Item 2 is consideration of our work programme. Before we consider the paper that is before us, I remind members that we are still carrying out a number of pieces of work. I hope that we will be well down on the oral questions by the end of the year. At the beginning of next year, we will have to consider the timing of First Minister's questions, which we agreed to review after Christmas. The clerk and I will write to the various parties involved, such as the journalists and broadcasters, to get their views on the changed timings and the information that we need on audience figures. We are in the middle of our inquiry into the non-Executive bills unit, and an outstanding, relatively small, item on emergency bills is due to emerge shortly.I am interested in members' views on the next major inquiry that we might want to undertake and whether they think that we should undertake any minor inquiries in parallel with that. Members have a paper on the work programme and a summary of some of the main points that arose in last week's debate on the consultative steering group principles. I invite comments.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Iain Smith only · show everyone- Iain Smith LD 21
- Mark Ballard Green 11
- Karen Gillon Lab 8
- Bruce Crawford SNP 7
- Cathie Craigie Lab 6
- Andrew Mylne Clerk 5
Iain Smith’s contributions
21 contributionsThere is a summary of the main points in annex B, although that is not included in the work programme paper. We do not have to make final decisions on our work programme today, but if there is consensus, we can start doing some of the background work on one or two of the big areas outlined.
The Scottish Civic Forum met only last week, so that issue has arisen since the report was prepared.
Do any other members have any thoughts?
I accept all those points. My inclination is to recommend to the committee that we deal with option 1, the legislative timetable, as our next major inquiry. We can ask the clerks to draft a paper on how we might handle that. We can then consider Sewel motions as our next inquiry after that, on the grounds that we might want to allow the present procedure to bed in a bit to give us a clear idea of what is and is not working within the revised procedures. We would not be throwing out that issue, but addressing it slightly further down the track.We can probably deal with the specific items that are referred to in option 3 rather than hold a wider inquiry on public bills, and we can address the issue of flexibility in the rules as an under-the-wire thing. A lot of the background work can be done and the proposals for the required changes to the standing orders can be produced without our holding a full inquiry, as the two bullet points under option 3 are largely technical matters. We may look at the whole private bill procedure in more detail at a later date.I suggest that we proceed on that basis. Are members content with that?
We will find that out and bring a paper to the next meeting to let the committee know what the position is. I agree with what you are saying in principle, as it seems like a good opportunity. However, I am pretty sure that the Westminster Government wants to have a specific bill that deals only with the issues on elected members and that it does not wish to open up any other areas of the act. Even if we agreed to do what you suggest, it may be difficult for us. If the bill is timetabled to be introduced next month, there will be no chance for us to do anything; if it is to be introduced in May, we could have a look at it.
We will try to find out.
I appreciate that, but I suspect that we will not get in any case.
The legislative timetable, which might throw up a few issues about the timetabling of business, and a few other developments suggest that we might have to consider the issue at some point in the not too distant future, either in an ad hoc way or as a full inquiry.
Absolutely. It could be a major piece of work, of course. The main issue is whether the parliamentary week is long enough or whether it should be reshaped across the parliamentary year. There have been a few comments about the subjects of the parliamentary debates at this time of year, when there is not a lot of legislation going through, while there never seems to be enough plenary time in May and June, when we are trying to get bills passed before the summer. We might have to consider how the Parliament balances its business. That would be a major inquiry, however.
My information is that we should leave that to the Parliamentary Bureau and the Presiding Officers at this stage. The allocation of time in the chamber is at the discretion of the Presiding Officer and I am not sure that we should be too prescriptive in that regard. However, we might have to discuss the matter.
That was mainly to do with the time scale, though.
Those points are noted.Are there any items on the draft work programme that members think we should drop at this stage on the ground that we need not consider them further?
Do we agree to drop option 5? Items that are dropped do not drop off for ever and can be dealt with at a later date.Members indicated agreement.
What about option 6, on petitions?
It is a question of whether we should leave the matter on the work programme. If members are happy to leave it on, we shall do so.What about Dennis Canavan's point, in item 7?
Perhaps the clerk can explain exactly what the rule is.
I am not sure that it is as simple as that. It might be possible for Jean Turner and Dennis Canavan, because they were elected on a constituency basis. Anyone who is elected on a list has to be a member of the list on which they are elected. The question is whether we want to keep the issue on our forward work programme as something to consider in future, or whether we are happy with the present process.
The Dennis Canavan point would require a change to standing orders.
The bureau, but essentially it is by agreement among the non-Executive parties. They allocate the time proportionately.
The time comes out of the existing allocation for non-Executive time, which means that the existing non-Executive parties could lose time, and they might not be happy about that. A number of issues have to be addressed, and we should do that as a proper inquiry, rather than as part of the discussion about the work programme.Are there any other issues that should be included in the work programme but which have not yet been included? We can pick up stuff from the debate on the committee's consultative steering group report, which is already contained in the annex.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Procedures Committee Tuesday 2 December 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Non-Executive Bills Committee business · 82
- Work Programme Procedure · 58
- Scottish Civic Forum Committee business · 20
- Item in Private Procedure · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.