Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Crown Appointees

Tuesday 21 June 2005 Procedures Committee Committee business 24 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

24 contributions
Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Agenda item 4 is about the reappointment of Crown appointees and related issues. The Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body requested that we consider how the Parliament handles Crown appointments—which, essentially, are made on a recommendation of the Parliament—when it is recommended that the existing office-holder continues for a second term in office or, exceptionally, for a third. Are members content with the recommendations in the report? It all seems fairly straightforward. Do members have any questions?

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link

The paper asks us only to take a preliminary view anyway.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

I would like further information on the circumstances in which it is envisaged that people would be reappointed for a third term. The paper states:"re-appointment for a third term is competent only if, by reason of special circumstances, such re-appointment is desirable in the public interest".What does that mean?

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The question is whether standing orders could define special circumstances. That would not necessarily be appropriate. If the legislation that set up the post does not define what special circumstances are, why should we do so in standing orders?

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link

The recommendation in paragraph 33(c) invites members to"indicate whether they wish to take oral evidence".The issue that Karen Gillon has raised could be covered in oral evidence—assuming that we decide to take oral evidence.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I was going to come on to that in a moment.

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link

Of course, our preliminary view could change after evidence has been led.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Absolutely. Do members have any other comments on the reappointment of Crown appointees before we take evidence?

Mark Ballard Green Lothians
link

Out of interest, are there issues other than the removal of Crown appointees on which statutory provision requires the agreement of a certain number of members? Is that true of anything else in the Scottish Parliament? I was surprised to see that such motions must be agreed to by two thirds of the total number of MSPs.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

That applies to particular posts, such as that of the Scottish information commissioner. The provisions are there to protect those appointees' independence and to prevent political interference. That is why there is such a high threshold. I am not sure whether any other appointees are covered by that.

Andrew Mylne
link

There are a number of statutory provisions, as well as provisions in standing orders that are not backed up by statutory provisions, where a specific threshold is required, rather than just a simple majority—either an absolute majority or a higher threshold of the sort that is described in the paper. However, the default position for most decisions that are taken by the Parliament is a simple majority.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

The provisions are designed to prevent a party with a majority in the Parliament from controlling who holds all the relevant posts.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Those issues will be clarified when we consider the matter in more detail at subsequent meetings. Are members content with the proposal on the directions given to the Scottish public services ombudsman on her annual report? There are a couple of options. For example, directions could come from the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body or from a parliamentary committee. Are members content that we take evidence on those options?

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link

As I said earlier, we are taking a preliminary view, presumably subject to what comes up in the oral evidence. I am not quite sure what that preliminary view does, but I presume that we will take a decision to hear some evidence and have a short inquiry, which will firm up—or otherwise—members' views. I do not think that it is necessarily helpful to deliberate on what our preliminary view is, however.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Recommendation (c) is for members to "indicate whether they wish to take oral evidence during this inquiry and, if so, from whom." I would have thought that it would be appropriate to take oral evidence from the SPCB, which is responsible for such matters. The question would then be whether we wish to take evidence from one or other of the commissioners and from the Scottish public services ombudsman in relation to her annual report. However, it might be inappropriate to take evidence from commissioners on the issue of reappointment, given that they are the people who would be reappointed.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

It is sensible to take evidence from the ombudsman in relation to her report and the practicalities for her and her office, but it would be totally inappropriate to take evidence from the commissioners, given that we are talking about their terms of employment. We must consider the matter in an impartial way.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Do any members feel that we should be taking evidence from anyone else on the reappointments issue?

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link

I am not sure how we get extra evidence on that. I understand Karen Gillon's point, but I am not sure about what the other options would be. There are potential vested interests to consider.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

There might be some similar postings at Westminster. It could be useful to find out how the situation has been handled in other jurisdictions.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

We do not have any yet in Scotland.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

It might be worth checking whether there are any similar provisions relating to the equivalent appointments in the other jurisdiction. That could be sought in written or, perhaps, oral evidence. Are members content with that?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Procedures Committee Tuesday 21 June 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Sewel Convention Inquiry Committee business · 185
  3. Parliamentary Time Committee business · 67
  4. Public Petitions (Admissibility and Closure) Petitions · 7
  5. Crown Appointees Committee business · 24
  6. Items in Private Procedure · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.