We have two items of subordinate legislation to deal with. We are pleased to have here the Minister for Enterprise, Energy and Tourism, Jim Mather, who is accompanied by a couple of his officials. I apologise to the minister and his officials for keeping them waiting while we were dealing with our tourism inquiry. We will try to find an imaginative way of asking him a question about that, but we are still working out how that could be consistent with the issues that are to be discussed. We must deal first with the draft Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2008. I invite the minister to introduce the draft order. We will then ask some questions.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2008 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Mather SNP 20
- Gavin Brown Con 10
- Tavish Scott LD 9
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 1
- Brian Adam SNP 1
The record
42 contributionsI remind the committee that wave and tidal power represent a huge opportunity for Scotland. I think that everyone accepts that. The resource has huge potential for us, and we have a number of innovative and enterprising device developers on our doorstep in Scotland. I believe that we have the shared political will to make things happen.We also have the dual imperatives of tackling climate change and providing secure, sustainable power for our future. The Government has set challenging targets for renewable electricity generation, including the target of meeting 50 per cent of Scottish demand by 2020. In addition, the European Union's wider and most welcome target for renewable energy could require as much as 50GW of renewable electricity capacity across the United Kingdom by 2020. Those important targets embody what we believe the sector can achieve and provide, but they will be meaningless without the right levels of support. The Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order mechanism is fundamentally important for the achievement of those goals.The draft order that is before the committee today relates to the marine supply obligation mechanism that was introduced last April. The draft order will amend the level of wave and tidal requirements for the forthcoming obligation period to zero, which is the same level as at present. That may seem an odd thing to do, given our determination to support the sector. However, it is fully in line with the commitment given when the marine supply obligation was introduced that the level would not be raised above zero unless generation was taking place that would enable licensed suppliers to meet a new level. The proposed amendment is perfectly sensible because it will mean that suppliers, and thus consumers, will not face additional costs, with no wave or tidal capacity to show for them.That does not mean that the MSO mechanism is a failure; on the contrary, the renewables sector and marine developers have warmly welcomed it. We know that projects and capacity are being actively planned on the basis that the MSO will support them over time. The signal that the MSO sends is vitally important, as is the confidence that it will remain in place.It is clear that the sector faces huge challenges in getting the technology to the stage at which it can benefit from what is purely a market mechanism. However, there is tremendous dedication, determination and perseverance among those battling to develop, prove and deploy those machines. As a consequence, it is right that the Government remains committed to doing all that it can to aid that process. That means continuing to support vital infrastructure at the European Marine Energy Centre in Orkney; addressing environmental issues; enabling the process of establishing the best sites for early development; continuing to press hard for a sensible, flexible and fair approach to making grid capacity available for the devices; and, above all, ensuring that our obligation continues to offer the right levels of support in the right way over the right period of time.I move,That the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee recommends that the draft Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2008 be approved.
Thank you, minister. The one issue that the committee is puzzled about is why some of the explanation that you have just given was not in the Executive note provided to the committee and—more to the point—to the Parliament. Are you prepared to give us an explanation as to why the necessary information, which any committee would need, was not given to us in writing in advance?
I can only regret that that was the case. The background to making the draft order was clear-cut to me. I take firmly on board what you have said and will ensure that the situation is not repeated.
We are all interested in understanding the issue, after all.
Absolutely.
I understand the reasoning behind the draft order, but I want to probe a couple of points a little to get an understanding of the minister's interpretation of the matter. First, there is a proposal to reduce the level of the obligation—the percentage of total supplies—to zero for the forthcoming year. As the minister said, that does not signal a failure. However, is it a signal that we were too optimistic in April last year in believing that the technology would allow the figure to be more than zero by this stage?My second question is connected to that. We had an informal briefing this morning from the Royal Society of Edinburgh that confirmed publicly made estimates of when wave and tidal power are likely to be commercial runners—it was said that it would be eight years before tidal power and 10 years before wave power became commercially available. Does that mean that the minister expects ministers to come back for the next seven years to adjust the requirement to zero for each year, or is that interpretation too pessimistic?
We may well share a similar blend of optimism and realism with the previous Administration, but having that blend and passing it on to the industry are important. However, it is important that consumers do not pay extra for no tangible return in the short term. Sending successive optimistic signals and anticipating engineering and technological breakthroughs are entirely healthy, to encourage the evolutionary process that is taking place in Scotland, particularly up at EMEC, where—fingers crossed—developments could accelerate much more. When we consider that through the lens of our scrutiny and present it to colleagues in Brussels, as we did recently with Scottish and Southern Energy, we can see the appetite that exists, which feeds back into more people being more willing to invest more money to accelerate the process. Let us keep the blend of optimism and realism. If that means that we need to come back for a few more years to adjust the figures, so be it.
The minister mentioned the change to the obligation for 2008-09 to make the requirements for wave and tidal power zero. Will he comment on the changes that the draft order will make in subsequent years?
In the light of the UK Energy Bill, we are considering carefully whether banding—the award of renewables obligation certificates in higher multiples for different technologies—might replace the marine supply obligation. We must keep monitoring the situation, ensure that the right signals are in place and have the correct checks and balances to ensure that we have value for money in the process. We must also have the correct forward momentum to encourage more and more people to develop the technologies.
Will the draft order reduce the figures in schedule 1 to the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order 2007 (SSI 2007/267) for tidal and wave power in subsequent years, or will those figures remain the same?
The figures are just an indication. Clearly, we will monitor the situation going forward. You can expect us to have our finger on the pulse.
Okay. My question is: will the draft 2008 order reduce the figures in the 2007 order for subsequent years?
Could my official just—
I am afraid that officials cannot speak at this point.
There will be some adjustments. In the schedule to the draft 2008 order, some requirements are less and some are more, but the key point is that the total will remain the same.
You say that some are less. Which ones are more?
In 2007-08, the requirement is the same. In 2008-09, it will be less. The sequence seems to be: the same, less, more, less.
In which specific year is the requirement more?
I am being told that, in 2009-10, we will have an increase.
An increase from what to what?
From 9.1 to 9.7. The issue is pretty complex, but I understand that the end figure is a representative cap. The data concern a progression that finalises at that cap. The total remains the same.
As you mentioned, the requirement for next year is going down to zero. Having examined online the information relating to the 2007 order, my concern is that the wave and tidal requirements that we set in April last year appear to have gone down for 2009-10—from 0.1 to 0.06 for both. The requirements have also gone down for 2010-11, from 0.15 to 0.12. For 2011-12, the requirements seem to have gone down from 0.2 to 0.18. That was not mentioned in the Executive note or in your opening remarks. The impression was given that a change was being made for one year, but it seems to me that changes for a number of years have been made in the one order.
That is true. However, the figures in the draft order are illustrative and will kick in and formalise as and when the system moves beyond zero as the opening position. The figures should not be taken as definitive until we move beyond zero.
But if the figures in the table are only illustrative, why have they been changed from last year?
I do not have a good answer to that. Interruption. I am told that the table is purely illustrative and that it is supposed to be linear up to the cap. The key figure is the cap. The changing timeframe and the reindexation at zero at the start change that linear progression. You can expect us to confirm that in writing to the committee.
That is why we wanted an explanation in writing in advance.
Yes—touché.
I do not want to hog the conversation, but I have a final question.I am not hugely satisfied and have some issues that will not be cleared up until I see an explanation in writing. If the figures are purely illustrative, why change the requirement from 0.15 to 0.12? Surely that change is based on something.My final question is about the impact on business and relates to the Executive note. Under the heading "Financial Impacts", the Executive note states:"The ROS creates small additional costs for electricity suppliers, which are then passed through".If we are reducing the obligation for wave and for tidal and are not making any change to the total obligation, how are we creating additional costs for electricity suppliers?
The issue is that the obligation as a whole creates costs for electricity suppliers, but in this instance, by having the return to zero on the MSO, we are not further complicating the situation.
This is not specific to the draft Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2008—the Executive note states clearly that it "creates small additional costs". We appear to be agreed that costs are not created by the changes to the figures—in some ways, they may reduce costs. There only two further changes that I can see: the replacement of references to the Department of Trade and Industry, because it no longer exists, with references to "the Secretary of State"; and a change to the initial drafting. What will be the additional costs to electricity suppliers as a result of the draft order?
The fact is that supply businesses have to do a bit of work to project forward what the implications will be. That is where the implications for cost could emanate from. Such businesses must have staff monitoring the situation, managing their position forward and understanding the implications. Change creates costs; the change creates a small cost for those businesses.
Is it not also true that the additional cost arises because, effectively, the public will have to subsidise the system for a period of time, and the subsidy that wave and tidal will require is currently higher than the subsidy that we give to onshore wind? As you rightly indicated, the administrative costs on suppliers are one of the reasons why there may well be additional costs to the consumer in the future as a consequence. Those costs will not arise for the consumer until such time as we generate any electricity.
That is the situation exactly. As we proceed with the consultation on the introduction of banding to the Scottish renewables obligation, which we will announce soon, that issue will come up because we are not convinced that the proposed banding level in the UK Energy Bill is sufficient. All those issues will crystallise and mature and we will be able to see the implications.
The committee next meets in Aberdeen on Monday. Given the questions raised by Gavin Brown, to which you kindly said that you would respond in writing, is there any chance that your officials could put together a letter for us for that meeting? Mr Brown has raised several questions that are clearly going to be tricky to deal with.
Absolutely. I agree with some enthusiasm, because I want increased clarity for my own purposes as well as for the committee's.
Would it therefore be acceptable to you if we decided on the draft order not today but on Monday in Aberdeen? That would still allow you to stick to your timetable.
Absolutely. I am more than happy with that.
Are committee colleagues content to deal with the draft order at Monday's meeting in Aberdeen, when we will have the answers to Gavin Brown's questions?
Members indicated agreement.
Is that acceptable, minister?
It is perfectly acceptable.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Mar 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 5 March 2008 Committee business · 1
- Tourism Inquiry Committee business · 96
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 44
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.