Do members agree that we adopt our standard practice and consider our draft reports on the Sewel convention and on public petitions in private? That would be in accordance with the normal procedure of the committee.
Official Report · Committee
Items in Private
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Smith LD 7
- Karen Gillon Lab 4
- Mark Ballard Green 3
- Jamie McGrigor Con 2
- Bruce McFee SNP 2
The record
19 contributionsI believe that we should consider draft reports in private. However, given the fact that we have already had our discussion on the matter in public and everybody knows what we are going to do, I wonder what the point would be of doing that on this occasion. However, if you think that taking those items in private would be in the interests of the committee, I can be persuaded. We have had all our discussion in public and the Official Report is there for the reading.
Are you talking about our draft report on the Sewel convention?
I am talking about our reports both on the Sewel convention and on petitions. We have just had our discussion in public, and the papers on the matter are all public. I have noted my concerns about doing it this way in the past. There is some difficulty in then having a private discussion on a report, but we are where we are.
We will still have to make some decisions on the draft report. The principle of having the discussion in private is that the report remains a private report and cannot be subject to the press, for example, saying that the committee has determined X when we have not made a decision on the matter. It is about protecting the report, so that only the final version is published. That is the main reason for dealing with the matter in private.
I am relaxed about the matter. As Karen Gillon says, the main arguments are out there, so it does not make a blind bit of difference.
I agree. I do not see the point in keeping the discussion private, but it is up to the convener.
It is up to the committee. If it were up to me, I would not have to bring the matter to the committee.
This raises some issues. In the past, committees that I have been on have taken in private all the decisions on how a report would be framed. However, it will be impossible for you to mount a leak inquiry should the Sunday Herald or any other newspaper decide to run a story on the Sunday ahead of the report's publication on the Monday, as nobody could say anything other than that the newspaper got the information from the Official Report. Discussing the report in private will not prevent publication ahead of the report, but I understand the point that you are making and, perhaps for the sanctity of the process, I think that we should meet in private.
There are two issues. One is to have items in private so that we can have the discussions in private. The second is to have items in private so that we can clarify that the report accurately mirrors our discussions and we do not have debates like the one that I seem to have been spared most of about the interpretation of particular paragraphs.
You can read it.
I will do. I look forward to doing so.I can see the validity of having a discussion in private if it means that we can clarify that what we all agree on matches what is set down in draft standing order proposals.
That is the primary purpose of discussing the report in private. We can agree that the report that is before is and is published is what we think it is.
I cannot envisage anybody storming the barricades to get into the great discussion—I think that it would be a big yawn for many people.
I am sure that it would be. Can we agree to take the items in private?Members indicated agreement.
That concludes today's business.As I said at the start of the meeting, this is likely to be Mark Ballard's last meeting as a member of the Procedures Committee. I am sure that committee members wish to put on record their appreciation of his contribution to the committee over the past two years and wish him every success wherever he moves on to.
It is the Finance Committee.
That concludes the meeting. I wish everyone a long and restful recess. We meet again on 13 September.
Meeting closed at 11:58.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Jun 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Procedures Committee Tuesday 21 June 2005 Committee business · 1
- Sewel Convention Inquiry Committee business · 185
- Parliamentary Time Committee business · 67
- Public Petitions (Admissibility and Closure) Petitions · 7
- Crown Appointees Committee business · 24
- Items in Private Procedure · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.