We now move on to the second instrument, which is slightly ironic, given Gavin Brown's questions, because it is on statistics. We will have a little bit of shuffling of personnel; I see that the Government's chief statistician is coming to the table—you are not allowed to say anything, but I welcome you anyway. I invite the minister to introduce the order.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Official Statistics (Scotland) Order 2008 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Mather SNP 15
- Tavish Scott LD 10
- David Whitton Lab 5
- Brian Adam SNP 5
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 2
- Gavin Brown Con 1
The record
44 contributionsThe purpose of the order is to extend the definition of official statistics that is found in the UK Statistics and Registration Service Act 2007 to include statistics that have been produced by three non-Crown bodies, which are the Common Services Agency for the Scottish Health Service, the Higher Education Statistics Agency and the Student Loans Committee.During 2008, the Scottish Government intends to engage with a number of public sector bodies that produce statistics on Scotland to discuss whether bringing their statistics into the definition of official statistics would help to improve statistical standards. However, there is a pressing need to draw up an initial list to ensure that non-Crown bodies that currently produce national statistics have them included as official statistics.The order that we are considering will therefore ensure that the statistics that have been produced by those three bodies are designated as official statistics, which will mean that they will fall under the remit of the statistics board that is now known as the UK Statistics Authority, and that national statistics that are produced by those bodies can continue to have official statistics status from the commencement of the new statistical system on 1 April 2008.The UK Statistics Authority is the new non-ministerial department that was created by the Statistics and Registration Service Act 2007. It has the statutory objective of safeguarding and promoting the quality of official statistics, and it has welcomed Scotland's proposed approach.The three non-Crown bodies have been consulted and have agreed that their statistics should be included in the definition of official statistics.I move,That the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee recommends that the draft Official Statistics (Scotland) Order 2008 be approved.
Thank you, minister. I will ask the first question. What is the Government's direction of travel? Does the Administration intend to move towards a situation where, broadly speaking, all Government statistics will be under the proposed regime? If that is the case, what is the envisaged timescale for different bodies and for the Government?
The issue of a timescale is more challenging. We will try to do it as quickly as we can, but the process needs to be orderly, and the draft order is the start of that. We want there to be a close and open dialogue with those entities that are liable to produce such statistics.
On the publication of statistics—a matter about which ministers get very exercised, as I and others remember—international best practice is that statistics should be published and given right out there to the world and that the advance warning to ministers should be as little as three hours. Do you plan to follow international best practice on publication?
The Government pays strong attention to international best practice. It remains to be seen when we will get to the three-hour level, but there is a direction of travel that people are noting.
You are asking us to approve bringing three bodies into the regime. Will they have the three-hour deadline? If it is not three hours, what is the regime?
The regime might not be quite three hours at this point in time, but that is the direction of travel. Moving forward along the lines of our political aspirations, matching the UK Statistics Authority by having an independent body is certainly the further long-term direction of travel. We cannot be advocates of continuous improvement and not want best practice on statistics.To an extent, we are playing an away game with the committee. Normally, such matters go to the Finance Committee. There are proposals with the Finance Committee to drive forward the process.
I have a technical question. I take it that the reference in the order to the Common Services Agency for the Scottish Health Service encompasses all the statistical information that is produced in the national health service in Scotland. Is that correct?
My understanding is that that brings in the main thrust, but that drilling down into specific health boards is work in progress. That is the direction of travel.
Does it include ISD Scotland and all the agencies that produce national statistics?
Yes.
I have only one question. It is probably a bit more than three hours since you were on the radio talking about tourism industry statistics. To divert you slightly, some people seem not to believe that we can reach the target of 50 per cent growth by 2015. Unfortunately, I missed your interview, which I am sure was excellent. Will you give us your view on whether the target is achievable?
It is very much achievable. It was a good interview and it is worth listening to, if I may say so.
I will catch it on the BBC.
I will try to move into full mode there.I have just come from the opening session of Scottish tourism week, where the flavour of the room was that achieving the target is eminently doable. The industry now understands how we can get the 50 per cent extra growth, which is not just by a simple foot on the accelerator, but by considering how the industry can extend value, improve the visitor experience and create better career opportunities for young people. The industry is focusing on that and letting the revenue numbers and individual profitability of businesses almost take care of themselves. There is a real healthy attitude through the Scottish Tourism Forum and the tourism framework for change. Everyone who was at the session today is on the forward foot and is seeking to drive the industry forward.At the end of the day, the 50 per cent target may well be seen in retrospect as modest. From the thistle awards and elsewhere, we can see that new businesses, which are coming through at a faster and faster rate, are premium price and high occupancy straight off. In my constituency in the past year, the new Machrihanish dunes golf course has been finished and is ready for business and the Victoria hotel in Rothesay, which sets the tone for Rothesay, has been refurbished and smartened up. On Saturday, I was on Mull for the opening of the Crerar Hotels pool, which is a joint venture between the community, the public sector and the hotel. There are many signals that things are going to happen.
Under the statistics legislation, official statistics include those of any Government department, so we will be able to track the growth in tourism that you expect through the statistical method.
I certainly hope so. I have just come back from the convention of the Highlands and Islands up in Shetland. Slipped into my visitor pack was a copy of "Shetland in Statistics", which I must say is good value at £4—it is absolutely rich. That community has its finger absolutely on the pulse of what is happening through its data. I come from the Peter Drucker school of thought that if you cannot measure it, you cannot manage it.
I kind of guessed that.
The more that we lean on statistics, the better. I am a real enthusiast.
Shetland is showing you the way. Are those the kind of stats that you hope that the industry as a whole will produce?
Yes, and local areas as well. I recently attended a small area statistics event at Our Dynamic Earth. I expected to speak to 20 or 30 people, but there were 240 people in the room. All were well-motivated statisticians from national Government, local government, the public sector, public bodies, et cetera, who were really interested in the issues. I am particularly interested to see the emulation of Shetland in Argyll and Bute—the cross-pollination in that, with people looking at the data and asking questions such as, "What could we do to get that graph that is turning up all of a sudden?"
I thank David Whitton for keeping the discussion moving forward.
Minister, you indicated that the SSI is the general direction of travel. Would you care to share with us—today, if you can—why you have chosen to put these three agencies into the process first? Can you also tell us whether you will choose exactly the same route for dealing with others that have to go into the process?
The American term is market readiness. These organisations have done the work and are well prepared, and the statistics that they have pretty much meet the standards and look as though they will improve over the piece. These agencies are doing the work and producing solid data and they are ready for the stamp of approval.
Can you give us some idea of who will be coming along soon and whether this is something that you are responsible for overall? Will other ministers go to other committees? Will that be the route for progressing further movement?
I suspect that, given the fact that the chief statistician works under my portfolio, the responsibility will continue to be here. I am not going to anticipate the other agencies that are coming forward, but more will be encouraged to come forward and enter the process to get the cachet of official statistics wrapped round their data.
So, statistics is under the umbrella of the finance and sustainable growth portfolio. Irrespective of what part of government they come from, the statistics will come through this route.
Indeed, they will.
How many different departments might be under consideration?
That is an important statistic. I will consult and get back to you on that. Interruption. I am advised that the number is open ended at the moment and will be considerable. We will start with the major public bodies such as the Scottish funding council and local government and move beyond that. Shetland Council will be at the top of the list at an early stage.
That is an admirable idea. Thank you for that explanation, minister. Are colleagues content to recommend that the draft Official Statistics (Scotland) Order 2008 be approved?
Motion agreed to.
That the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee recommends that the draft Official Statistics (Scotland) Order 2008 be approved.
Unfortunately, we are not allowed to do what I hoped that we might be able to do with the first instrument. Because the minister moved the motion on it earlier, we must decide on it today; however, we have the minister's statement on the record that he will provide an explanation and answer the points that Gavin Brown has raised. We will have to make a decision on the order this afternoon, as the minister moved the motion on it. The question is, that the committee recommends that the draft Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2008 be approved. Are we agreed?
With the minister's assurance that we will get the information that is sought.
On the basis of today's evidence, I am not content to agree the motion; however, it must be a committee decision.
There will be a division.
ForTavish Scott (Shetland) (LD)Brian Adam (Aberdeen North) (SNP)Christopher Harvie (Mid Scotland and Fife) (SNP)Lewis Macdonald (Aberdeen Central) (Lab)Dave Thompson (Highlands and Islands) (SNP)David Whitton (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (Lab)AgainstGavin Brown (Lothians) (Con)
The result of the division is: For 6, Against 1, Abstentions 0.
Motion agreed to.
That the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee recommends that the draft Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2008 be approved.
We will await Mr Mather's answers to the questions that Gavin Brown raised.
Meeting closed at 12:55.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Mar 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 5 March 2008 Committee business · 1
- Tourism Inquiry Committee business · 96
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 44
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.