly the room for manoeuvre is reducing.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

That is interesting. To be clear, three of the projects are due to complete in March 2014, which is only a matter of months before the beginning of the games. I can understand that there might be constraints on getting into Hampden to make changes, but I do not really follow the reasons why we might be sailing so close to the wind with the other two. However, Caroline Gardner is quite right: we can direct that question to the games management committee.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Carolyn Smith might be able to give you a bit more information.

Carolyn Smith Audit Scotland
link

It is to do with the activities that will take place in those venues. It would not make sense to have them prepared too early because operating costs would have to be picked up if the venues were to be ready at that earlier date. It would not be possible for them to be used for other things in the meantime and the operating costs would have to be picked up. There is a short window for the venues to be put in place; the report is saying that that risk needs to be managed and that contractors need to be available so that changes can be made to the venues in time. That will have to be monitored closely, because the venues are due to be ready so close to the time at which they will be needed.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I want to pick up on a couple of Nicol Stephen's points. Who do we challenge with regard to the 2007 figures that are to be updated? Who do we ask to update them properly?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

The four partners are jointly responsible for that. The Scottish Government is the biggest funder of public money, and the overall strategic group is chaired by the First Minister. The Scottish Government is the key player, but I imagine that it will want to involve its partners in Glasgow City Council as well.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

If we want those figures to be updated, which would seem to be sensible and in line with Treasury guidelines, we should take it up with the Scottish Government. Is that right?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

That would be the starting point, I think.

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Yes.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

My other point is about the extra cash going beyond the budget, and money being taken out of virement or contingencies or whatever. Does that not strengthen the case for what we discussed at our most recent meeting—having a report from you on outturn compared with budget, which we do not have for the Scottish Executive's expenditure? Where are you in your thinking on that? We threw that idea at you at our most recent meeting. Have you had time to think about it yet?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Yes, we are thinking about it at the moment. The timing is extremely good, because we are finishing the Scottish Government's audit for 2008-09. The team is looking at what we could do currently and how we might be able to develop that for 2009-10 and future years. We will come back to you on that in 2010 to talk it through.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

When do you think that you will be able to let us know about that?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

After Christmas and new year would be a good time to come back and talk to the committee about it. We would probably do so informally, to start with, and would give you some options to ensure that we were on the right tracks as regards what you are looking for.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

You said that a number of joint working groups have been set up at operational level by the strategic partners, but that neither their status nor their lines of responsibility are always clear. Will you expand on that? Are the four partners aware of that? Will they do something about it? When are they likely to do that? At this stage, given that the games are four and a half years away, are you concerned about that, or are you satisfied that they are doing enough to deal with the issue?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

It is probably worth saying that we think that the working groups are generally a good thing and are necessary—they are ways of getting together the right people on matters such as finances, the venue and some of the people issues that Mr Kidd asked about, on which a mechanism will need to be available.With such a complex project, it is really important that everyone understands where decisions are taken and who is accountable for them. We think that that has not yet been ironed out properly. In some ways, that is not surprising. The bid was approved in 2007, so there are still nearly five years to go. As the detailed planning is bedded down between now and March, we think that it is critical that those lines of accountability are clear to everyone. The partners have accepted the recommendation and know what is in the report, so I expect to see progress on that quite soon.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I have one more question. Have we had any indication whether there are plans to send a delegation to the 2010 Commonwealth games?

Caroline Gardner Audit Scotland
link

Carolyn, do you know?

Carolyn Smith Audit Scotland
link

There will definitely be staff from the organising committee and I imagine that there will be staff from all the partners at the 2010 games.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

And no doubt Il Duce—I am sorry; I mean the First Minister—will go as well. Is that right?

Carolyn Smith Audit Scotland
link

We do not know exactly who will go from the partners, but they will certainly be represented because of the closing ceremony, the handover and so on.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

As there are no other questions, I thank Caroline Gardner and Carolyn Smith for their contribution, which we will consider in due course.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Audit Committee Wednesday 2 December 2009 Committee business · 1
  2. Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
  3. Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 330
  4. Section 23 Reports Committee business · 72
  5. Section 23 Reports Committee business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.